Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have routine smears anymore?

114 replies

SmearFear191 · 29/12/2023 15:06

I'm 29 and had my first smear age 25 which was clear. It all went downhill from my second one.

I got a telephone call inviting me for a colposcopy before I'd even received my smear results. The colposcopy nurse on the phone explained I had HPV and high grade severe dyskaryosis, the worst grade, and had been referred urgently under the 2 week wait. I asked whether this meant I had cancer and she said she just couldn't say.

You can imagine the panic I had over the next 2 weeks waiting to be seen and then the biopsy itself was quite traumatic.

Long story short, it wasn't high grade severe it was mild and no treatment was necessary. They had me back in 6 months and confirmed the cells had resolved on their own.

I'm then invited back again for another check, I assume to see if the HPV had cleared, and the colposcopy was clear again with no abnormality seen at all.

They took a smear whilst I was there and I got the results for that today, dyskaryosis again but no mention of HPV.

There was no dyskaryosis observed at all during the colposcopy so the smear is inaccurate again.

I can't fault the care of the NHS, they've looked after me very well, it's the smear test inaccuracies that have caused alot of unnecessary worry. I'm told it's not unusual for the results to be wrong either.

Given how unreliable the tests have been up until now do you think IABU to opt out and stop getting them? I'm thinking I could instead pay privately for a colposcopy every couple/few years and avoid all of the angst the smears bring.

OP posts:
Elfoutthewindow · 02/01/2024 21:04

@Chowit you just really don't understand the risks/benefits of screening, then. Screening is complex.

OP, I'm glad you're going. With your story, I really think screening is for you.

Chowit · 02/01/2024 20:10

@Elfoutthewindow it's a risk I'm willing to take for the good of my health.
The screening is less likely to kill me than breast cancer.

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/01/2024 19:35

Of course you keep going.

SmearFear191 · 02/01/2024 19:34

kenadams86 · 02/01/2024 18:48

It's difficult for I understand but from what you've written I don't think they've got the results wrong necessarily.

Dyskarosis is cell changes - often linked to HPV

You had HPV and cell changes on the first smear.

The HPV resolved as it does in most cases from your own immune response; but the cell changes are still there (damage from the HPV)
The colposcopy unit couldn't tell you how bad it was until they investigated further.

It would be a bad idea to stop attending for smears. Maybe book a phone consultation with your practice nurse to try to make sense of your smear history

I think that's a good idea yes, I'm still quite confused.

From what I thought I knew, a colposcopy is alot more reliable than a smear

My latest colposcopy showed no areas of abnormality at all. No dyskaryosis. No CIN1 left over. Nothing. The doctor told me there was nothing there at all.

But the smear they took at the same time of ruling out any dyskaryosis.. came back with mild changes.

OP posts:
hangingonfordearlife1 · 02/01/2024 18:52

my cousin died early 30s from cervical cancer because she didn't go for her smear and missed it before it was too late.

kenadams86 · 02/01/2024 18:48

It's difficult for I understand but from what you've written I don't think they've got the results wrong necessarily.

Dyskarosis is cell changes - often linked to HPV

You had HPV and cell changes on the first smear.

The HPV resolved as it does in most cases from your own immune response; but the cell changes are still there (damage from the HPV)
The colposcopy unit couldn't tell you how bad it was until they investigated further.

It would be a bad idea to stop attending for smears. Maybe book a phone consultation with your practice nurse to try to make sense of your smear history

RainyDaysSundays · 02/01/2024 18:34

Delassalle · 31/12/2023 15:29

@RainyDaysSundays 'CC is caused by HPV which can be transferred by fingers, oral sex and full sex (with an infected man.)

It can lie dormant for years and then become more active if your immune system is weak.

The best way is to have the HPV test and if you are sexually active, you need to keep being tested.'

I'm at no risk whatsoever.

sorry @Delassalle I don't need educating.

Women who are lesbians can get CC. Someone here left a screenshot of medical information.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/01/2024 16:09

squashyhat · 31/12/2023 13:06

Please go. I have just had my last one (they stop doing them routinely once you get to 65). I hummed and haad as I've never had a recall and because of my internal physiology they are always painful. However I showed up and the nurse was lovely and made it as bearable as possible. Once again no recall and I feel that chapter of my life is now successfully over and am quite proud of myself (when you get to my age you take what wins you can get Smile).

Yes at least very soon I only have to go once every 5 years, although as I had the last one at 49 I sadly have to go to the next one within 3 years. But after that it goes to 5. Hurrah!

Delassalle · 31/12/2023 15:29

@RainyDaysSundays 'CC is caused by HPV which can be transferred by fingers, oral sex and full sex (with an infected man.)

It can lie dormant for years and then become more active if your immune system is weak.

The best way is to have the HPV test and if you are sexually active, you need to keep being tested.'

I'm at no risk whatsoever.

user1471538283 · 31/12/2023 13:47

@squashyhat - you should feel proud! I'm proud of you!

squashyhat · 31/12/2023 13:06

Please go. I have just had my last one (they stop doing them routinely once you get to 65). I hummed and haad as I've never had a recall and because of my internal physiology they are always painful. However I showed up and the nurse was lovely and made it as bearable as possible. Once again no recall and I feel that chapter of my life is now successfully over and am quite proud of myself (when you get to my age you take what wins you can get Smile).

Wisenotboring · 31/12/2023 12:29

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 22:56

You don't need to take offence at any of this

I'm not taking offence. I found your post distasteful.

That's your perogative and I certainly didn't intend to cause you to feel distaste.

user1471538283 · 31/12/2023 09:11

Oh no please continue to have them! This is how screening works. I know it's a worry but honestly catching anything sooner is so much better.

I've had 3 years of numerous mammograms just in case the cysts were cancerous. It was all so worrying but I'd take that every year over having breast cancer. And this year I was ok at the first mammogram.

RainyDaysSundays · 31/12/2023 09:00

Delassalle · 30/12/2023 20:58

@Zanatdy no family history and I've survived this far.

@Delassalle Family history has no bearing on cervical cancer. Why do you think it has?

CC is caused by HPV which can be transferred by fingers, oral sex and full sex (with an infected man.)

It can lie dormant for years and then become more active if your immune system is weak.

The best way is to have the HPV test and if you are sexually active, you need to keep being tested.

RainyDaysSundays · 31/12/2023 08:57

The results from my second smear test were inaccurate as they came back with severe high grade CIN3 hence the biopsy, but they were actually only CIN1 and had resolved when I went back 6m later.

@SmearFear191 Has anyone explained that the cells can be different on different parts of the cervix? A smear might show a certain grade of CIN and a colposcopy might show differently.

So the smear may well have shown cells that were CIN3.
AND as you have suggested, your body can 'fight' the changes and sometimes cells revert to normal. However, any CIN3 change should be monitored.

I have a friend who had the colposcopy and the Letz treatment. She was in her early 30s then and advised the vaccine wouldn't help as it was too late.

tomatoontoast · 30/12/2023 23:01

Get your smears.

Few deaths are as horrific as cervical cancer. The worry about results is more than worth the pain of treatment.

Elfoutthewindow · 30/12/2023 22:58

@Chowit

And do you appreciate that screening can kill, or lead to lifelong harm?

Not much of a risk with cervical, but with colorectal, or breast, etc.

No screening is without risks, or should be taken without a thought of "this may be good at a population level, but is it right for me?"

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 22:56

You don't need to take offence at any of this

I'm not taking offence. I found your post distasteful.

Wisenotboring · 30/12/2023 21:06

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 20:54

No, you were using another woman's tragedy to make a point. You don't know if she had regular smears and the pre cancerous changes were missed.

I haven't claimed that I do. I'm not using anyone's tragedy. I'm encouraging the poster to take the opportunity for screening from scientific and real life points of view. You don't need to take offence at any of this.

Delassalle · 30/12/2023 20:58

@Zanatdy no family history and I've survived this far.

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 30/12/2023 20:54

Wisenotboring · 30/12/2023 18:18

I'm afraid I don't know and it would be inappropriate for me to ask. My point really was that seeing the potential fall out I try to stack the odds in my favour.

No, you were using another woman's tragedy to make a point. You don't know if she had regular smears and the pre cancerous changes were missed.

Chowit · 30/12/2023 20:26

Elfoutthewindow · 30/12/2023 10:46

@Chowit said by someone who doesn't understand the risks/benefits of screening. Did you read the leaflets? Do you understand the over treatment risks? Did you weigh it up in any way?

I understand that screening can possibly save lives.
Given that you don't know anything of me or my employment, then I find your comment rather silly.

Trinity69 · 30/12/2023 19:52

It’s not something I’d miss. I had a dodgy smear after my son was born and had cold coagulation treatment on iffy cells. Every smear since has been clear but if I’d not been having them, chances are I’d be dead.

GG1986 · 30/12/2023 19:48

I would just keep getting them. My first smear at 25 showed HPV, I had a colposcopy which showed CIN1, I then had to have smears every year for a while and a repeat colposcopy. Eventually the HPV cleared by itself and I am back to 3 yearly. Keep yourself in the system. I know someone who died from cervical cancer in her late 30s unfortunately.

Poorlycatadvicewanted · 30/12/2023 19:23

Please carry on having your smears. I have mine next week. Its just one of those things. Any test can come back with results that aren't always correct and can be re tested. I understand the stress and upset and worry. But its still important