Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High Income single families losing Child benefit

139 replies

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 15:30

Hi there - I know this has been talked about extensively over the years, but I wondered if anyone has been following the topic and discussions around it in parliament for the future? Are there any changes to come for the next budget?

I am a single mother with no input from my 2 kids father. I live in London work full time and currently cannot afford to put my 2 year old in nursery as fees are too high, and I am not eligible for any help (fees are 2k + a month in my area). Luckily my mother has stepped in, but without her I'd have to claim benefits and not work, or I'd have to dial down my ambitions and go for a part time job which puts me at a disadvantage in my work place.
This year I will gratefully receive a bonus that just about puts me at the point of not being eligible at all for any Child Benefit down to the penny. This really bothers me because all the families I know all receive it still. Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

When is this going to change in order to be fair for single mothers like myself? I cannot afford nursery and I also do not get any child benefit. Something is incredibly wrong here.

Am I being unreasonable to feel as though this is unfair to single mothers?

OP posts:
Idratherbepaddleboarding · 31/12/2023 13:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

wronginalltherightways · 31/12/2023 12:07

DonnaBanana · 31/12/2023 11:42

It is a very silly policy. Surely the government wants to encourage people to have children as they’ll be future tax payers and the ones paying towards our pensions one day. To then dissuade the most accomplished and well earning people from having children is ridiculous because they are more likely to raise children who aren’t a net burden on the state. It’s back to front really. They should be encouraging high earners to have more children to fill the demographic gap

You will get hammered for your comment, but I agree with you.

DonnaBanana · 31/12/2023 11:42

It is a very silly policy. Surely the government wants to encourage people to have children as they’ll be future tax payers and the ones paying towards our pensions one day. To then dissuade the most accomplished and well earning people from having children is ridiculous because they are more likely to raise children who aren’t a net burden on the state. It’s back to front really. They should be encouraging high earners to have more children to fill the demographic gap

TrashedSofa · 31/12/2023 11:17

ReturnoftheMe · 31/12/2023 11:13

@TrashedSofa what? How is that possible?

@Workworkandmoreworknow exactly, your point hits the nail on the head.

As far as I can tell, you need very high rent and childcare costs to be eligible. But some people do. About 50,000 families in 2022, according to this.

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/childrens-benefits-mess-leaves-families-facing-effective-tax-rates-of-80-to-96-per-cent/

The number will likely be a bit higher now as rent, childcare and average salaries have all gone up in the last year but the child benefit thresholds have remained frozen.

‘Children’s benefits mess’ leaves families facing effective tax rates of 80 to 96 per cent • Resolution Foundation

https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/press-releases/childrens-benefits-mess-leaves-families-facing-effective-tax-rates-of-80-to-96-per-cent

ReturnoftheMe · 31/12/2023 11:13

@TrashedSofa what? How is that possible?

@Workworkandmoreworknow exactly, your point hits the nail on the head.

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 31/12/2023 09:01

Workworkandmoreworknow · 31/12/2023 08:42

I think the idea is if you're earning a certain amount you don't need benefits?

If that's the case, then make the threshold household income, not individual. You can't argue that £60k is somehow 'sufficient' in a single parent household but allow a 2 income household to claim when they are bringing in £90k.

Additionally, it's possible to earn too much for full CB whilst also being entitled to some UC. It happens. So that isn't the explanation either.

BibbleandSqwauk · 31/12/2023 08:46

But with "household" income, what if you live with extended family? Should aunt or uncle or grandparent of working age income count? I don't disagree at all it is unfair but it would need refining to "household income of those with parental responsibility" or similar.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 31/12/2023 08:42

I think the idea is if you're earning a certain amount you don't need benefits?

If that's the case, then make the threshold household income, not individual. You can't argue that £60k is somehow 'sufficient' in a single parent household but allow a 2 income household to claim when they are bringing in £90k.

TrashedSofa · 31/12/2023 08:23

TheresaWa · 30/12/2023 21:21

What could be done to this unfair "system" to be changed? What's the legislative/Parliament way ?

Make CB universal again, as it has been for the majority of the time since it was introduced.

RoséProsecco · 31/12/2023 08:11

Totally agree.

I'm about to go over the threshold too.

It would be so easy to administer by self assessment, perhaps a pain in the arse to do but it could be as simple as a tick box.

I don't see how the argument about the complexity of administration adds up in these circumstances.

Aubree17 · 31/12/2023 07:46

Theoneandonlyjrae · 30/12/2023 15:42

Can't you increase pension contributions slightly so you are under £50,000?

Good suggestion. There may be an equalisation point where you are just as well off by paying into your pension.

It's grossly unfair.

WhereGlasses · 30/12/2023 22:18

I agree OP. I am also a single parent on a similar salary and don't receive any child benefit. My sibling, in a couple and partner both earn c£35k each. So £70k total, they get to keep child benefit. But I don't, on £65k.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 22:04

Thanks to everyone who contributed to this discussion, I've definitely seen a few good points to consider going forward, will be speaking to my local MP to gauge how many others are in a similar situation, if there are many others coming forward and what the likelihood is of any changes being made.

I am very grateful to get the 30 childcare hours in a couple months for my son, but as for the CB, clearly so many are frustrated by this issue, and "administrative" efforts aside, there simply is no justified or logical reasoning behind this. It's one of the most illogical and disriminatory policies I've ever been affected by. I know the Tories brought it in, but with Labour in power I can't see that they'd want to back the single "high earning" mother. They need to completely get rid of this idea of £50k income being high earning for a mother and two small children, then we can go from there. Instead of feeling down about it, I am going to be dedicating time in 2024 to look further into the development of this shitty policy. I was scared Id get a lot of criticism for bringing this up, but it has helped to hear from so many of you that are in the same situation and hear from those of you who aren't but still see how unfair it all is.

Thanks @Pippippipi I have signed and shared on my social media. @Ottersfortea I am going to check the deadline for paying my bonus into my Pension. Admittedly, I have been too spaced out with all of this to have really understood what my best course of action is, but I am going to also ask HR for some guidance if they have any. Thank you.

OP posts:
Ottersfortea · 30/12/2023 21:43

Op - just pay the bonus into a pension this year and future years assuming you can afford to
live on 50k. You may be very thankful when you retire! If you work out what each £1 into your pension costs you from your pocket (taking into account tax, Ni and the loss of Cb) it’s worth doing it to get 10k into your pension.

Remember charity contributions can be popped onto your tax return. Keep your evidence. Many other bits can be offset too. The gov uk tax website is a good read 😂.

TheresaWa · 30/12/2023 21:21

What could be done to this unfair "system" to be changed? What's the legislative/Parliament way ?

DragonMama3 · 30/12/2023 21:08

Visit a good accountant op x

DragonMama3 · 30/12/2023 21:06

Hi,

Could you ask HR to not get the bonus?

DragonMama3 · 30/12/2023 21:05

Also apply for Child Maintenance - even if small it will help.

It took 2 to tango!

DragonMama3 · 30/12/2023 21:05

Theoneandonlyjrae · 30/12/2023 15:42

Can't you increase pension contributions slightly so you are under £50,000?

do THIS!

saynotoo · 30/12/2023 21:04

Calabou · 30/12/2023 20:02

I do agree with you OP. It's weird that you won't be eligible with your bonus, yet DP and I jointly earning much more are, because it's in my name and my personal income is below the threshold.
As a pp said, weird how other benefits are assessed on household income, yet this one is personal.

It doesn't matter who claims the child benefit, if either partner are over the threshold you are not eligible to receive Child benefit.

It's a ridiculously unfair system for single parents and also families with one higher earner and one low earner.

Blinkityblonk · 30/12/2023 20:49

I agree with you OP. I'm a lone parent, no other parent alive, and so it annoys me immensely that if I work hard, get promoted and get paid more money I am penalised in comparison to other households with the same income, in terms of losing child benefits and the tax advantages of having two tax allowances. It's not fair.

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 20:45

I’m from the south east and most aren’t making that money

Calabou · 30/12/2023 20:02

I do agree with you OP. It's weird that you won't be eligible with your bonus, yet DP and I jointly earning much more are, because it's in my name and my personal income is below the threshold.
As a pp said, weird how other benefits are assessed on household income, yet this one is personal.