Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being in top set at a state school makes a HUGE difference

129 replies

theprincessthepea · 29/12/2023 19:24

To think that you have a better chance of having a successful secondary school experience if you are in top set.

I was catching up with some mums and I asked them how the secondary school experience is going for them so far.

It’s a good school (we didn’t get into our first choice) but they have a huge focus on sports, music and extracurricular aswell as encouraging extra studies.

My DD is in top set, I have found that she has been challenged. She is taking up 2 instruments which she is enjoying. She has joined the drama club and outside of this does gymnastics. She has been chosen to take up Latin and takes up extra duties at the library. She is encouraged by teachers. So are the other 2 friends in top set, their parents are pretty happy with the experience so far. Her form tutor is also very encouraging (e.g. reminding her she can run for things like school council. Said she was bright etc).

However the parents that have their children in the lower sets (mid to low) felt that the school didn’t encourage their children at all. Were not happy with the experience. Didn’t feel that the school were pushing their children. Most of these parents ensured their children were involved in at least 1 extracurricular activity, both at school and outside school.

Personally I went through state school education - was in second set and found the experience OK compared to friends that were in top set.

AIBU for believing that to make the most of a state school or get an education that is close to what people pay for in private school - you have to be in top set classes.

OP posts:
Pebbles16 · 29/12/2023 19:30

Lammveg · 29/12/2023 19:26

From my experience higher sets also have better behaved children in them generally, so I can see teachers having more time to actually teach/engage. Sometimes in lower sets they're having to do lots of behaviour management.

This is so true... when I was at school (a gazillion years ago), it was the chattering and non-engagement of some pupils that undid what was otherwise good teaching.
Mind you some of the teachers were fierce and passionate which probably wouldn't be allowed now

MahShinyShoes · 29/12/2023 19:29

I don't think that in any way equates to private school experience, but IME it's preferable than being in the lower sets where the teachers have to waste more time on behavioural issues, instead of teaching.

BabyYoshke · 29/12/2023 19:28

Gosh no, my daughter is in the top set, straight A student with grade 8 piano and violin and swims competitively 5 days a week. She is a national chess champion and is having a dreadful time at school. She is utterly bored and not nearly challenged enough.

Lammveg · 29/12/2023 19:26

From my experience higher sets also have better behaved children in them generally, so I can see teachers having more time to actually teach/engage. Sometimes in lower sets they're having to do lots of behaviour management.