Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Female sex: only negative associations?

64 replies

Appleinthepark · 29/12/2023 22:07

I mostly don't think about this but when I do, I get so upset.

I have 3 DCs and I have children of both genders. When expectong my DD I came across scientific papers on offspring sex ratio. Most of them claim that:

-more girls are born in stressful times like during a famine or war
-poor, short, starving mothers have more girls
-stressed mothers have more girls
-fathers with anxiety history have more girls
-billionaires have more sons

I found these facts so upsetting and still do. Boys are associated with all the good stuff: they are walking indicators of wealthy, dominating, well nourished, condident yet relaxed parents. Those who have girls are worse off.

I know they are just scientific papers but I actually got quite offended first, then sad: I generally find it difficult to think I am not capable of something and those papers make me feel like being a woman or having girls is somehow an indicator of being less worthy or not being the best version of yourself.

How do others feel about such scientific papers? Any woman here who does not feel like these statements get under your skin?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 30/12/2023 21:40

Good, hope you're feeling better OP.

Appleinthepark · 30/12/2023 20:57

manoffthelead · 30/12/2023 17:12

Much will depend on the quality and integrity of the research. To my uninformed ear some of this sounds a bit outdated, certainly so far as so called 'developed' countries are concerned. However, in so called 'developing' countries there are practicalities of life that can (wrongly and unfairly) make a difference, which do not apply in more developed countries.

I think your reaction is perfectly reasonable and understandable. Don't get sad or upset - get active. Look for ways you can support girls and young woman in countries where the issue is most acute.

Thank you, this is probably like you said.
When I reread the papers they were based on data from 1800s or so and some major world events like the Spanish flu.

Many have pointed out that what I don't get right is how statistics should be read. Not every boy is born to the wealthy and clueless, confident couples and not every girl is born to anxious, stressed, worried couples. Just like there are very tall people born in spring even tough statistically people born in autumn are slightly taller, on average.(for example: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1570677X22000533)

I really did find it upsetting that all female offspring related seemed to portray mothers of girls in quite sad light (famine, stress, poverty) but many of you offered some really positive points of view. Now I see mothers of girls as resilient survivors as well.

OP posts:
StragglyTinsel · 30/12/2023 18:48

That’s true @ErrolTheRednosedDragon. She is saying something extremely weird about the shame of gestating a girl.

But this OP being weird and ridiculous and having no ability to grasp the basic arguments of what she’s reading doesn’t tell us anything about the research itself. So we shouldn’t write any research off based on this OP’s odd summary.

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 30/12/2023 17:21

This kind of anthropological research shows population level patterns.

Quite so - at an individual it's mostly just the heads or tails of whether an X or Y sperm does the fertilisation

It actually has nothing to do with this ‘women are the constitutionally weaker sex’ crap this OP is pedalling.

I don't think that's quite what she's saying - it's actually something odder: that having a girl marks the mother out as being weaker in some way compared to other women.

Whereas actually it could well be that in the studies of malnourished populations, some of the 'weakest' women lost a male foetus and didn't have a baby at all.

manoffthelead · 30/12/2023 17:12

Much will depend on the quality and integrity of the research. To my uninformed ear some of this sounds a bit outdated, certainly so far as so called 'developed' countries are concerned. However, in so called 'developing' countries there are practicalities of life that can (wrongly and unfairly) make a difference, which do not apply in more developed countries.

I think your reaction is perfectly reasonable and understandable. Don't get sad or upset - get active. Look for ways you can support girls and young woman in countries where the issue is most acute.

StragglyTinsel · 30/12/2023 17:08

Zuve · 30/12/2023 17:06

Oh I don't believe that research. You can prove anything by research. Personally I am pleased I am a girl

This kind of anthropological research shows population level patterns. It actually has nothing to do with this ‘women are the constitutionally weaker sex’ crap this OP is pedalling.

Don't write research off because this OP is being ridiculous.

StragglyTinsel · 30/12/2023 17:06

I think it is the weakness/worse off aspect that disturbs me. I like girls' and women's company and love pink, and I adore and am inspired by many female leaders (who have daughters). I prefer female doctors cause I think they are often more competent and precise. So this is quite embarrasing really!

What the fuck does liking pink have to do with the price of fish?

Honestly. What nonsense. Insulting nonsense.

Step away from Google scholar. You clearly are not equipped to interpret academic results.

Zuve · 30/12/2023 17:06

Oh I don't believe that research. You can prove anything by research. Personally I am pleased I am a girl

HappyBusman · 30/12/2023 16:46

Appleinthepark · 30/12/2023 13:56

Thank you - I know that it cannot be black and white. How would one otherwise explain boy/girl twins or triplets with both sexes?

I think it is the weakness/worse off aspect that disturbs me. I like girls' and women's company and love pink, and I adore and am inspired by many female leaders (who have daughters). I prefer female doctors cause I think they are often more competent and precise. So this is quite embarrasing really!

It is only that having weaknesses has always been scary to me. Dominance and confidence are hard to measure and they cannot be seen and I easily feel lagging behind and "less" and maybe these scientific papers sort of underline my occasionally low self esteem?

OP, the only thing you should be concerned about is your complete inability to understand statistics and your misapplication of the results of some scientific studies to your own rather confused ideas about femaleness. I would suggest a short sharp course of self-education in statistics. Maybe someone has already suggested a Future Learn or equivalent.

Benibidibici · 30/12/2023 14:48

The differences they are talking about, while statistically significant on a population level, are tiny on an indivual levels. It can be 52% girls vs 48% boys, as opposed to 51% girls 49% boys.

Its nothing to do with you being in a "poor state"!

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 30/12/2023 14:43

SerendipityJane · 30/12/2023 14:36

You said got kids of both sexes, right?

Most pointedly, the OP did not say that .....

No, I am assuming she's using 'gender' as a euphemism for sex as 'gender' is otherwise irrelevant and she immediately followed by mentioning 'sex ratios'.

SerendipityJane · 30/12/2023 14:36

You said got kids of both sexes, right?

Most pointedly, the OP did not say that .....

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 30/12/2023 14:24

You're really misinterpreting and overthinking all this, I think, OP.
You said got kids of both sexes, right? Maybe you happened to have a girl when you were feeling more stressed than when you had a boy? But that's just coincidence - it's near enough a 50:50 coin flip.

TheUser420 · 30/12/2023 14:14

Cannabis is a good example. When stressed (day lengths) it goes onto flower.

Ahem.

Most strains of cannabis (which is dioecious) use photoperiodicity to trigger flowering - shorter days lead to a build up of a light sensitive hormone which signals flowering. As an annual plant cannabis only gets one shot.

There are strains that "autoflower" and will move into flowering regardless of photoperiod.

A stressed cannabis plant can tend towards hermaphrodite tendencies. "Hermies" in the unreconstructed trade of cannabis breeding.

If your main goal is cannabis for medicine you want female plants. Which explains why seeds for sale are quite often "feminized". Since for reasons of reality cannabis knows nothing about gender.

There is a whole body of research which shows how evolution led to the cannabis plant coming in 2 distinct sexes (like stinging nettles and some trees).

So the take home message is that female cannabis plants are more valuable. Most growers will bin any male plants as soon as possible since for the drug you want unpollinated females (sinsemilla means "without seed" in Spanish)

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 30/12/2023 14:07

I'm not sure I see 'dominance' as being a positive trait!!

Appleinthepark · 30/12/2023 13:56

Eekmystro · 30/12/2023 12:51

How interesting. I’ve never heard of that before.

I do not find it offensive. Seems a bit odd to find the outcome of research offensive, unless you think the outcomes are biased and not accurate.

I have a DD and I don’t find it upsetting either. Just because infant girls are more common under some circumstances doesn’t mean that every girl is born because of those circumstances.

Thank you - I know that it cannot be black and white. How would one otherwise explain boy/girl twins or triplets with both sexes?

I think it is the weakness/worse off aspect that disturbs me. I like girls' and women's company and love pink, and I adore and am inspired by many female leaders (who have daughters). I prefer female doctors cause I think they are often more competent and precise. So this is quite embarrasing really!

It is only that having weaknesses has always been scary to me. Dominance and confidence are hard to measure and they cannot be seen and I easily feel lagging behind and "less" and maybe these scientific papers sort of underline my occasionally low self esteem?

OP posts:
Desecratedcoconut · 30/12/2023 13:32

That's so weird, it was definitely there this morning.

Butchyrestingface · 30/12/2023 13:29

Desecratedcoconut · 30/12/2023 13:20

You should see the op's other thread, there she is oppressed by a patriarchal system that judges her for perfectly ordinary things that women do now that may have been frowned upon fifty or more years ago.

Can't see any other threads for that username in my advanced search.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 30/12/2023 13:26

As the daughter of sheep farmer it's always made sense to me that men are evolutionarily disposable

It's the same as all the "men were so important because they hunted the big animals" when (apart from the fact research shows women did too) if this was the case it was because men were more disposable not because they were more important

After all we only need a few rams for 100s of sheep to keep the herd going...

Desecratedcoconut · 30/12/2023 13:20

Butchyrestingface · 30/12/2023 13:03

It just makes me feel like I failed: I was not dominant or relaxed or confident but in a "poor state" and then becomes obvious to anyone and to yourself when you have a girl. It is like an indicator that you cannot hide 🫤

You DO seem fragile though, such that you've framed an evolutionary adaptation so negatively and admit to feeling "so upset" whenever you think of it.

You should see the op's other thread, there she is oppressed by a patriarchal system that judges her for perfectly ordinary things that women do now that may have been frowned upon fifty or more years ago.

Butchyrestingface · 30/12/2023 13:03

It just makes me feel like I failed: I was not dominant or relaxed or confident but in a "poor state" and then becomes obvious to anyone and to yourself when you have a girl. It is like an indicator that you cannot hide 🫤

You DO seem fragile though, such that you've framed an evolutionary adaptation so negatively and admit to feeling "so upset" whenever you think of it.

Willyoubuymeahouseofgold · 30/12/2023 12:57

Really not sure that's all based on evidence. Women don't determine the sex of babies and some facts there imply attributes of women are linked to predetermining the sex.
If there is a change in ratio then I'd be pretty happy mother nature is adjusting to environmental factors.

Eekmystro · 30/12/2023 12:51

How interesting. I’ve never heard of that before.

I do not find it offensive. Seems a bit odd to find the outcome of research offensive, unless you think the outcomes are biased and not accurate.

I have a DD and I don’t find it upsetting either. Just because infant girls are more common under some circumstances doesn’t mean that every girl is born because of those circumstances.

Allthatglittersisntart · 30/12/2023 12:29

It’s more of a positive thing. When things are worrying outside, the world needs more women. We really don't need that many men to continue the human race. Just enough for genetic diversity.

keeyartheseagull · 30/12/2023 12:24

I bloody love having girls and I'm proud of them and of me.

We are resilient and bloody amazing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread