Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have routine smears anymore?

114 replies

SmearFear191 · 29/12/2023 15:06

I'm 29 and had my first smear age 25 which was clear. It all went downhill from my second one.

I got a telephone call inviting me for a colposcopy before I'd even received my smear results. The colposcopy nurse on the phone explained I had HPV and high grade severe dyskaryosis, the worst grade, and had been referred urgently under the 2 week wait. I asked whether this meant I had cancer and she said she just couldn't say.

You can imagine the panic I had over the next 2 weeks waiting to be seen and then the biopsy itself was quite traumatic.

Long story short, it wasn't high grade severe it was mild and no treatment was necessary. They had me back in 6 months and confirmed the cells had resolved on their own.

I'm then invited back again for another check, I assume to see if the HPV had cleared, and the colposcopy was clear again with no abnormality seen at all.

They took a smear whilst I was there and I got the results for that today, dyskaryosis again but no mention of HPV.

There was no dyskaryosis observed at all during the colposcopy so the smear is inaccurate again.

I can't fault the care of the NHS, they've looked after me very well, it's the smear test inaccuracies that have caused alot of unnecessary worry. I'm told it's not unusual for the results to be wrong either.

Given how unreliable the tests have been up until now do you think IABU to opt out and stop getting them? I'm thinking I could instead pay privately for a colposcopy every couple/few years and avoid all of the angst the smears bring.

OP posts:
2mummies1baby · 30/12/2023 18:42

NImumconfused · 30/12/2023 17:48

The nurses at your GP surgery need retraining then, that's terrible advice. I can't currently see anything on the NHS website saying that, perhaps it's been updated since? But the section on screening specifically says you're still at risk of cervical cancer if you are lesbian or bisexual, and that HPV can be passed on through oral sex or sharing sex toys.

I have worked in a related area for over 20 years and we have definitely been advising lesbians that they should consider screening for as long as I've been in the job.

Oh I totally agree that it's terrible advice! Low risk doesn't equal no risk.

Sorry, it's on the Gov.uk website, not the NHS website: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cervical-screening-lesbian-and-bisexual-women/cervical-screening-for-lesbian-and-bisexual-women#cervical-screening-is-not-just-for-heterosexual-women
Fourth paragraph down under 'The cause of cervical cancer'.

Not to have routine smears anymore?
Wisenotboring · 30/12/2023 18:18

I'm afraid I don't know and it would be inappropriate for me to ask. My point really was that seeing the potential fall out I try to stack the odds in my favour.

MintJulia · 30/12/2023 17:57

Please keep going for all smears and other advised tests.

My DSD discovered she had CC at 21.5yrs when, in theory, she was too young to need a smear. Sadly diagnosed too late and could not be saved.

I can see that the inaccurate results are annoying but please don't let that discourage you. Let the NHS take care of you.

zusje · 30/12/2023 17:54

SmearFear191 · 30/12/2023 12:43

Thank you for the replies. I've had a rethink and will continue to go for my smears. It's very sobering reading about women my own age being dx with cervical cancer 😔

It's scary to me how some go from a clear smear to cancer in three years, esp as we're told that CC is generally slow growing.

I've given my head a wobble and won't be missing any. I have children to live for.

Good, keep going, they are lifesavers.

Also to clear something up, dyskaryosis isn't something that's visible with the naked eye. It refers to an abnormally nucleated cell (basically when cells are abnormal they multiply in a much higher rate than normal cells, resuling in multiple cells with multiple nuclei, whereas normally most cells should have 1 nucleus as they aren't dividing/multiplying to create new cells). You can only see those changes under a high power microscope, so your cervix may look absolutely normal with the naked eye but still have dyskaryosis on a microscopical level. Hope that makes it clearer that no result was "wrong" just depending on what you're looking at (how many layers of cells, how big a piece of tissue you have, what types of stains you use and how powerful your microscope is) you can get different results with different tests!

NImumconfused · 30/12/2023 17:48

2mummies1baby · 30/12/2023 17:35

I assumed lesbians were low risk for cervical cancer since, as recently as 10 years ago, I was told by multiple nurses at my GP surgery that I didn't need to get a cervical smear test. The same is true of other lesbians I know. The NHS website also states that HPV is more easily passed to women through heterosexual sex.

The nurses at your GP surgery need retraining then, that's terrible advice. I can't currently see anything on the NHS website saying that, perhaps it's been updated since? But the section on screening specifically says you're still at risk of cervical cancer if you are lesbian or bisexual, and that HPV can be passed on through oral sex or sharing sex toys.

I have worked in a related area for over 20 years and we have definitely been advising lesbians that they should consider screening for as long as I've been in the job.

2mummies1baby · 30/12/2023 17:35

NImumconfused · 30/12/2023 15:32

Why would you think a lesbian would be incredibly low risk for cervical cancer?? Anyone can have HPV and it can be passed on by touch in or around the genital area, there's no link to PIV intercourse.

I assumed lesbians were low risk for cervical cancer since, as recently as 10 years ago, I was told by multiple nurses at my GP surgery that I didn't need to get a cervical smear test. The same is true of other lesbians I know. The NHS website also states that HPV is more easily passed to women through heterosexual sex.

TheWrongAllmanBrother · 30/12/2023 16:24

Please PLEASE keep going for screening! High risk HPV infection here too, low stage dyskaryosis but looked high grade through the colposcope when seen by two separate consultants. I had treatment and remember the fear whilst waiting for it. It’s so important to pick up any pre cancerous changes early - you are still so young.

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 16:05

I would add that I teach a child whose mum died from cervical cancer I her 40s

Did she have regular smears?

Wisenotboring · 30/12/2023 15:35

Delassalle · 30/12/2023 08:29

I've only ever had one smear and that was in the early eighties and I've never had one since as they mucked me around giving the impression something was wrong and making me wait a few weeks to find out and then it turned out that it was just the sample wasn't able to be tested properly..

You are very lucky but your response is a bit angry seeming. You would actually miss out on the benefits of smear because nearly 40 years ago you feel you were mucked around!

OP, all screening programmes come with the potential disadvantage of false negatives. The data and my personal opinion is that the benefits outweigh these negatives. You obviously have quite a 'dynamic' cervix. I would get the HPV vaccine and continue with screening. Having been through your experience so far you may find your anxiety lessons until you receive definitive answer.
I would add that I teach a child whose mum died from cervical cancer I her 40s. A really delightful child and the mum is missing watching that. The child also gets upset every Christmas especially. It's very sad. There are no certainties in life, but I would always rather stack the odds I can affect in my favour.

NImumconfused · 30/12/2023 15:32

2mummies1baby · 30/12/2023 08:33

Someone I knew, who was incredibly low risk for cervical cancer (lesbian) and therefore had never had a smear test, recently died of cervical cancer aged 45. Please, please go for your smears. I know they're horrible and stressful, but they could be life saving.

Why would you think a lesbian would be incredibly low risk for cervical cancer?? Anyone can have HPV and it can be passed on by touch in or around the genital area, there's no link to PIV intercourse.

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 15:27

Babyblackbear78 · 29/12/2023 15:14

Don’t be silly, go for the smears. 1 friend has just recovered from cervical cancer at the age of 31 and another from vaginal cancer which apparently is unusual in a 40 year old.

Don't call a woman "silly."

Confrontayshunme · 30/12/2023 15:22

I thought you were going to say that, like me, you have only had one partner and both of you were hpv free. I reject the smear to every 5 years because the chances are very low anything is wrong.

But if you have had abnormal smears please please keep doing them.

Flamingo68 · 30/12/2023 15:19

Keep getting the smears as it will likely stop being this stressful. I previously was told I had high grade changes which turned out to be lower than they thought, so that clearly does happen. I had treatment to my cervix then another one or two abnormal results but they have all been normal for several smears now to the point I am back on three yearly screening instead of yearly which I was on for probably a decade!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 30/12/2023 15:16

I am surprised at your age that you didn't get the HPV vaccine when it was administered in school?

Definitely get it.

But it's not a good idea to ask about smears on here because most MNers seem to think that not having them means you will get cancer. They seem to forget that cervical cancer is rare and the smears are to find it (or more accurately cell changes that may (but may not) lead to it).

tokesqueen · 30/12/2023 15:12

Happiholidai it's helpful if it dispels the myths that people peddle and enlightens others with the correct information.

wudubelieveit · 30/12/2023 13:26

MatildaTheCat · 30/12/2023 12:46

So don’t but nobody is forcing anyone to do anything. You receive an invitation to a screening appointment, not a summons. I had a smear last year and was impressed by the detailed information booklet that was sent out. Unfortunately very few people actually read these things.

For anyone interested in the ethics around screening programmes there was an interesting programme on R4 this morning around 11am on the very subject.

Thanks Mat I’ve had a listen to the r4 programme….I also recommend Dr Hannah Fry’s to programme she did around the time she had her c/cancer diagnosis.there’s going to be a lot of debate around c/screening in the future I suspect but I do hope they roll out self hpv testing .

CoteDAzur · 30/12/2023 12:51

YABU but do as you please. There are too many people on earth as it is 🤷‍♀️

MatildaTheCat · 30/12/2023 12:46

HappyHolidai · 30/12/2023 12:19

Anyway I'm not putting myself through it any more. If the NHS wanted people to continue then they should have not hidden information and forced women to have smears which wouldn't be looked at. The lack of informed consent is a massive problem for me and I'm not prepared to do it again.

So don’t but nobody is forcing anyone to do anything. You receive an invitation to a screening appointment, not a summons. I had a smear last year and was impressed by the detailed information booklet that was sent out. Unfortunately very few people actually read these things.

For anyone interested in the ethics around screening programmes there was an interesting programme on R4 this morning around 11am on the very subject.

SmearFear191 · 30/12/2023 12:43

Thank you for the replies. I've had a rethink and will continue to go for my smears. It's very sobering reading about women my own age being dx with cervical cancer 😔

It's scary to me how some go from a clear smear to cancer in three years, esp as we're told that CC is generally slow growing.

I've given my head a wobble and won't be missing any. I have children to live for.

OP posts:
HappyHolidai · 30/12/2023 12:21

And calling me ignorant is really not helpful.

it's that attitude from nurses that so destroys trust.

HappyHolidai · 30/12/2023 12:19

Anyway I'm not putting myself through it any more. If the NHS wanted people to continue then they should have not hidden information and forced women to have smears which wouldn't be looked at. The lack of informed consent is a massive problem for me and I'm not prepared to do it again.

tokesqueen · 30/12/2023 11:06

HappyHolidai · 30/12/2023 09:03

@tokesqueen - but they don't check. They can hardly see my cervix, then immediately put the brush in to twiddle.
Anyway the screening is about HPV/cancer not polyps.

Edited

Happiholidai wrong. The screening is absolutely about a visual inspection of the cervix too. Our training centres around it. If the nurse can't see the cervix she shouldn't be doing any twiddling at all, as the sample needs to be very specifically taken from the os (centre) and transformation zone surrounding it. Saying it's not about polyps just demonstrates people's ignorance.
Practice nurse.

tokesqueen · 30/12/2023 11:02

wudubekieveit I work as a practice nurse. As per the patient group directive she is not eligible over the age of 25. The nurse is not covered to give. The GP wouldn't have a clue about eligibility or vaccination schedules.

1967Kitherly · 30/12/2023 10:55

Please please keep going OP, it’s important.

I’ve had colposcopy's and biopsy, I’ve also had to have Lletz procedure to burn out cells and HPV. My last 2 smears have been clear but I’ll continue to go.

My doctor told me that HPV is very common and that its crucial that smears are done (that was just the advice I have been given) Results can be scary but it’s so important that you are seen and its taken care of.

Elfoutthewindow · 30/12/2023 10:46

@Chowit said by someone who doesn't understand the risks/benefits of screening. Did you read the leaflets? Do you understand the over treatment risks? Did you weigh it up in any way?