Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.. to point out the folly of insisting children must "clear their plate"

116 replies

5foot5 · 30/12/2023 12:43

Hopefully this attitude to children's eating habits is a thing of the past, but just in case, here we go.

We currently have elderly FIL staying with us over the Christmas and New Year period. He lives alone but comes to stay with us quite regularly. He is in his 90s now and, like many elderly people, his appetite has shrunk and he can't manage more than a small helping. If he eats too much he will typically be awake all night with indegestion and want nothing to eat the next day other than tea and toast.

I am mindful of this when serving meals and either put food out so he can serve himself or, if it is a meal to be plated up, I try to give him a small portion. But sometimes I guess we misjudge. Last night it appears was one of those occasions and this morning he is looking sorry for himself.

The thing is he ALWAYS clears his plate.

Now I have a small appetite, always have had since I was a child and still do in my 60s. Fortunately my parents recognised this and never insisted I carried on eating when I had clearly had enough. (Teachers at school dinners sometimes tried to, to no avail.) I don't think we had heard the phrase "self regulation" in the 1960s but I guess this is what I learnt to do. I frequently leave food on my plate if the helping I have been given is too much and don't think twice about it.

When FIL this morning was going on about how we overfeed him I did try saying, as I have many times before, that he doesn't have to eat everything, I won't be at all offended if he leaves what he can't eat, I leave stuff all the time. But I am wasting my breath. The usual comments come out "I hate waste", "It's how I was brought up" and even admitting today "I have been conditioned to do it".

I guess he is not going to change now at nearly 93,but it does seem like such a harmful practice. No matter that you are completely full, that eating more will make you uncomfortable, keep you awake, maybe even make you ill, you nevertheless must plough on and stuff it all down because plates must be cleared. And then it is my fault for giving him too much!

So I suppose I am asking AIBU for thinking this is an out-dated and misguided attitude? And if you do insist on it have you considered the consequences?

OP posts:
Fallenangelofthenorth · 30/12/2023 16:03

You can't compare practices from decades ago when food was scarce to today when it's relatively plentiful. I imagine if we were in a position where we had to go back to rationed food, we'd have to do the same to ensure our children weren't malnourished. It's completely different when you don't know where the next meal is coming from - you HAVE to eat everything and waste nothing.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 30/12/2023 16:02

I was bought up poor, you can damn well be sure that if we had a full plate of food that I would eat it all no matter what, as we could never be sure when another decent sized meal was coming.

I don't force my kids to finish their plate, but I don't give them stupid amounts either. My 11yo eats like a baby bird, my 12yo has hollow legs and my 14yo has a larger appetite but self regulates.

None are overweight and I think grown ass adults blaming their parents for being overweight as adults is stupid. Granted, they could cause children to be overweight but as adults you are all capable of adjusting your diets and activity levels to lose that weight if you really wanted to.

QueSyrahSyrah · 30/12/2023 16:02

Completely agree OP. As a child it was insisted that plates were cleared especially if we were eating out not for waste but for waste of money; ie: if you didn't eat every scrap you'd not got the full value.

It took me years to train myself to stop eating in a restaurant when I'm comfortably full, and eating out is a much more pleasant experience for it. No longer do I leave feeling stuffed and uncomfortable and with as the lasting memory of the meal.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 30/12/2023 16:00

I was brought up to clear my plate. My Mum was a war baby when food was scarce and this led to some of the things she taught us. You were rude and ungrateful if you left any food on your plate at mealtimes however portion sizes then were not big, especially for women and girls.

It is more likely he just cannot push his plate away due to ingrained behaviour.

NewPinkJacket · 30/12/2023 15:59

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/12/2023 15:47

She does. It's mainly a problem with eating out and eating at other people's houses. It's not the only thing contributing to the problem either.

How often does she eat out and at other people's houses that it makes her overweight? Confused

Mojolostforever · 30/12/2023 15:59

We were not forced, but encouraged to eat everything (this was in the sixties). There was always the comment "think of all the starving children in Africa," which made me so annoyed.

I wanted to say, "parcel it up and send it to them, then."

Did she really think that whether I finished the food or not would make any difference to the children in Africa?

My own children ate as much as they felt like eating.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 30/12/2023 15:59

It depends... If you put food on anyone's plate, you can't expect them to eat it all up.

If however they are in charge of their portion size, I would expect them to eat what is on the plate!

NoTouch · 30/12/2023 15:57

I am fat because I put too much and the wrong food on my plate, I am an adult and for 90% of my meals I decide how much goes on the plate. I could choose, if I over indulged the previous day, to put less food on my plate.

Nothing to do with, and I won't blame my poor mum trying to make her 5 fussy children eat the food they were served - which was veg heavy as it was cheaper than meat - so none was wasted and she didn't have to pander to or have the expense of different snack requests later.

Being made to clear you plate as a child is the tiniest drop in the ocean of problems why people like me are obese nowadays.

Icelandic9 · 30/12/2023 15:50

I've always felt the same about having 3 structured meals a day too. Sometimes you don't need 3, sometimes you need more than 3.

MereDintofPandiculation · 30/12/2023 15:49

I was brought up to clear my plate, both-at home and at school. Can’t say it had any effect, probably because I totally ignored the ruling. My tolerance of sitting list in my own thoughts with a plate of congealing dinner in front of me far exceeded the patience of any adult.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/12/2023 15:49

LaughterTitsoff · 30/12/2023 14:59

People can actually get themselves off of heroin and alcohol addiction.

She can stop clearing her plate if she tries.

And some people are addicts for life. One person being able to achieve something doesn't mean someone else can. Humans are very complex creatures.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/12/2023 15:47

x2boys · 30/12/2023 15:38

As an adult she can give herself smaller portions surely ?

She does. It's mainly a problem with eating out and eating at other people's houses. It's not the only thing contributing to the problem either.

MereDintofPandiculation · 30/12/2023 15:45

Very few people plate up food differently for women even though they have smaller appetites & BMIs. There was an AIBU post a year or so back in which everyone piled on to say how outrageous it was that MIL gave larger helpings to the men.

There's a difference between being wasteful and having someone incorrectly guess how hungry you were when they dished up! The only difference is in who is being wasteful

In our house there's no such thing as "hungry for yoghurt/bananas/crackers/snacks/cheerios" but not "not hungry for more nutritious food eg vegetables, meat, fish, beans". What we used to call “nice hungry” as opposed to “hungry”

x2boys · 30/12/2023 15:38

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/12/2023 14:36

Yes it's a terrible thing to instill in kids. I have a friend who has a big problem with her weight and she can't not clear her plate because it's just so conditioned into her. She's making sure she doesn't do the same to her kids. For your FIL I suggest never putting food on his plate for him, regardless of what it is, always put it in a serving dish and let him help himself. I've done this as an approach to help my fussy child, to the point where if two kids are each having a burger I put two burgers in a serving dish and they take one each. They can leave some on their plate though, you may need to consider cutting things up for your FIL. At his age he is unlikely to be able to change.

As an adult she can give herself smaller portions surely ?

ToWhitToWhoo · 30/12/2023 15:37

YANBU. It can cause or reinforce very negative attitudes to food, if children are forced to eat things that they hate. And no doubt it often trains children to ignore their own sensations of being 'full' and contributes to later obesity.

It didn't happen to me, but it did to friends of mine, especially at school. I have heard several stories about children reacting to force-feeding by being sick all over the teacher or dinner-lady!

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 30/12/2023 15:36

We were never told as kids to clean the plate we were always asked to make a decent effort and to eat our veggies especially. I’m the same with my kids now

2024fit · 30/12/2023 15:32

User4363463 · 30/12/2023 13:29

I find the correlation between etiquette and bodily autonomy utterly bonkers. So many people take it as the rudest of social gestures if someone doesn't finish their plate, or worse every course of the meal. Yet if they serve up massive portions that it would make guests sick to finish it all, how the fuck is that supposed to work? It's honestly mind boggling. And portion size is almost always based on an adult male, which is patriarchal bullshit. Very few people plate up food differently for women even though they have smaller appetites & BMIs. Exactly the same for kids. It's shocking how often small children get a full plate of food roughly the same as for adults and are forced to clean it.

I don't have any history of ED but just a small appetite and genuinely enjoy food. However I hate social eating because I always feel obliged to eat until I feel sick in order to satisfy other people's ideas of "politeness". It takes the joy and fun out of everything. Needless to say I don't enforce any sort of that bullshit with my kids. They get kid-sized portions and can eat whatever or however much they want. They are never made to feel guilty if they don't or can't finish their food.

Edited

Completely agree. In primary school I remember one kid spilling milk over his chips and a teacher forcing him to eat it anyway. Absolutely vile.

I have family from another country and when I stayed them with the last time they were constantly forcing food upon me. I was just lying about the whole day in the heat so didn’t have much of an appetite yet they’d insist on serving massive bowls of porridge for breakfast and large dinners etc. that was 9 years ago, if that happened again I’d put my foot down and be quite blunt about it.

Fern86 · 30/12/2023 15:27

RowanMayfair · 30/12/2023 12:49

It's a terrible practice with kids. I was brought up this way and still struggle to leave food if I'm full. Needless to say I'm overweight!

I came here to say the same!

now with my little one as soon as he says he done it’s ok no problem!
sometimes he eats it all, sometimes only manages a few mouthfuls - I know he won’t starve! I let him listen to his on body rather than me telling him he needs to eat more.

Blondebutnotlegally · 30/12/2023 15:26

Calmdown14 · 30/12/2023 15:10

Bit on the fence with this.

If I have served up a reasonable sized meal and the kids have only fished out the best bits and are ignoring veg that they are known to like, I will make them eat more. Sometimes this is to clear it, other times a couple of mouthfuls.

But if we go out and the portion is massive I don't care as long as they have a reasonable stab.

I think for absolutely everything it's a bit much but there's nothing wrong with insisting they eat more of food which sometimes requires a bit more effort/is healthy than having them ask for snacks five minutes later. If I didn't require a bit more from my kids they would probably eat about three mouthfuls, especially if green things feature!

Would the better way to go about it be to feed them smaller portions and not let them have anymore chicken or potatoes for example until they've eaten their broccoli? I'm trying this with my toddler and it's working thus far 😂

Guess it depends how stubborn your children are! One of mine will go hungry to avoid the veg!

Blondebutnotlegally · 30/12/2023 15:23

You can't change his habits of a lifetime at 93. All you can do is the polite thing of putting less on his plate.

And let's raise our kids different so at 93 they aren't shovelling food down thay they don't want!

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 15:19

In some cultures where poverty is common, it is/was the custom when a guest in someone's house, to always leave something on the plate to indicate that your hosts have given you enough to eat. If you ate everything that would indicate that you were still hungry and they would keep giving you more, which could leave them short of food.

Flyingsunflower · 30/12/2023 15:14

Our Dc are encouraged to serve themselves however much they want but they have to finish what they put on their plate,easy. Not eating with your eyes. If they are served food they know to say it's too much before they touch it, nobody will be offended.

AvengedQuince · 30/12/2023 15:14

platinumplus · 30/12/2023 15:03

One of my friends still does it. Everyone forced to sit at the table until everyone has cleared their plate.

Depends if she has already accounted for appetite. I mean I never forced a child to finish but I would encourage them to eat an adequate amount knowing their appetite. Some will eat a decent amount of a favourite meal but pretend they aren't hungry for something that isn't a favourite. Then go on about being starving for a snack later 🙄 .

Tree12 · 30/12/2023 15:10

I always clear my plate - I find it so hard to stop when I’m full. But with my kids, the mantra is stop when you’re full.

Calmdown14 · 30/12/2023 15:10

Bit on the fence with this.

If I have served up a reasonable sized meal and the kids have only fished out the best bits and are ignoring veg that they are known to like, I will make them eat more. Sometimes this is to clear it, other times a couple of mouthfuls.

But if we go out and the portion is massive I don't care as long as they have a reasonable stab.

I think for absolutely everything it's a bit much but there's nothing wrong with insisting they eat more of food which sometimes requires a bit more effort/is healthy than having them ask for snacks five minutes later. If I didn't require a bit more from my kids they would probably eat about three mouthfuls, especially if green things feature!