Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Late mum's husband has new partner - still living in mum's home

542 replies

stepparentdilemma2023 · 29/12/2023 13:55

Hi all

Bit of a backstory, my mum remarried a new guy (stepfather - SF) in 2018. They subsequently bought a house together, which mum paid about 80% and him about 20% of, that same year.

Mum sadly was diagnosed with an aggressive form of breast cancer and died relatively quickly in May 2022. SF received a third of her pension in the will, which already raised eyebrows among me and my brother (mum's only children), but mum's investment into the house was protected, so we still own her share.

Since mum died, SF has continued living in the house, which has increased in value quite dramatically since 2018. He has had one of his adult children, who is a bit of a tearaway, living there on off (in life, the adult child was not allowed to stay at the house by my mum as he had been involved in drug debt and had had a brick put through the window of his own mother's house, as well as being briefly kidnapped (!!) to pay off the debt).

We have maintained generally cordial relations with SF, and had arranged via WhatsApp to see him this Christmas when my brother noticed his WhatsApp picture was a photo of him and a new woman. When we eventually did go for our Christmas meetup yesterday at the house, his wedding ring was off, several photographs of mum had been taken down, and he confessed he had been seeing a new woman for a number of months.

Brother is very disappointed as previously SF had gone on about how mum was his soulmate, he'd never love another, etc... only to enter a relationship with someone new in just over a year.

I'm not sure how I feel, because I was never as close to SF in the first place, but I do know I think my mum would've been quite upset at how quickly (in the grand scheme of things) this had all come about.

FWIW, the new woman lives independently to him (as far as we know), is apparently quite wealthy (he's landed on his feet again!) and has two children of her own.

AIBU to now think that if SF has moved on with his life to the extent he is comfortable enough to take off his wedding ring and meet a new woman, that it is time we take back the house and sell?

My brother is getting married in 2025 and could do with some funds for that, and I have had a couple of my own financial issues this year so am now at a stage where the money would be hugely beneficial.

Sorry it was a long one!

OP posts:
Muchof · 30/12/2023 10:50

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 10:40

We can all speculate till the cows come home, but without knowing whether OP's DM's will allows him use of her share of the house for life, we are really wasting our time.

Agree 16 pages of comments but without OP confirming what the will says it is all pointless. I don’t think OP and brother can even be sure that they have inherited a 80% share, that could just be an assumption as her mum paid 80% of the purchase price.

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 10:40

PropertyManager · 29/12/2023 15:54

But why would he, he only has to pay rates on the property he part owns - he'd be mad to do anything else!!

We can all speculate till the cows come home, but without knowing whether OP's DM's will allows him use of her share of the house for life, we are really wasting our time.

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 10:33

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 10:32

What do you mean he isn’t grieving now?

It’s entirely possible to start new relationship and grieve someone still.

Possibly he may still be grieving, but grieving people often have to downsize if living beyond their means.

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 10:32

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 09:37

OP's mother died relatively quickly after diagnosis so he didn't have to "nurse" her for long. Sounds like DM and SF were retired so if he put in 20% of the house price that's probably because that's what he had to put in, not because he couldn't work to look after his wife, and since the house has increased in value he has made a profit. He is already quids in as after a very short marriage he has inherited her pension. He is not grieving now, he has a new GF, which I don't judge him for at all, life is indeed for the living and he should now be living it somewhere else.

What do you mean he isn’t grieving now?

It’s entirely possible to start new relationship and grieve someone still.

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 09:57

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 09:37

OP's mother died relatively quickly after diagnosis so he didn't have to "nurse" her for long. Sounds like DM and SF were retired so if he put in 20% of the house price that's probably because that's what he had to put in, not because he couldn't work to look after his wife, and since the house has increased in value he has made a profit. He is already quids in as after a very short marriage he has inherited her pension. He is not grieving now, he has a new GF, which I don't judge him for at all, life is indeed for the living and he should now be living it somewhere else.

100% agreed.

DeeLusional · 30/12/2023 09:37

aurynne · 30/12/2023 04:16

His late wife of only 2 years developed cancer and died, and he stayed with her and took care of her for the following 2 years. Not many men, in reality, would do this for someone they have been in a relationship for such a short time. This, and this fact only, makes me believe this is actually a quite remarkable man, not just a chancer who wants to keep the house.

How did this man survive while caring for his dying wife? Has anyone considered that perhps he only owns 20% of the house because he became her sole carer and could not work? There are many parts of this story which are unknown because trhe OP has refused to share more details.

Where were OP and her brother during their mum's illness? By the timeline it appears the OP's mum died while she was overseas, so please forgive me if I am wrong, but it does not appear she was spending any of her time caring for her sick and dying mum. This would be because OP's SF was filling that role, and believe me, this is a horrendous and overwhelming job to do. Not having to care for a mum dying of cancer has been a wonderful gift this man has given to his step-children. None of this seems to be recognised anywhere by the OP.

Wanting him out of his house because they want the money (which they would not have by now, had their mum not died too soon anyway) and because he has dared now to date another woman 18 months after the horrendous death of his wife, is the truly obscene fact in this whole saga for me.

OP's mother died relatively quickly after diagnosis so he didn't have to "nurse" her for long. Sounds like DM and SF were retired so if he put in 20% of the house price that's probably because that's what he had to put in, not because he couldn't work to look after his wife, and since the house has increased in value he has made a profit. He is already quids in as after a very short marriage he has inherited her pension. He is not grieving now, he has a new GF, which I don't judge him for at all, life is indeed for the living and he should now be living it somewhere else.

muggart · 30/12/2023 09:24

I don't know what the OP should do about her money but I do think she needs to have a less selfish attitude about her SF dating again. Her feelings about that are irrelevant and he has done nothing wrong. He went through a horrible loss too and may need companionship.

I lost a much-loved parent as a young child and even then had the emotional maturity to support my surviving parent when they dated again because I learned the hard way how hard it is, and how important it is, to find happiness in this life. It baffles me to see adults here discussing whether it's ok to kick a old man out of his home seemingly in part to punish him for how he has handled his bereavement. Of course if it is purely a financial decision about needing the money that would be different but don't try to make it into a moral one.

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/12/2023 08:49

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 30/12/2023 01:21

And honestly, I've lost a parent and a partner, and there is no comparison. 'A partner can be replaced' is an awful thing to say, you cannot replace your person. Ever. I could point out that most people can expect to lose their parents, but few expect or can be prepared to lose a spouse relatively young. It's meant to be the person you spend the rest of your life with. Its heart breaking losing a parent, but a very natural part of life. Losing your spouse is not in the slightest bit comparable.

Well said. A friend of mine lost her partner at a relatively young age. She had lost parents, and a baby, so thought she could accept grief, but said what she felt at the death of her partner was a whole other level.

Agree with both replies

My first husband died nearly 13yrs ago next year

My mum 10yrs next year

Both were unexpected. Both were awful but different.

Yes you know one day your parents are likely to die before you / but my mum shouldn't have died when she did at 73

She should be alive now. She never knew or met mini blondes 6 which breaks my heart

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/12/2023 08:45

healthadvice123 · 29/12/2023 21:51

@Newchapterbeckons how do you know he doesn’t as it depends on the will?
my friend died and the house belongs to his children but the will states that his partner can live their for life , despite not owning it

This is what my will says

My house was mine before my I met my now second dh

He has 3 older kids in 30's

We have a shared dd6 mini blondes

If I die first the house goes to mini blondes /in trust if think under 21

But dh can live there till he dies

whowhatwerewhy · 30/12/2023 07:24

Regardless of anyone's views nothing can be done until op has a copy of the Will .
Op said the will has already been read and administered so it's very simple to go online to get a copy.
If it states SF has a lifetime interest there is absolutely nothing op can do to force him to sell .
If he doesn't op can approach him to discuss the sale .

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 07:04

I hope op stopped reading this bile a long time ago.

And is looking after herself.

Wishing you the best op. Some of us really understand your pov. Don’t forget many stepmothers are on here with their own (questionable)agendas, clearly.

Talk to sf and come to a civilised and fair agreement, I am sure if he is a decent person he will be more than willing to do the right thing for you and your brother 💐💐

aurynne · 30/12/2023 04:16

mayorofcasterbridge · 29/12/2023 18:52

It's a fact isn't it - his late wife was clearly also better off financially than he was too?

His late wife of only 2 years developed cancer and died, and he stayed with her and took care of her for the following 2 years. Not many men, in reality, would do this for someone they have been in a relationship for such a short time. This, and this fact only, makes me believe this is actually a quite remarkable man, not just a chancer who wants to keep the house.

How did this man survive while caring for his dying wife? Has anyone considered that perhps he only owns 20% of the house because he became her sole carer and could not work? There are many parts of this story which are unknown because trhe OP has refused to share more details.

Where were OP and her brother during their mum's illness? By the timeline it appears the OP's mum died while she was overseas, so please forgive me if I am wrong, but it does not appear she was spending any of her time caring for her sick and dying mum. This would be because OP's SF was filling that role, and believe me, this is a horrendous and overwhelming job to do. Not having to care for a mum dying of cancer has been a wonderful gift this man has given to his step-children. None of this seems to be recognised anywhere by the OP.

Wanting him out of his house because they want the money (which they would not have by now, had their mum not died too soon anyway) and because he has dared now to date another woman 18 months after the horrendous death of his wife, is the truly obscene fact in this whole saga for me.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 30/12/2023 01:21

And honestly, I've lost a parent and a partner, and there is no comparison. 'A partner can be replaced' is an awful thing to say, you cannot replace your person. Ever. I could point out that most people can expect to lose their parents, but few expect or can be prepared to lose a spouse relatively young. It's meant to be the person you spend the rest of your life with. Its heart breaking losing a parent, but a very natural part of life. Losing your spouse is not in the slightest bit comparable.

Well said. A friend of mine lost her partner at a relatively young age. She had lost parents, and a baby, so thought she could accept grief, but said what she felt at the death of her partner was a whole other level.

whiteshutters · 29/12/2023 23:44

If the OP's mother signed 1/3 of her pension to him then I suspect she will have made provision for him staying on in the property - albeit with conditions.

newnamethanks · 29/12/2023 23:09

So he should be lonely and single for how long? What's an acceptable amount of time for you to approve of? You are letting your own grief cloud your judgement.

CanImakethisbetter · 29/12/2023 22:49

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 21:55

It's your last sentence that sums up the issue.
You are saying that OP had no intention of selling the home until SF met the new woman. And is only doing it to punish him. So, according to your interpretation OP would have waited indefinitely had he continued, erm, play the part of the grieving widow.

But my interpretation is that OP always intended to sell the house if possible, and get her share. Why would anybody NOT want any cash they're entitled to? It's just that, as I have stated several times on this thread doing that ASAP, say after the funeral would be callous and cruel.

18 months later, OP + her brother are needing cash and the SF appears to have moved on. Is it still 'callous and cruel'?

THIS is really the question OP is asking and has been mired by discussions of the new woman, landed on his feet, etc etc.

Quite frankly I think if the OP was indeed grabby and wanted cash ASAP she'd have gotten a copy of the will, done all of this as soon as possible.

There are options here depending on what the will says, OP could negotiate with SF, go to court, etc etc but that's not the question being asked. What's legal is legal. What's moral is moral.

Btw, not sure who the PP was who said that SF is likely to be allowed to stay as DC never lived there. That depends on who is responsible for the maintenance cost. If SF doesn't have enough money to maintain it and neither do the children a court isn't going to force the latter as majority owners to go into debt for it.

Edited

To date Op hasn’t even learned the details of the will. That’s not someone who is interested in selling. Because she doesn’t know she can.

It’s quite unlikely that she can. But up until the girlfriend appeared, the detail wasn’t an issue.

If op planned on raising the subject the first port of call would have been to read the will. She has been thinking about this for a while but never thought to actually find out if she could or not? That makes no sense.

Actually, at this point, she isn’t entitled to any money. Because she has no clue of the terms of the will so how can she determine she is entitled to the money at this point? She may become entitled when he either remarries or dies or whatever the will might say. It’s depends on the will. Failing that she might need to fight it legally and lose. Which again, would be that in law she owns a portion of the house but isn’t entitled to the money from it until a given point.

Its not as simple as she owns part of the house so therefore she is entitled to its value right when she wants it.

It’s far more likely Op knows her mother intended for him to live there. She knows that was in the will with some caveats. But is going to see what she can get him to agree to. And she has chosen to do this now because she is angry and upset.

I never suggested op was grabby. I don’t think it’s about the money at all. It’s about their anger that he moved on, what is in their opinion, too soon. But that’s not going to help their legal case if it comes to that. It won’t change what’s on the will.

You talk about morals. Morally, I think it’s wrong to believe your parents widower is only allowed to move on in your own timeline that suits you. And to attempt to move them out because the timeline didn’t suit.

Op is very clear. She thinks he should move out because he has a girlfriend.

How do you know he doesn’t have enough money to maintain it?

porridgeisbae · 29/12/2023 22:35

Why would anybody NOT want any cash they're entitled to?

A lot of people would be mildly annoyed but they wouldn't be actively planning to make their late mum's husband move out of the home he shared with her.

porridgeisbae · 29/12/2023 22:31

I think it’s quite disgusting actually that sf hasnt offered to sell before now, or at least offered!! That says a lot in itself. If I only owned 20% of a property I wouldn’t be depriving my late wife’s children of their rightful inheritance, and just sit on the money indefinitely for my own benefit. I would do the decent thing and let them choose what is the best way forward.

@Newchapterbeckons As with many people, when my dad dies he is leaving the house to my sister and I in trust, and it's stipulated that if our step mum is still alive, she can live in it until she dies.

She wont own any % of it and she'll still be there until she dies, 'depriving us of our inheritance.' Grin

@stepparentdilemma2023 You need to know if there's anything like that in the will, or what it says. Without knowing that, this whole convo is moot really.

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 21:55

CanImakethisbetter · 29/12/2023 21:45

of course the argument is logical. It’s entirely illogical to suggest it’s ok to force him to leave because his girlfriend, whose finances are nothing to do with home, is wealthy.

If you want to look at this purely from an emotional point of view, it’s definitely a tantrum.

From an emotional point of view they only want him out because he has a girlfriend and is no longer playing the part they think he should.

Owning 20% is neither here nor there. It’s his home. It’s also likely that the lighter have some guidance on what she expected. Op believes she knew her mother that well she knows what she think of him moving on. But seems to have no clue what her mother would have expected regarding the home. Given he lives there, it’s not as simple as they want the house sold so it can be. It’s far more likely that the will contains wishes for him to stay than leave. Surely the op and the brother didn’t just forget that part?

If someone posted here that they owned 20% of a house with their husband and their husband kept pointed out that their fraction was tiny and not important would you think it was ok?

I think it’s highly unlikely there was nothing in the will about what was to happen to the house. Or that the issue has been ignored.

Ops question isn’t when is it morally right. It’s is it morally right to expect him to leave since he has lived on quicker than I would have liked. You are suggesting that he lives his life at a pace that suits op to stay in his home.

The Op can move on. She doesn’t need the cash to move on. She can move on as much as he can. We don’t even know what’s on the will. If the mother said he was to live there as long as he wants or until he remarries, would that be the mother preventing him from moving on.

and yes the girlfriend being wealthy is neither here nor there. Because her finances are nothing to do with the Op.

I would have far more sympathy for the Ops position if this was something They were pursuing already. Op doesn’t even know what was in the will. But killed straight to, right he needs to leave because I don’t like his choices. Op appeared to be quite fine up u til he made a choice she didn’t like. I know what it’s like to lose your mum. It’s awful. But it’s also awful to decide you want someone’s home sold, only because you don’t like a choice they made for themselves.

It's your last sentence that sums up the issue.
You are saying that OP had no intention of selling the home until SF met the new woman. And is only doing it to punish him. So, according to your interpretation OP would have waited indefinitely had he continued, erm, play the part of the grieving widow.

But my interpretation is that OP always intended to sell the house if possible, and get her share. Why would anybody NOT want any cash they're entitled to? It's just that, as I have stated several times on this thread doing that ASAP, say after the funeral would be callous and cruel.

18 months later, OP + her brother are needing cash and the SF appears to have moved on. Is it still 'callous and cruel'?

THIS is really the question OP is asking and has been mired by discussions of the new woman, landed on his feet, etc etc.

Quite frankly I think if the OP was indeed grabby and wanted cash ASAP she'd have gotten a copy of the will, done all of this as soon as possible.

There are options here depending on what the will says, OP could negotiate with SF, go to court, etc etc but that's not the question being asked. What's legal is legal. What's moral is moral.

Btw, not sure who the PP was who said that SF is likely to be allowed to stay as DC never lived there. That depends on who is responsible for the maintenance cost. If SF doesn't have enough money to maintain it and neither do the children a court isn't going to force the latter as majority owners to go into debt for it.

healthadvice123 · 29/12/2023 21:54

Also I'm not sure anyone can decide for someone else that its too quick to move on. That is down to the individual and nobody else's business either really. Sometimes these things happen and the person is not even expecting it.

healthadvice123 · 29/12/2023 21:51

@Newchapterbeckons how do you know he doesn’t as it depends on the will?
my friend died and the house belongs to his children but the will states that his partner can live their for life , despite not owning it

CanImakethisbetter · 29/12/2023 21:45

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 20:27

This.
@CanImakethisbetter all of your arguments are 'logical' (e.g. of course if he has a financially wealthy girlfriend it's not her job rationally to support him).
But this isn't about logic. It's about the OP's feelings.

If you wanted to be completely logical he only owns 20%, OP and her brother could have tried to get him out via the courts earlier. Even a lifetime tenancy depending on the terms and whether adequate provision has been made for maintenance etc can be challenged.

So when is the right time to do this? 18 months? 5 years? 10 years?

If all avenues are investigated and they're unable to sell fair enough but the OP's question is really when is it morally right. I'm sure everyone would agree that a week after the funeral is too soon. Is 18 months?

He has moved on. With the new woman. Why can't the children be allowed to move on too? If OP's mother wanted him to stay I'm sure she'd have legally made provision. If not they have every right to sell the house.

Her being wealthy is neither here no there SF has a third of OP's late mum's pension and will have 20% from the value of the house sale.

Edited

of course the argument is logical. It’s entirely illogical to suggest it’s ok to force him to leave because his girlfriend, whose finances are nothing to do with home, is wealthy.

If you want to look at this purely from an emotional point of view, it’s definitely a tantrum.

From an emotional point of view they only want him out because he has a girlfriend and is no longer playing the part they think he should.

Owning 20% is neither here nor there. It’s his home. It’s also likely that the lighter have some guidance on what she expected. Op believes she knew her mother that well she knows what she think of him moving on. But seems to have no clue what her mother would have expected regarding the home. Given he lives there, it’s not as simple as they want the house sold so it can be. It’s far more likely that the will contains wishes for him to stay than leave. Surely the op and the brother didn’t just forget that part?

If someone posted here that they owned 20% of a house with their husband and their husband kept pointed out that their fraction was tiny and not important would you think it was ok?

I think it’s highly unlikely there was nothing in the will about what was to happen to the house. Or that the issue has been ignored.

Ops question isn’t when is it morally right. It’s is it morally right to expect him to leave since he has lived on quicker than I would have liked. You are suggesting that he lives his life at a pace that suits op to stay in his home.

The Op can move on. She doesn’t need the cash to move on. She can move on as much as he can. We don’t even know what’s on the will. If the mother said he was to live there as long as he wants or until he remarries, would that be the mother preventing him from moving on.

and yes the girlfriend being wealthy is neither here nor there. Because her finances are nothing to do with the Op.

I would have far more sympathy for the Ops position if this was something They were pursuing already. Op doesn’t even know what was in the will. But killed straight to, right he needs to leave because I don’t like his choices. Op appeared to be quite fine up u til he made a choice she didn’t like. I know what it’s like to lose your mum. It’s awful. But it’s also awful to decide you want someone’s home sold, only because you don’t like a choice they made for themselves.

PropertyManager · 29/12/2023 21:41

Newchapterbeckons · 29/12/2023 21:29

He owns a tiny 20 %…. Op and her brother own 80%. He does not have the right to live there indefinitely depriving them of their inheritance.

The law is very clear, where a property is held as "tenants in common" which it almost certainly is with an 80/20 split, no party can sell without the agreement of all parties.

Technically one party could sell their %age, but it would be massively devalued as there is no market for such percentages, and it would cost a potential buyer dear to realise the value.

In the case parties cannot agree the party wanting to sell petitions the court for an order for sale.

The court then has to consider the purpose the "trust" (legalese for tenancy in common in this case) was formed for, and whether the purpose of said trust still exists.

It would be argued the purpose of the trust was to provide a home for SF and DM, DM having passed then the purpose of homing SF still exists.

DC have never resided in this home, so the purpose of the trust never involved them.

Likely then the court would uphold the DCs financial interest, but also the SFs right to remain for his life.

This process would costapacket, loadsamoney, to the DCs - far easier to wait for SF to move on of his own accord and realise the 80% as and when..

Newchapterbeckons · 29/12/2023 21:39

I think it’s quite disgusting actually that sf hasnt offered to sell before now, or at least offered!! That says a lot in itself. If I only owned 20% of a property I wouldn’t be depriving my late wife’s children of their rightful inheritance, and just sit on the money indefinitely for my own benefit. I would do the decent thing and let them choose what is the best way forward.

Cosyblankets · 29/12/2023 21:39

cloudteabublecvoe · 29/12/2023 21:21

@mayorofcasterbridge unfortunately inheritance, along with opening the door to strangers :) drives MN nuts. People fall over themselves to kick someone call them greedy, unfeeling, selfish etc etc whenever money is involved I'm afraid.

Regardless of OP's purported motives or otherwise. SF only owns 20% of the house. It doesn't matter that he lives there. The majority of the property belongs to OP and her brother! It's useless for people to say OP has no right to feel anything, speak out etc etc. She literally does. It's HER property. She owns more of it than the SF.

We'd all agree that it's callous for OP to consider kicking SF out within a week of the funeral.

Do the PP castigating OP also think 18 months is callous? If not, when?

Edited

But we don't actually know this though. Not for sure. As has, quite rightly, already been pointed out, if the house was jointly owned rather than tenants in common, then the mother's ownership will automatically have been transferred to the stepdad. So the OP won't actually own anything.
But all this is speculation as, ridiculously, OP hasn't seen the will 18 months on!

Swipe left for the next trending thread