Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overhead conversation - wwyd?

240 replies

notlisteningwithmother · 29/12/2023 16:27

I'd just stepped out of the shower when MIL and FIL (staying with us for family Christmas) started to have an animated conversation outside the bathroom door. The gist was that they were pleased to be heading home because I'd made them feel unwelcome and unwanted and ruined their Christmas.

I could have opened the door at that point, but decided against fanning the flames and waited in the bathroom till I heard them go downstairs.

I didn't want Christmas to end with an argument. And I can't see any benefit in raising this with them when we next talk.

WWYD? Let sleeping dogs lie or ask for an explanation?

OP posts:
tachetastic · 29/12/2023 21:32

I agree with others that I would call your MIL directly and explain the whole thing, and have a good laugh at her DS's, your DH's, expense. Otherwise tension will continue no matter what DH says to his mum. She will think he is hiding something on your behalf.

This could be a good opportunity for you two to open up your relationship, so in future cake conversations are not had between FIL and DH, but instead between the MIL that made it and the DIL that will serve it.

Good luck!

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 21:31

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 29/12/2023 21:27

I think in this situation you not DH need to ring her.

tell her he's only just told you about the cake and you are furious with him as her cakes are wonderful (or whatever) and you would much rather have had hers if you had known.

no need to mention you overheard her, she gets reassurance that you knew nothing and weren't being a dick and you get to 'clear your name' without a row or anyone being embarrassed.

what a knob your DH is, if a guest brings a gift accept it! What exactly did he think she was going to do with the cake once he rejected it?

This will only make things worse!
The DH rejecting the cake straight upon being given it. It was blooming obvious OP didn't know about it. Unless he had a telepathic communication channel open with OP. Or MIL had said she was bringing one in advance.

OP fluffing and apologising is just going to make her look like she's backtracking in MIL's eyes.

It's her HUSBAND who caused this and HIM who needs to own up to his mistake. Not his wife. Stop letting men off the hook for bad behaviour and leaving the wimminz to smooth over hurt feelings.

MILTOBE · 29/12/2023 21:30

My DIL would call me and say, "MIL, DH has been a dick. He told you we didn't want your cake etc but we do! We all love your cakes and I'm furious with him for telling you to take it home. I'm so sorry if you're upset."

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 29/12/2023 21:27

I think in this situation you not DH need to ring her.

tell her he's only just told you about the cake and you are furious with him as her cakes are wonderful (or whatever) and you would much rather have had hers if you had known.

no need to mention you overheard her, she gets reassurance that you knew nothing and weren't being a dick and you get to 'clear your name' without a row or anyone being embarrassed.

what a knob your DH is, if a guest brings a gift accept it! What exactly did he think she was going to do with the cake once he rejected it?

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 21:26

Fruitcakesanddogs · 29/12/2023 21:19

Glad the mystery was solved. I’m intrigued at how level headed you are though! Id be really upset if MIL had gone from 0 to 100 like that

I'm not surprised. This is exactly the sort of thing my MIL would do.
Also blaming the DIL instead of her precious son. Classic.
Any reason why he choose to allow her blaming of you?
I am level headed. But that's because DH is 100% on my side. We just leave them to it. She's crackers aided and abetted 👸 by FIL.

Your DH was cowardly to quietly let you take the 'blame' for something he did.

Reallybadidea · 29/12/2023 21:26

Don't quite understand the relief. Your DH was rude, you've got the blame and your MIL has decided that their stay was ruined because you declined her cake. I'd find all that a bit upsetting really when you've obviously done your best to make them welcome and their stay enjoyable.

Fruitcakesanddogs · 29/12/2023 21:19

Glad the mystery was solved. I’m intrigued at how level headed you are though! Id be really upset if MIL had gone from 0 to 100 like that

wombats78 · 29/12/2023 21:18

I would get him to explain you didn't know...

notlisteningwithmother · 29/12/2023 21:15

MYSTERY SOLVED!!

ILs left late morning. I've just cleaned out their room and found an earring on the floor that I think belongs to MIL. I asked DH to call her, and maybe also check that they'd got home okay and thank them for coming.

DH response - fine, as long as she doesn't mention the cake. (Now I'm confused!)

So, MIL had made and brought (as a surprise) a Christmas cake and Christmas pudding. FIL handed them to DH when they arrived, but DH then gave them back to MIL saying that I'd also made a Christmas cake and a pudding so we'd just use those and didn't need anything else. From this, MIL extrapolated that I had refused to accept her carefully prepared contribution to the Christmas food, and by implication sent a clear message that neither she nor her food were welcome in the house.

If offered the option I would absolutely have accepted them as gifts. But MIL was clearly still upset by the apparent rejection when I overheard the conversation this morning, deliberate or otherwise.

Nobody knows that I heard anything, and they don't need to. I'm quite relieved!

OP posts:
tachetastic · 29/12/2023 21:14

Do you need DH to get to the bottom of this? Isn't he likely to just come back with "I spoke with dad and it's all a misunderstanding. He says you misheard. They were actually saying how amazing you are and they love how you decorated the tree this year. Don't worry. Everything's fine."

Would you be satisfied with that response? Once DH has spoken to them it would be impossible for you to raise anything without calling them liers.

muggart · 29/12/2023 20:42

Reading your updates, I can't understand why they would say that. Maybe they are very high maintenance, maybe you misheard them, maybe they misunderstood something you said and have formed a gripe in their head. Either way, I'd want DH to get to the bottom of it if I were you.

tachetastic · 29/12/2023 20:18

notlisteningwithmother · 29/12/2023 16:27

I'd just stepped out of the shower when MIL and FIL (staying with us for family Christmas) started to have an animated conversation outside the bathroom door. The gist was that they were pleased to be heading home because I'd made them feel unwelcome and unwanted and ruined their Christmas.

I could have opened the door at that point, but decided against fanning the flames and waited in the bathroom till I heard them go downstairs.

I didn't want Christmas to end with an argument. And I can't see any benefit in raising this with them when we next talk.

WWYD? Let sleeping dogs lie or ask for an explanation?

@notlisteningwithmother, what do you want to achieve? Did you genuinely enjoy this Christmas and believe they had too?

I confess, I don't think I would be able to remain completely silent. If you thought it was a good Christmas, I would express that to them. Before they go, tell them just how much you enjoyed spending time with them, and say that you know it is hard to stay at another person's house and you really hope they had a nice time too.

If you think there was any moment of awkwardness, raise it. Say that I remember that moment when X happened, but I hope that didn't spoil things because we really enjoyed having you over to stay.

Or you could play the psychic card and suggest that it feels like there is an awkwardness in the air. We really enjoyed you visiting, but it feels like maybe there was something you didn't enjoy or that we could have done better? We would really love to understand, as to us it was a great Christmas.

In other words, celebrate what you saw as a good Christmas, but encourage them to be open. If they do say that they really hated the fact that you stay up too late / get up so early / insisted on them walking too far / watch really chavvy TV / drink too much / smell a bit, then at least you know and just nod sagely and thank them for the feedback. If they say everything was wonderful, accept their comments or at the very least know that they can never criticise you later without looking bad because you gave them the chance to tell you and they didn't.

notlisteningwithmother · 29/12/2023 20:14

Sallyh87 · 29/12/2023 19:45

Just a thought, you speak about mobility issues and also asking your MIL to take things easy.

I have some mobility issues and it really grinds my gears when people tell me to take it easy or rest. I know you mean well but I know my own limits and I like to be involved. It feels condescending to me.

I know this is all in my own head and not the intention but possibly this is how MIL felt? The only way to know is to ask.

@Sallyh87 Sorry, I wasn't clear. FIL has mobility issues, but point taken that we shouldn't make assumptions about what is possible.

OP posts:
Seaside3 · 29/12/2023 20:11

I wouldn't sweat it too much. People can often be tetchy at Christmas, especially when not in their own home.
I'd mention it to your dh, see what he says .

Ramalangadingdong · 29/12/2023 19:58

notlisteningwithmother · 29/12/2023 17:39

Tired maybe. They went out to the midnight service and I stayed up till they got home, made mince pues and mulled wine ready for them. DC woke up early on Christmas morning so sleep was in short supply.

This is probably what it is. We all get tired and stressed over Christmas and people misconstrue it as grumpiness. It happened to me this year too. It is so easy to offend people unintentionally. You are in a difficult place because sometimes asking people what's going on just opens the floodgates and they start going on about things you did years ago (do I sound as though I am speaking from experience? I am). I wish I had more advice for you, but I am not very good at advice giving. Sorry.

Dibdob27 · 29/12/2023 19:56

Maybe have a chat and ask in a conversational way if they had a nice Christmas and what they usually do at home. Xxx It's nice to keep the peace and at least try to smooth things over.

wombats78 · 29/12/2023 19:53

I actually admore your restraint. I have adhd and I'd have had the red mist descend before they'd got to the end of the sentence. Even with a lifetime of trying to get some semblance of control, this would have been the step too far.

I think I possibly agree it might be a power issue, is she used to being the matriarch, who "does" Christmas?

CharmedCult · 29/12/2023 19:47

Tacotortoise · 29/12/2023 17:54

Really, why? That seems to me to be the worst possible way to handle it.

Because if I'd busted my balls to give them a lovely Christmas like the OP did, only to overhear them talking shit about me in my own home, like not even having the decency to wait until they'd left and be sure they couldn't be overheard, it'd be the last Christmas I ever spent with them.

In fact they'd be lucky to ever set foot in my house ever again.

Sallyh87 · 29/12/2023 19:45

Just a thought, you speak about mobility issues and also asking your MIL to take things easy.

I have some mobility issues and it really grinds my gears when people tell me to take it easy or rest. I know you mean well but I know my own limits and I like to be involved. It feels condescending to me.

I know this is all in my own head and not the intention but possibly this is how MIL felt? The only way to know is to ask.

Newnameshoos · 29/12/2023 19:37

If I'd heard something like that after running around like a mad thing hosting them it would be the last time I had a Christmas with them.
Unless you've misheard or there's something specific, it sounds as though they didn't like dancing to your Christmas traditions in your home.

Ladybirder · 29/12/2023 19:33

If you and DH both felt the stay went well, and there was no obvious reason as to why they felt unwelcome then it must be a minor thing they are unhappy about (if anything!), which is very unreasonable of them. It’s difficult with in-laws - they aren’t your family by blood so they can be less forgiving and there can be pressure to be on your best behaviour at all times. Don t go over everything you did and said during their visit - I’m sure on the whole you were friendly and welcoming - you stayed up with mulled wine and mince pies when they returned from church FGS! They were rude to talk unkindly of you in your own home - they should have waited until they had left to prevent the dilemma you’re in now. Speak to DH and see what he says - I think I would be minded to ask the in-laws why they said what they did though as it would eat me up and would be on my mind at future meet ups.

IDontOftenComment · 29/12/2023 19:29

You sound lovely OP and it’s hard to see from your post that you did anything wrong. I certainly wouldn’t go into a strop as other posters are suggesting but I think I would need to say something, just to settle my own curiosity.
I'm wondering if it would be best mention it not in a confrontational way but in a concerned way, perhaps your OH could say you thought you overheard them say they hadn’t had a good time and see what they say.
It does sound as if you all have a very good relationship, I’d be careful to try not to spoil that, after all you may have misheard them.

ChristmasEvemaddness · 29/12/2023 19:25

Where do you usually spend Xmas and did mil want to take it easy.

ScribblingPixie · 29/12/2023 19:25

I'm guessing that if Christmas is usually at their house, your MIL didn't like being treated as a guest who wasn't allowed to help rather than a central figure at the heart of the action. It doesn't sound like anything you've done wrong, more that she felt on the fringes of things and pushed out. Maybe it made her feel a bit old too. Just guessing, OP.

HoppingLady · 29/12/2023 19:21

Are you sure you haven’t been mistaken in what you heard?
e.g
‘We’re lucky we’ve had such a lovely time. John just rang me about his Christmas…he said we’ve been made to feel so unwelcome and it ruined Christmas’

Swipe left for the next trending thread