Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants kids to meet BIL's love children?

234 replies

perfumelover99 · 30/12/2023 06:21

So basically my husband has just told me that his brother has twins with another woman despite being married.

The twins are two years old and it had been very hush hush and even the wife didnt find out until recently, my husband knew from day one but I understand him not telling me as its none of my business.

My SIL is adamant that she does not want her kids meeting the twins or having anything to do with them and they are not aware that they have these new siblings.

The mother of the twins has requested via my BIL that she wants to meet us and our kids and sent us presents for the kids at Christmas.

Our children are 13, 10, 6 and 6 weeks old.

Im abit concerned about having our kids meet some random woman and how confusing it will be for our own kids explaining the situation especially since they are close with the cousins from the marriage and will obviously have to keep it a secret from the cousins are unaware of the twins and affair which I dont think is fair or right.

I also do not want my kids growing up thinking its acceptable to behave the way my BIL behaves and treats women.

The twins are innocent in all of this and I feel bad as most of the family have shunned them and have sided with my SIL who is now pregnant and if she gets wind that we may possibly meet this woman it will really upset her.

My husband and BIL are keen for meeting but I dont want my kids being caught in my BIL's mess.
I have told my husband that it will be best to wait until our kids are older and can make their own decisions.

My BIl is really upset by this and has stopped speaking to me and my husband.

Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
HerMammy · 30/12/2023 09:19

SIL found out 18mths ago, yet stayed and is now pregnant?
I've no sympathy for anyone here, keeping bringing kids into this hideous situation is madness.

Esmerelda2024 · 30/12/2023 09:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TempName247 · 30/12/2023 09:17

Goes without saying that BILs’ behaviour is disgusting and I feel massive sympathy for SIL, however I think she is wrong to keep her kids away from their siblings. BIL, as their father should absolutely be having regular contact with them, they are his children and I think any men who disown or don’t see their children are pathetic and the lowest of the low.

Shinyandnew1 · 30/12/2023 09:16

My BIl is really upset by this and has stopped speaking to me and my husband.

I really don’t think this is much of a loss here-he sounds like a total tosser.

Doyoumind · 30/12/2023 09:16

What a bunch of selfish adults (not you OP) and poor kids. Your BIL is an awful man. Obviously he shouldn't have been having an affair in the first place but when she got pregnant he should have come clean with everyone. He's messing up the lives of all his DC at the moment and the consequences will impact their whole lives.

Your SIL isn't blameless. Wtf was she doing getting pregnant in an attempt to trap him into staying knowing what she was bringing the child into?

And your DH expects his own DC to lie?

They all need to grow up and be honest. They aren't protecting the children by keeping quiet about it. They're just drawing out the deceit and making the whole situation more explosive in the long term.

LondonJax · 30/12/2023 09:13

happyduckk · 30/12/2023 07:29

I think both you and the SIL are being massively unreasonable. What you choose to do will have a massive impact on the lives of the twins.
They will see and feel the rejection and that will stay with them forever.
Regarding not wanting your children to copy BIL's behaviour, presumably your children will watch movies, play games and generally be present it in the world? Do you think them watching news of war will make them copy that behaviour and go off and kill people?
It's not BIL's behaviour that your children my copy - they will copy your behaviour. Whether you choose to be kind and inclusive or not is what your children will learn.

So finding out months/years later that your cousins knew you had half siblings won't damage the SIL/BIL children? They'll be fine will they @happyduckk, knowing that their 13, 10 and 6 year old cousins knew about the existence of these children before they did? That they all trundled off to meet them and 'play happy families' (which seems to be what the OW and BIL want). Have you actually read what BIL wants to happen and how his other kids know nothing about all of this? I'd say where was his backbone rather than pick on SIL and OP. If he really wanted this woman and the twins, he'd have grown some by now and explained it all to his children - with or without SIL blessing. Instead, all he's done, is sat back and enjoyed two families then blamed it all on SIL. What a catch!

Yes, SIL AND BIL need to tell their children that these siblings exist. But that's their job. It's not the job of a 13 year old,10 year old or 6 year old to accidentally blurt it out. And what sort of idiot expects a 6 year old to keep that secret?! It's bad enough even asking the other two to keep it quiet - you may, if you're lucky, succeed. But a 6 year old? Are BIL and the OW living in cuckoo land? Or are they playing a very clever game by, eventually, having the 'secret' slip to the BILs children (but not by either of them) - forcing SIL hand?

It's the adults secret. It's for the adults to sort out. The twins won't suffer - the only people who can cause them heartache are BIL and OW if they tell them 'the family don't want to meet them'. That's not true. The family don't want their children dragged into something that only adults can sort out. Totally different and nothing to do with all the innocent kids on all sides.

Sodndashitall · 30/12/2023 09:12

Your BIL needs to understand that your DC cannot keep this secret. It's not even fair to ask this of them. Therefore if the SIL doesn't want her DC knowing then your DC can't meet them as they can't be expected not to say anything.
Forget the rights and wrong of the situation it's just not fair on your DC

Ktime · 30/12/2023 09:12

JurassicFantastic · 30/12/2023 09:03

The twins are two years old and it had been very hush hush and even the wife didnt find out until recently

it was the twins mum that text SIL of my BIL's phone when he was asleep one time and this is when the twins were 6 months old

Which is it? Has SIL known for 18 months or just found our recently?

I'm beginning to smell a rat. Should have spotted it at the mention of twins.

Good spot, @JurassicFantastic .

OP, please explain the discrepancy, as people are giving advice in good faith here.

MinervatheGreat · 30/12/2023 09:11

“JurassicFantastic · Today 06:37

What the status of this woman's current relationship with BIL? Her sending gifts sounds as though they are still in a relationship and she wants to be accepted by the family, not just the children.”

This in part from @JurassicFantastic !

She is pushing herself where it is currently not appropriate to do so.

A family is being imploded and she’s sending gifts? Really?

Your children can’t be expected to keep secrets. Your husband and his brother are being immature to attempt to foist this on the wider family.

Keep your kids out of it until BIL has sorted out his wife and the OW. Then and only then, it would be nice to welcome the twins.

liveforsummer · 30/12/2023 09:11

RowanMayfair · 30/12/2023 06:22

Your kids can't develop a relationship with these kids until their own siblings know about them. Expecting kids to keep a secret like this is ridiculous.

This. Your dc can't even know about these twins unless their cousins to. Hugely unreasonable for anyone to expect them to keep that secret and I'd be furious if they were my dc that anyone might think that's ok

Ilovelurchers · 30/12/2023 09:10

Firstly, I don't think your children will be damaged in any way by meeting this woman and her children their cousins. They are going to meet people in their lives who have affairs (and much worse). It's OK - it's not contagious! It certainly wouldn't be right to ask your children to lie about or conceal the meeting however - is this what your husband their father is pushing for?

Your oldest child, and arguably the second oldest, are at an age where you can ask them if they have any interest in meeting these two year old twins or not. I would certainly be asking my daughter, who is 12, and would be guided by her answer.

What I wouldn't be doing is making any massive moral judgements about anyone involved. Clearly your brother and SIL have a highly unusual relationship, as she has accepted him having two children with another woman, and gone on to have more kids with him herself.

Different strokes for different folks - one assumes they are polyamorists or something? (I can't even spell it). As clearly, most people would leave their husband if he had twins with someone else, not crack on and have another baby with him.

It's up to them, isn't it? No point being angry on the SIL"s behalf when she clearly isn't that bothered about it herself.

The twins are CERTAINLY innocent parties on this, so I wouldn't deliberately exclude them from the family. I think that would be horrible. But it's up to your kids whether they want to meet them or not. If they don't I'd maybe meet the mom for a coffee myself and have a look at the babies or whatever she wants you to do. I wouldn't like to anyone about it tho - why should you?

ElevenSeven · 30/12/2023 09:08

No, I wouldn’t have anything to do with them.

Lydia777 · 30/12/2023 09:07

Agree! Your husband has behaved terribly and I would question the kind of person he is.

TrolleyCase · 30/12/2023 09:07

And currently for the twins, perhaps ‘ignorance is bliss’. They are not being actively ‘punished’. They are actually being kept away from the big family dramas that might ensue if the new family is forced to ‘accept’ them.

I have no idea why the sil has stayed with this man. There must be some compelling psychological or practical reasons at play. But for now, her view should be respected. She must be so hurt and devastated. And is vulnerable right now.

I would not accede to a single one of bil’s requests. I would not really be able to even look at him right now.

What a mess.

AllEars112232 · 30/12/2023 09:05

JurassicFantastic · 30/12/2023 06:37

What the status of this woman's current relationship with BIL? Her sending gifts sounds as though they are still in a relationship and she wants to be accepted by the family, not just the children.

In terms of meeting the twins, agree with what PP have said. Your BIL can't have his cake and eat it. He can't be expecting you and your children to keep secrets from his wife and children, so if you meet the twins you are able to talk openly about it.

I also don't think it would be fair for cousins to meet before siblings meet.

These are issues he needs to resolve in his own marriage before getting pissy with you.

If having the twins in his family life is so important to him he is free to leave SIL and make his own decisions about what happens with their children and who they meet, on his time with them. If he doesn't want to do that then he needs to start treating SIL with some respect and not pressure you to treat her views with disrespect.

Exactly!
clearly this relationship is on going otherwise sending gifts to your children is totally bizarre.
I think you are right to refuse to drag your children into BIL’s seedy world.
Your DH is not acting reasonably, presumably because he has a misguided (in this case) loyalty to his twin.

emilysquest · 30/12/2023 09:05

I'm beginning to smell a rat. Should have spotted it at the mention of twins.

Now I think of it, this.

Tonight1 · 30/12/2023 09:05

This is so messy. For now, distance is best. OW seems to think she is family??

Keep close to SIL and discuss things with her. Surprised she wants to stay with him.

AuContraire · 30/12/2023 09:05

Feel very sorry for your SIL, clearly her conceiving this latest baby was done as part of a pick-me strategy, to try and keep her family and marriage together after your awful, deceitful BIL's decision to destroy everyone's stability. But this baby will always exist in the shadow of these circumstances, which will make it very hard for SIL to enjoy it how she should. Ultimately this whole thing will tear her apart.

Poor baby. Poor SIL, and your poor neices and nephews (and the twins).

LadyEloise1 · 30/12/2023 09:04

Did I read correctly that your sil is now pregnant despite knowing her husband has had an affair behind her back and has twins with the ow ?
Is her cheating husband the father of the baby she is expecting ?

JurassicFantastic · 30/12/2023 09:03

The twins are two years old and it had been very hush hush and even the wife didnt find out until recently

it was the twins mum that text SIL of my BIL's phone when he was asleep one time and this is when the twins were 6 months old

Which is it? Has SIL known for 18 months or just found our recently?

I'm beginning to smell a rat. Should have spotted it at the mention of twins.

TrolleyCase · 30/12/2023 09:03

I would never make a child lie or keep a secret like this. Other than perhaps a surprise gift for their other parent, children should not be burdened with the responsibility of secrets, especially life-changing ones like this.

WonderingWanda · 30/12/2023 09:03

This sounds incredibly complicated. So is the bil with his wife still or with this other woman? I think that makes a huge difference. If he is still with his wife but wants to facilitate some sort of extra family then this is bonkers what on earth is he playing at? If he has left his wife....or if his wife has any sense and has kicked him out and is now trying to form new life with this woman and the twins then as disgusting as his behaviour was I would say that this is the new normal. These twins are also his children and I doubt his wife will be able to keep them a secret forever as much as she doesn't want to hurt her own children.

Lwrenagain · 30/12/2023 09:03

Toomanysquishmallows · 30/12/2023 08:27

@Lwrenagain , my dd is in the opposite situation, my ex , his ow and their child are part of his family, dd has been blanked for 20 years.

Your poor daughter. I'm so sorry they've done this to her and you, fuckers. I hope he falls arse first on a cactus making every poo spikey & insufferable!

Ktime · 30/12/2023 09:01

I do feel a bit annoyed that my DH didnt tell me but apparently he was sworn to secrecy.

I don’t think such a thing should be kept from a spouse. My first thought was that your DH doesn’t seem to think what his brother did is that bad but hopefully that’s not the case as he’s agreed your family won’t be meeting BIL’s second family.

I would also minimise contact with BIL where possible.

emilysquest · 30/12/2023 09:00

There are people who choose to live polygamous lives, I have known some, and I don't judge them negatively if everyone is consenting and on board, without coercion. In that situation the children were all well aware they were all part of the same family and no secrets were ever kept. That is emphatically not the case here and I would refuse to involve my children in it if I were you.