Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell daughter I'm adopted?

110 replies

Starfish125 · 29/12/2023 21:35

So my dad adopted me when I was 6 (mum is my biological mum) the man who got my mum pregnant wasn't interested and I've never seen or met him in my 34 years of being here and I never will. My dad was a fantastic dad and grandad and tragically died at 55 4 years ago. My daughter has no idea he adopted me, and I always felt I would tell her one day (she's 10 btw) but not yet. However, the problem here is someone else telling her. My cousin (dad's brothers daughter) used to relish in reminding me that we weren't 'real' family and our shared cousins were more her family than mine. This was gutting at the time but she was a horrible child. She has changed since then but unfortunately has also had, a horrible child of her own. Now I'm 99% sure knowing my cousin that she's told her daughter (who is also 10) that my dad adopted me. I'm so so worried she'll tell my daughter before I get the chance to, but equally I don't want to tell her either, as I'm worried it'll change her views on me and my family? I couldn't bare it if she thought they were all 'pretend' or whatever. For the record my other cousins are very close to me and never treated me like my other cousin did and the irony is that they don't speak to her anymore, just me. What do people think I should do regarding telling my daughter? Also to not drip feed,.this cousin of mine I still see as she's grown up to be a lot nicer but I still think she may have told her daughter this.

You are being unreasonable - tell her
You are not being unreasonable - don't tell her

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MollyButton · 05/01/2024 11:17

Dontcallmescarface · 31/12/2023 09:37

DD has zero tolerance for cheaters.......she is VLC with her dad for that very reason (she hasn't told him about her upcoming wedding and doesn't want him there). Having half siblings due to divorce or remarrying after a spouse dies is no big deal to as far as she's concerned, but knowing that her nanna cheated on her gramp would absolutely taint DD's memory of her.

I have to warn you that it could have serious health consequences in the future. For a lot of health problems the first questions they ask are about family history.
(Nevermind finding out from ears or cleft chin etc that your ancestry can't be what you thought).

Porageeater · 02/01/2024 09:48

Well done OP that’s great!

Cheepcheepcheep · 01/01/2024 20:32

That’s wonderful news OP, I’m glad it’s been such a straightforward experience. Sometimes I swear the things we worry about turn out to be nothing at all!

Starfish125 · 01/01/2024 19:02

Thought I would give an update, I took on board everyone's thoughts which was pretty much unanimous that there was no need to hide it like a dirty secret and best coming from me, and sooner rather than later. Well I didn't want to just announce it randomly so thought I would casually mention it at an appropriate time. Well, half an hour ago her and her younger brother were doing that 'you're adopted' insult (and people wonder why I was worried lol) and I said, well I'm adopted, not fully, nanny is my nanny but grandad adopted me when I was little. She said really? I said yup, but I was so breezy about it I think it definitely made it less of a deal. She asked a few questions like why, how, I explained and she literally said ok, oh mum look at what I built on fortnite! Which made me smile as it was clearly a conversation that was over and done with, with no issues, which was my biggest worry. Thanks so much to everyone, I definitely had worries due to the 'taboo' feeling I had when I was little but I realize now times have changed and there's nothing to be ashamed of.

OP posts:
PinkCandles · 31/12/2023 11:50

Just tell her like you've told us what a wonderful dad he was. Sorry for your loss op

dressedforcomfort · 31/12/2023 11:49

My Mum was adopted. I found out when I was about 8. It didn't make a blind bit of difference to me. Kids tend to accept the reality with which they are presented and Mum's adopted family never felt any less my family....

chompargh · 31/12/2023 11:42

Good idea to. She'll be asked about family medical history at some point in her life.

SevenKingsMustDie · 31/12/2023 11:41

Please tell her!

I found out that a family member was adopted, from a comment made by a neighbour. It turned out that everyone else knew and my parents thought I did too!

Not a nice feeling to find out by accident...

Dontcallmescarface · 31/12/2023 09:37

DD has zero tolerance for cheaters.......she is VLC with her dad for that very reason (she hasn't told him about her upcoming wedding and doesn't want him there). Having half siblings due to divorce or remarrying after a spouse dies is no big deal to as far as she's concerned, but knowing that her nanna cheated on her gramp would absolutely taint DD's memory of her.

SingaporeSlinky · 31/12/2023 09:11

@Dontcallmescarface no need to be snarky, when I said your daughter’s children I just meant potential future generations who may also decide to trace a family tree. I wasn’t meaning to go into the ins and outs of your personal life.
But it’s interesting that you’ve listed all these half siblings everywhere, and yet you think your mother’s memory would be “tainted” in your DD’s eyes if she knew your paternity.

Incogg · 31/12/2023 09:10

So there's your answer, DD is not interested in finding out anymore about her ancestry than she knows already so there is no need to tell her.

Phew! You have all of the answers so the secrets and lies can continue.

Dontcallmescarface · 31/12/2023 07:54

SingaporeSlinky · 30/12/2023 22:26

@Dontcallmescarface agree with others, you might be thinking of the basic Ancestry test, where your Dd would get a sheet saying for example ‘80% English, 15% Scottish, 5% Swedish’. Assuming that isn’t going to cause any questions in itself, the problem comes if she or her children decide to trace a family tree with names, dates etc. It’s so easy with records online these days, she may discover something that way. Wouldn’t it save a lot of hassle if she knew the truth from you?

The family tree has already been done right back to the 1700's on both sides of my family by my cousin (her mother was my dad's sister and her dad was my mum's brother), so there would be no need for her to start tracing the family tree as it has already been done. As she won't be having children ever (well done for that assumption by the way), that won't ever be an issue. As for anything untoward being thrown up well, given that she has a half sibling, her father has 2 half siblings and both my parents had 5 half siblings between them them (which DD knows all about), then it's safe to say that there will be a match that none of us knew about, but it won't automatically be through me. Anyway all of that is a moot point as I asked her( when we spoke yesterday) what she would do if someone sent her an ancestry kit and her answer was "why would they? I'd just ask if anyone wants it and give it to them, 48 people in my family is quite enough, I don't need anymore"
So there's your answer, DD is not interested in finding out anymore about her ancestry than she knows already so there is no need to tell her.

SingaporeSlinky · 30/12/2023 22:26

@Dontcallmescarface agree with others, you might be thinking of the basic Ancestry test, where your Dd would get a sheet saying for example ‘80% English, 15% Scottish, 5% Swedish’. Assuming that isn’t going to cause any questions in itself, the problem comes if she or her children decide to trace a family tree with names, dates etc. It’s so easy with records online these days, she may discover something that way. Wouldn’t it save a lot of hassle if she knew the truth from you?

ChellyT · 30/12/2023 21:50

Chosen bonds are more precious than blood bonds. Your (adoption) father chose you, loved you and stood with you @Starfish125 absolutely beautiful in every way anyone looks at it. You are overthinking this, tell your daughter in a light loving way 🌸

PurpleBugz · 30/12/2023 21:35

"I also would never have called matey boy a sperm donor to her, that's just what I call him, I can't even say bio father because using the word father about him feels horribly betraying to my dad."

I think you need to see the words mean different things. A father makes a baby. That is what a father is. Your father was your father that can't be denied. Because so many many fathers are dads the words mean the same for a lot of people. But the words are not interchangeable. A dad is sooo much more than a father. Your father was never your dad. Your adopted dad was 100% your dad.

TimetoPour · 30/12/2023 18:16

Your lovely Dad adopted you because he loved you and wanted you. No one can take that away and those that try to tarnish it by saying he isn’t your real father are jealous and utter cretins.

I personally wouldn’t create a serious sit down conversation but when you next chat about your dad you can say your favourite memory is of him adopting you and let the conversation flow from there. It most certainly shouldn’t be a secret that you feel you are hiding.

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 18:08

AuntMarch · 30/12/2023 15:50

But in this case, OPs dad (like mine) did choose her.

Very good point.

MoreDollies · 30/12/2023 18:04

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 15:41

For anyone contemplating telling a child that they are adopted, please first ensure that the child knows where babies come from in the first place. If they don't know that, you are telling the child that they are somehow different without them having the knowledge of what that difference is. And please don't tell them "We chose you". You probably didn't, the child was allocated to you by whatever agency you dealt with - you don't choose a child like you choose a puppy. Speaking as an adopted child.

Speaking also as an adopted child, I couldn't disagree with you more. I loved that my mum and dad told me they chose me. And my mum used to pretend that she picked me out from among the other babies - of course I realise now that wasn't how it happened, but it made me feel very special as a child. And, while we might be dealing in semantics, they did choose to be adoptive parents and that's close enough.

LlynTegid · 30/12/2023 16:42

I think you should. It is quite likely that friends of hers will be being brought up by a mum and stepdad (or man who adopted them), so what you will tell her will not be something unique. Also an opportunity to tell her again how lovely he was, hope she has happy memories of him as well.

Benibidibici · 30/12/2023 16:02

It would be very different if it was one of her own immediate family (parent or sibling) but its a very different relationship with extended family. Its probably far less of a big deal for her than it is for you, just tell her.

Be prepared for her to wonder about the biological grandfather. Do you have a name or any other information about him?

Silverbirchtwo · 30/12/2023 15:58

Dontcallmescarface · 30/12/2023 13:26

Well as that won't tell her who her gramp was just his origins, I can't see how getting an Ancestry test would result in some sort of big reveal.

She might get matches with half siblings if he had other children, which would be very obvious with the closeness of the matches.

I've been hesitating to suggest this to my cousin, who was adopted by her Dad after he married her mother. She knows all about it, but not who her biological father was, her mother would never tell her and she and anyone else who might have known are now gone, almost certainly her biological father is also gone, but he may well have other children alive.

I found my GF had a half brother when I got an unknown close match on Ancestry, that I tracked back.

DoAWheelie · 30/12/2023 15:56

The younger you tell her the better it will go.

Finding out your family isn't what you thought it was can mess with your sense of identity. It isn't the actual family make up that causes issues - it's knowing you were not told the truth (and often leads to "well what else did they not tell me about).

I'd bring it up casually and let her know she can ask any questions she has. Don't treat it like a big dark secret.

There was a similar thing in my family - one of my uncles has a different father to everyone else and it was hushed up. It finally came out when I was late teens and most of my cousins were in their twenties. It caused a lot of hurt and broken trust that took a while to get over. Again but because of the facts -no one cares and we love him just the same as we always did, but because of the lies. Mo

Silverbirchtwo · 30/12/2023 15:50

If he adopted you he is your Dad in every legal way. He's not your biological father, but once you are adopted you have equal rights with any other children and he is your Dad.

Does your 10 yr old understand about how babies are made? This could turn into more a sex talk than an I was adopted by my Dad talk!

AuntMarch · 30/12/2023 15:50

But in this case, OPs dad (like mine) did choose her.

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 15:41

For anyone contemplating telling a child that they are adopted, please first ensure that the child knows where babies come from in the first place. If they don't know that, you are telling the child that they are somehow different without them having the knowledge of what that difference is. And please don't tell them "We chose you". You probably didn't, the child was allocated to you by whatever agency you dealt with - you don't choose a child like you choose a puppy. Speaking as an adopted child.