Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being in top set at a state school makes a HUGE difference

129 replies

theprincessthepea · 29/12/2023 19:24

To think that you have a better chance of having a successful secondary school experience if you are in top set.

I was catching up with some mums and I asked them how the secondary school experience is going for them so far.

It’s a good school (we didn’t get into our first choice) but they have a huge focus on sports, music and extracurricular aswell as encouraging extra studies.

My DD is in top set, I have found that she has been challenged. She is taking up 2 instruments which she is enjoying. She has joined the drama club and outside of this does gymnastics. She has been chosen to take up Latin and takes up extra duties at the library. She is encouraged by teachers. So are the other 2 friends in top set, their parents are pretty happy with the experience so far. Her form tutor is also very encouraging (e.g. reminding her she can run for things like school council. Said she was bright etc).

However the parents that have their children in the lower sets (mid to low) felt that the school didn’t encourage their children at all. Were not happy with the experience. Didn’t feel that the school were pushing their children. Most of these parents ensured their children were involved in at least 1 extracurricular activity, both at school and outside school.

Personally I went through state school education - was in second set and found the experience OK compared to friends that were in top set.

AIBU for believing that to make the most of a state school or get an education that is close to what people pay for in private school - you have to be in top set classes.

OP posts:
cardibach · 30/12/2023 11:55

theprincessthepea · 29/12/2023 21:43

@cardibach I think it’s more so instruments are encouraged for top set. Everyone has the opportunity to do them but top set seem to have the teachers that are more encouraging. It was like that when I was young and the same for my DD. Although her school have said everyone should have at least 1 extracurricular activity.

@ZebraDanios I have noticed that there are some children that care about learning and some that don’t - it doesn’t mean that they don’t care about other things. This is just my observation from once being a student and hearing from other children. It’s not good or bad - it’s just all children have different interests.

I just asked my DD who is in yr 7 - she was in top set in maths and was put down to the 2nd set. She said “my top set teacher was so kind and we always had treats because we all do our homework. In the second set the teacher is ok, but we don’t always get treats because not everyone does their homework”.

Generally in top set the peer pressure may be more about being academic - my guess is that those children may share that common interest. I remember being in a top set class when I was younger (just for one lesson) and I was praised by the children for solving a complex puzzle! In my usual class nobody would have cared (second and middle)- the class clown was more impressive than the “boffin that knew the answers”.

I agree in practice it is more challenging - but it is unrealistic to expect all children to be on board unless there is a massive culture shift in the school itself. Also if all teachers regardless of set have the same drive to set expectations.

This seems an odd school. In every school I’ve worked in the teachers teaching top and bottom sets/streams have been the same people - teachers get a spread of ability across their timetables. Also the only teachers likely to have any view on taking up an instrument are music teachers (and music is very, very rarely set - so I still think you mean stream, not set).

Tacotortoise · 29/12/2023 23:45

Being in the top set does make a huge difference. After 6 years of boredom learning at a snail's pace in primary you can really engage with the curriculum and re-engage with learning again. Things move quicker, there's more and better discussion and far less bullying for participation. Behaviour is also largely better and you get to focus on your work, not the teacher trying to control the class.

Preschoolmum78 · 29/12/2023 23:29

Plij · 29/12/2023 20:46

I teach top set year 11 English this year and, believe me, behaviour issues are present there too. It really depends on the children and their values.

It's the Christmas holidays and I told my class I'd be available via email (not just because they're top set) as their mocks start on the first day of term. So far all the ones who work hard and engage have got on without asking for extra help, but I'll clarify things or give reminders, if need be. The ones who don't listen and expect to be spoonfed have bothered me to ask which topics are on the exams; as if this hasn't been been made clear and isn't readily available in the revision materials already provided.

Only some of these 'top set" students will actually reach their potential, whatever schools do for them.

As a previously underperforming top set student who looked like one of your latter students, I was suffering from abuse at home. I had a high ace score. Suffered neglect too so didn’t look/smell the same as my peers, had extremely low confidence and self esteem. Would regularly have panic attacks in class plus severe anxiety (was told it was normal by parents and if I told anyone I would be a attention seeking drama queen no one would believe me) and spend so much time focusing on not drawing attention to myself during panic attacks I could barely concentrate in class. Also had low attendance (regularly kept up till 3am).

also had female presentation of adhd and asd which wasn’t picked up. I didn’t know I was dyslexic either until college.

I just looked like a lazy, can’t be bothered child with poor hygiene happy to get a b grade instead of a/a* and was told as much.

pleaae show more compassion and vigilance for your pupils. You have no idea what they are going through.

Hairyfairy01 · 29/12/2023 23:29

I don't disagree with setting but it is tough for those like my dd who work hard, behave well but aren't academic. She is in the bottom set for most subjects and not pushed at all as she quietly gets on with things the best she can whilst the teachers try and deal with all the behavioural issues. I don't blame the teachers at all btw. Strangely she has just been placed in the top set for English, despite being predicted a d grade and having 1:1 sessions last year. I have no idea what that is all about but she is loving it and says the class is so quiet! She's fully aware she is not at the same level as the other kids but the teacher has apparently told her she is very welcome in her class (and her English and confidence have improved loads, plus she has now found a love of books).

Wincher · 29/12/2023 23:23

Our school sets for maths and science and my DS does enjoy the fact that more learning goes on in those lessons than in some others as he's in the top sets where kids want to learn. Mind you in our primary they settedfor maths in year 6 and he was only in the middle set then so I was quite surprised he was in top set at secondary. I think it's good to stick with mixed ability in other subjects where the emphasis is more on depth than pace though.

x2boys · 29/12/2023 23:22

BabyYoshke · 29/12/2023 22:49

Oh lads I was just being facetious. My kids are low average and quite content.

(or maybe I don’t have any kids at all.)

You can never tell.on here tbf😂

DingleDangleDogAndBone · 29/12/2023 23:16

@BabyYoshke Interesting, what is her name?

converseandjeans · 29/12/2023 23:13

@BabyYoshke

Oh lads I was just being facetious. My kids are low average and quite content.

I did wonder if your post was sarcastic. 😂

babyshroom · 29/12/2023 23:10

We didn't have "top set" at my comprehensive and neither do my kids' comprehensive have this.

We were streamed for English and maths and that was it.

I only ever hear this 'top set' badge of honour stuff on MN.

Changeychang · 29/12/2023 23:06

We were allocated in year 8 in sets 1-4 (4 being high). I was placed in set 2 which would have meant taking exams capped at a C grade in most subjects (inc. Maths).

My mum, thankfully, campaigned to get me moved into set 3 by Year 9. I achieved B-A*s in GCSEs, 3 As at A-level and a First from a redbrick (who by the way said I needed a B in maths GCSE to attend). I wonder what would have happened if my mum hadn't stepped in.

I think the initial setting was highly likely due to my mediocre performance in year 7 having come from a dreadful primary school. Like the 11+, your whole life potentially determined by the calibre of primary school.

Also, yes there is definitely a difference in the amount of crowd control required in lower versus higher sets.

AuntieSoap · 29/12/2023 23:04

Depends on the ethos and resources of the school. My DD is now in Yr13 but was in the bottom set for maths from Yr7 to Yr11. We had conversations with the teacher regularly about her moving up, but as her set only had about 12 kids with 2 teachers, she got loads of attention and easily achieved a grade 5 at GCSE.
So I couldn't fault how that (comprehensive) school looked after the lower set kids.

forcedfun · 29/12/2023 22:51

Blobblobblob · 29/12/2023 21:01

I was this kid. Used as an unpaid teaching assistant in some unsetted classes. Fuck that nonsense.

It's fucking miserable. Your peers resent you. You're still bored and fully aware you're being exploited... Not challenged or learning anything extra. Also petrified that being seen as teachers pet would make you a target for bullies. I avoided this by being as avoidant as I could and never ever speaking in class.

Setting allows bright kids from families who can't afford private education a chance to escape from the hellscape that is their peers and actually get out of that environment.

Fewer kids from my year group went to Russell Group universities than ended up doing lengthy prison sentences. School was fucking terrifying. I was one of very few high achievers but so many more smart kids underperformed against their ability, dragged down by their feral peers.

Making bright kids do unpaid labour to try and teach the less able ones is morally corrupt and unfair.

Agreed.

And I'd pull my son out of school and send him to private school sharpish if his secondary stopped setting. He's not there to help another child /a teacher, he's there for his own education.

BabyYoshke · 29/12/2023 22:49

Oh lads I was just being facetious. My kids are low average and quite content.

(or maybe I don’t have any kids at all.)

SaturdayGiraffe · 29/12/2023 22:38

BabyYoshke · 29/12/2023 19:28

Gosh no, my daughter is in the top set, straight A student with grade 8 piano and violin and swims competitively 5 days a week. She is a national chess champion and is having a dreadful time at school. She is utterly bored and not nearly challenged enough.

Is this not just because she's a genius? Can she start some university work?

AllTheChaos · 29/12/2023 22:38

Blobblobblob · 29/12/2023 21:01

I was this kid. Used as an unpaid teaching assistant in some unsetted classes. Fuck that nonsense.

It's fucking miserable. Your peers resent you. You're still bored and fully aware you're being exploited... Not challenged or learning anything extra. Also petrified that being seen as teachers pet would make you a target for bullies. I avoided this by being as avoidant as I could and never ever speaking in class.

Setting allows bright kids from families who can't afford private education a chance to escape from the hellscape that is their peers and actually get out of that environment.

Fewer kids from my year group went to Russell Group universities than ended up doing lengthy prison sentences. School was fucking terrifying. I was one of very few high achievers but so many more smart kids underperformed against their ability, dragged down by their feral peers.

Making bright kids do unpaid labour to try and teach the less able ones is morally corrupt and unfair.

@Blobblobblob has hit the nail on the head!

Singleandproud · 29/12/2023 22:38

DD is in top set, school work is too easy, behaviour is better than mixed humanities classes. Is often encouraged to take part in extracurriculars gets to go on lots of trips and those aimed at (former) G&T type students.

However, she's autistic and finds the entire school experience thoroughly overwhelming and therefore hates school, does a minimal number of after school clubs as it's all she can cope with. Would love to learn an instrument and be more involved but completely shattered by the end of a normal school day.
Admittedly, if she was in mixed sets across the board and in a class where children have behavioural issues and w less academic it would be unbearable for her and her MH would spiral.

Personally I don't think the state school is fit for purpose for any ability student, the curriculum isn't fit to stretch the most able, there is too much content to teach and scaffold for those that need extra support, there are too many academic choices and not enough hands on practical work for those that thrive in that area DD got into a private girl's school but we didn't get a scholarship so had to turn it down. Even being in top sets can't compete with only 20 students of academically selected students in a class, 300 students in the entire school not the entire year.

ReadyForPumpkins · 29/12/2023 22:36

I voted YABU because it’s nothing like private school even if you are in the top set. However you get better behaved children in the top set. Year 8 DC is in a school that has sets for maths. Kids aren’t told what set they are in but guessed by the work set. DC said her maths class is so quiet compared to her other classes. That must be the biggest difference. She much preferred to be in the quieter class, and I hope it rubs off on her to be harder working too.

converseandjeans · 29/12/2023 22:35

Sets are best for more able students. They don't get teased for being a nerd & can get through content quicker.

Bottom sets do tend to be really small though. Probably the worst place is one from bottom set as there will be more students & less time from teacher.

The issue is that schools don't cater currently well for students who aren't an academic. Not being academic isn't necessarily an indicator of future success in my opinion. Lots of tradies earning loads & running their own company etc & people with degrees earning lots less.

I think more able students tend to do extra curricular.

AllTheChaos · 29/12/2023 22:35

Further to this, I would say that fit some
of the children in top set, not streaming can mean them being bored and frustrated, and can itself lead to behavioural difficulties. Several of my friends at that age were from a similar background as me as our families were friends, and several of them went to schools where they weren’t engaged and challenged, and they ended up going off the rails, and never did get back on the straight and narrow. The assumption that clever kids will do well regardless is not, alas, entirely correct.

RatatouillePie · 29/12/2023 22:31

BabyYoshke · 29/12/2023 19:28

Gosh no, my daughter is in the top set, straight A student with grade 8 piano and violin and swims competitively 5 days a week. She is a national chess champion and is having a dreadful time at school. She is utterly bored and not nearly challenged enough.

Is she asking for extra and more challenging work?

I'm a secondary school teacher. Top sets often have bigger classes as the pupils need less prompting to do work. Homework takes longer to mark. I always set challenge questions but I expect my top pupils to ASK for something even more challenging if they're interested!

My bottom set Y10 class is exhausting. I feel sorry for the kids who are well behaved but find the work challenging. They're in a class with naughty kids who are often bright but are in a bottom set as they refuse to behave and work. I always have high expectations of any child regardless of ability.

AllTheChaos · 29/12/2023 22:30

theprincessthepea · 29/12/2023 20:43

@Cerealkiller4U and @BabyYoshke I have heard about this boredom a few times whereby some children may not feel challenged enough.

I am not an academic expert at all but something I have seen as being super valuable as an adult is the idea of peer learning (which is something we practice a lot within my career) and the idea that “copying” is good. Whereas schools tend to prioritise individual learning and “looking at answers = cheating”

I am wondering if the idea of mixed abilities within a class encourages that a little more - as surely the teacher cannot teach so many abilities at once as @ChristmasEvemaddness pointed out. It will be so frustrating for the children that are more academic to wait for their peers to catch up - unless they are somehow involved in also contributing and sharing answers and there is more acceptance with a peer to peer approach. Which also allows them to gain other skills such as sharing their work and teaching etc. As someone pointed out it seems this method has benefits for those that may be forgotten about academically - but maybe there are some perks for those that would “do well anyway”.

It does rely on the children being happy to that though, which is not necessarily going to be the case. My early family life was what would now be described as ‘chaotic’. However, I was extremely bright. Streaming from primary school onwards helped me to escape that background, and actually achieve something in life. When I was bored, ie when I wasn’t being stretched enough academically, I fell back on disruptive behaviour, as it’s what I was familiar with. When I was engaged, I would totally focus, and was happy to work hard and do a lot of self-led learning.
At my secondary school they decided to try having the more academically capable girls tutor those who were struggling in the years below. It was a disaster. None of the girls asked to do the tutoring had any interest in it, all found it incredibly frustrating dealing with people who just couldn’t understand what they were told the first time, a lot were very bad at hiding that frustration and the girls they were meant to be helping were left demoralised. Plus we all resented being asked to give up our learning time to help girls we, frankly, considered thick (teenage girls are not all very nice, let’s be honest!) The experiment was dropped pretty quickly. Had we been forced to continue, maybe some of us would have learned valuable life lessons, but honestly, I don’t think any of us were emotionally mature enough at that stage of our lives.

KnowWhatIMean · 29/12/2023 22:26

25 or so years ago I was in top sets and it did, on the whole, mean that behaviour was manageable so we could actually get through the curriculum (tough school in a deprived area). It’s good to hear that your child is being stretched academically, OP.

toomanyleggings · 29/12/2023 22:23

Really in secondary the top two sets are the best places to be for a variety of reasons. They tend to get better opportunities and better lessons because there’s better behaviour and teacher’s aren’t wasting energy and resources managing issues.

WomanFromTheNorth · 29/12/2023 22:19

All the research points towards the setting system setting up those in the lower sets to fail. And it can last a lifetime. Often the basis for selecting which kids go into which sets is quite random, with poorer / SEND pupils far more likely to end up in bottom sets. The whole system is shit - and I say this as a former secondary teacher.

bellocchild · 29/12/2023 22:16

Not all bright kids are motivated, and vice versa, - but from a (former) teaching point of view, they do need to be in sets to allow appropriate academic progress. Bad behaviour is another issue entirely, and that needs to be dealt with firmly and quickly. That's easier said than done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread