Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is my new partner starting to get abit weird about money and assets

638 replies

smilingeleanor · 29/12/2023 19:27

Name changed as some of this might be abit outing. My DH passed away unexpectedly over 4 years ago and I have been seeing my partner for about 9 months. Wasn't looking and still not sure I'm that ready but we met at a work conference thing and it's been fun and easy ....ish until more recently

I have 5 children - 4 living at home, eldest DD24 lives with boyfriend, adult DD20 at university, DS19 working full time and then DS14 at secondary and DD9 in primary school. New partner has 2 sons also both 14 who live mainly with their mum - all amicable.

There's been a few things of late concerning me - Started when i was having new flooring laid and he asked how I could afford it on my salary (we both earn about the same - we do the same sort of role so everyone knows the salary bands). He's hinted before about my house early on and I kinda had to say well my husband died but he's been angling for more info since. Life insurance paid off the mortgage plus a payment & death in service. I've mostly invested this and use my salary for the bills - but no mortgage or debts means salary goes further

anyhow I just laughed the flooring question off - but over xmas we got in a convo about a summer holiday. I was inviting adult DD who wanted to go and he overheard me say it was my treat - he was already wanting to go and would be paying himself but he then said can his boys come - fine by me they are nice lads and seem to get on on with mine but he sort made a joke about me paying for them as a treat. I nipped that straight away and said he'd have to pay for them as i couldn't and he got a bit narky saying well my sons and daughter who both work could pay for themselves freeing up that money

he later apologised but tried to say i do t get it as obviously have no mortgage or debt

anyhow - we've had another set to today. Having a NYE get together- DD and her boyf coming and will use the guest bedroom (her old room) as they always do. He seemed to think his boys would be there and has told them this - they don't want to sleep on air bed in my son's room or in the living room apparently.

He also says i'm closed off and secretive about my financial situation and doesn't get why

Im just abit fed up now - i dont want drama and i will not get into conversations about what i have invested and where. Although he did admit to looking up the market value of my house!

OP posts:
exitviathegiftshop · 31/12/2023 19:47

is it possible that he is mentally getting ahead of himself and sees this as a long term thing and was (misguidedly and inappropriately at this stage but people are silly sometimes) trying to ensure his boys were treated fairly and equally in his new family...?

DeeLusional · 31/12/2023 18:39

Whatever OP decides to do, keep seeing him or dump him, the fact is that she WORKS with him so best all round to keep things civil. Way too soon to have started bringing his boys round, though, whichever way it goes.

LaurieStrode · 31/12/2023 18:37

I wonder, if it were such a "joke," if he would have declined had OP actually acquiesced to funding a holiday for HIS kids.

Would he have backpedaled and protested "Oh, no, I was only joking! I wouldn't dream of letting you subsidize my family, that's MY job as their dad." Or would he have eagerly hopped online and started investigating beach resorts?

So glad you spoke plainly to him, OP. The whole "he went quiet for a while" though suggests he is flummoxed at the idea of your finances being off limits for conversation or anything else.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/12/2023 18:33

Most people are inherently good, but sometimes say or do stupid or thoughtless things.

How can you afford that flooring, you’re on similar wages to me?!

This question possibly come under ‘stupid or thoughtless’ things to say. He possibly hadn’t clocked that she had her mortgage paid off due to life insurance and isn’t paying child maintenance like he has so she has more disposable income.

I might buy that, but telling her she shouldn’t pay for treats for her own adult children and having a ‘thing’ about that-isn’t stupid/thoughtless, it’s interfering and none of his business. Telling her that his sons should get to stay in her daughter’s bedroom rather than her, isn’t thoughtless, it’s bossy and none of his business. Suggesting his sons come on holiday with them when he knows he can’t afford that, and then ‘joking’ that she should pay for them by telling her own kids to pay for themselves, isn’t stupid or thoughtless either. It’s opportunistic and none of his business.

pikkumyy77 · 31/12/2023 18:29

“I want to see the best in people and not hold a grudge “ is such a lovely sentiment!

But don’t let sentiment make you foolish. I take people at their deeds, not their words, until I know them well enough to know that they are completely honest and transparent. Just because I don’t take the word for the deed also doesn’t mean I don’t see the best in people! I do see the best when they show their best!

I don’t think taking a “trust but verify” stance towards a new person in your life is “grudge holding” either. To me that is a very problematic way of thinking. If my accountant embezzles from me and I don’t choose to be a repeat customer am I “holding a grudge?” If I date someone for a while and discover they don’t bathe, or steal tips, and I decide this is not for me am I “holding a grudge?” This feels like nice girl syndrome weaponized against you. Deciding you don’t like a behavior is not grudge holding! Remembering an incident and not choosing to forget or rug sweep it is not grudge holding. We have memory for a reason! We aren’t plankton—we need memory to learn from the past.

I wish and hope that this guy is a keeper. But don’t ever put the image of the nice girl who “sees the best” and doesn’t “hold grudges” above an appropriate level of skepticism and a healthy respect for your intuition.

Thisreallyisntmyproblem · 31/12/2023 18:19

This thread is MN at its best and it's worst.
OP has received some excellent advice, put it into place and is comfortable with her decision.

People still yell RUN. They think they can deduce an entire person's character and motivations based on a few short posts, which are inevitably loaded with the OP"s interpretation, intentionally or not. When the OP decides not to instantly implode her life, but rather be circumspect, watch and see, they can't get their little Internet thrill of excitement.

The man may be entirely genuine, had not considered how his questions about finances could be interpreted by a widow who has had to go through the pain of loss and come out financially comfortable but alone. Where he has divorced and as well as being alone is nowhere near where he thought he would be financially.

Most people are inherently good, but sometimes say or do stupid or thoughtless things.

DelurkingLawyer · 31/12/2023 18:18

I’ve read your updates OP. You’re obviously a kind and thoughtful person who wants to think the best of people.

However I am glad you are wary of this man. Honestly, I don’t think his explanation stacks up.

First, whatever he says now, he pretty clearly was hinting that you should pay for his kids, hence you had to nip that suggestion in the bud. You knew at the time what he was actually saying. Everyone who’s read this thread knew it.

Second, how on earth were you supposed to guess from a “joke” about paying for his kids that he was instead trying to say that you’re too generous to your adult kids? (answer: it’s a crap excuse. He was, in fact, angling for you to pay for them).

Third, it is none of his business what you spend your money on and a real red flag that he wants both to interfere with you treating your children and to have you spend it on his kids instead. It’s the thin end of a very long wedge in my view. Someone upthread talked about him moving in and then gradually elbowing your children out so you spend all your money and time on him. I think they are absolutely right and this is the first hint of that. Who does he think he is to even have an opinion about you spending money your husband left you on his and your children?

BeelzebubsHoover · 31/12/2023 17:23

smilingeleanor · 31/12/2023 15:37

i don't think it's jealousy as prior to this he has said he thinks it's amazing what i've done to carry on after my husband died. Ive said to him it's not amazing in the slightest but you do what you have gotta do and he's seeing me with my shit together - not the darkest days.

I think it's more a case of comparison being the thief of joy - and as he said he is ashamed of himself for going down that route as he wasn't thinking about his boys having 2 loving parents in their lives when doing the comparison. It's taken him a long time to get back in his feet after his divorce and build a little bit of security, not where he thought he would be at his age etc. I also suspect he imagined i might be struggling as a lone parent - kinda like he is.

I have my eyes wide open now to any more of this but he has apologised, provided an explanation for the behaviour unprompted. I do want to see the best in people and am not holding a grudge.

Still run

GabriellaMontez · 31/12/2023 16:44

LuluBlakey1 · 31/12/2023 13:38

I think you are doing exactly the right thinks- looking after your family, taking your time, asking questions , trusting your instincts, slowing things down and giving yourself some space, having boundaries, not allowing him to push and control. You sound as if you are level-headed, rational and a great mum and not going to allow a man to interfere and, possibly, take advantage. Your terms that you're comfortable with. Good for you OP. Happy New Year!

I agree with all this.

Take your time. Keep your eyes open. Protect yourself.

I know we're all on the look out for cocklodgers/scoundrels. There are so many about. He may still be one. But not necessarily.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/12/2023 16:27

@smilingeleanor

I have my eyes wide open now to any more of this but he has apologised, provided an explanation for the behaviour unprompted. I do want to see the best in people and am not holding a grudge.

OK. Sounds as if you have his measure and he (hopefully) understands your position wrt discussing/opining on your finances. The only thing left to make him understand would be that you are not interested in marriage or cohabitation, assuming that's the way you feel. Because IMHO simply saying "My finances are none of your business" isn't the same as saying "My finances will NEVER be any of your business because you aren't parking your boots under my bed now or in the future". And because him saying "I understand and apologize" doesn't mean he isn't thinking "But if we should marry/cohabit, things will different as married/cohabiting couples share finances".

I've seen too many times where one or both members of a couple think they've made themselves plain and covered all the bases when they haven't. And when one or both members of a couple silently puts an 'if' or a 'but' or an assumption to their agreement to what's being said. Of course, you may feel you've said enough for now and you may be quite right. You can tackle any assumptions about the future if/when they arise.

DeeLusional · 31/12/2023 16:21

LittleGreenDragons · 31/12/2023 15:11

Just so you know. I reported your post and MN deleted it for breaking guidelines so you might want to have a big think about your actions going forward.

Despite all that, have you any support or advice for the OP?

What actions? Completely bewildered about what has upset you so much, however I wish you and everyone else on here a very Happy and Healthy New Year.

AzureBlue99 · 31/12/2023 16:04

He is looking to increase his wealth to a level pre his divorce. He sees a future with you, which includes shared assets. He wants you to stop unnecessary spending on your adult kids so that you can leave the money in what he thinks will be a shared pot, or for you to bail him out by paying for his kids. You sound sensible but perhaps more vulnerable, understandably, than you think. Personally I could not trust him fully, so what's the point of the relationship? Fine if it's casual but not a keeper.

Floofydawg · 31/12/2023 15:49

Bloody hell, get rid. I say this as someone who has more assets than my second husband and he has not once tried to take advantage of that or get me to pay for his kids. What an absolute cheeky fucker.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/12/2023 15:41

I also suspect he imagined i might be struggling as a lone parent-kinda like he is.

And so he thinks that dropping hints that you pay for his kids to go on holiday is appropriate?! And wants you to pay less for your kids? And wants his kids to sleep in your daughter’s bedroom rather than her?

I honestly don’t see how him having had a divorce and having less money than he’d hoped he might at this stage, means that any of that is reasonable? What do you think his thinking behind all that is?

smilingeleanor · 31/12/2023 15:37

i don't think it's jealousy as prior to this he has said he thinks it's amazing what i've done to carry on after my husband died. Ive said to him it's not amazing in the slightest but you do what you have gotta do and he's seeing me with my shit together - not the darkest days.

I think it's more a case of comparison being the thief of joy - and as he said he is ashamed of himself for going down that route as he wasn't thinking about his boys having 2 loving parents in their lives when doing the comparison. It's taken him a long time to get back in his feet after his divorce and build a little bit of security, not where he thought he would be at his age etc. I also suspect he imagined i might be struggling as a lone parent - kinda like he is.

I have my eyes wide open now to any more of this but he has apologised, provided an explanation for the behaviour unprompted. I do want to see the best in people and am not holding a grudge.

OP posts:
Santaisscouringindeedfornewjob · 31/12/2023 15:31

Do his insecurities mean op should now watch what she says about spending her own money now?

LittleGreenDragons · 31/12/2023 15:11

DeeLusional · 31/12/2023 14:05

Just spelling. Correcting pronunciation is unkind.

Just so you know. I reported your post and MN deleted it for breaking guidelines so you might want to have a big think about your actions going forward.

Despite all that, have you any support or advice for the OP?

ZiriForGood · 31/12/2023 15:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wronginalltherightways · 31/12/2023 14:43

'Insecurities' didn't have him redistributing your child's room in their mother's home to his children. That's just brass entitlement to space in your house for his children.

pikkumyy77 · 31/12/2023 14:29

There is quite a relevant article in the New York Times Sunday edition today https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/29/style/modern-love-suicide-new-year-dating.html

it is about a lovely, four month, romance between the writer, whose husband’s unexpected suicide left her struggling with two children and a recently divorced doctor. What makes it useful is that there were many wonderful, restorative, aspects to this romance but ultimately it was not right and she ends it. She knows it will make room for the next, deeper, relationship.

OP take this relationship for what it is. Nice in many ways, appropriate and supportive. But be wise about it and consider carefully because it will crowd out another, perhaps better, relationship with someone more in tune with you.

raspberrycardigan · 31/12/2023 14:22

smilingeleanor · 31/12/2023 13:27

and I've paraphrased his message - he did give abit more detail about the insecurities it's brought out and his reflections on this.

We're not all perfect and i know i've not always reacted in logical ways to situations. At least he has worked out what pushed his buttons

Nobody is suggesting he's a slathering psychopath. But his behaviour and attitudes - particularly the attempts to control - are not the behaviours and attitudes of a decent man.

God help you, you seem to have swallowed his kool-aid. Best of luck.

Shinyandnew1 · 31/12/2023 14:16

Saying he has insecurities could easily be another way of manipulating you into feeling it's your problem to help him overcome them, spending your money on him to minimise the difference between you and allay his insecurity.

Yep!

TinkBevan · 31/12/2023 14:07

Bin him. Now.

DeeLusional · 31/12/2023 14:05

Sparklfairy · 31/12/2023 13:49

I have to ask, if you're talking to someone in person and they mispronounce a word, do you gleefully jump in and correct them to their face? I'm just wondering if you lack social grace IRL or if you're just a twat when safe behind a keyboard...

Just spelling. Correcting pronunciation is unkind.

Gymnopedie · 31/12/2023 13:55

Sorry OP, the tone of your last posts suggests that you think we're all pissing on your chips. Because of how he was at the start and the good times you had when perhaps you thought you'd never have happy times again, I understand that you don't want to let that go. But the red flags are still waving. He's obviously a smooth talker with the right answers for everything, whether those answers are genuine or not. Saying he has insecurities could easily be another way of manipulating you into feeling it's your problem to help him overcome them, spending your money on him to minimise the difference between you and allay his insecurity.

Actions speak louder than words. PPs have pointed out all the things he's done and I won't repeat them. But don't let your guard down. I'm not convinced he's had the Damascene conversion he'd like you to think he has. Even if he is (right now) genuine it's unlikely to be very long before he can't keep his feelings under wraps and he'll start again - perhaps hoping that after another few months you'll be more into him and more receptive.