Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth some MNetters ever saw in these men?

211 replies

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

OP posts:
Foxblue · 30/12/2023 20:11

I find it excessively frustrating, tbh.
I also find it frustrating when people come on these threads and go 'men change, abuse ramps up during pregnancy' which are VERY valid points, but it's said as if that's the ONLY thing that happens, that no woman has ever knowingly been with a shit man then had kids with him, like no woman has ever had kids with a shit man, zero responsibility or agency at all, that every case is a man whose duped a woman until they were locked in, and that's just not true, and it's extremely damaging to suggest that it is! We absolutely should be raising awareness that men can change, but it's so deeply unhelpful towards the overall issue to shut conversation down with 'men change, so how dare you imply it's the woman's fault'
Until we can, as women, acknowledge that the two things exist in this discussion - men can present as good and then change, and women do also knowingly have kids with awful men, then we are not able to inspect WHY both these things happen, which is entrenched societal conditioning of both genders, as described very eloquently on these threads - unless we admit and acknowledge it, then we're never going to tackle this problem.

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/12/2023 19:05

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 18:44

You're being incredibly naive OP

They change. Its recognised that abuse often doesn't start until children come along.

As so many people have pointed out, they often do not change which is precisely the problem. The lazy, financially incompetent, sexually incontinent loser who won’t clean the bathroom and thinks ever boss is out to get him won’t want to change nappies or hold down stable employment to support a family.

Far too many women take on a project and realise they can’t make a decent man out of a useless man child. Doesn’t stop loads trying but it’s a fools errand. Adding innocent children to the mix perpetuates the cycle of poor male and female role models. If mum’s a skivvy her sons will treat women that way and her daughters will expect no better.

VanityDiesHard · 30/12/2023 18:51

Bohemond23 · 30/12/2023 18:50

Advice regularly on here to have the child if you want the child infuriates me. NO. Apply some critical thinking before you have the child FFS. If you do then you are much less likely to be in the - together for 3 years with a two year old and he’s a shit or the father that is dodging his responsibilities. The vast majority of women have agency in their lives nd should use it.

Hear hear! This site is awful for promoting both victimisation and phony empowerment. Be realistic, be insightful, and don't be a victim. It is really, really not that hard.

Bohemond23 · 30/12/2023 18:50

Advice regularly on here to have the child if you want the child infuriates me. NO. Apply some critical thinking before you have the child FFS. If you do then you are much less likely to be in the - together for 3 years with a two year old and he’s a shit or the father that is dodging his responsibilities. The vast majority of women have agency in their lives nd should use it.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 18:44

You're being incredibly naive OP

They change. Its recognised that abuse often doesn't start until children come along.

kitsuneghost · 30/12/2023 18:26

To be fair. If my OH decided he was going to do all the cleaning i wouldn't stop him so if a woman continues to do all cleaning cooking and childcare why would he bother stopping her.

Every single thing these women do, they choose to do and that's OK hut why whinge. If you don't want to cook dinner, don't cook dinner. If you don't want to clean the bathroom don't clean the bathroom.

TerrysChocolateBorangejuice · 30/12/2023 18:21

arethereanyleftatall · 30/12/2023 16:49

Then lucky you Terry's chocolate. But the point of this thread is that unfortunately many women are.

The poster I quoted specifically said "women".

I was just pointing out that it would be correct to say some women (just as it is often correct to say some men).

As @GreyCarpet has said, her mother actively chose to take a subservient approach despite not being raised with that mindset.

On MN there appear to be a disproportionate amount of women who don't make the same decisions as @GreyCarpet clearly has, and by staying in these awful relationships they (as women) are consciously passing on the wrong message to their children, female and male, so it's no wonder that nothing ever changes.

Daleksatemyshed · 30/12/2023 18:20

@Atethehalloweenchocs point about men never wanting their wives to change is very valid here, they marry a woman whose focussed on them, whose fun and that's the woman they chose to marry and the one they want to stick around. If a man's not that keen to be a parent then he's probably going to be unprepared for how much his wife changes once the DC arrive especially if he's come from a family where Dad didn't do much parenting, suddenly he's slipped down the rankings to below the DC, his sex life has diminished and he's resentful, this isn't what he signed up for so he doesn't help with the DC. By now he's wife is resentful because he's not the DF she hoped he'd be and the whole relationship blows up.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/12/2023 18:06

A lot of the women I know are very concerned about not disadvantaging others or affecting them negatively so will self regulate their behaviour. Whereas many of the men I know are just interested in making their life as pleasant or easy as possible, even if that disadvantages others - and not only would not feel bad, but would feel good about themselves for getting one over. Even when they supposedly like or care for the other person.

Delassalle · 30/12/2023 17:59

I can't understand how some of the awful men that are constantly farting in front of their wives, have skid marks in their pants, don't flush the toilet etc, that are complained about on here only started these appalling behaviours after they got married?

Why would you marry someone with such poor hygiene and spend years with them before finally getting fed up? 🤷🏼‍♀️

SirQuintusAureliusMaximus · 30/12/2023 17:50

Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

Two reasons

  1. People put on their best behaviour at the start of any relationship. "Like me, like me". It's human nature. Women do it too. Have you never started a relationship in a sexy black basque and suspenders and a beautiful little lacy nighty and ended it in big cotton pants and comfy PJs?
  2. Many many many women want a relationship at all costs - for many different reasons at different times of life. They really want children and have sunk costs fallacy about an existing relationship that isn't ideal. Social status of a couple. Not liking to be alone. Not enjoying a social life without a partner. Financial support. Home ownership.
    Horses for courses. Some people would rather be alone than accept anything less than 'perfect for them'. Others really want a partner and would prefer someone unpleasant or useless than no one.
SaltburnIsNotAboutTheBeach · 30/12/2023 17:46

TerrysChocolateBorangejuice · 30/12/2023 16:32

Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.

No they aren't.

I wasn't, my mother wasn't, my daughter wasn't, my grand-daughters aren't and none of the women in my (or my husband's) family were either.

Life often proves otherwise, unfortunately.

How many threads where girls in schools are expected to sit next to the “naughty boy” at school, in hopes of helping the teacher.

I don’t know one couple where the man does more than the woman in terms of parenting and looking after the house (I had a conversation in rl about this and a friend pointed out that she and her ex are 50/50 with their children, but she didn’t factor in that the children’s stepmother did the lions share of everything!). I’m sure there are some men who genuinely share the load, but I’ve yet to meet one. They’re a minority whatever.

I am the child and grandchild of very strong women, who did more than most women in their generations, but that doesn’t mean the burden was split any differently. The very fact that they did so well is a testament to how hard they worked, whilst still taking care of children and facilitating their husbands.

SparkleyMud · 30/12/2023 17:42

Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture?

Mine was great when we met and were in love he was great with first born, sprung into action doing night feeds, cleaning house etc. Was OK with second born. Then his remaining parent died and he changed. He's been to therapy which has helped his stress levels but he's not in love with me anymore and has no motivation to care for me in the way he used to. We are getting divorced.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 17:39

SaltburnIsNotAboutTheBeach · 30/12/2023 17:35

But there are many women who have all the information they need about a man long before co-habitation, marriage or babies are on the cards and still continue with it hoping they'll change.

Having the information and being being able to recognise it for what it is are very different things though.

I’m not trying to make out that women are victims, not at all, but for too many of us our time to make a stand and recognise what our lives have become only comes later on. We make decisions as young women naively.

I didn’t understand that my father being a hard worker but a non present parent was even a thing until I was in my forties, when I had the blinding realisation that my ex was exactly the same. In my twenties I simply didn’t have the life experience or the knowledge to have any comprehension of this. My family set up was more or less identical to most others I knew - mother, whether she worked or not, was the one to sort out washing, cleaning the house, dealing with teen dramas, going to parents evenings, doing the shopping. Men doing these roles were hugely in the minority - why would anyone expect or imagine any difference when that was the norm?

There is maybe a more even split in household tasks than there was 40+ years ago, but it’s still very normal for women to bear the brunt of parenting, and very normal for men to be the secondary parent (obviously not counting the many Not My Nigels out there Hmm).

There’s a huge element of boiling frog going on too. When life becomes full of babies and the chaos that comes with that it can be impossible to see reality, or, once you can see it, difficult to gain control of the situation on your own.

It’s no surprise to me that around 70% of divorces are instigated by women.

But if he cheats on you, doesn't work, has kids he doesn't see from previous relationships, is an alcoholic, does drugs...

And there are a lot of threads on here by women who have chosen a man knowing he was like this from the start.

Some of the more subtle things, I can understand but these are fairly big things!

MargaritaThyme · 30/12/2023 17:39

Because many women are desperate to have children and need to do so within a finite timescale, so they end up married to men who are not as keen on becoming parents as they are. And many men are ambivalent, at best, about having children but agree to do so to make the woman they love happy.

When children come along in such relationships, the man is often horrified by the realities & demands of parenthood and filled with regret so he deliberately takes a back seat and allows the woman to get on with it. After all, that is the mother’s natural role & it was her who wanted them in the first place, wasn’t it?

She becomes resentful of his lack of interest and the fact that the entire burden of parenting falls onto her while he selfishly goes off to work / football / the pub. After all, he did agree to becoming a dad, didn’t he?

SaltburnIsNotAboutTheBeach · 30/12/2023 17:35

But there are many women who have all the information they need about a man long before co-habitation, marriage or babies are on the cards and still continue with it hoping they'll change.

Having the information and being being able to recognise it for what it is are very different things though.

I’m not trying to make out that women are victims, not at all, but for too many of us our time to make a stand and recognise what our lives have become only comes later on. We make decisions as young women naively.

I didn’t understand that my father being a hard worker but a non present parent was even a thing until I was in my forties, when I had the blinding realisation that my ex was exactly the same. In my twenties I simply didn’t have the life experience or the knowledge to have any comprehension of this. My family set up was more or less identical to most others I knew - mother, whether she worked or not, was the one to sort out washing, cleaning the house, dealing with teen dramas, going to parents evenings, doing the shopping. Men doing these roles were hugely in the minority - why would anyone expect or imagine any difference when that was the norm?

There is maybe a more even split in household tasks than there was 40+ years ago, but it’s still very normal for women to bear the brunt of parenting, and very normal for men to be the secondary parent (obviously not counting the many Not My Nigels out there Hmm).

There’s a huge element of boiling frog going on too. When life becomes full of babies and the chaos that comes with that it can be impossible to see reality, or, once you can see it, difficult to gain control of the situation on your own.

It’s no surprise to me that around 70% of divorces are instigated by women.

Deadringer · 30/12/2023 17:20

Traditionally women needed to attract a man to look after her and hang on to him at almost any cost, while this isn't the case any more there is still a 'pick me' and 'I am not like other girls/my mother/your mother' hangover from previous generations that means a lot of women will accept a fair amount of shit to keep a man, and if she bucks the trend and has the confidence to walk away she will likely be heavily criticised for it. And many men get worse after dc, their beautiful obliging sexy partner is suddenly a tired frazzled mother and they slink off, avoid doing their share and spend their free time watching porn.

thisbetheverse · 30/12/2023 17:19

From personal experience I had very low self esteem when I first met him. Somehow managed to build more confidence in myself and also sites like mumsnet help you to realise there are better men out there

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 17:15

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/12/2023 17:09

There is that old saying (cant remember who it is attributed to) that men marry women thinking they will never change, and women marry men thinking they can change them. Some truth to it I think.

I wouldn't even date someone hoping he'd change. I certanly wouldn't marry them.

All that saying does is underline how crap men are.

It might as well read, men want women to be 21 forever and women hope that, at some point, men will grow up.

We cant change men. All we can do is make positive choices for ourselves rather than suffering and complaining about it and seeing it as inevitable.
.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/12/2023 17:09

There is that old saying (cant remember who it is attributed to) that men marry women thinking they will never change, and women marry men thinking they can change them. Some truth to it I think.

Southpoint · 30/12/2023 16:57

I only really met my soon to be ex- husband when we started a family plus house renovations. Utterly hopeless and also grumpy if and when asked to do his bit. I realised he expected me to do all the work as his mother did. 🤢

VanityDiesHard · 30/12/2023 16:53

arethereanyleftatall · 30/12/2023 16:49

Then lucky you Terry's chocolate. But the point of this thread is that unfortunately many women are.

Then they need to unlearn that and not be so passive. It isn't the 1950s.

VanityDiesHard · 30/12/2023 16:53

KimberleyClark · 30/12/2023 14:05

Unfortunately I think some women are prepared to overlook a lot if they are desperate for children. “ He’s not perfect but he’ll have to do because I want kids”.

God knows why. I think you're right but to me that is just so selfish. Children are a privilege, not a right. If you are in an unhappy domestic situation, why add children to that?

Suddenlychrimbo · 30/12/2023 16:52

Women at a certain point will ignore multiple red flags , if a man says he wants to start a family.

Sad but true.

arethereanyleftatall · 30/12/2023 16:49

TerrysChocolateBorangejuice · 30/12/2023 16:32

Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.

No they aren't.

I wasn't, my mother wasn't, my daughter wasn't, my grand-daughters aren't and none of the women in my (or my husband's) family were either.

Then lucky you Terry's chocolate. But the point of this thread is that unfortunately many women are.