Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High Income single families losing Child benefit

139 replies

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 15:30

Hi there - I know this has been talked about extensively over the years, but I wondered if anyone has been following the topic and discussions around it in parliament for the future? Are there any changes to come for the next budget?

I am a single mother with no input from my 2 kids father. I live in London work full time and currently cannot afford to put my 2 year old in nursery as fees are too high, and I am not eligible for any help (fees are 2k + a month in my area). Luckily my mother has stepped in, but without her I'd have to claim benefits and not work, or I'd have to dial down my ambitions and go for a part time job which puts me at a disadvantage in my work place.
This year I will gratefully receive a bonus that just about puts me at the point of not being eligible at all for any Child Benefit down to the penny. This really bothers me because all the families I know all receive it still. Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

When is this going to change in order to be fair for single mothers like myself? I cannot afford nursery and I also do not get any child benefit. Something is incredibly wrong here.

Am I being unreasonable to feel as though this is unfair to single mothers?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whatkatydid2014 · 13/01/2024 21:34

I didn’t read every reply so someone may already have told you this but you should make sure you are working off your taxable income and not your salary when checking what you need to pay. Some deductions like pension/some share schemes & charitable donations (& possibly others as I just know the ones we do) can be used to adjust your salary for calculating what you need to pay back.

TrashedSofa · 13/01/2024 21:22

Yeah it's a really good article.

ReturnoftheMe · 13/01/2024 21:00

@Araminta1003 thank you, it’s an interesting read, especially with the comments at the end. So many in this situation!

OP posts:
Araminta1003 · 13/01/2024 17:20

Just read this article and thought of the OP, written by a well known tax lawyer.

https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/11/20/hicbc/

PurpleBugz · 31/12/2023 20:00

To give the other side of this. My ex earnt over the limit so I got no child benefit and no entertainment to help with childcare etc. But I earnt less than the cost of childcare and ex didn't share his money with me. In fact I had to contribute to bills. Our household income as over £100k back then now I'm on about £16kish and I have way more money now than then.

Yes it's unfair but in situations of financial abuse it's all some women get

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 18:20

wronginalltherightways · 31/12/2023 16:43

LOADS of people cared at the time. I don't know anyone who didn't complain, point out the injustice, write to their MPs, or something!

As I said, couples who earn £99k between them (both just below £50k) could keep it, but a single earner who earned over £50k lost it.

Madness.

People certainly cared at the time. It didn’t affect me but, having been a single parent, I was shouting at the radio when it was announced. It’s completely bonkers.

TrashedSofa · 31/12/2023 18:13

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 31/12/2023 16:56

Doing it in such a blunt way was the only way they could bring it in quickly, whilst public opinion was largely on their side over it, without needing a new computer system.

Not because of any ideology or any big thinking.

Hmm, agree with your first paragraph but not the second. It's pretty obvious it had the wider aim of gradually reducing the number of people eligible, turn it into something for lower earners. That's an ideological choice.

Torchdino · 31/12/2023 18:07

glossypeach · 31/12/2023 17:06

Single parents really get penalised. Similar thing where if you’re a single stay at home parent your child doesn’t get help with childcare, whereas if you’re a stay at home parent but have a partner that works you’re entitled to help with childcare including the 30 free hours. It’s baffling, especially if you’re a disabled single parent and can’t work - you’re still not entitled.

That's not true, for the 30 hours both must be employed unless for a reason beyond being a SAHP such as disability or being a named carer for someone. If one is a SAHP you aren't eligible.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 31/12/2023 18:03

It was all disgraceful. Eleanor Rathbone MP lobbied for and created child benefit because she could see horrific inequality and need amongst mothers with children. It went across all socio economic demographics and so she stipulated it be non means tested and went to the mother unless there were extenuating circumstances.
Then we got the Tories this time round.
Situations like yours are a disgrace. As are those where the man earns £60k +, won't 'let' his wife work, and keeps her with no money, seeing all he earns as his. Yes they do exist in this day and age.
It needs to be returned to what it was.

glossypeach · 31/12/2023 17:06

Single parents really get penalised. Similar thing where if you’re a single stay at home parent your child doesn’t get help with childcare, whereas if you’re a stay at home parent but have a partner that works you’re entitled to help with childcare including the 30 free hours. It’s baffling, especially if you’re a disabled single parent and can’t work - you’re still not entitled.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 31/12/2023 16:56

Doing it in such a blunt way was the only way they could bring it in quickly, whilst public opinion was largely on their side over it, without needing a new computer system.

Not because of any ideology or any big thinking.

wronginalltherightways · 31/12/2023 16:43

Ottersfortea · 31/12/2023 16:19

Nobody cared at the time it was introduced. If you mentioned it people said ‘but 60k is rich’. I did write letters at the time but most people I mentioned it to thought I was bonkers.

The government did a grand job at getting us to fight amongst ourselves and no doubt planned on never raising the threshold.

LOADS of people cared at the time. I don't know anyone who didn't complain, point out the injustice, write to their MPs, or something!

As I said, couples who earn £99k between them (both just below £50k) could keep it, but a single earner who earned over £50k lost it.

Madness.

Ottersfortea · 31/12/2023 16:19

Nobody cared at the time it was introduced. If you mentioned it people said ‘but 60k is rich’. I did write letters at the time but most people I mentioned it to thought I was bonkers.

The government did a grand job at getting us to fight amongst ourselves and no doubt planned on never raising the threshold.

Ottersfortea · 31/12/2023 16:16

Very basic calculation but:

60k - 50k = 10k
Tax would be 40%
NI 2%

leaves £5800 minus but means paying back
child benefit 2 kids = 2074.80

5800 - 2074.80 = 3725.20 in your pocket.

If you pay into your pension the 10k via salary sacrifice you will get 10k in your pension and it will ‘cost’ you 3725.20. (310.43 a month over 12 months).

wronginalltherightways · 31/12/2023 16:03

Alcyoneus · 31/12/2023 15:56

OP, your concern is fair. Basically anyone supporting themselves in this country is milked for every last penny. Which is why we have such a dependent, unproductive population on welfare.

The main thing here is how your children’s father is allowed to get away without paying for his kids. This government, the civil servicants managing CMS and the like are utterly incompetent.

100%

I'm rather fed up of working hard and watching people around here not work at all and have more holidays and nicer cars, clothes and things than we do.

Alcyoneus · 31/12/2023 15:56

OP, your concern is fair. Basically anyone supporting themselves in this country is milked for every last penny. Which is why we have such a dependent, unproductive population on welfare.

The main thing here is how your children’s father is allowed to get away without paying for his kids. This government, the civil servicants managing CMS and the like are utterly incompetent.

Wherearemybooks · 31/12/2023 15:52

Yep. It was utter cowardice of the government. They basically got some flack so quickly changed it to this half baked scheme which is blatantly unfair, but which they thought no-one would care about.

MrNovember · 31/12/2023 15:42

Catterbat · 30/12/2023 16:41

You earn £60k so you don’t need it. The threshold is far too high and the money would be better diverted towards those that do.

She does need it. £65k is about £3600 per month after tax. She then pays £2k Per month for nursery fees. So that leaves £1600.

many lower earners think that £60k is a fortune. But many lower earners are propped up by multiple benefits and pay a hell of a lot less tax than the higher earners; and with the cost of working (childcare, travel) many are not rolling in it… especially a single parent in a an expensive part of the country

Thatswhy11 · 31/12/2023 15:32

I can't understand this argument, single mum too. If you are earning a decent salary surely £90 odd pound a month isn't really neither here or there. For the couples part who can each earn 45k each yes that's unfair and a silly rule.

AfterXmas · 31/12/2023 15:12

Yes, it should be household income but I am a single parent with 4 children on a very low income and could only dream about earning the amount you do.
Lots of things are unfair on single parents, inheritance tax is another one. As I understand it, 2 married people will have double the inheritance tax allowance for their children if they leave their home to them. Unmarried single parents will only get the one allowance, which if you live in the southeast, will likely leave your kids with an inheritance tax bill. I worry about this as I have kids with Sen and would like them to be able to stay in their home should something happen to me.
Also, I am a widow not eligible to claim any other benefits as I was left with a relatively small amount of life insurance. Yet, if I had divorced, any maintenance would be disregarded so a lot of my divorced friends are in a much better position than me. When my money runs out, I will have no maintenance to help me. That also seems unfair to me but others will disagree.
Life is already hard for single parents but couples seem to be given additional advantages.

Halfemptyhalfling · 31/12/2023 14:47

This is one of the many ways that the conservatives have undermined women and children. Even two parent rich families have more expenses and often a drop in income with a new baby. And a means tested benefit is much more complex and expensive to administer

Circe7 · 31/12/2023 14:43

@MrNovember
And a couple each earning minimum wage working full time would bring home c.£3k per month net and probably get some benefits. There is a significant penalty within the tax system to being a single income household.

MrNovember · 31/12/2023 13:44

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 16:00

£65k not a huge income? It’s like a parallel universe on here sometimes.

If OP is in London or another high cost area then it’s really not.

take home is about £3600. She already pays £2k in childcare, leaving her £1600 to live on. If she lives in London then that £1600 will be swallowed up by rent / mortgage. Not to mention everything else she needs to live

Wateroverwine · 31/12/2023 13:38

DonnaBanana · 31/12/2023 11:42

It is a very silly policy. Surely the government wants to encourage people to have children as they’ll be future tax payers and the ones paying towards our pensions one day. To then dissuade the most accomplished and well earning people from having children is ridiculous because they are more likely to raise children who aren’t a net burden on the state. It’s back to front really. They should be encouraging high earners to have more children to fill the demographic gap

Agree as well but people will disagree because for whatever reason, some don't believe having children is a choice with all the birth control methods out there. If you can't afford children don't have them.

Wateroverwine · 31/12/2023 13:35

Absolutely unfair as you're contributing however the government see this as having children is your choice. We are lucky to get anything for having children, in other countries that's why you always have to be married before giving birth

Not agreeing with it but just see it as it's a choice you made you need to deal with it