Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth some MNetters ever saw in these men?

211 replies

gothicomedy · 30/12/2023 11:30

I'm not talking about abusive and controlling bullies, who are cunning and well able to hide their true personalities before gaslighting women and separating them from friends and families.
But there are so many threads on here about spoilt, childish, selfish, lazy, prima donna partners and husbands sulking over this, that and everything, refusing to help with the children etc etc Surely they would always have been like this and didn't just change personality as soon as they got married or children entered the picture? Why on earth would anyone want to share their lives and take on huge joint responsibilities with these men? Some of the threads on here make for really depressing reads.

OP posts:
telestrations · 01/01/2024 09:39

It's seems most start off as decent with fairly equal relationships and then during maternity leave the woman starts doing everything, and that becomes and stays the norm even once she's back at work full-time. If she's PT or SAHP then it's entrenched.

I think it's societal, cultural and economic.

The woman's own expectations, pressures and standards of herself and by others to pull her weight and get everything right or even be perfect. The blokes sense of entitlement and resentment at being The Breadwinner, validation at work by other men (who have a vested interest in him prioritising work over family) and sometimes grandparents as well, with a genuine economic needs to perform.

The only soultion imo is for both parents to share parental leave

User135644 · 01/01/2024 09:10

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 16:36

But far more men turn out to be arseholes when they didnt appear to be to begin with and we can't hold women (or men for that matter) responsible for not having a crystal ball.

People lie, they mask, they present themselves as one thing when they are another. It's textbook narcissism.

Everyone presents the best of themselves at the start of a relationship. I think couples need to at least live together for a while before kids are considered.

KimberleyClark · 01/01/2024 00:43

It’s certainly true that women are just as capable of thinking with their fanjos as men are with their dicks.

GarlicGiftsAndGlitter · 31/12/2023 23:27

Well ... one thing that hasn't been mentioned, but can't be that uncommon: I had an absolute car crash of a marriage with a man who'd light up the Relationships board with massive, neon flags. I didn't know just how bad he was, but I sure as hell knew there were issues.

Why did I do it? I was HYPNOTISED BY MY VAGINA Blush

Back when more of the threads used to be about full-on NPD types and psychopaths, it was widely accepted that many of them are really, really good in bed because it achieves exactly that effect. They gradually (or suddenly) stop making the effort once they feel they've nailed you down. Then you're left with nothing but the crap you were too orgasm-addled to care about when you should have.

Never let your fanjo make life decisions for you!

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 31/12/2023 23:02

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 16:19

DecafOatMilkCappucino
The Shark Cage analogy is good.

I think on the whole there's a lot of posters on Mumsnet who are good at supporting other women who may not have good shark cages to build one. The posters who encourage women to know their worth, protect their long term security, stop and think before having a baby with a reluctant partner, or run for the hills when there's bunting of red flags are worth their weight in gold.

It's difficult to do when there's always a loud minority who'll excuse poor male pattern behaviour or act like women are support animals for men or it's women's job to rehabilitate men. Sometimes I can't tell whether they do this because their own shark cages are poor or whether they'd rather defend shitty behaviour than acknowledge their partner isn't a very good partner.

This. This again. And again this.

all the live long day this.

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/12/2023 16:36

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:13

I think it's far more misogynistic to suggest women are always and only victims without agency who can't possibly make a positive choice or use their judgement of current or past actions to predict likely future behaviours tbh.

This would suggest that it is only the luck of the draw. And it's not.

Some men are arseholes. We don't have to date them, marry them or have children with them.

But far more men turn out to be arseholes when they didnt appear to be to begin with and we can't hold women (or men for that matter) responsible for not having a crystal ball.

People lie, they mask, they present themselves as one thing when they are another. It's textbook narcissism.

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 16:19

DecafOatMilkCappucino
The Shark Cage analogy is good.

I think on the whole there's a lot of posters on Mumsnet who are good at supporting other women who may not have good shark cages to build one. The posters who encourage women to know their worth, protect their long term security, stop and think before having a baby with a reluctant partner, or run for the hills when there's bunting of red flags are worth their weight in gold.

It's difficult to do when there's always a loud minority who'll excuse poor male pattern behaviour or act like women are support animals for men or it's women's job to rehabilitate men. Sometimes I can't tell whether they do this because their own shark cages are poor or whether they'd rather defend shitty behaviour than acknowledge their partner isn't a very good partner.

heartofglass23 · 31/12/2023 14:11

This is why women should always continue to work full time after DCs.

Work for nothing, pay for ft childcare... anything but don't cut to pt/stop work.

JadziaD · 31/12/2023 14:10

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:25

Often women hope someone will improve with time.

I agree but it is a choice to hope for that.

They could also__ choose not to hope for that and dump him long before pregnancy and single parenthood looms.

But some people are suggesting it's misogynistic to say women have a choose and could choose otherwise.

I agree that structural inequalities make it harder to leave once the children are there but having children, and tying yourself to someone in that way, is a choice.

I don't think it's misogynist to say women should choose better, I just like to look at it in the broader context (and I know you appreciate that as you've already said that in response to my earlier comments so not a go at you). It's not always as simple as that. Too often women don't even realise they have a choice or they're told they don't have choices or they're pressured into making the wrong choices.

I think the shark cage analogy above is quite an interesting one and it's really true - that these things have to be taught and too often they aren't. When SIL got together with (now ex) BIL, it was fairly clear to me and DH from pretty early that this wasn't a good relationship. But we were naive and stupid and we didn't understand the red flag signs - we just thought it was about incompatibility etc. Meanwhile, MIL and FIL were actively telling SIL that she should ignore her concerns. They told her that she needed to settle down, that she'd let multiple good men go (totally not true - only ONE of her previous boyfriends had actually been a potential keeper, but in their heads, any man is better than no man...), that she wouldn't be able to have children if she didn't stop being so fussy. They also are responsible for her being the kind of person who can be manipulated by using aspects of her own personality against her - she absolutely can be reactive and defensive. It is an extraordinarily irritating aspect of her personality. But they did nothing to help her manage it when she was young and to this day, it's still a reason to "beat her" and it's what exBIL did - "Ohhhh, she's so mean to me, poor me..." and he own family bought into it and agreed that SHE was the problem.

exBIL absolutely HATES me with every fibre of his being. The reason? I was the only one who stood up for her against him and he 100% blames me for the breakdown of their relationship. I lost my temper with PIL on a few occasions and pointed out a few home truths, which, backed by DH being a bit more reasonable with them, allowed them to see exBIL's behaviour for what it was. I'll never forget being incredulous at MIL because she was upset that SIL (her DD) was not preparing daily meals for BIL - she told me she might be old fashioned but she thinks it's nice if a woman cooks for her man..... but it literally had not occurred to her for one minute that she didn't expect the same old fashioned gender shit from BIL (who she wasn't even related to). So while she was complaining her daughter wasn't doing enough, she hadn't thought to be upset that BIL didn't earn much money or even work full time, that he'd never once done any of the "dirty boy" jobs that her DH and DS did routinely around their home etc etc etc.

DecafOatMilkCappucino · 31/12/2023 12:52

I like the Shark Cage metaphor:

"The concept of the Shark Cage begins with the idea that the world is like an ocean, filled with fish of all colors and sizes, and there are also predatory sharks which are dangerous. In the ocean, the woman needs a ‘shark cage’ to protect her from predators, but allow friendly fish to pass through.

We aren’t born with our shark cages, our caregivers and others we come into contact with support the construction of our shark cage. Each bar of the cage represents a boundary or a basic human right, such as the right to not be touched, not to be shouted at or called names. Once the bars are in place, the cage provides a protective barrier making it difficult for sharks to get close enough to take a bite.

However, not everyone has had caregivers who knew how to help their child build a sturdy cage, and many women have shark cages with missing bars or a weak alarm system that needs some work. Importantly, the metaphor emphasises that it is not the person who is deficient, but it is their cage. It follows then that the skill of maintaining a robust cage (boundaries) is something that can be learned and refined."

I grew up in a very abusive and volatile home. Drugs, violence, police raids, psychological and sexual abuse were a normal and sometimes daily occurrence. When I met ex dp he was a like a protector come to save me from the big bad world. Sure, he was a stoner and had selfish, lazy tendencies but he never raised his voice, wasn't violent, didn't smoke crack upon waking and most importantly he protected me from other men. I honestly thought I'd found a good one.

It was mumsnet and reading about different types of abuse that finally made me realise that he wasn't in fact, a good one. He's a lying, selfish, lazy covert narc that almost broke me. I compare him to a black hole, beautiful and mysterious from a distance, but get too close and he'll suck you in and crush you. There absolutely were signs there in the beginning, but I thought his good points outweighed the bad. As time went on the bad points eventually outweighed the good and now the gloves have come off and he's gone full arsehole.

I know my example is extreme but I think it applies to a lot of bad relationships. So many of us grew up in dysfunctional households or had bad relationships modeled to us so we didn't see those red flags for what they were.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:26

Have a choice obvs.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:25

Often women hope someone will improve with time.

I agree but it is a choice to hope for that.

They could also__ choose not to hope for that and dump him long before pregnancy and single parenthood looms.

But some people are suggesting it's misogynistic to say women have a choose and could choose otherwise.

I agree that structural inequalities make it harder to leave once the children are there but having children, and tying yourself to someone in that way, is a choice.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:18

JadziaD · 31/12/2023 12:10

We all grew up with those messages. for some, it's easier to push back and realise it's wrong. Sometimes.bwvause of who we meet along the way, the experiences we have, the books we read, etc. I had some teachers who were very important in my thinking. I also read more than any of my.peers so that probably.exposed me to different things. There may well have been some inbuilt misogyny in my upbringing (definitely) but I also was taught to think and question too, even when those questions weren't in line with the views of my family.

That's a fair point.

mumsytoon · 31/12/2023 12:15

They don't start out that way.

What many women tell themselves to make them feel better about their choices. Off course they were always like that , you were just happy enough to turn a blind eye or want to 'change' him.

Lizzbear · 31/12/2023 12:14

Often women hope someone will improve with time. Then find themselves pregnant and find it easier not to be a single mother bringing up a child alone. Sadly.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:13

I think it's far more misogynistic to suggest women are always and only victims without agency who can't possibly make a positive choice or use their judgement of current or past actions to predict likely future behaviours tbh.

This would suggest that it is only the luck of the draw. And it's not.

Some men are arseholes. We don't have to date them, marry them or have children with them.

Lizzbear · 31/12/2023 12:12

Delassalle · 30/12/2023 17:59

I can't understand how some of the awful men that are constantly farting in front of their wives, have skid marks in their pants, don't flush the toilet etc, that are complained about on here only started these appalling behaviours after they got married?

Why would you marry someone with such poor hygiene and spend years with them before finally getting fed up? 🤷🏼‍♀️

This Grin

JadziaD · 31/12/2023 12:10

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:00

JadziaD (great name btw)

Except that I was brought up with those same messages and teachings and I rejected them.

There's nothing special about me.

I grew up in abuse, have had therapy for the resulting trauma and still only feel I'm functioning rather than thriving in life.

But I would rather be single any day of the week than with a useless man whose behaviour I feel I have to excuse, tolerate or ignore.

We all grew up with those messages. for some, it's easier to push back and realise it's wrong. Sometimes.bwvause of who we meet along the way, the experiences we have, the books we read, etc. I had some teachers who were very important in my thinking. I also read more than any of my.peers so that probably.exposed me to different things. There may well have been some inbuilt misogyny in my upbringing (definitely) but I also was taught to think and question too, even when those questions weren't in line with the views of my family.

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 12:00

JadziaD (great name btw)

Except that I was brought up with those same messages and teachings and I rejected them.

There's nothing special about me.

I grew up in abuse, have had therapy for the resulting trauma and still only feel I'm functioning rather than thriving in life.

But I would rather be single any day of the week than with a useless man whose behaviour I feel I have to excuse, tolerate or ignore.

KimberleyClark · 31/12/2023 11:56

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 11:43

Of course we're blaming women for it @Willyoujustbequiet !!! It's literally the point of this thread
No, it isn't.

Men are responsible for their behaviour.
Women are responsible for their behaviour.

If a man chooses to be a useless man child and awful partner he is 100% responsible for his behaviour.

If a woman meets a man who is lazy, selfish, has children he doesn't see or pay for and a string of excuses about his crazy ex girlfriends, the woman is responsible for stopping and deciding whether he's really a good catch or not before settling down and having kids with him. Having multiple babies with a man who already has shown he's a crap father who walks away from his existing children is silly at best. He's shown his new girlfriend exactly who he is

Exactly this. But pointing it out is misogynist apparently. Not denying that some men do turn nasty or useless. But if you know already that he’s a useless dad to his existing children why put another bar on the window by having yet another with him?

GreyCarpet · 31/12/2023 11:53

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 11:43

Of course we're blaming women for it @Willyoujustbequiet !!! It's literally the point of this thread
No, it isn't.

Men are responsible for their behaviour.
Women are responsible for their behaviour.

If a man chooses to be a useless man child and awful partner he is 100% responsible for his behaviour.

If a woman meets a man who is lazy, selfish, has children he doesn't see or pay for and a string of excuses about his crazy ex girlfriends, the woman is responsible for stopping and deciding whether he's really a good catch or not before settling down and having kids with him. Having multiple babies with a man who already has shown he's a crap father who walks away from his existing children is silly at best. He's shown his new girlfriend exactly who he is

This with bells on!

gano · 31/12/2023 11:52

My stbxh was lovely for 6 years. We got married after 4 years. He was a model husband, and I felt so lucky to have him. He was kind, thoughtful, supportive and pulled his weight domestically. It all changed after 6 years together, about 6 months after the birth of dd. He slowly became selfish, unsupportive, did less and less housework, didn't want to spend time as a family, started messaging other women and became an aggressive drunk. I think he was great before we had a child, but having a young child meant that he wasn't my biggest priority anymore, and he couldn't deal with that. He became resentful and selfish, until I decided I wasn't willing to put up with it anymore.

LolaSmiles · 31/12/2023 11:43

Of course we're blaming women for it @Willyoujustbequiet !!! It's literally the point of this thread
No, it isn't.

Men are responsible for their behaviour.
Women are responsible for their behaviour.

If a man chooses to be a useless man child and awful partner he is 100% responsible for his behaviour.

If a woman meets a man who is lazy, selfish, has children he doesn't see or pay for and a string of excuses about his crazy ex girlfriends, the woman is responsible for stopping and deciding whether he's really a good catch or not before settling down and having kids with him. Having multiple babies with a man who already has shown he's a crap father who walks away from his existing children is silly at best. He's shown his new girlfriend exactly who he is

alwayslearning789 · 31/12/2023 11:08

JadziaD · 31/12/2023 10:54

I've only read bits of this thread but I am always amazed at threads like this where everyone seems to think it's just ONE thing. It's not. It's a whole bunch of issues that work alone and together depending on the circumstances. Ranging from:

The way women have been taught to expect less/do more.
The way men have been taught to expect to be at the top of any hierarchy and to have their needs and desires met first
The fact that many poor behaviours are not as obvious when life is easy and happy.
The way that many many women even when they question the behaviours are told they are wrong, that they need to "help him to learn" etc etc etc (seen on here ALL the time - it's all very well saying that women should spot the behaviours but th amount of minimising and excusing on here and in real life is mind-blowing).
The fact that once children come along, women's choices are reduced anyway because unlike men, they can't just stop looking after them.
Deep seated economic inequalities that mean men still overall earn more than women with more opportunities.
A society that has different expectations for men than it does for women.
Women's needs/preferences not considered as important

The list goes on and on and on and on and on.

@JadziaD

Long thread with good points however I feel you have hit the Nail on the Head with your post.

"The way women have been taught to expect less/do more.

The way men have been taught to expect to be at the top of any hierarchy and to have their needs and desires met first
The fact that many poor behaviours are not as obvious when life is easy and happy.
The way that many many women even when they question the behaviours are told they are wrong, that they need to "help him to learn" etc etc etc (seen on here ALL the time - it's all very well saying that women should spot the behaviours but th amount of minimising and excusing on here and in real life is mind-blowing).
The fact that once children come along, women's choices are reduced anyway because unlike men, they can't just stop looking after them.

Deep seated economic inequalities that mean men still overall earn more than women with more opportunities.
A society that has different expectations for men than it does for women.

Women's needs/preferences not considered as important"

JadziaD · 31/12/2023 10:54

I've only read bits of this thread but I am always amazed at threads like this where everyone seems to think it's just ONE thing. It's not. It's a whole bunch of issues that work alone and together depending on the circumstances. Ranging from:

The way women have been taught to expect less/do more.
The way men have been taught to expect to be at the top of any hierarchy and to have their needs and desires met first
The fact that many poor behaviours are not as obvious when life is easy and happy.
The way that many many women even when they question the behaviours are told they are wrong, that they need to "help him to learn" etc etc etc (seen on here ALL the time - it's all very well saying that women should spot the behaviours but th amount of minimising and excusing on here and in real life is mind-blowing).
The fact that once children come along, women's choices are reduced anyway because unlike men, they can't just stop looking after them.
Deep seated economic inequalities that mean men still overall earn more than women with more opportunities.
A society that has different expectations for men than it does for women.
Women's needs/preferences not considered as important

The list goes on and on and on and on and on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread