Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Late mum's husband has new partner - still living in mum's home

542 replies

stepparentdilemma2023 · 29/12/2023 13:55

Hi all

Bit of a backstory, my mum remarried a new guy (stepfather - SF) in 2018. They subsequently bought a house together, which mum paid about 80% and him about 20% of, that same year.

Mum sadly was diagnosed with an aggressive form of breast cancer and died relatively quickly in May 2022. SF received a third of her pension in the will, which already raised eyebrows among me and my brother (mum's only children), but mum's investment into the house was protected, so we still own her share.

Since mum died, SF has continued living in the house, which has increased in value quite dramatically since 2018. He has had one of his adult children, who is a bit of a tearaway, living there on off (in life, the adult child was not allowed to stay at the house by my mum as he had been involved in drug debt and had had a brick put through the window of his own mother's house, as well as being briefly kidnapped (!!) to pay off the debt).

We have maintained generally cordial relations with SF, and had arranged via WhatsApp to see him this Christmas when my brother noticed his WhatsApp picture was a photo of him and a new woman. When we eventually did go for our Christmas meetup yesterday at the house, his wedding ring was off, several photographs of mum had been taken down, and he confessed he had been seeing a new woman for a number of months.

Brother is very disappointed as previously SF had gone on about how mum was his soulmate, he'd never love another, etc... only to enter a relationship with someone new in just over a year.

I'm not sure how I feel, because I was never as close to SF in the first place, but I do know I think my mum would've been quite upset at how quickly (in the grand scheme of things) this had all come about.

FWIW, the new woman lives independently to him (as far as we know), is apparently quite wealthy (he's landed on his feet again!) and has two children of her own.

AIBU to now think that if SF has moved on with his life to the extent he is comfortable enough to take off his wedding ring and meet a new woman, that it is time we take back the house and sell?

My brother is getting married in 2025 and could do with some funds for that, and I have had a couple of my own financial issues this year so am now at a stage where the money would be hugely beneficial.

Sorry it was a long one!

OP posts:
CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 20:08

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 19:49

Regardless, the house doesn’t belong to him. It mostly belongs to the children. Whether he is fine or not fine - it’s not right to hold on to 80% equity that belongs to someone else ( unless his wife left a life time provision ) They had a very short marriage, not decades of shared life. I don’t know why so many are struggling to see the difference.

Edited

I don’t understand how people can’t see that the actual ownership isn’t the issue.

He could own non of it and still have the right to live there.

It all depends on the will. If he has the right to live there, the Ops mother never intended the Op to be able to liquidise her portion until a trigger is hit. The trigger’s are usually death or remarriage.

Op owning a portion doesn’t mean she is entitled to the money it is worth.

Tandora · 30/12/2023 20:00

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 19:49

Regardless, the house doesn’t belong to him. It mostly belongs to the children. Whether he is fine or not fine - it’s not right to hold on to 80% equity that belongs to someone else ( unless his wife left a life time provision ) They had a very short marriage, not decades of shared life. I don’t know why so many are struggling to see the difference.

Edited

I think most people are recognising that point , which is why almost everyone has focused their advice to OP on telling her to check the conditions of will , establish if there is a life time provision or not , and then make an informed choice about how to proceed.

What people are objecting to are those linking the SF’s rights to stay in the house to whether he is dating or not.
one has nothing to do with the other. OP understandably has emotions around this, but that is not a reason to kick him out the house, when previously she was happy for him to stay. As a pp had pointed out, there is no legal or moral basis for linking the two.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 30/12/2023 19:57

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 19:49

Regardless, the house doesn’t belong to him. It mostly belongs to the children. Whether he is fine or not fine - it’s not right to hold on to 80% equity that belongs to someone else ( unless his wife left a life time provision ) They had a very short marriage, not decades of shared life. I don’t know why so many are struggling to see the difference.

Edited

Not agreeing with you does not mean struggling to see the difference. I’m not sure why that’s so difficult for many to grasp?

The legal situation, as he owns 20%, is that he cannot be forced to sell without a court order, and a court order may very likely go in his favour as (a) he’s a part owner and (b) he’s living there. So the OP needs to find someone to buy 80% of the property to get her hands on her Mothers money.

But, the OP is very unclear on the contents of the will, which is odd. Without knowing what’s in the will it’s difficult so state anything other than the legal position. Whatever is in the will can only strengthen his position though. All those posting about how she should get him out asap are lamentably lacking in knowledge of what that actually entails.

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 19:49

Tryingtokeepgoing · 30/12/2023 19:38

As someone who lost my husband over 4 years ago I am sure I do things most days/weeks/months that would give the indication I’m coping. And of course at one level I am, I have no choice. I’m dating again, and have been seeing a lovely guy for a year or so. But, I’m still grieving. Badly at times. And this time of year is always tough; more so because my late husband loved Christmas. You really have no idea what it’s like, and am pleased for you that you don’t. I wouldn’t wish losing a husband (or wife) early on anyone.

Regardless, the house doesn’t belong to him. It mostly belongs to the children. Whether he is fine or not fine - it’s not right to hold on to 80% equity that belongs to someone else ( unless his wife left a life time provision ) They had a very short marriage, not decades of shared life. I don’t know why so many are struggling to see the difference.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 30/12/2023 19:38

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:00

It is explicit from his decision to start a new relationship of ‘many months’ which could be a very long time already potentially, removing his ring and taken down the photos. I think most of us can be pretty certain he is most definitely ‘coping’ and getting through the days 😂

As someone who lost my husband over 4 years ago I am sure I do things most days/weeks/months that would give the indication I’m coping. And of course at one level I am, I have no choice. I’m dating again, and have been seeing a lovely guy for a year or so. But, I’m still grieving. Badly at times. And this time of year is always tough; more so because my late husband loved Christmas. You really have no idea what it’s like, and am pleased for you that you don’t. I wouldn’t wish losing a husband (or wife) early on anyone.

mayorofcasterbridge · 30/12/2023 19:08

ReallyAgainReally · 30/12/2023 19:02

@stepparentdilemma2023 Well, we all like a happy ending. The fact that the op who actively and aggressively defended her position based on emotions alone and zero fact has not come back, since either downloading the will or getting clearer info from DB about the contents of the will, can only mean one thing.

SF has a life time interest in the 80% until he dies or sell and, SF is only required to sell [and move out] if he remarries.

As other have pointed out, no way 18 months on, op and db didn't know what of the 80% whilst SF lives there. Also, no way they would have been charitable to him to keep him in the house 18 months ago, and only since GF has entered the pic, op wants to know their position.

the way op phrased the op was telling: kinda asking mn if since SF has a new GF if it wasn't time he moved out. but why? what does the will- the only thing allowing him to be there at the moment, says? or did executors not finish the job? op must go lie to others, not us.

well, glad i could be of service!

Or it could be she got pissed off with all the nasty posts and chose to stop engaging!!

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 19:05

GreenLampLight · 30/12/2023 18:54

I've never said SF has to leave the house. I've said OP needs to get independent legal advice on exactly what her legal position is. And then if she has options she can make an emotional/moral decision on what she thinks is 'right'. Random internet posters, me included, don't have the information to know or advise what is 'right'.

I mentioned the son with the drug problem because he doesn't sound like someone her mother or she would want moving permanently into the house and it might prompt the OP to think the sooner she knows exactly where she stands legally the better.

And he didn’t come to the house while the Ops mother was alive. I don’t understand the point of the mum not wanting him there. Even being brought up by the Op. Though it’s obvious why it was brought up.

She isn’t here anymore. It’s entirely irrelevant whether her mother wanted him in the house or not. That’s the point that’s irrelevant.

He is in the house and yes that needs to be discussed. But would need to be discussed whether the mum would let him in the house or not.

Again, I am sure this was all discussed and is in the will. Which I am sure op, actually, has full knowledge of.

ReallyAgainReally · 30/12/2023 19:02

@stepparentdilemma2023 Well, we all like a happy ending. The fact that the op who actively and aggressively defended her position based on emotions alone and zero fact has not come back, since either downloading the will or getting clearer info from DB about the contents of the will, can only mean one thing.

SF has a life time interest in the 80% until he dies or sell and, SF is only required to sell [and move out] if he remarries.

As other have pointed out, no way 18 months on, op and db didn't know what of the 80% whilst SF lives there. Also, no way they would have been charitable to him to keep him in the house 18 months ago, and only since GF has entered the pic, op wants to know their position.

the way op phrased the op was telling: kinda asking mn if since SF has a new GF if it wasn't time he moved out. but why? what does the will- the only thing allowing him to be there at the moment, says? or did executors not finish the job? op must go lie to others, not us.

well, glad i could be of service!

GreenLampLight · 30/12/2023 18:54

I've never said SF has to leave the house. I've said OP needs to get independent legal advice on exactly what her legal position is. And then if she has options she can make an emotional/moral decision on what she thinks is 'right'. Random internet posters, me included, don't have the information to know or advise what is 'right'.

I mentioned the son with the drug problem because he doesn't sound like someone her mother or she would want moving permanently into the house and it might prompt the OP to think the sooner she knows exactly where she stands legally the better.

mayorofcasterbridge · 30/12/2023 18:53

MzHz · 30/12/2023 15:37

I see this has hit a nerve @stepparentdilemma2023 but it is true- you can’t force anyone to do anything once you’re gone. You can’t even do that when you’re alive tbh.

The only way that would have happened is by a stipulation in the will that you’d probably already know about

there IS something unseemly about your fingers in this man’s pie. You’re judging him unfairly and are coming across as grabby.

get advice and then decide what you want to do but understand how this is all making you look and if you can live with that behaviour towards a good man who was loved by your mum.

But it's her pie too???!

Britinme · 30/12/2023 18:47

Moving on does not mean someone isn't still grieving.

This.

When I remarried 18 months after my first DH died, I was very happy in my new relationship, but I still ended up going into therapy for a couple of years to deal with the fact that I was still grieving my first DH. Luckily my second DH was both understanding and supportive, once I explained to him that it didn't mean I loved him less than my first DH but that I needed time to come to terms with that loss.

Before anybody points out that I needn't have remarried so quickly, there were logistical reasons around the age and education of my youngest DC that meant we either had to move quickly or wait anything up to four years in a very long-distance relationship. As I was in my fifties at that point, I didn't feel I could sacrifice those four years to waiting, and I felt that my youngest DC would be better off in the US education system than the UK education system, which in fact turned out to be the case.

TheSquareMile · 30/12/2023 18:44

stepparentdilemma2023 · 29/12/2023 14:35

Thank you, this is the most sensible comment I have read all thread.

I am unclear as to the exact set up of the will, to answer questions that many have been asking, as I was based abroad when it was read and executed. I have put these questions to my brother who is having it looked over by a solicitor in the new year.

OP

Has your brother seen the will and does he have a copy of it?

He must have a copy of it, surely?

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 18:35

GreenLampLight · 30/12/2023 18:04

But it's not 'their' house now. If OP's mum wanted SF to have it she wouldn't have ring-fenced her 80% and given it to her own children.

And nobody has mentioned SF's son with the drug problem and dodgy associates who OP's mum wouldn't have in the house. Who has been living there on and off with SF since OP's mum died. What if SF were sadly to be run over by a bus next week and Dodgy Son decides to move into his 'inheritance' because 'it's what dad would have wanted'? It could get very messy, very quickly indeed.

The fact that it (might) be ring fenced for op doesn’t mean the mother didn’t want her husband to live it.

She didn’t have to give him it. He can live there anyway.

The son is entirely irrelevant. No one is forced to stick to rule their deceased partner put into place.

That 20% will go to the SF child/ren anyway. Which is another thing that needs to be sorted out

Non of this means he has to leave the house.

MumblesParty · 30/12/2023 18:27

I knew of a case in which a woman with 2 adult kids had bought a house with her childless partner. Partner and kids never got on. Woman died and left her half to her kids, but gave her partner the right to live in the house till he died or sold it. He wanted to stay in the house as long as he possibly could, in order to prevent the kids (who he actively disliked) getting their inheritance. He got very old and disabled, and really needed to move into a care home, but flatly refused, openly admitting that he didn’t want the kids to get their inheritance. He stuck it out for years, with frequent hospital admissions due to his inability to be safe at home. Eventually the hospital wouldn’t discharge him as social services couldn’t facilitate his care at home, so he had no choice but to accept residential care and the sale of his house. He was well into his 90s by then and his stepkids were pensioners themselves !

sparkellie · 30/12/2023 18:20

GreenLampLight · 30/12/2023 18:04

But it's not 'their' house now. If OP's mum wanted SF to have it she wouldn't have ring-fenced her 80% and given it to her own children.

And nobody has mentioned SF's son with the drug problem and dodgy associates who OP's mum wouldn't have in the house. Who has been living there on and off with SF since OP's mum died. What if SF were sadly to be run over by a bus next week and Dodgy Son decides to move into his 'inheritance' because 'it's what dad would have wanted'? It could get very messy, very quickly indeed.

They bought the house together. It is their house.
OP doesn't actually know if anything has been ringfenced for her and her brother, let alone if there are conditions to that. Most likely that the SD has a home until he either doesn't want or need it any more.
It's quite normal to divide your share of a property among your children, it doesn't mean they are entitled to the property before the SD passes. And definitely doesn't make it ok for them to try and kick out the surviving spouse before they are ready to go.

MumblesParty · 30/12/2023 18:18

Here’s a question - hypothetical situation - not same a the OP, but I’m curious.

Dave and Sue are both widowed. They get married and buy a house together.
Dave has adult kids, Sue doesn’t have kids.
Dave and Sue both have a will leaving their half of the house to their chosen beneficiaries (in Dave’s case it’s the adult kids), but giving each other the right to live there until they die or sell.
Dave dies.

Sue stays in the house, as per the will, so Dave’s kids don’t get their inheritance yet.
Years pass and Sue meets Mike.
Mike has no assets or kids, and moves in with Sue.
Sue amends her will leaving Mike her half of the house, and giving him the right to stay living in the house in the event of her death.
Sue then dies.
Do Dave’s kids still have to wait for their inheritance?
Or would Sue not have been allowed to give Mike lifetime rights to the house, given that she only owned half of it?

GreenLampLight · 30/12/2023 18:04

But it's not 'their' house now. If OP's mum wanted SF to have it she wouldn't have ring-fenced her 80% and given it to her own children.

And nobody has mentioned SF's son with the drug problem and dodgy associates who OP's mum wouldn't have in the house. Who has been living there on and off with SF since OP's mum died. What if SF were sadly to be run over by a bus next week and Dodgy Son decides to move into his 'inheritance' because 'it's what dad would have wanted'? It could get very messy, very quickly indeed.

Palacelife · 30/12/2023 17:53

I’d check your DM’s will, if it leaves a right of occupation to her husband, these are usually worded to end if he cohabits with someone new. Have you asked him what his plans are?
be careful as if he doesn’t have enough means to support or house himself without your mum’s share, he may have a claim against her estate

Goodlard · 30/12/2023 17:50

You can look at the will
Online right now!

Why don't you?

I fear you're going to get unpleasantly surprised and he will have a life interest.

Your quote of "confessed" seems unnecessary, he's not done anything wrong

Before you judge him, walk a mile on his shoes?

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 17:43

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:22

You are still talking about your own situation!

He is fine! He is enjoying life in a new relationship - moving on in every way. Why are you so uncomfortable with it? There is no judgement just observation that he is not falling apart but getting on with his life, and op should be able to do the same. The last thing she needs to witness is a new woman moved into her mother’s house that is now mostly owned by the children. It’s cruel and unnecessary.

You are talking about no situation.

You are presuming a lot and using that as a basis. All you know is that he is dating.

Then deciding that dictates the situation around the house. It doesn’t.

Dating doesn’t mean you are over it someone’s death. Living your life doesn’t mean you are over it.

In the time since mum died, I travelled. I got promoted twice. I had a birthday party for my 40th. I went out on a Christmas party on the first anniversary of her death. I was coping and living. I was still devastated. 2 years after her death I am still devastated. In fact today is 2 years since her funeral and I went out for lunch and did some shopping.

But all that is beside the point. Non of it is connected to his legal or moral right to live in his home.

sparkellie · 30/12/2023 17:38

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:22

You are still talking about your own situation!

He is fine! He is enjoying life in a new relationship - moving on in every way. Why are you so uncomfortable with it? There is no judgement just observation that he is not falling apart but getting on with his life, and op should be able to do the same. The last thing she needs to witness is a new woman moved into her mother’s house that is now mostly owned by the children. It’s cruel and unnecessary.

No I'm not. I have said it doesn't matter if he is OK or not. It isn't a reason to kick him out of their house.
It wasn't OPs childhood home, it holds no special memories or meaning to her. It is purely financial, and a way of punishing him for getting a gf. Him living there does not in any way stop her from moving on.

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:22

sparkellie · 30/12/2023 17:13

Moving on does not mean someone isn't still grieving. And like I said, it doesn't matter. It is not a reason to try and get him out of the house that he owned with her mum. You are doing the same thing OP is. Saying it is OK to punish him for coping/moving on by trying to remove him from the house. I disagree with that.

You are still talking about your own situation!

He is fine! He is enjoying life in a new relationship - moving on in every way. Why are you so uncomfortable with it? There is no judgement just observation that he is not falling apart but getting on with his life, and op should be able to do the same. The last thing she needs to witness is a new woman moved into her mother’s house that is now mostly owned by the children. It’s cruel and unnecessary.

sparkellie · 30/12/2023 17:13

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:00

It is explicit from his decision to start a new relationship of ‘many months’ which could be a very long time already potentially, removing his ring and taken down the photos. I think most of us can be pretty certain he is most definitely ‘coping’ and getting through the days 😂

Moving on does not mean someone isn't still grieving. And like I said, it doesn't matter. It is not a reason to try and get him out of the house that he owned with her mum. You are doing the same thing OP is. Saying it is OK to punish him for coping/moving on by trying to remove him from the house. I disagree with that.

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 17:10

Newchapterbeckons · 30/12/2023 17:00

It is explicit from his decision to start a new relationship of ‘many months’ which could be a very long time already potentially, removing his ring and taken down the photos. I think most of us can be pretty certain he is most definitely ‘coping’ and getting through the days 😂

Getting through the days and coping is the bare minimum people do when grieving.

Do you expect them to dress in black and never leave the house to prove outwardly he is in an appropriate amount of grief? would that mean it was ok for him to stay?

I can imagine my mums sister judging my Dad like that after my mum died. He carried on living. They don’t like it. He is not even 70 and has a life to lead. His home is his home and he can take down or put up what he wants. I can’t imagine the will has ‘he can live there as long as he grieves in a way my children and MN think is appropriate’ 😂

CanImakethisbetter · 30/12/2023 17:04

He right (legally or morally) to live on the house is not connected to him having a girlfriend.

The Op linked them that’s all.

I don’t believe Op doesn’t know the situation in the will. That would mean someone (brother/executor) told op they had 40% portion of the house and she asked no questions and made no comments. No ‘ok so how does that work with Bob (made up name) living there’. No ‘how long does Bob get to live there’. No ‘what does that mean for Bob’ or even ‘what does that mean for us since Bob lives there’.

I think Op knows he has life time interest in the house and was just hoping she could persuade him to love of his own account. And has decided that since he is dating he must (morally) move out.

I think she knows her mother would have wanted him to stay there but just isn’t saying. It makes no sense to be so sure about what portion you have but no idea about any of the terms.

Swipe left for the next trending thread