Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.. to point out the folly of insisting children must "clear their plate"

116 replies

5foot5 · 30/12/2023 12:43

Hopefully this attitude to children's eating habits is a thing of the past, but just in case, here we go.

We currently have elderly FIL staying with us over the Christmas and New Year period. He lives alone but comes to stay with us quite regularly. He is in his 90s now and, like many elderly people, his appetite has shrunk and he can't manage more than a small helping. If he eats too much he will typically be awake all night with indegestion and want nothing to eat the next day other than tea and toast.

I am mindful of this when serving meals and either put food out so he can serve himself or, if it is a meal to be plated up, I try to give him a small portion. But sometimes I guess we misjudge. Last night it appears was one of those occasions and this morning he is looking sorry for himself.

The thing is he ALWAYS clears his plate.

Now I have a small appetite, always have had since I was a child and still do in my 60s. Fortunately my parents recognised this and never insisted I carried on eating when I had clearly had enough. (Teachers at school dinners sometimes tried to, to no avail.) I don't think we had heard the phrase "self regulation" in the 1960s but I guess this is what I learnt to do. I frequently leave food on my plate if the helping I have been given is too much and don't think twice about it.

When FIL this morning was going on about how we overfeed him I did try saying, as I have many times before, that he doesn't have to eat everything, I won't be at all offended if he leaves what he can't eat, I leave stuff all the time. But I am wasting my breath. The usual comments come out "I hate waste", "It's how I was brought up" and even admitting today "I have been conditioned to do it".

I guess he is not going to change now at nearly 93,but it does seem like such a harmful practice. No matter that you are completely full, that eating more will make you uncomfortable, keep you awake, maybe even make you ill, you nevertheless must plough on and stuff it all down because plates must be cleared. And then it is my fault for giving him too much!

So I suppose I am asking AIBU for thinking this is an out-dated and misguided attitude? And if you do insist on it have you considered the consequences?

OP posts:
DixonD · 30/12/2023 22:04

One of the reasons I had an eating disorder in my teens was down to this - my mum insisted we ate everything or we would be accused of being unwell and sent up to bed, where we were treated as filthy, disgusting children for being ill.

I had such fear at mealtimes that it got to the point I couldn’t physically eat and sometimes made myself sick before dinner. It was awful. I NEVER make my daughter eat everything. She decides when she’s full.

greengreengrass25 · 30/12/2023 22:03

Yanbu

I remember being made to eat things I really didn't want at school or a Brownie pack holiday

Don't agree with it at all and my dm never made me eat anything I didn't want

VikingLady · 30/12/2023 22:02

I believe in WW2 it was illegal to leave food on your plate. There simply wasn't the food to waste. If he was raised with that attitude he likely can't change - it's too deep.

Katemax82 · 30/12/2023 22:01

I thought it was the done thing when my stepsons were young. I made my older stepson vomit once from insisting he eats his dinner and I've never forgiven myself

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/12/2023 21:42

It can go too far in the other direction - the 'mustn't ever eat anything they don't actively beg for/say they're too full to have, give them extra if they say they're hungry later', as that results in children that will reluctantly place a tiny morsel of food on their fork/spoon, possibly let a couple of atoms touch their tongue and declare they're full up, only to say when their feet have barely touched the ground 'I'm hungry. Can I have pudding/a biscuit/sweeties now?'.

ETA: and there's the other version, where you're pressurised to leave food because 'it's not ladylike/elegant/good manners to eat everything'. had that from my ex, it didn't matter if I was starving from a combination of BF and his insistence that you mustn't eat fat or more than one type of plant, I had to leave at least a quarter of it or I'd be bollocked for greediness.

Walkacrossthesand · 30/12/2023 21:24

Looking at plates left on tables in cafes (that I know serve 'normal' size meals), it does look sometimes like people deliberately only eat half the meal they chose & ordered. That, to me, is wasteful - if you know you're not that hungry, why not order just a starter/childrens size meal/whatever?

Girlsjustwannahavefundamentalrights · 30/12/2023 17:54

My parents tried to do this with my kids, after they caused me a lifetime of disordered eating by forcing me to eat everything on my plate growing up. I put a stop to it with my own kids and every time we eat at their house, i loudly remind my children they don't have to eat anything they don't want to.

My mother never, ever cleared her own plate, incidentally.

I would just leave it to FIL to put his own food on his plate. I always prefer to serve myself at other people's homes if it's an option.

CHEESEY13 · 30/12/2023 17:49

I as brought up with the words "there are plenty of starving children who would be glad to eat that!" ringing in my ears.

I would like to have replied "so wrap it up, Mum, and post it to them." But I never, ever had the nerve......

Ilovelurchers · 30/12/2023 17:45

It's really nice to read on this thread almost everybody saying they never force their kids to eat things against their will.

I have read other threads on here where many posters almost brag about the strict rules they enforce with their children regarding having to eat things, whether or not they want to. I have always found it monstrous.

Being forced to eat food that is noxious to you is actually a means of abuse akin to torture often found in the arsenal of horrible domestic abusers. I'd personally rather be slapped in the face than forced to swallow food that repulses me (sadly like many I've experienced both - not from my parents but from an abusive partner as an adult). Yet I have often heard people who consider themselves kind and loving parents in other ways, talk quite happily about completing their children to eat foods they hate.

Thank God people on here have stopped doing it to their children! It's really good to hear.

Thanks for starting this conversation OP. Because if just one new parent reads it, and decides to adapt the feeding approach they were planning to take to a kinder, more healthy one, then this is definitely worth it!

SteveMcqueensJeans · 30/12/2023 17:40

my grandfather was in a Japanese POW camp. almost starved to death just before VJ day. he encouraged my mum and her siblings to clear their plates through sheer fear of hunger that he couldn't get over due to PTSD.
that carries on through my mum who did the same with me and my brothers. my aunt is still a feeder to this day and always plates up so much more than any human should be able to eat.
i haven't done this with my children at all. i have one child who will eat everything infront of him plus extras if i didn't gently keep an eye on them and another who won't even force the last spoonful of ice cream in if they are full.
i do struggle with the idea of waste but i haven't transferred that over to my children.

laclochette · 30/12/2023 17:34

It's such an awful thing to do to kids. I was made to do this as a child (and nobody else was allowed down from the table until I had finished, so everyone was just staring at me irritated and impatient). I would literally feel like I was going to be sick. Eventually I started chewing food but not swallowing it and then spitting it out as soon as I could. Surprise surprise, I ended up with disordered eating later in life.

Boomer55 · 30/12/2023 17:13

LaughterTitsoff · 30/12/2023 14:29

I thought clearing your plate died in the 1970s?

It's what an awful lot of overweight MNetters blame for their weight issues.

I think future overweight MNetters will be blaming their parents constantly feeding them snacks.

Yeah, it did. I grew up in the 50’s/60s when it common. I had my kids mid-70s, and it had gone out of fashion. I can’t say it ever affected me one way or another. Of its time.

LastRites · 30/12/2023 17:07

There was even a lollipop for ‘eating all your meal’ in the roadside Little Chefs when I was growing up!

I remember being told I ‘ate like a bird’ and feeling guilty in restaurants because I could never ever finish my portions. I hate feeling full and will stop before I do - although I love food. I’ll often share food with my boys or husband now which is liberating because there’s no one to make me feel like I’m wasting money or food! We’ve always told our boys to ‘eat what they want’ and have never praised or chastised for finished or unfinished meals.

Icannoteven · 30/12/2023 16:54

Yanbu. I wish this wisdom would trickle down to the thicko dinner ladies at my daughters schools. The youngest’s school gives out stickers for clean plates and the eldest’s school will not let them out for playtime until they have eaten what they deem enough 🫤. It makes me so angry!

greglet · 30/12/2023 16:48

@User4363463 I’m a tall, thin, greedy woman and I would lose my shit if I were served a smaller portion than the men at the table just because I’m female.

EarlGreywithLemon · 30/12/2023 16:40

Very few people plate up food differently for women even though they have smaller appetites
No, not all women have small appetites. I don’t and neither does my mother (we are both slim before anyone says anything). I need a proper size portion or else I feel faint by mid morning or mid afternoon. So please don’t assume everyone is the same!

I pack dried fruit and crackers if I know I’m staying in one of those households that do male and female portions.

I suppose one thing is that I was brought up that the default desert is fruit, and snacks are olives, carrots or more fruit. We do the same at home and have sweet pudding once a week, or twice max. We never eat crisps, biscuits, or chocolate bars - don’t even have them in the house. So the “main course” has to be substantial enough to keep us going.

thecatsthecats · 30/12/2023 16:29

Farwell · 30/12/2023 14:16

I was brought up this way. I am not overweight. As an adult, it is up to me to stop eating when I choose and not blame someone else, whether they are my parent, me theirs, or other unrelated adult.

You are not going to change a 93 year old though.

How is it possible to change your ways as an adult, but not as a 93 yo? Make your mind up on whether you're ageist or not.

Rockrobon · 30/12/2023 16:20

Yes totally agree! I have taught my kids to stop eating when their ‘tummy is full’. Whereas whenever my dm or mil are here it’s all ‘no pudding if you don’t finish your dinner’ etc. Or some nice bribing ‘if you finish that then you can have some ice cream’. So basically they want them to keep eating. even though they’re already full, and then have ice cream on top of that? It really irritates me.
Same with not forcing things to eat things they don’t like, I encourage them to try everything and not just say ‘I don’t like that’ and mostly do eat everything. But I have awful memories of being forced to eat food I genuinely didn’t like when young.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 30/12/2023 16:19

x2boys · 30/12/2023 14:07

If your FIL is in his 90,s he will have Been a teen/ young adult during the war when food was home cooked and there were shortages waste would have been frowned upon
I don't think it's sill common practice to insist children clear their plates .

Edited

Absolutely this…then they brought up my generation to clear our plates….and then we ended up with weight/food issues and swore not to do that to our kids!
The end 😂

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 30/12/2023 16:17

I never leave anything (unless I don't like it)
This is no judgement on others btw - my weight makes it very obvious I am not a food leaver.....😆

Jom222 · 30/12/2023 16:11

Yanbu but his generation grew up when food was often scarce so its ingrained in them not to waste food. They also saved tinfoil, string, all the stuff we just throw away after use.

Poverty creates lifelong habits, some good some bad.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/12/2023 16:08

NewPinkJacket · 30/12/2023 15:59

How often does she eat out and at other people's houses that it makes her overweight? Confused

As I said, it's not the only thing contributing to the problem.

Fionaville · 30/12/2023 16:08

I've never said it to my kids, because I can't leave food on my plate. I don't think I was made to finish my food growing up, but our portions were smaller so I naturally did and in my 40s I still can't break the habit. So I understand the predicament. I enjoy my food and will keep eating until the plate is clear, even when I'm fit to burst! It would feel so wrong to leave food on the plate. I plate up smaller portions now, but at restaurants with big portions, it's all getting eaten regardless of comfort level.

AvengedQuince · 30/12/2023 16:05

Fallenangelofthenorth · 30/12/2023 16:03

You can't compare practices from decades ago when food was scarce to today when it's relatively plentiful. I imagine if we were in a position where we had to go back to rationed food, we'd have to do the same to ensure our children weren't malnourished. It's completely different when you don't know where the next meal is coming from - you HAVE to eat everything and waste nothing.

In many households food is not plentiful today. It's not just a problem in the past.

AvengedQuince · 30/12/2023 16:03

NewPinkJacket · 30/12/2023 15:59

How often does she eat out and at other people's houses that it makes her overweight? Confused

I also don't get it. If I eat more because I'm out, then I am less hungry at the next meal or the following day. I had Christmas dinner at 2:30 but then skipped dinner for example.