Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Top 500 runners at parkrun unfair on female runners?

215 replies

MrsPCR · 30/12/2023 13:12

Every parkrun event has a list of its top 500 fastest runners; however, our local event is gradually just becoming a list of men! There are only 25 women on the list, and the number is constantly decreasing. I made it on there for one week, (about 50 women at that point) before a man kicked me off. I'd now need to run over a minute faster than my PB in less than 21m30 to get back on the list.

YABU - all is fair, it's fastest 500 runners.
YANBU - this is not acknowledging women's achievements or physiological differences.

OP posts:
puncheur · 03/01/2024 16:05

@BogRollBOGOF the volunteer marshals have no idea what name, age, or indeed sex category you have registered on the parkrun website under. There's no registration or sign-on like in a conventional race, you just get your barcode scanned as you cross the finishing line. When you scan a runner's barcode the app doesn't display any identifiable details about that runner - it just sends the barcode ID and time off to the parkrun website.

MrsJamin · 03/01/2024 15:56

@BogRollBOGOF what if it was clear to run directors that someone was saying they were a completely different age? What do they do if there's a teenager rocking up to parkrun? There must be situations where they have to intervene to protect the fairness for everyone? Also it was the fact that, as I said, there was a bloody email saying that for a subset of people, they are being encouraged to lie in their parkrun form? It's not even about people registering incorrectly without parkrun's endorsement.

puncheur · 02/01/2024 10:30

@BogRollBOGOF your observation about sex differences in children will come as absolutely no surprise to anyone involved in children's endurance sport. Sex differences are non-existent pre-puberty, girls get a slight advantage as they hit puberty earlier, then the boys catch up and power away.

BogRollBOGOF · 01/01/2024 23:50

Looking at my parkrun, #54/500 is the fastest woman. On the day she set that, she set the world female parkrun record. There's 23 women on the list.

As pure fact it's interesting seeing that context, and there are other more useful data provided too with the age gradings and sub 20/ 17 lists.

Interestingly, the top 500 list at my junior parkrun is far more balanced. Fastest female is #15. In the u10 category, the sex makes little difference, and in the 11-14, the girls get a temporary boost at the lower end of the range, and it's about 13-14 when the male advantage emerges.

I'm a very average runner and will never get on those lists. I love the fact that I can see how average I am for my class, aim to beat my own pbs, jog or walk around at my own pace and just rock up on a Saturday morning. It always has been a timed run, always has been keen on producing data, and always has valued participation.

The gender self-ID is a seperate issue, but as much as it stinks that men can self ID as women and claim times that can only be matched by elite women, I don't know what practical action parkrun could take to manage it. It's not going to be clear at the finish line, or barcode scanning stage, and by the time the results are published each week it would be hard to piece together that a result is claimed by a gender that doesn't match the sex. RDs spend hours each week making the events happen without risking incurring political wrath. It's not just about an HQ policy, it's about thousands of volunteers being able to uphold it each week.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 01/01/2024 23:28

From the website. Not competitive.

parkrun is a free, community event where you can walk, jog, run, volunteer or spectate. parkrun is 5k and takes place every Saturday morning. junior parkrun is 2k, dedicated to 4-14 year olds and their families, every Sunday morning.
parkrun is positive, welcoming and inclusive, there is no time limit and no one finishes last

You're welcome to treat it as a competition, that's up to you but it's off to try and get everyone else to as well. They are inclusive to people who are trans. If you don't like that, find a race that isn't or set up your own race.

If it's only a fun run and results are irrelevant why have them at all?
To compare your scores to your past ones and try and beat your personal best.

Fizbosshoes · 01/01/2024 23:08

Yeah, that's not going to happen though is it, because not all women see Park Run as a bloody competitive race.

Firstly it's parkrun - small p all one word
Secondly why should women (actual biological women) only be able to treat it as an inclusive fun run...while men can do as a fun run or as a competitive race.
If it's only a fun run and results are irrelevant why have them at all?

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 01/01/2024 22:36

One day I think women should all re-register for parkrun and either put their ages as way later and get all the age grading accolades, or put themselves down as children and run junior parkrun or get the kids accolades
Yeah, that's not going to happen though is it, because not all women see Park Run as a bloody competitive race.
Go moan about you know, actual competitive races instead of expecting an inclusive for everyone fun run to bend to you.

MrsJamin · 01/01/2024 22:11

Imagine if strava or parkrun emailed members with a story about how a 35 year old man feels like a 60 year old and they explain that the 35 year old can change their age on the app/website to 60 so they can feel more authentically themselves. What would all the men feel and say then? This is the very organisation themselves endorsing recording of personal data that is incorrect. Personal data that other members rely on as honest and truthful data.

One day I think women should all re-register for parkrun and either put their ages as way later and get all the age grading accolades, or put themselves down as children and run junior parkrun or get the kids accolades.

puncheur · 01/01/2024 20:45

Runkittyrun · 01/01/2024 10:20

Some of the Strava QOM are held by men because Strava also allows self-id.

I mean, yeah. It also allows you to self declare your name, age, weight etc with no checks in place because it’s just an app that the majority of users don’t even pay for. Everyone local to a segment will know when a QOM/KOM is dodgy though (bloody e-bikes!) and will flag them.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/01/2024 16:01

I'd keep the fastest 500 runners but have male and female categories - after all, they have the sections for under 17 and under 20 mins, 17 for men and 20 for women.

As for Strava, I no longer subscribe due to their allowing men to take QOMs.

xsquared · 01/01/2024 11:45

I didn't think it was possible to waste even more time looking at yet more stats after a parkrun, and like a pp, I have never looked at the Top 500 fastest runners for a local course until this thread.

Having looked at mine, there are 22 female runners, with only one being in the top 100 at a time of 16:32, who is a female bodied female. You need to have a time of faster than 18:16 to make it on that list.

As many have already said before, we need to have two lists where it's segregated strictly by sex and not gender. It won't stop those who are trans registering as the opposite sex which isn't fair, but 249 out of 250 female bodied women on that list is better than 22 out of 500 for comparison.

Or get rid of the fastest runners list altogether. You already have the results for that day and your own results are stored from previous weeks so analyse your performance that way.

Runkittyrun · 01/01/2024 10:20

puncheur · 01/01/2024 09:29

@YellowMeeple thanks, found it. TBH I had no idea it existed. The results are predictable, only 38 women in top 500 and fastest is at 68 with an 18:13. I don’t really understand the point, should be separate lists for men and women, like Strava has separate KOM and QOM rankings for each segment. Basically this is a top 500 men ranking, with a few honourable mentions.

Some of the Strava QOM are held by men because Strava also allows self-id.

puncheur · 01/01/2024 09:29

@YellowMeeple thanks, found it. TBH I had no idea it existed. The results are predictable, only 38 women in top 500 and fastest is at 68 with an 18:13. I don’t really understand the point, should be separate lists for men and women, like Strava has separate KOM and QOM rankings for each segment. Basically this is a top 500 men ranking, with a few honourable mentions.

JanefromLondon1 · 01/01/2024 08:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 01/01/2024 08:23

DewHopper · 01/01/2024 00:50

Seriously you have outed yourself as a massive misogynist on this thread. Just stop.

Nothing misogynistic at all. The numbers are simply the numbers and reflect the times achieved by the runners. Zero interpretation applied, zero bias. Stop seeking injustice where it doesn’t exist.

RunningAndSinging · 01/01/2024 07:23

It is the top 500 ever on that course. There are a few similar lists if you click on the results arrow from the menus on the page for each event. If you click on your own category on any of the results for a particular event you can also see the ranking for everyone in that category who has ever done the course. I think a fastest 500 females list would be a good addition.

SpringleDingle · 01/01/2024 07:04

Most of the park runs we do have very few people!! We did one with 30 recently so everyone would be in the top 500!!

Parkrun is free and run by volunteers, I find it best not to moan about a free thing that I am not volunteering to run!

YellowMeeple · 01/01/2024 06:48

puncheur · 31/12/2023 23:55

OP, I’m confused as to which results page you’re talking about, can you link to an example please? I’m looking at the results and stats pages for our parkrun and I can’t see anything that looks like what you are describing.

If you go to the results menu on any specific parkrun site ‘fastest 500’ is one of the options.

my personal view is it’s not great, would be better if it was fastest 250 women and 250 men but it’s not as an important issue for me as the prioritisation of gender over sex.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 01/01/2024 01:27

People are entitled to different opinions to you, you know.
Just stop? 🙄

DewHopper · 01/01/2024 00:50

Seriously you have outed yourself as a massive misogynist on this thread. Just stop.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 31/12/2023 23:59

There are both men AND women who don’t make the top 500. But just look at the filtered data if you are fearful of raw results.

puncheur · 31/12/2023 23:55

OP, I’m confused as to which results page you’re talking about, can you link to an example please? I’m looking at the results and stats pages for our parkrun and I can’t see anything that looks like what you are describing.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 31/12/2023 23:37

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 31/12/2023 23:29

Your poor daughter
Whoo, we're on the faux concern trying to emotional guilt trip for those who don't agree with you now.
Yawn
Oh and
Biscuit

No you are mistaken. I feel genuine concern for any girl being raised by a man who refers to women as c grade students and doesn't understand equity

But I don't think you will even try to understand that

ZoomerDinosaur · 31/12/2023 23:33

This is NOT a patriarchy / sexism / inclusivity issue at all - the fastest 500 are simply the fastest 500.

The fastest 500 list is obviously intended to be aspirational and a way for people who want to be competitive or to attain a goal, to work towards that.

Because of the way biology works, the top spot, and probably most of the top 500, will always go to a male runner. So the male runners get an idea of the fastest times and how much work they need to put in to place next time.

The competitive male runners, therefore, get a source of motivation that is not open to the competitive female runners.

The obvious solution is to split by sex. That way both male and female runners get equal motivation to climb the rankings, and if you want the overall fastest times you can just look at the men's.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 31/12/2023 23:29

Your poor daughter
Whoo, we're on the faux concern trying to emotional guilt trip for those who don't agree with you now.
Yawn
Oh and
Biscuit

Swipe left for the next trending thread