Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Late mum's husband has new partner - still living in mum's home

542 replies

stepparentdilemma2023 · 29/12/2023 13:55

Hi all

Bit of a backstory, my mum remarried a new guy (stepfather - SF) in 2018. They subsequently bought a house together, which mum paid about 80% and him about 20% of, that same year.

Mum sadly was diagnosed with an aggressive form of breast cancer and died relatively quickly in May 2022. SF received a third of her pension in the will, which already raised eyebrows among me and my brother (mum's only children), but mum's investment into the house was protected, so we still own her share.

Since mum died, SF has continued living in the house, which has increased in value quite dramatically since 2018. He has had one of his adult children, who is a bit of a tearaway, living there on off (in life, the adult child was not allowed to stay at the house by my mum as he had been involved in drug debt and had had a brick put through the window of his own mother's house, as well as being briefly kidnapped (!!) to pay off the debt).

We have maintained generally cordial relations with SF, and had arranged via WhatsApp to see him this Christmas when my brother noticed his WhatsApp picture was a photo of him and a new woman. When we eventually did go for our Christmas meetup yesterday at the house, his wedding ring was off, several photographs of mum had been taken down, and he confessed he had been seeing a new woman for a number of months.

Brother is very disappointed as previously SF had gone on about how mum was his soulmate, he'd never love another, etc... only to enter a relationship with someone new in just over a year.

I'm not sure how I feel, because I was never as close to SF in the first place, but I do know I think my mum would've been quite upset at how quickly (in the grand scheme of things) this had all come about.

FWIW, the new woman lives independently to him (as far as we know), is apparently quite wealthy (he's landed on his feet again!) and has two children of her own.

AIBU to now think that if SF has moved on with his life to the extent he is comfortable enough to take off his wedding ring and meet a new woman, that it is time we take back the house and sell?

My brother is getting married in 2025 and could do with some funds for that, and I have had a couple of my own financial issues this year so am now at a stage where the money would be hugely beneficial.

Sorry it was a long one!

OP posts:
ReallyAgainReally · 29/12/2023 15:31

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:20

But legally true.

@stepparentdilemma2023 OP is very aggressive on this thread. Maybe signs OP is on shaky grounds legally?

Also, if OP had the child SF has, would she continue with the not welcome into the her house, after her partner dies, if the set-up was in this case? I doubt anyone would, as the house is 'practically' SF's until its provisions in the WILL have all been activated.

OP, the best way to look at your issues, is to put yourself in SF's shoes. That will answer all your dilemmas. Your other concerns about your 80% share can be sorted by keeping in touch with SF as you currently do- how hard is that for you to do? If I were you, I would start visiting at Xmas and Easter. You even have access to Face Timing with him, so you can ring him and keep him on whilst he moves around the house to check it's condition- in fact, say it brings you closer to mum seeing the inside of the house, so ask for regular FT. That and solicitors obv so you know where you stand and what you need to do now, if anything. Job sorted. Good luck- try to remove emotions as much as possible.

PropertyManager · 29/12/2023 15:30

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:23

Not true

Absolutely, complete rubbish, if he has a life interest, that is that, they have no right to the property until he dies, rent free.

Even if that is not true forcing a sale is also not easy, especially in a case like this where he will claim, rightly, that it's his home - the court would just as likely award him leave to remain for his lifetime.

He's not going to sell out to you either, his 20% is potentially his guarantee of a roof over his head for the forseeable, what he gets for 20% won't get him anything - so unless hes a mug, he will do nothing.

BrimfulOfMash · 29/12/2023 15:30

Frangipanyoul8r · 29/12/2023 15:26

I am unclear as to the exact set up of the will

Until you find this out in the new year, no one here can give you advice.

This .

Especially as being AIBU the thread is full of people who have no idea what they are talking about in legal terms.

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:29

LadyMary50 · 29/12/2023 15:27

It depends entirely on what the will states.No one can force a sale or charge rent in this situation.It takes seconds to download a will,why hasn’t op done this?

Quite.

BrimfulOfMash · 29/12/2023 15:29

Hairyfairy01 · 29/12/2023 14:45

I'm not sure it matters how much your mum or SF put into the house, they were married. Surely if one dies the house goes to the other?

Nope.

Not if they owned the house as 'Tenants In Common' with the mother's share of 8-% specified. She can then leave her share to whoever she likes.

Thehop · 29/12/2023 15:28

YANBU at all

hes had time to grieve and has now moved on so you're fine to talk to him

surely he either pays you and your brother 80% of what the rental would be or biys you out? If he can't do that then he has to sell and move out.

assuming your mums will doesn't give him leave to see out his days there?

LadyMary50 · 29/12/2023 15:27

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:23

Not true

It depends entirely on what the will states.No one can force a sale or charge rent in this situation.It takes seconds to download a will,why hasn’t op done this?

MeridianB · 29/12/2023 15:27

The specific provisions of the will are crucial here. Because your mum may have given him permission to continue to live in the house for the remainder of his life, a defined period or as long as he chooses which could prevent a sale.

So ask the solicitor to confirm this. If there’s nothing of this kind then I think you are well within your rights to raise the topic and ask him his plans. It’s been 18 months and he has started to move on with his life so the timing seems right.

Frangipanyoul8r · 29/12/2023 15:26

I am unclear as to the exact set up of the will

Until you find this out in the new year, no one here can give you advice.

LangMayYerLumReek2024 · 29/12/2023 15:26

Until you read the will you don't know anything for a fact.

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:23

Genevieva · 29/12/2023 14:55

You need level advice. Essentially, you and your brother can force a sale or he should be paying you rent at 80% of the market value.

Not true

LadyMary50 · 29/12/2023 15:22

LifeExperience · 29/12/2023 14:36

I would discuss having him buy you out. If SF can't afford it, the property will need to be sold. If your mother wanted SF to get the house, she would have willed it to him.
Instead she willed it to her children, meaning that she set up the situation where he would likely have to move when she passed. Follow her wishes.

You don’t know what is in the will,neither does the op it seems, although it’s easy enough to get a copy online.A similar scenario happened to a friend.Her father died when she was quite young her mother owned the house they lived in.Her mother eventually married again but the step father was never put on the deeds. Her mother died many years ago and her will stated that the stepfather had no financial claim on the house but could continue living in it until he died or decided to move out.Stepfather stayed in the house for 20yrs and let the house fall into disrepair,he did no maintenance in that time.I assume the ops mother made a similar will as I’m sure she wouldn’t have wanted her husband to be homeless..

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:20

stepparentdilemma2023 · 29/12/2023 14:46

Incredibly cold message. You seem unpleasant.

But legally true.

Whyisitalwaysraining1 · 29/12/2023 15:20

In terms of him moving on, I read a psychologist write once that this is the sign a relationship was healthy and parting as good as can be, that that person is emotionally healthy enough to have another relationship. I’d wish him well.

In terms of the house I’m interested that your mum’s 80% share is protected in her will - are you sure about this? Or did the will just say ‘her share’? When I was divorced the legal advice I received was that when you are married assets effectively become 50/50 regardless of who paid for what and when. This advice may have been wrong or not nuanced enough but i’m curious as it doesn’t sound right.

Regardless I’m also curious about the position with your stepfather as the same thing did happen to a friend of mine a few years back where her mum died and had said she wanted her assets to go to her daughter. But because the mum and stepfather were married and the property was in mother and stepfather’s names together, under uk law the property became entirely his when she died regardless of what the will said. When he sold it my mate didn’t get a penny, and she had legal advice at the time that this was totally legal and just tough luck.

Maybe you have had legal advice and my concerns are unfounded. But in any case I don’t think you can ask someone to sell their home that is legally partly theirs unfortunately. If someone did that to me i’d react very very badly x

LuluBlakey1 · 29/12/2023 15:18

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 29/12/2023 15:00

hmmmmm @LuluBlakey1 .

Try and understand the motivation; as the OP and her brother own 80% of an asset only SF is enjoying at the moment it's absolutely reasonable for them to explore options, which is what they are intending to do, respectfully and with tact.

OP, as it's quite a delicate situation I wouldn't make any approaches to SF without a solicitor's advice - and a back up plan in case he says he doesn't want to sell / buy you out / move.

That isn't my comment you have quoted.

The law is that the SF owns 20% of the house. It's his, it wasn't left to him. He has a right to live in it.

His late wife may have (OP has not been clear what the will says) said he can live in her 80% until his death or re-marriage- she can not restrict him seeing a new person. It would be almost impossible to force him to sell if he does not wish to- he bought and owns 20% of the house. It is extremely unlikely a judge would force a sale and even then he could appeal it. OP needs to know all costs will come from the estate as it is the beneficiaries who would be pushing this.

They are free to sell their 80%. They will find it impossible to find a buyer.

Depending on the wording of the will (which OP has not been clear about) His late wife may or may not have said he can remain rent free in the property. They may be able to charge him rent if they wish. It is more likely she said 'rent-free' .

They need to see a specialist solicitor- it is a complex area. Their best bet may be mediation- if he will agree- and the outcome is likely to be he will be offered more than 20% as compensation for agreeing the sale eg 33%. At the moment he appears to have a legal, lifetime, rent-free, interest in an attractive home. Why should he give that up?

Iwasafool · 29/12/2023 15:17

Solongtoshort · 29/12/2023 14:05

When my friend died in Feb 2021 her husband of 30 years moved on within 6 months and got married in March this year.I felt betrayal for her and their 7 children.

l was talking about a similar situation with friends the other week and apparently the happier the marriage the faster man move on, there’s been a study about it.

l know that doesn’t give an answer to your question sorry.

I think this is very true but I don't think it just applies to men. My mother was remarried within a year of my father's death. She loved him deeply and even as a child I could see she was trying to recreate that. Unfortunately she picked the wrong man but that is another story.

ReallyAgainReally · 29/12/2023 15:16

Testina · 29/12/2023 15:11

@ReallyAgainReally “Finally, any judge will stick with SF (60/40) so you and DB's odds are lower IF you don't handle this correctly.”

Where are you getting 60/40 from?
Judges don’t get to make up percentages.

odds 60 to 40 in SF favour. None is making up numbers. Can you not read?

They will always get their 80% back as per the will (i.e with or without IHT on the 80%, again as per the will).

Only the WILL OR calm heads from Op and DB will sort this in case the will is shortcoming or in more in favour of SF. OP is not showing any clam head so far. Hopefully a good solicitor can assist her in accepting the reality- whatever the Will say or its likely interpretation by the courts, if required. We cannot. But we cannot fail to see OP's attitude to SF hence the majority of us are advising her to tread very very carefully there.

MyBlueDiary · 29/12/2023 15:16

You can apply for a copy of the will here https://probatesearch.service.gov.uk/#wills I would do this and make sure you understand what the set up is before doing anything.

I think people have given you a hard time here unfairly because of the linking of his new relationship and selling the house. In fact, it sounds as if you have good financial reasons to want to sell and have been holding off out of respect. But that can't carry on forever.

Once you know the exact arrangements in the will, you'll be better placed to start a conversation about it. As PP said, it's important not to link any of it to his new relationship or what your mum might have felt about it- that's irrelevant and might sour discussions. You really need him on side as he's resident there and could make it practically impossible to sell. One option might be to offer to sell to him at a small discount.

Search probate records for documents and wills (England and Wales)

https://probatesearch.service.gov.uk/#wills

DiddyHeck · 29/12/2023 15:15

I find it incredible, and unbelievable, that a beneficiary to a will doesn't know the contents of the will.

Me too.

Whataretheodds · 29/12/2023 15:15

LlynTegid · 29/12/2023 13:59

To ask someone to leave the house and presumably live with the new woman in his life after what could be just a year seems a harsh thing to do.

It's been 5 years and he is in a new relationship.

@stepparentdilemma2023 totally reasonable for you to raise selling the house if you need to release funds. Sounds as though he will have a nice profit on the 20% since 2018. Better to get it sorted while he is able to move.

ReallyAgainReally · 29/12/2023 15:14

LoopyLooooo · 29/12/2023 15:08

OP, why don't you or your brother have any clue whether your SD has a life long interest or not?

How long ago was the will read?

This is easy to answer. It was all triggered by 'new partner' in the pic as OP 'knows' clearly mum would be disappointed. Most loving people are HAPPY the other got someone else so soon after their untimely death. Only kids with one thing on their mind, (money), mind. Squire that one.

Testina · 29/12/2023 15:11

@ReallyAgainReally “Finally, any judge will stick with SF (60/40) so you and DB's odds are lower IF you don't handle this correctly.”

Where are you getting 60/40 from?
Judges don’t get to make up percentages.

WhistPie · 29/12/2023 15:11

I find it incredible, and unbelievable, that a beneficiary to a will doesn't know the contents of the will. It's the executors duty to inform beneficiaries, and to keep details of disbursements. I can only assume that probate has either not been gone through or that it has and it's within the 12 months after that, meaning the estate has not been distributed

jeaux90 · 29/12/2023 15:10

You seem reticent about actually checking the will.

It's likely that he allowed to live there until death or unless he remarried.

Cyclebabble · 29/12/2023 15:10

When my mum died, my dad was in a new relationship within a year. I did not like it one bit to be frank. Not helped by the fact that the women he met had the same name as my mum did. It is difficult to put into words how it made me feel, but in essence I felt like I was still grieving and he was not. He was at the shiny and new stage of a new relationship.

Yet rationally I know that the problem here was mine, not his. I would rather see my DD happy than the alternative which was to crumble away, which I have seen people do when they loose a long term partner. I made a special effort to make his new partner welcome and they had 15 years of a good life together.

In terms of the house and your SD, this depends on the will. Does he have a life interest in the property, i.e. is he allowed to use it for the rest of his lifetime? If not then I think there needs to a discussion on a timescale to move out. I would suggest roughly 12 months to find somewhere new and release the property for you and your brother. I think this is generous and reflects your mother's clear wishes- that you and your brother had access to funds when you need them, which is now.