Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth some MNetters ever saw in these men?

211 replies

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 16:48

TerrysChocolateBorangejuice · 30/12/2023 16:32

Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.

No they aren't.

I wasn't, my mother wasn't, my daughter wasn't, my grand-daughters aren't and none of the women in my (or my husband's) family were either.

Funny thing is, my grandmanwas very independent and raised my mum to be so.

Unfortunately, my mum disagreed and chose to he completely subservient to men. She tried (and failed) to raise me similarly. I have raised my daughter to he independent.

And that includes not letting men do exactly as they want.

maddiemookins16mum · 30/12/2023 16:43

I agree some don’t start out like that. However there are some women who unfortunately (for many different reasons) would rather just put up with having a Cocklodger husband/partner than being single, especially as they get older.

Rocksonabeach · 30/12/2023 16:42

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/12/2023 12:12

@SusanKennedyshouldLTB loads of women post on here saying that their partner absolutely was fine pre children, or if they were a bit lazy and selfish, so was the woman..being double income no kids is a great lifestyle. You can game or cycle or go to the gym 5 days a week. Hypothetical conversations about how things will change are easy and for whatever reason, probably the enforced changes during pregnancy these changes come more easily to the woman. It's wrong to blame woman for assuming their partner, with whom they have chosen to settle down with, won't change and adapt as they are. How about we blame the men for not stepping up?

Mine started off complimenting me on my independence and career etc and stepped up rapidly and also had his own hobbies but for example my ex was a keen cyclist and he said he would take a step back once children were in the picture and even said this to everyone at his club and his parents. Baby born and me very ill but he then gave me a choice I could go out to the gym or he would as we both didn’t need to be there. So every night he was out training I didn’t want to and never had - at the weekends the argument was always he’s worked hard all week so wants a long bike ride Saturday am and Sunday am - that me doing all the childcare. After a 4 hours bike ride each day on the weekend he then wanted to clean his car, prepare work for the following week or …. Relax but certainly not do family stuff. He liked the idea of being in love, married, having a family …. But it wasn’t something he could do. I do think most men don’t realise what a slog it is and how much grunt work goes on

TerrysChocolateBorangejuice · 30/12/2023 16:32

Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.

No they aren't.

I wasn't, my mother wasn't, my daughter wasn't, my grand-daughters aren't and none of the women in my (or my husband's) family were either.

BertieBotts · 30/12/2023 16:20

James Cleverly presumably did not make any date rape 'jokes' before he married, for example.

I don't know who he is so unsure of the context of this. But every single man I knew in the 00s made date rape jokes. That was "how men talk". Objecting to date rape jokes made you "not a cool girl" or a "humourless feminist".

BertieBotts · 30/12/2023 16:09

If you have good role models perhaps it's hard to understand but some of us grew up with very few positive male role models. My idea of what men are like was based on teenage boys at school (mostly awful), my dad (he's OK but I didn't see him very much and I don't think I ever really saw him doing housework), some of my mum's friends (only ever saw snapshots; adult men don't usually befriend teenage children of their friends), my uncle (violent and abusive), my grandad (old fashioned, sexist, though he did take over cooking and cleaning when my grandma got ill).

My mum had been in loads of abusive relationships so only had horror stories about men, which I took for granted (and honestly, I think so did she. I don't think she has high expectations of men. She is constantly amazed if I say anything about what DH is like.)

Society gave me the message: Men are useless/lazy with housework and have to be nagged constantly. Men are hopeless with babies/children. In fact they don't really even want babies or children, like women do. Men are emotionally stunted, and deal with emotions via aggression. Men don't understand or empathise with women. Men find fart jokes funny and like sport and gaming and star wars and superheroes, they definitely don't like the things you like, so you'll never have common interests. Men are constantly gagging for/obsessed with sex and "need" it, very visual, any time they see women it makes them want sex, it's unfair to tease them, OTOH you can use this to manipulate them, it's basically your only advantage so might as well use it. So empowerfulising!!!

I really had this impression that men are basically an entirely different, mysterious species, that you have to relate to in a wholly different way to how you relate to women, and they were basically all a bit shit so it was unfortunate because if you were attracted to men you had to put up with a load of crap in order to get the good parts of a relationship. Weirdly I did actually know I was attracted to women as a teenager but hardly anyone my age was out back then, so I didn't really consider dating girls as a realistic possibility.

My mum also used to rave about books like "Men are from Mars" which did not entirely dispel the myth.

Because I had such a low bar for men in general I tended to think if I met someone who was tidy, OR who wasn't constantly burping/farting/obsessed with sport, OR who showed a genuine interest in having children (etc) that this was some kind of special rare unicorn, the idea of looking for all of these things in one man just never even occurred to me that it was possible, it didn't compute.

Also, first teenage boyfriends, you don't think about housework etc at that age. And I was fairly messy and lazy at that age too so it was actually fairly likely that most boys were tidier than me Blush

But also I have observed that a lot of people in general, when they are young they throw their clothes on the floor and they go out drinking and they eat crap and they smoke and they have unproductive hobbies and they might take drugs on occasion etc. But I can't think of a single female friend who has stuck to this past about their mid twenties. They settle down, they get more grown up. I think that because women often do this we sort of assume that men will do this too - but they don't seem to do it in the same way. I do know men who went from the loud, lazy, laddish type to a decent, kind, grown up adult - but the vast vast majority, they either don't do this at all and stick with the student type habits all their life, or they change in response to a female partner because she doesn't put up with it. Or they were never like that at all in the first place.

In fact this is going to sound absolutely neanderthal Blush but I think National Service really fulfilled this role well for a lot of men of my grandad's generation. Having that experience of the army discipline really instilled in them a sense of morality about laziness, cleanliness, tidiness, manners etc.

LlynTegid · 30/12/2023 15:31

It is not that hard for someone to put on a front for a few years and then revert to their old self. Same as those who are good people at work until they have worked for two years and have employment protections making them more difficult to dismiss.

Or say that they have changed and someone believes them, putting their historic behaviour before the relationship down to youth or their former wife/partner.

James Cleverly presumably did not make any date rape 'jokes' before he married, for example.

C1N1C · 30/12/2023 15:28

Marrying the hot, charismatic alpha male, who thinks they're God's gift... only to find out those men think they're 'above' this sort of work, and that it's a woman's job?

Usually the same people who have friend-zoned the actual nice guys who might not be a '10', but then complain later in life when these nice men have gone on to marry less shallow women. These men are then appreciative of the attention, and as such, actually put effort into the relationship...

To continue the theme of this post :)

Daleksatemyshed · 30/12/2023 15:15

Much as I'm usually firmly on the side of the women with rubbish DP/DH's there are posts where I wonder what possessed them. Men who take drugs, who drink too much, who spend every penny they earn on their hobby, who have children with multiple women and the woman thought when they had a baby together it would be different. Usually the man says he'll give up his bad habits and low and behold, once she's pregnant nothing changes. I'd like MN to head up every page with" Words are cheap, actions are what matter "

Mirrorballsocial · 30/12/2023 15:00

Kwasi · 30/12/2023 12:37

When DS was born, literally nothing changed for my husband. DS is 5.5 now and two weeks ago was the first time I was 'allowed' to leave him with DH while I went to the supermarket.

Sounds like you should have divorced him about 5 years ago then. Why would you possibly continue to put up with this and stay married? Is it not just massively unappealing?

Mirrorballsocial · 30/12/2023 14:56

arethereanyleftatall · 30/12/2023 11:42

Because for the many many women with low self esteem who have been socially conditioned to believe it, having a man, absolutely any man, means they've 'won'.

I think this is so true. I don't think it's true that many don't start that way or have significant red flags. Teh relationships I know that have problems or have broken up all had problematic behaviour early on.

But I do feel this behaviour is largely normalised, women are made to feel hysterical if they react to small things (which will turn into big things). I think a lot is low self esteem, but also even without that the social conditioning is very real.

WavingCatsandDogs · 30/12/2023 14:44

arethereanyleftatall · 30/12/2023 11:42

Because for the many many women with low self esteem who have been socially conditioned to believe it, having a man, absolutely any man, means they've 'won'.

^ This. And the men think we should be grateful too.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 14:36

StickyProblem · 30/12/2023 13:35

Some men's misogynistic views only become apparent in particular circumstances. I knew someone who lived with her DP, they shared chores quite happily, both worked, then they got married. As soon as he had a "wife" he stopped doing anything, clothes thrown on the floor, nothing done in the kitchen etc. They came back from it but it took counselling. Having a baby can turn men into menchildren as the dynamic changes in the house.

I don't disagree that this happens. Amd it's shit when it does.

But these aren't the situations the OP is talking about. If someone fundamentally changes (or eventually reverts to type) with no sign of it before and, of course, that's all on him.

But there are many women who have all the information they need about a man long before co-habitation, marriage or babies are on the cards and still continue with it hoping they'll change.

In the relationships you describe - where chores are shared equally, they are respected etc, the women take the next step assuming they won't.

feellikeanalien · 30/12/2023 14:35

As another pp has mentioned I also do think there can be an element of feeling that she will be the one to change him. There are some women who think that they can change their OH into what they would like him to be rather than what he actually is and when they finally realise that this is not going to happen it is more difficult to leave. There may be children involved or it may be difficult financially.

One thing I have learned is that the old MN cliche "When someone shows you who they are believe them" is so true. I think sometimes when you are in the first flushes of lust it is easy to overlook certain things and believe that you can change them but this very rarely happens.

LolaSmiles · 30/12/2023 14:23

Some men change over time, especially once children arrive.

Some men were always selfish man-children but their partner overlooked these qualities or minimised them, only for them to become really obvious when he didn't step up a gear after having children.

Some men are happy doing their fair share but once they get used to a wife on maternity leave they conveniently decide they're not going to go back to doing what they did before, especially if wife goes part time.

Some men were selectively incompetent from the start and the woman didn't mind because she enjoyed making the house nice so she chose to ignore the lazy and selfish behaviour. Fast forward 5-10 years and keeping a house nice with a useless husband and 2 kids is a chore.

Some men have red flags all over them but some women decide that they'll be the one to change him / it will be different with them / they'll not be like his ex.

Some woman have such a low bar for men, for a range of reasons, that simply breathing and not being violent is enough to make him a catch.

Some women would rather be in a relationship with an arse than be single because they feel they need to be in a relationship.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 30/12/2023 14:19

My dad was an equal partner around the house. He worked shifts and had been in the Army, so he'd learned to do a lot of 'household' stuff for himself, so he just carried on doing them once he was married to my mum. They both worked, although my mum stopped when my brother and I were born until my brother went to school, and after that they split the housework.

I thought all men were like that. I genuinely thought that was how life went, that husband and wife did most jobs equally. Which was why it came as a huge shock when DC2 came along and my husband, essentially, 'downed tools'. I had no way of dealing with it, because I'd never seen it modelled; it had never needed to be.

My XH went on to marry a woman who very firmly put him in his place and made him pull his weight in the way that I should have done the first time he put his plate on the floor or dropped dirty laundry or told me that getting up to the kids every night was 'my job'. I wished I'd known then how to really put my foot down.

MammaTo · 30/12/2023 14:18

I must admit I do often think the same. I say all this from a very privileged position - 2 very loving parents and an amazing partner now. Sometimes I wonder whether it’s to do with how you was raised maybe? Sometimes I think people long so much for a “normal” family if they’ve been deprived of one that they’ll settle for anyone in the hope of getting it.

FayCarew · 30/12/2023 14:14

refusing to help Because women expect the men to help when they should expect the men to pull their weight.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 30/12/2023 14:14

User135644 · 30/12/2023 14:10

Yeah, women have agency and are accountable for their own choices, saying they aren't is misogyny in itself and not feminist. Who women choose to have kids with is such an important decision, as it impacts on the child and the next generation.

Men are also accountable for their own actions.

This!

Both women and men 'change' as they age, experiences, health, and general development will mean a person at 25 won't be the same at 45. The problem is when those developing character traits are negative rather than positive, and the balance shifts in a relationship.
Both sexes need to take responsibility for their life decisions. 100+ years of feminism yet still some women prefer to shout 'victim blame' rather than accept agency for their own lives. Men are 💯 responsible for their own behaviour and should always be accountable, but women are too. Unacceptable behaviour shouldn't be tolerated by either sex.

User135644 · 30/12/2023 14:10

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/12/2023 14:02

Boys experience childhood trauma just as equally as girls do, but it’s rare that anyone defends men’s behaviour because it’s the result of trauma or negative patterns they learned in childhood. We quite rightly now believe men should be held accountable for their behaviour and believe they should shoulder the responsibility for choosing to make better choices rather than rely on others making excuses for it. If we’re going to change things then it does women no favours not to do likewise, whilst being sympathetic in doing so as to how difficult it is - for both sexes - to move beyond ingrained learned behaviour.

Yeah, women have agency and are accountable for their own choices, saying they aren't is misogyny in itself and not feminist. Who women choose to have kids with is such an important decision, as it impacts on the child and the next generation.

Men are also accountable for their own actions.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 30/12/2023 14:09

I do think it can get worse when you have children. When you don't have kids, it is relatively easy to work full time, do some chores and still have a time consuming hobby like gaming etc. You may even be able to afford to buy in a bit of help, like a cleaner. I also think if the woman is picking up a bit more of the slack in this scenario, they may not even notice, necessarily, or care as much, because it is manageable?

Obviously, with young children that dynamic changes complete, and for anyone sensible, the hobby time has to be cut. But some people (often men) can't cope with that, and push more and more onto the woman. And then the woman pushes back and you get the sulking/guilt tripping type dynamic etc. But at that point there are young children and it's hard to leave etc...

I do also think the bar is still a lot lower for men in many ways e.g. pre kids a man who cooks regularly but never washes up or whatever may be seen as "good"- but later you realise he only cooks when he finds it fun, and isn't going to do a boing mid week tea for the kids, etc etc.

In terms of men who already have children, or who obviously aren't pulling their weight at all, I do think some of it is people who can't cope with being on their own for whatever reason, and feel they have to have a partner, no matter how rubbish!

KimberleyClark · 30/12/2023 14:05

Unfortunately I think some women are prepared to overlook a lot if they are desperate for children. “ He’s not perfect but he’ll have to do because I want kids”.

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/12/2023 14:02

Okitten · 30/12/2023 13:52

But often times it’s childhood trauma that is unseen by the victim that leads them to subconsciously seek out a partner who will make them re-experience that childhood traumatic relationship with the hope of making it ‘right’ this time. People can’t even see that they’re doing this so it’s not weak or deliberate in the main.

Boys experience childhood trauma just as equally as girls do, but it’s rare that anyone defends men’s behaviour because it’s the result of trauma or negative patterns they learned in childhood. We quite rightly now believe men should be held accountable for their behaviour and believe they should shoulder the responsibility for choosing to make better choices rather than rely on others making excuses for it. If we’re going to change things then it does women no favours not to do likewise, whilst being sympathetic in doing so as to how difficult it is - for both sexes - to move beyond ingrained learned behaviour.

Ihadenough22 · 30/12/2023 13:59

I know some people who think they are nothing without a man because they are bought up this way by family or it important to get married in their part of society. One of my friends was at a family wedding about 20 years ago and one of her aunt's made a comment - we never see you with anyone. My friend at the time was apox 30 and single. She pretended she did not hear this comment but it was hurtful at the time. Most of her friends and relatives around her age were in relationships or getting married.

My friend said afterwards her aunt's husband knew her aunt was financially comfortable when they met and she was sure this helped him marry her.

I don't think anyone wants to tell a woman to stay away from x when they knew that he could chet, lie, gamble, be a heavy drinker or they have noticed the red flags with him. Some woman just refuse to listen to something like this. Then complain when a few years later they are stuck with him because of kids, lack of money ect.

I know men as well that just keep going for the same type of woman and then wonder why things don't work out.

One of my friends was rejected by a man like this and he went on to get another woman pregnant. This woman had plenty of red flags that he chose to ignore. A few years later he wanted to get into a fwb situation with my friend and she told him they could just be friend's. My friend told me I am not taking him on with all his current baggage and most of his problems are due to not listening to the advice I gave him in the past.

I know parents then put in the work early on so their kids built up good self awareness, confidence and realise what other kids are like. So their kids develop good friendships and keep away from the kids that are bullies, mean ect.
As their kids get older the friends became more important as if you have friends that want to do well in school, go to university they encourage friends to want the same. Then sometimes the friends can see if the new boyfriend/girlfriend is wrong one and tell them I don't like what X said or did.

Okitten · 30/12/2023 13:52

VanityDiesHard · 30/12/2023 13:37

And I think you are making excuses for learned helplessness and women being doormats.

But often times it’s childhood trauma that is unseen by the victim that leads them to subconsciously seek out a partner who will make them re-experience that childhood traumatic relationship with the hope of making it ‘right’ this time. People can’t even see that they’re doing this so it’s not weak or deliberate in the main.