Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth some MNetters ever saw in these men?

211 replies

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

OP posts:
TempestTost · 31/12/2023 00:07

I think a certain percentage of people are lazy, gross, manipulative, etc. And so a certain percentage of people who marry will get a partner like that.

What I often wonder is the extent that people like that end up with each other. How many of the women complaining on MN are neglecting to tell us their own issues? Or what would we see if men came and complained on MN about their wives?

Anyway, in the end lots of people, in the courting stage, try and show their best side. And then many people are willing to overlook a lot in order to have a partner.

ReflectiveRogue1001 · 30/12/2023 23:50

TwinklingLightsEverywhere · 30/12/2023 22:46

From the relationships I've observed, including my own, it's started out unequal without feeling unfair.

She likes the house spotless, he doesn't mind a bit of mess but isn't slovenly - who is to say she is right? So if she wants to live in a spotless house they both do the work to keep it acceptable then she does the additional to make it spotless.

Lots of women want to make a show of their homemaking skills - cooking up a fantastic meal or beautifully decorating the livingroom. Again this may not be important to him so why should he do the work?

It works fine this way whilst she accepts that his wants are not unreasonable and if she wants to go the extra mile then it's on her. But often somewhere along the road it changes, either she gets annoyed at all the extra work she's doing whilst he reaps the benefits, or he realises he can do less and less and she'll pick up the slack.

Then you throw dc into the mix, there was no prior agreement as to standards, and it's very hard for mum to not be deciding the standards if she's doing most of the care.

Moral of the story is to make sure you are well matched in your expectations, and to be prepared to LTB if things change and cannot be resolved.

I agree with this. And I think it taps into something deep (primeval????) with a lot of women (and I include myself in this).

When our DD was born (she's adult now) I automatically went into "No! DH! You don't hold her like this, you hold her like that" mode.
I hated him at the time, but he told me to fuck off, he told me his way was fine.
It wasn't MY way, but he was right.... his way WAS fine.

I think new mothers can get locked in to doing things "their" way. So the DH, who can't do anything right anyway, backs away.
Mum then complains it's all on her and that he's useless.

I'm REALLY not a male apologist.
But I'm interested in this discussion

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 23:44

Dragonfly97 · 30/12/2023 23:01

Completely agree with this. Women are judged & blamed for men's behaviour, by other women as well. We need a government that acknowledges the damage misogyny does, and stamp on it. Misogyny is at the root of women's problems.

There is a lot of truth in what Saltburn says but women don't have to accept the expectations.

Some of it is beyond our personal/immediate control. We don't have any responsibility for men's behaviour and we don't have a whole lot of control over systemic and societal inequalities. But we absolutely can choose what we will and won't accept in our personal relationships.

It's one of the reasons I stayed single for the best part of 10 years. I'd rather be single than accept behaours and abide by expectations that don't sit right with me.

User135644 · 30/12/2023 23:33

Dragonfly97 · 30/12/2023 23:01

Completely agree with this. Women are judged & blamed for men's behaviour, by other women as well. We need a government that acknowledges the damage misogyny does, and stamp on it. Misogyny is at the root of women's problems.

Can't just blame misogyny for women choosing bad men. Women have agency and make their own choices.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 23:25

Dragonfly97 · 30/12/2023 23:01

Completely agree with this. Women are judged & blamed for men's behaviour, by other women as well. We need a government that acknowledges the damage misogyny does, and stamp on it. Misogyny is at the root of women's problems.

Not blamed for men's behaviour, no. And no one on here has suggested that women are responsible for men's behaviour.

But they are responsible for their own choices.

Eg If you enter, or continue, a relationship with someone who cheats - expect him to cheat.

Still his choice to do it but you knew what you were getting into and you could have chosen not to.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 23:22

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 22:35

But again women can't be held responsible for men's actions. Using your example, if a man cheats then that's on him. To then blame a woman for showing forgiveness is simply misogyny.

Of course it's his decision to cheat.

But if I step out into the road without looking and get hit by a bus, well, it wouldn't be unreasonable to suggest I should have looked first would it? It wouldn't mean I deserved to be hit by a bus but it was a fairly predictable outcome that I'd be hit by something. So I always look because it isn't worth the risk.

It's not misogynistic to suggest that, if a woman finds put her new boyfriend cheated on her, that its reasonable to assume he's probably going to do it again at some point.

Dragonfly97 · 30/12/2023 23:01

SaltburnIsNotAboutTheBeach · 30/12/2023 13:42

YABU.
Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.
It stands to reason that when it comes to picking a life partner we’re not always as qualified as we’d like to be.
Off the top of my head:

We’re expected to put up with crap behaviour from boys in school. We were even made to sit next to them to help control them.

Most Romcoms feature creepy behaviour from men, which we’re conditioned to believe is sexy or romantic or other such rubbish.

Porn is rife. Too much porn features violence that actively put me women in danger. Women and girls are expected to be cool with it. To accept harmful practices as mainstream.

Many men keep up a pretence of being a decent man until they have children, then whatever it is, resentment, jealousy, controlling urges, I don’t know, is unleashed. Having put in the scant effort required to win a woman over, once babies are on the scene he subconsciously knows it’s very much more difficult for a woman to make free choices about her life, and even if he doesn’t outwardly become a shithead, it’s a fact that most mothers (NOT fathers) are the default parents, who carry the mental load. It’s much easier for men to take a step back and do fuck all, under the guise of “well I work”.

How about we start treating women and girls truly as equals? How about we have the same expectations of behaviour from men as we do women? How about we work to raise the conviction rates of rape?

The way society is a set up seems to mean that women are held responsible for male behaviour. It should be the other way round. Hold men responsible for their own behaviour.

Completely agree with this. Women are judged & blamed for men's behaviour, by other women as well. We need a government that acknowledges the damage misogyny does, and stamp on it. Misogyny is at the root of women's problems.

TwinklingLightsEverywhere · 30/12/2023 22:46

From the relationships I've observed, including my own, it's started out unequal without feeling unfair.

She likes the house spotless, he doesn't mind a bit of mess but isn't slovenly - who is to say she is right? So if she wants to live in a spotless house they both do the work to keep it acceptable then she does the additional to make it spotless.

Lots of women want to make a show of their homemaking skills - cooking up a fantastic meal or beautifully decorating the livingroom. Again this may not be important to him so why should he do the work?

It works fine this way whilst she accepts that his wants are not unreasonable and if she wants to go the extra mile then it's on her. But often somewhere along the road it changes, either she gets annoyed at all the extra work she's doing whilst he reaps the benefits, or he realises he can do less and less and she'll pick up the slack.

Then you throw dc into the mix, there was no prior agreement as to standards, and it's very hard for mum to not be deciding the standards if she's doing most of the care.

Moral of the story is to make sure you are well matched in your expectations, and to be prepared to LTB if things change and cannot be resolved.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 22:35

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 22:14

As has been said many times, no one is talking about those situations.

There are threads on here every day by women who say the red flags were there from the start; he was still in a relationship when they started seeing each other; he cheated on her 3 months in and she forgave him; he's an alcoholic who's been 'dry' for a month; he was crap with their first child and got no better with the second and third akd many, many variations on these and other themes.

No tall men change. Some men are exactly as they always were and women chose them anyway 🤷🏻‍♀️

But again women can't be held responsible for men's actions. Using your example, if a man cheats then that's on him. To then blame a woman for showing forgiveness is simply misogyny.

VanityDiesHard · 30/12/2023 22:32

FerreroFan · 30/12/2023 22:27

Agree with those saying that many men change after kids, even if they were fine before. The work load seems to become unequal in so many cases when it comes to childcare and rarely seems to change when women go back to work.

Don't blame the women. Blame the men who can't be bothered to look after their own kids.

Some do, some don't. A lot of women seem to think that these men will miraculously change and become responsible, helpful , caring fathers, even if they have been shit husbands. I'm sorry but I have limited sympathy with those women. They are living a life of delusion and dragging completely innocent children into the mess.

DeeCeeCherry · 30/12/2023 22:30

I wonder about this sometimes. But then I remember the devil doesn't show his horns when he's approaching and wants to get next to you. If he did you'd run a mile. Never underestimate the power and will of people to completely hide their real personality until they feel comfortable enough to let loose.

I also think sadly, society to this day still encourages women to have a man by any means necessary, and to validate themselves via whether they're in a relationship or not. Its hard for some women not to buy into the pressure.

FerreroFan · 30/12/2023 22:27

Agree with those saying that many men change after kids, even if they were fine before. The work load seems to become unequal in so many cases when it comes to childcare and rarely seems to change when women go back to work.

Don't blame the women. Blame the men who can't be bothered to look after their own kids.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 22:14

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 21:51

As far as dv and abusive behaviour goes research and all the domestic abuse charities confirm that pregnancy is often the most likely trigger. It smacks of victim blaming when people suggest women knew what they were getting in to.

As has been said many times, no one is talking about those situations.

There are threads on here every day by women who say the red flags were there from the start; he was still in a relationship when they started seeing each other; he cheated on her 3 months in and she forgave him; he's an alcoholic who's been 'dry' for a month; he was crap with their first child and got no better with the second and third akd many, many variations on these and other themes.

No tall men change. Some men are exactly as they always were and women chose them anyway 🤷🏻‍♀️

KimberleyClark · 30/12/2023 22:07
  1. People put on their best behaviour at the start of any relationship. "Like me, like me". It's human nature. Women do it too. Have you never started a relationship in a sexy black basque and suspenders and a beautiful little lacy nighty and ended it in big cotton pants and comfy PJs?

Tbh no. Always felt comfortable being myself from the start. DH has not changed. We don’t have children but I don’t think that would have changed him either. We have always been a team. Been married 33 years.

5128gap · 30/12/2023 22:06

Living with a young man when you're also young and child free in a smallish easy to clean flat, where no one cooks very often because you can afford takeaway and eating out; where regular drunken nights out with your respective friends are the norm for you both, is a very different thing to living in a family home with a couple of children. Often men fail to change their ways to adapt to their new circumstance. Unfortunately they don't announce in advance to their partner this will be the case, and so she erroneously believes they will mature as herself does.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 22:05

Howbizzare22 · 30/12/2023 21:24

This.

Do other women really live their lives this way? Always worrying what other people will think and making decisions based on silly comments?

Seriously?

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/12/2023 21:51

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/12/2023 19:05

As so many people have pointed out, they often do not change which is precisely the problem. The lazy, financially incompetent, sexually incontinent loser who won’t clean the bathroom and thinks ever boss is out to get him won’t want to change nappies or hold down stable employment to support a family.

Far too many women take on a project and realise they can’t make a decent man out of a useless man child. Doesn’t stop loads trying but it’s a fools errand. Adding innocent children to the mix perpetuates the cycle of poor male and female role models. If mum’s a skivvy her sons will treat women that way and her daughters will expect no better.

As far as dv and abusive behaviour goes research and all the domestic abuse charities confirm that pregnancy is often the most likely trigger. It smacks of victim blaming when people suggest women knew what they were getting in to.

tescocreditcard · 30/12/2023 21:46

I think it's just financial necessity. Not earning enough money to support yourself. Especially women whose children have just turned 18 and now they no longer get all the child related money they used to.

BayCityCoaster · 30/12/2023 21:44

As per PP, one thing I have found incredibly eye-opening about MN is how utterly lax people are about contraception, and how willing they are to go ahead with pregnancies to men they barely know, let alone care about / trust / deem to be good men / potential fathers.

MN is a window into another world for me.

I do not understand the mindset of anyone wanting to saddle themselves to domesticity with the wrong person, to motherhood with the wrong person, to a relationship that is that much harder to extricate from, once children come along.

ReflectiveRogue1001 · 30/12/2023 21:41

This is such an interesting thread. And points I agree with on both sides.

To be clear, I mostly disagree with the OP.
Apart from two points.

One is kind of what @kitsuneghost said....

To be fair. If my OH decided he was going to do all the cleaning i wouldn't stop him so if a woman continues to do all cleaning cooking and childcare why would he bother stopping her.
Every single thing these women do, they choose to do and that's OK hut why whinge. If you don't want to cook dinner, don't cook dinner. If you don't want to clean the bathroom don't clean the bathroom.

IMHO, Women often have a higher standard of cleanliness, which they expect their partner to live up to. And get angry and resentful if things are done, but not to their standards. Same applies to childcare, actually.

Second point, which makes me seem like I agree with @gothicomedy (which I really mostly don't) is if your DH/DP turns out to be a shit dad, why have another one, two, more with them? You KNOW what you're getting into at that point.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 21:39

LolaSmiles · 30/12/2023 20:31

Until we can, as women, acknowledge that the two things exist in this discussion - men can present as good and then change, and women do also knowingly have kids with awful men, then we are not able to inspect WHY both these things happen, which is entrenched societal conditioning of both genders, as described very eloquently on these threads - unless we admit and acknowledge it, then we're never going to tackle this problem.
Agree with this. Both things can be true.

I find it troubling on here how often some posters seem to quickly from relationship to relationship, each one with the expectations that the new fella will take on the dad role and how often some posters will argue that anyone advising caution before introducing children/blending families is shaming women for wanting a relationship, rather than suggesting that parents put their children before their sex life.
It also troubles me how often when a couple can't agree on TTC how often some posters tell people to just come off your contraception, tell him you're not preventing and it's up to him to decide to use a condom or not. He's 100% responsible if he chooses to have unprotected sex when he doesn't want a child, but is that really a sign that he's a brilliant catch who will be a hands on father?
Same for the number of posts that can be paraphrased as "DH/DP is a great dad, but here is a long list of behaviour that is being a crap dad and rubbish spouse. I want to have another baby and a sibling for DC, AIBU to think we should have another?"

This is so true.

I can think of so many threads I've read recently (won't give details as it's not fair on those posters) where it's OBVIOUS it's not as simple or straightforward as man, bad/evil/abuser/manipulative/controlling; woman, good/innocent/blameless/powerless and yet so many posters jump straight to that.

The lexical gymnastics at play sometimes to absolve women of any and all responsibility is incredible.

Until someone takes responsibility for their own decision making (whatever background trauma or whatever led them to make that decision), they can't accept that they have agency. Until they accept they have agency they will (continue to) be powerless to change their situation.

It's very frustrating at times.

Disclaimer: this obvipusly doesn't apply to actual abuse but not leaving the house for 5 and a half years because you weren't allowed to leave the baby with him? Come on!

Howbizzare22 · 30/12/2023 21:24

Brynandwin · 30/12/2023 11:58

Women are conditioned to think that life is better with a man in it. It starts from a very young age with Disney and fairytales and romantic movies, and therefore we’re praised when we bag ourselves a man.
It takes a really significant amount of time being single to really get to know yourself , and to build your inner strength and self esteem to a point where it’s really difficult to find a man who’d improve your life rather than deplete it, because he’d have to be a God.
Not many women have such periods of being single, because when we do society starts with the crazy cat lady comparisons, people start trying to fix you up, etc.

This.

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 21:18

Foxblue · 30/12/2023 20:11

I find it excessively frustrating, tbh.
I also find it frustrating when people come on these threads and go 'men change, abuse ramps up during pregnancy' which are VERY valid points, but it's said as if that's the ONLY thing that happens, that no woman has ever knowingly been with a shit man then had kids with him, like no woman has ever had kids with a shit man, zero responsibility or agency at all, that every case is a man whose duped a woman until they were locked in, and that's just not true, and it's extremely damaging to suggest that it is! We absolutely should be raising awareness that men can change, but it's so deeply unhelpful towards the overall issue to shut conversation down with 'men change, so how dare you imply it's the woman's fault'
Until we can, as women, acknowledge that the two things exist in this discussion - men can present as good and then change, and women do also knowingly have kids with awful men, then we are not able to inspect WHY both these things happen, which is entrenched societal conditioning of both genders, as described very eloquently on these threads - unless we admit and acknowledge it, then we're never going to tackle this problem.

👏

LinnieM · 30/12/2023 21:02

Vistada · 30/12/2023 11:31

These cannot be the same men Dolly begged Jolene not to take

Like?! When Destiny’s Child were singing Cater 2 You, I’d love to know who those men were. Because it can’t be these ones!

LolaSmiles · 30/12/2023 20:31

Until we can, as women, acknowledge that the two things exist in this discussion - men can present as good and then change, and women do also knowingly have kids with awful men, then we are not able to inspect WHY both these things happen, which is entrenched societal conditioning of both genders, as described very eloquently on these threads - unless we admit and acknowledge it, then we're never going to tackle this problem.
Agree with this. Both things can be true.

I find it troubling on here how often some posters seem to quickly from relationship to relationship, each one with the expectations that the new fella will take on the dad role and how often some posters will argue that anyone advising caution before introducing children/blending families is shaming women for wanting a relationship, rather than suggesting that parents put their children before their sex life.
It also troubles me how often when a couple can't agree on TTC how often some posters tell people to just come off your contraception, tell him you're not preventing and it's up to him to decide to use a condom or not. He's 100% responsible if he chooses to have unprotected sex when he doesn't want a child, but is that really a sign that he's a brilliant catch who will be a hands on father?
Same for the number of posts that can be paraphrased as "DH/DP is a great dad, but here is a long list of behaviour that is being a crap dad and rubbish spouse. I want to have another baby and a sibling for DC, AIBU to think we should have another?"