Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth some MNetters ever saw in these men?

211 replies

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:53

If a man cheats, which was the example, it is his fault. Its patently ridiculous to state its her fault for not predicting his future actions.

But if he cheated on her at the start why wouldn't she assume its something he's likely to do again and walk away?

My ex husband cheated after 12 years. My dad cheated after 25 years of marriage. Neither of those were 'predictable' unless you take the view that all men will cheat eventually, which I don't.

But if you'd been dating someone for 3 months and he'd had a couple of one night stands during that time why wouldn't you predict he was likely to do it again?

What's the thinking there?

If you knew someone had cheated on you in the early stages, would you really take the risk? Because I wouldn't!

MissTrip82 · 31/12/2023 10:48

Have you really never been in love with someone who wasn’t really a great person? You’ve never looked back on a relationship and seen that someone you loved at the time was quite selfish?

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:46

The best predictor we have of someone's future behaviour is their past actions.

This is why these men fall into two distinct camps too.

Women have reasonably predicted that a decent man will continue to be decent. They had no idea he was going to change. Why would they?

arethereanyleftatall · 31/12/2023 10:44

Of course we're blaming women for it @Willyoujustbequiet !!! It's literally the point of this thread 😂

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 10:44

KimberleyClark · 31/12/2023 10:32

I should have said “failing to predict them based on the information she already had”. Are you seriously suggesting that women should never be held accountable for any decisions they make, or viewed as having any agency at all, because everything is men’s fault?

No. I'm suggesting women aren't held accountable for men's actions which is exactly what I said.

If a man cheats, which was the example, it is his fault. Its patently ridiculous to state its her fault for not predicting his future actions.

It's blatant misogyny.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:43

MeinKraft · 31/12/2023 10:30

Haven't RTFT but imagine writing an entire post about how women are fault for the actions of lazy men.

Has anyone popped up to blame the mothers of these men yet?

Not one single person has blamed women for men's actions. HTH.

Men choose to donthese things.

Thebqiestion is why do some women choose to put up with it?

Some men don't reveal this side of themselves until the woman is effectively trapped by marriage or children but others are displaying these behaviours from the start.

Women aren't responsible for these behaviours but they are responsible for accepting them.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:40

Willyoujustbequiet

The best predictor we have of someone's future behaviour is their past actions.

We make predictions all the time. It's not about being able to 'predict the future' with certainty but we make predictions all the time about everything. Otherwise we'd constantly be surprised by everything that happens in life/the world.

There are no guarantees but if you choose to date someone who has cheated, has been consistently out of work, is reckless with money, drinks to excess or whatever, on what basis is someone predicting they won't do it again or will stop?

KimberleyClark · 31/12/2023 10:32

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 10:21

Lol. Thank you for proving my point.

Now we are blaming women for not being able to predict the future rather than a man for his own actions. The internalised misogyny is real.

I should have said “failing to predict them based on the information she already had”. Are you seriously suggesting that women should never be held accountable for any decisions they make, or viewed as having any agency at all, because everything is men’s fault?

MeinKraft · 31/12/2023 10:30

Haven't RTFT but imagine writing an entire post about how women are fault for the actions of lazy men.

Has anyone popped up to blame the mothers of these men yet?

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 10:21

KimberleyClark · 31/12/2023 10:18

But it’s not blaming the woman for the man’s actions, it’s blaming her for failing to predict them. Not the same. There are so many posts on here from women complaining about how useless their husbands are at childcare and the poster is pregnant again or has had a baby quite recently. As Einstein said, the definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.

Lol. Thank you for proving my point.

Now we are blaming women for not being able to predict the future rather than a man for his own actions. The internalised misogyny is real.

KimberleyClark · 31/12/2023 10:18

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 09:15

Ludicrous comparison.

If you step out into the road that's your own actions. If a man cheats its their actions. That's the whole point. It's misogynistic to blame a woman for a man's actions.

But it’s not blaming the woman for the man’s actions, it’s blaming her for failing to predict them. Not the same. There are so many posts on here from women complaining about how useless their husbands are at childcare and the poster is pregnant again or has had a baby quite recently. As Einstein said, the definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:12

WandaWonder · 31/12/2023 09:41

Because they choose not to see it, but surely it could work the other way why is your list about how bad men are, are women immune from being the same?

It is a choice what behaviour people accept or not

The thread is about men who behave badly and why women tolerate it.

If you want to start a thread about women who behave badly in relationships, do so.

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 10:12

Because they choose not to see it, but surely it could work the other way why is your list about how bad men are, are women immune from being the same

The thread topic was about poor male behaviour in relationships so people are discussing this.

What is it about threads discussing male pattern behaviour that means there's always 'but what about women, women can be bad too'

🙄

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 10:10

In my experience they don't start off like that, they hide it and sometimes they are genuinely interested in the relationship for the first year or so but once you are committed emotionally financially and possibly with children they feel secure enough to revert back to their default state which is as you describe in your post. You then find yourself stuck with this man child that you love but don't like very much.

I feel there are two distinct groups of men who behave badly in relationships.

One is, as you describe, someone who has played their part well, shown an interest, been attentive, been (or at least appeared to be) good partner/family man material etc who seems to morph beyond recognition during pregnancy and beyond. I think there are a few reasons for this - which have been articulated by different posts already.

But there is a second camp of men who don't hide who they are. Who are proudly X, Y or Z right from the start. Who consider it their 'right' to flirt, cheat, message other women online. There are women who post on here who discovered their new boyfriend is still active on dating apps and some women choose to forgive and move on from it only to find they have continued it and wonder why.

Or men who don't work and aren't independently wealthy, who've claimed that they've had to leave every job because their boss didn't like them.

Who who have a string of 'crazy' exes who won't let them see their children.

Some.women seem more focused on fixing or helping and 'supporting' these men than thinking, "Is this the sort of man I want to be with?"

I read so many threads on here where women post about their 'new' partners - a man they've been on 3 or 4 dates there are things they're not happy with and, rather than walking away, are asking how they can understand, support, deal with various faults. Why?

WandaWonder · 31/12/2023 09:41

Because they choose not to see it, but surely it could work the other way why is your list about how bad men are, are women immune from being the same?

It is a choice what behaviour people accept or not

EnterFunnyNameHere · 31/12/2023 09:39

Interesting thread!

I agree with PP who say that men are often pretty ambivalent towards having kids. DH & I have no kids (by choice) and a few years back he got to see first hand the "you'll change your mind when you're older"/"when you meet the right man" BS that I get to deal with. He was stunned - and told me when he said we were planning staying childfree to his cricket mates any comments made were all "you lucky bastard"/"how did you swing that?!". Some of those cricket mates were already dad's at the time!!

I do believe there are men who do want to parent and do it well - but I think in a not insignificant number of cases it's happened because the woman wants kids/wants them now.

As a result, all the hard work of parenting and the increased workload of keeping a clean home is seen a bit as the woman's "fault"/her hobby and therefore her problem to resolve.

It doesn't make these men less pathetic in my eyes at least, but I think that's at the core of it in many cases.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 09:33

Willyoujustbequiet

It's not about blaming women for men's actions. It's about women taking responsibility for their own.

No one has said that it's a woman's fault a man cheats (or behaves badly in any way) but if someone behaves badly and you continue to accept it then there is some responsibility on you for accepting it repeatedly. That's a choice you made.

Obviously, this doesn't apply when abuse is at play or when, as other posters have said, this is a behaviour that only emerges once marriage and babies have happened.

That is firmly and only on the men.

Being crap, lazy, unfaithful, workshy from the outset is also a choice on the man's part.

But women who choose and accept that behaviour from men from the start? Well it's reasonable to ask why.

Women aren't responsible for how men behave but they are responsible for ignoring, overlooking and excusing it from the start because they could have decided they didn't want to date someone like that and they didn't.

susiedaisy1912 · 31/12/2023 09:24

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

In my experience they don't start off like that, they hide it and sometimes they are genuinely interested in the relationship for the first year or so but once you are committed emotionally financially and possibly with children they feel secure enough to revert back to their default state which is as you describe in your post. You then find yourself stuck with this man child that you love but don't like very much.

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 09:15

GreyCarpet · 30/12/2023 23:22

Of course it's his decision to cheat.

But if I step out into the road without looking and get hit by a bus, well, it wouldn't be unreasonable to suggest I should have looked first would it? It wouldn't mean I deserved to be hit by a bus but it was a fairly predictable outcome that I'd be hit by something. So I always look because it isn't worth the risk.

It's not misogynistic to suggest that, if a woman finds put her new boyfriend cheated on her, that its reasonable to assume he's probably going to do it again at some point.

Ludicrous comparison.

If you step out into the road that's your own actions. If a man cheats its their actions. That's the whole point. It's misogynistic to blame a woman for a man's actions.

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 09:13

TempestTost
I take your point, but this isn't about being a bit messy and in a relationship with a neat freak. Different people will have different levels of mess, that's a given.

I'm thinking on balance what percentage of men are genuinely incapable of seeing mess and previously lived in squalor and filth when single Vs the percentage of men who were perfectly capable of basic housework when single only to drop it when they move in with a woman?

I highly doubt all these men who are incapable of using a washing machine without being prompted and don't realise that dishes need washing never did laundry or dishes when they lived alone. I also doubt they go to work and leave their lunchbox and coffee mug festering in the communal kitchen for weeks.

On so many threads on here there's the same old male pattern behaviour, same old weaponised incompetence and on every thread there's always a handful of posters willing to excuse it or add to a woman's mental load by suggesting she gets her partner to "help" by writing him a chore list, or asking him specifically to help her with tasks. It's all same shit, different day where domestic responsibilities are viewed as women's work.

AuntieJoyce · 31/12/2023 08:27

This is a really interesting thread and good to see it develop rather than become a slanging match.

I think a big proportion of the problem is that men are generally ambivalent about having children, this then extends to being ambivalent about doing all the caring for them. Unfortunately, a lot of this is going to be driven by biology.

Once we have our children, we love them so much that we do a mental weigh up of circumstances will be best for them and end up staying with unsatisfactory men.

TempestTost · 31/12/2023 07:41

A man who "doesn't see mess" and needs telling to take the bins out or asking to put the dishwasher on, doesn't see women and men as domestic equals. He will have done it himself before he found himself a willing housekeeper. This should have women considering if they really want a lifetime of this because he sure isn't changing when children arrive.

I'm not so sure about this one. As a person who doesn't always see mess, I don't think it's particularly reflective of any kind of moral lack. Some people are not so attuned to the environment around them.

It's like executive function tasks. Some people really struggle with that stuff, especially where financial management is concerned.

It's a problem if one partner is a neat freak and the other isn't. And one partner can easily feel like they've been left with the bulk of the work. But I don't see it as insurmountable, necessarily. Not like a man who is a drunk, or serial cheater, or seems to have issues with his various child support arrangements.

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 07:16

Don't blame the women. Blame the men who can't be bothered to look after their own kids.
Men are 100% responsible for their own rubbish behaviour.

However, we need to have standards for ourselves and know our worth. So,

  • A man who has children he doesn't see and lots of tall stories why he doesn't see them should have women running a mile, not getting into a relationship and having a baby with him.
  • A man who has lots of stories about his multiple "crazy" ex partners is probably going to be a rubbish partner. This should be a giant set of red flags to a woman, not jumping into a relationship with him thinking it will be different with you, you're not like his ex girlfriends.
  • A man who has a young child and a lot of drama about if/when he sees them, if he's going to pay appropriate maintenance, etc should have women being cautious about pursuing a relationship, not moving him in and having him play daddy to her children within 6 months of meeting.
  • A man who "doesn't see mess" and needs telling to take the bins out or asking to put the dishwasher on, doesn't see women and men as domestic equals. He will have done it himself before he found himself a willing housekeeper. This should have women considering if they really want a lifetime of this because he sure isn't changing when children arrive.

The men are totally responsible for their awful behaviour, but as women we don't have to accept it.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 31/12/2023 01:24

Women are taught from birth that it’s our job to let men do what they want.
It stands to reason that when it comes to picking a life partner we’re not always as qualified as we’d like to be.

I was never taught that, and my DM was no feminist. I don't actually even know anyone who thinks it is their job to let men do what they want.

TempestTost · 31/12/2023 00:13

ReflectiveRogue1001 · 30/12/2023 23:50

I agree with this. And I think it taps into something deep (primeval????) with a lot of women (and I include myself in this).

When our DD was born (she's adult now) I automatically went into "No! DH! You don't hold her like this, you hold her like that" mode.
I hated him at the time, but he told me to fuck off, he told me his way was fine.
It wasn't MY way, but he was right.... his way WAS fine.

I think new mothers can get locked in to doing things "their" way. So the DH, who can't do anything right anyway, backs away.
Mum then complains it's all on her and that he's useless.

I'm REALLY not a male apologist.
But I'm interested in this discussion

I think there is something to this with kids. There is a tendency for new mums to be over-the-top protective. I suspect there might be a hormonal element. I felt it really strongly with my first baby, but it decreased a lot by the time my youngest was born. Dad's do often tend to accept the mum's prerogative in those cases.

One common thing I've observed is mums who want a lot more things like activities for kids, and dads who don't care so much, so don't really look to be the driver - literally driving, but also looking for the best playgroup, or researching schools, or music lessons, etc. (The exception might be for families where the dads are into playing sports and actively are involved with that for the kids.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread