Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants kids to meet BIL's love children?

234 replies

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 06:21

So basically my husband has just told me that his brother has twins with another woman despite being married.

The twins are two years old and it had been very hush hush and even the wife didnt find out until recently, my husband knew from day one but I understand him not telling me as its none of my business.

My SIL is adamant that she does not want her kids meeting the twins or having anything to do with them and they are not aware that they have these new siblings.

The mother of the twins has requested via my BIL that she wants to meet us and our kids and sent us presents for the kids at Christmas.

Our children are 13, 10, 6 and 6 weeks old.

Im abit concerned about having our kids meet some random woman and how confusing it will be for our own kids explaining the situation especially since they are close with the cousins from the marriage and will obviously have to keep it a secret from the cousins are unaware of the twins and affair which I dont think is fair or right.

I also do not want my kids growing up thinking its acceptable to behave the way my BIL behaves and treats women.

The twins are innocent in all of this and I feel bad as most of the family have shunned them and have sided with my SIL who is now pregnant and if she gets wind that we may possibly meet this woman it will really upset her.

My husband and BIL are keen for meeting but I dont want my kids being caught in my BIL's mess.
I have told my husband that it will be best to wait until our kids are older and can make their own decisions.

My BIl is really upset by this and has stopped speaking to me and my husband.

Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
CherriesInChocolate · 30/12/2023 07:37

VivaVivaa · 30/12/2023 07:33

Your SIL should have developed some self respect and left this awful, awful man as opposed to have got knocked up by him.

I’d be very concerned in your shoes too about your DH’s deviousness.

Your DC should absolutely not have a relationship with the twins until their half siblings do. I think your BIL should ask their mother to back off. I feel very sorry for the twins in all this having such sh*tty, dysfunctional parents.

I assumed if she only recently found out and is pregnant enough for the wider family to know that BIL deliberately disclosed after she was pregnant knowing she would feel trapped and have to stay with him.

I could be mistaken of course.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 30/12/2023 07:36

"We'd be delighted to get to know your twins, and will happily meet them when you have ALL of your DC together with you, with your DW's knowledge. We will not be meeting them on their own and keeping it a secret, there have been enough secrets already."

DinoDays · 30/12/2023 07:35

Jeezus what a mess. Your poor poor SIL. Why is putting up with it? I suppose because she's pregnant and feels she has no choice. :(

Imagine being heavily pregnant and knowing your husband was off "visiting" his other kids. Most women when they're that pregnant won't want lots of high energy sex. However a woman who's desperate to get "her man"'will be offering it on a plate! He's obviously shagging the ass off the OW.

He's living the life of Riley.

I would have no part of it OP, the OW sounds as mad as a hatter! This will probably escalate if BIL doesn't leave his wife.

SIL should take back control of her own life, throw him out and tell her kids.

Also your DH's attitude leaves a bad taste, think I'd feel he was tainted being involved. Why did his brother tell him? To boast? It's all such a mess.

VivaVivaa · 30/12/2023 07:33

Your SIL should have developed some self respect and left this awful, awful man as opposed to have got knocked up by him.

I’d be very concerned in your shoes too about your DH’s deviousness.

Your DC should absolutely not have a relationship with the twins until their half siblings do. I think your BIL should ask their mother to back off. I feel very sorry for the twins in all this having such sh*tty, dysfunctional parents.

happyduckk · 30/12/2023 07:29

I think both you and the SIL are being massively unreasonable. What you choose to do will have a massive impact on the lives of the twins.
They will see and feel the rejection and that will stay with them forever.
Regarding not wanting your children to copy BIL's behaviour, presumably your children will watch movies, play games and generally be present it in the world? Do you think them watching news of war will make them copy that behaviour and go off and kill people?
It's not BIL's behaviour that your children my copy - they will copy your behaviour. Whether you choose to be kind and inclusive or not is what your children will learn.

LadyBird1973 · 30/12/2023 07:25

Sil is mad to have stayed and gotten pregnant a third time. Shes not helping herself here either.

Whatever you do it will be wrong - there's no win in this situation and I'd be absolutely fuming at bil for putting me and my kids in the middle of his shit show! It's probably good that dh didn't tell you, as it meant you weren't in the position of having to tell sil yourself. As a brother, your dh can argue that his primary loyalty was to his blood relative, but you wouldn't have had that argument. So by jot knowing, it's saved you the dilemma of what to do. Or kicked the can down the road at least.

I think I'd refuse to do anything without it being open and honest with sil. You can't do anything about their fucked up family situation but you can refuse to be complicit in lying to her. Agree with pp that you should ideally meet the twins when they are with their dad, if it's going to happen. The mum sounds pushy and batshit.
But whatever you do, someone is going to be annoyed. I think I'd let that person be bil, who is a piece of shit and shouldn't be enabled to have his cake and eat it!

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 30/12/2023 07:20

I would though discuss it all with SIL before my older dc so she has some control over the narrative.

BananaSpanner · 30/12/2023 07:17

Poor SIL, she needs to end the marriage, the betrayal is immense.

You should keep you and your children away from this until the adults directly involved come to an agreement and the children are all aware of the situation.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 30/12/2023 07:16

When the cousins know about their own siblings or when your dc reach 16/18 I would give them the option of meeting them. Depending on the maturity of your dc. Until then they do not have the maturity to not know but refrain from discussing it. Possibly explain to both older dc at the same time so they can discuss with each other. I would also be making it clear to my dc that while you don't agree with the set up you think they are old enough to manage the decision on whether to meet them or not. Until then your dc only know once their cousins know.

I would tell them at some point though because as soon as they are easily accessible on social media then either the mother or the twins themselves will contact them directly.

Mumoftwo1312 · 30/12/2023 07:15

A similar story happened to my best friend from school. She found out around age 11/12 that her dad had a second family with a son, when the son was about 5yo (ie she had a half brother she never knew). She had to keep the second family a secret from her (childless) step mum, who hed been married to since my best friend was a toddler.

She was totally and utterly devastated and felt betrayed by her dad - I remember at the time being so at a loss how to comfort her, it was all so dreadful and bizarre. The dad kept living a double life between the two women, the boy's mum and the second wife. After years of this, my BF became convinced that the stepmum did know, but pretended not to. A dreadful secret to have to keep so young.

My BF felt like she wasn't "enough" for her dad, that he had to go have another child. Also from a culture that traditionally prefers boys. It was heartbreaking for her.

This is going to be a total bombshell to your poor nieces and nephews (SIL's kids, but also OW's kids) when they find out. I'd urge everyone to tell the truth asap. If the 2yo twins grow up knowing the truth too then itll just be their normal.

I wouldn't be surprised if the BIL was living part time with the OW as a couple rather than just co parenting.

Unescorted · 30/12/2023 07:14

By asking your children to keep quiet about the twins when they speak to their cousins is asking them to be complicit. Your BIL and DH are asking your children to lie and potentially ruin the long term relationship they have and will have because your BIL cannot sort his crap out with his wife.

That would be an over my dead body situation for me.

Once BIL stops his cake and eat it lifestyle then I would have no problem with them meeting the twins. They after all are also innocent victims of the chaos your BIL is creating.

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 07:12

BananaSpanner · 30/12/2023 07:04

So is the affair still ongoing? Or has he separated from SIL?

A very good question.

DH says BIL has told her that he will never leave his wife and they cant be together but in a text DH showed me from Christmas where they exchanged pics of the kids BIL referred to the twins mom as "his girl" so it does make me wonder if the affair is ongoing?

OP posts:
JurassicFantastic · 30/12/2023 07:09

I do feel a bit annoyed that my DH didnt tell me but apparently he was sworn to secrecy

This is such a cop out and you know it.

He chose to be sworn to secrecy. He accepted those terms. He could have said no.

Your DH is a man who valued a quiet life more than honesty - including to you. He was happy to help cover up his brother's cheating and lying for years.

Even now he's thinking of himself and his brother, not you, your children, your SIL or her children. And now he wants you and your children to join him in the dishonesty.

I really think you need to have a long hard look at who he is and think seriously about whether you can trust him in your marriage. I couldn't.

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 07:09

BananaSpanner · 30/12/2023 07:00

Hang on, are BIL and SIL still married? And he is still in contact with other woman and still keeping secrets from SIL and trying to arrange for family to develop relationships with his new children behind the back of his wife and children? That is beyond deceitful and absolute madness.

I would not block a relationship with the twins in the future, as you say they are innocent in this, but it needs to be out in the open.

They are still married and she is currently pregnant with their third child.

BIL regularly goes to the twins house and spends time with them from what my DH tells me.

It does seem as if he is enjoying having two families and DH tells me that he is on very good terms with the twins mom and she gives him advice with his business.

OP posts:
CherriesInChocolate · 30/12/2023 07:05

I’d be happy for the children to meet during BIL’s contact time. That would be the most appropriate way for the children to build a relationship with their father’s extended family.

The gifts and meetings with the other woman I would say no to.

BananaSpanner · 30/12/2023 07:04

So is the affair still ongoing? Or has he separated from SIL?

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 07:04

Greenpolkadot · 30/12/2023 06:59

Apologies OP..just re-read your original post and see that sil already knows.She needs your support. You sound a strong person and I'm sure she's glad that she has you.

Aww thank you for your kind words.
I am doing my best to support SIL.

OP posts:
ItsMyPartyParty · 30/12/2023 07:02

What a mess. No I would not want my kids having a relationship with them if it involved keeping them a secret from the cousins. If the cousins knew, then I’d be happy for my kids to know them.

BIL needs to get real here, sounds like he’s enjoying having two families. There’s a lot more hurt to come if he doesn’t grow up quickly.

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 07:01

In glad I am not the only one who thinks this is a messed up situation.

The twins mother sounds a bit too much, when I gave birth to my son she was begging my BIL to send her a picture of my son and then brought us loads of gifts the same day which BIL brought round.

Apparently BIL and the twins mum just co parent and but she is hopeful that that they will be a family one day and be together.

From what I understand my BIL had no intention of telling my SIL about the twins it was the twins mum that text SIL of my BIL's phone when he was asleep one time and this is when the twins were 6 months old.

I do feel a bit annoyed that my DH didnt tell me but apparently he was sworn to secrecy.
I do feel he is a bit scared of my BIL (he is older) and even though he dosent say much about it I know he thinks its a messed up situation as well judging by his comments.

OP posts:
BananaSpanner · 30/12/2023 07:00

Hang on, are BIL and SIL still married? And he is still in contact with other woman and still keeping secrets from SIL and trying to arrange for family to develop relationships with his new children behind the back of his wife and children? That is beyond deceitful and absolute madness.

I would not block a relationship with the twins in the future, as you say they are innocent in this, but it needs to be out in the open.

Greenpolkadot · 30/12/2023 06:59

Apologies OP..just re-read your original post and see that sil already knows.She needs your support. You sound a strong person and I'm sure she's glad that she has you.

Greenpolkadot · 30/12/2023 06:52

Your poor sil. Your quite right op, you can't keep a secret such as this from her and can't expect your own kids to do so either
I can't understand why this woman wants to go from zero contact with you all to exchanging gifts.
And the twins aren't old enough to understand a relationship with you and your family.
Stay loyal to your sil and bugger what the stupid men want.
Jesus..it's a huge mess..
Sending you a hug

Shoppingfiend · 30/12/2023 06:49

She wants to buy your children presents???? What - this is odd - how is this a priority in this set up. I would say this is the last thing you want - she might start spending large amounts of money on things for your 3 children - you are then obligated to buy similar for hers??!!!
I would definitely leave it - anything you do affects your SIL and her children - i'd stay out of it.

HoppingPavlova · 30/12/2023 06:45

Under no circumstances should you participate in this dysfunctional bullshit. I’d also really be questioning your relationship with DH if he thinks this is okay/normal/acceptable. Fuck that.

JurassicFantastic · 30/12/2023 06:44

As a side note, I'd be very worried about and cross about DH keeping this a secret since day 1. He is not blameless in this either. On day 1 he could have said to his brother "you have a week to tell SIL or I do". But he didn't. He was happy to be complicit in cheating and lying - including to you. For years. Now he wants you to make his brother's life easier with no regard to the feelings of SIL or his brother's children.

Personally this is not a man I would want to be married to or would trust.