Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is elitist?

62 replies

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 08:44

State secondary school, year 7&8 currently has sets 1-5 for all classes (DD isn’t with her form group for any lessons and every class is different children).
Letter just before half term advised from next week when they return all the classes will be moved around and they will have a new timetable. Going forward, set 1 will be based on ability and be the highest achieving standard. Then classes 2-5 will now be mixed ability, there will be no ability setting within these groups.
Now I know there are lots of arguments for or against ability setting, but surely it’s one or the other. Why should the set 1 children get taught with like minded children but a child who just missed out on set 1 not, or a child who is really struggling academically now has to listen to a child who just missed out on set 1 know all the answers every week.
It feels totally elitist to me, but interested in hearing other peoples opinions.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 29/12/2023 10:42

They're trying to give the best option to as many children as possible.
Most able children tend to do better with setting. Middle attaining and lower attaining children tend to do better in mixed ability classes.

By removing the top group, the mixed ability class doesn't have the same outliers so the teacher can focus on the smaller attainment range.

I don't mind teaching sets or mixed ability, but find that true mixed ability is very difficult if you're trying to extend your grade 9 students with A Level content at the same time as making sure the lower attaining student know what's happened in the chapter you've just read. It can be done, but it's difficult and I know of colleagues who've taught to the middle with a couple of extension activities.

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 10:40

Mumofteenandtween · 29/12/2023 08:51

If I remember correct (and it was years ago I read this but I’m freakishly good at numbers) the research says that the top 10% of kids do best with setting. For those who are from 10% to 33% then setting has no impact. For those who are not in the top third, they do better with mixed ability.

So they are trying to give everyone their “best option”.

However, you have spotted the fallacy with the method.

That the kids who are from 20% to 28% are the new “top 10%” in the mixed ability group and so are losing out.

I guess that you could argue that this is the best option though as now only 8% of the year are losing out rather than 10% (if they went completely mixed ability) or 67% (if they stuck with setting).

This is an interesting theory. Will look at this more, thanks.

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 10:38

Benibidibici · 29/12/2023 09:49

Im not surprised at the school doing this but its unusual to communicate it so openly. Most schools these days favour an approach of leaving you guessing what set your child is in and only communicate progress rather than relative achievement against peers.

I assume because the children know they are setted currently that if they suddenly changed for class X2 next week to X5, they and parents will think they have moved from set 2 to set 5

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 10:35

Well yes I would if it was the same set up. DD plays in Div 5 at football, her best friend plays in Div 1. If the league suddenly said, Div 1 will remain but we’re mixing up Div 2-5 then yeah, I’d be upset, she’s playing at her right ability in Div, I wouldn’t suddenly wish for her to be playing again Div 2 every week. That’s how she gets demotivated and quits.

She used to dance, she was good enough to be invited to join the comp team. Of that team 2/3 from each age group were invited to compete in Championships, she wasn’t at that level, I wouldn’t wish for her to go and never ever get placed or look out of place every single week.

edit - this should have quoted @WickDittington ’s post

OP posts:
Benibidibici · 29/12/2023 09:49

Im not surprised at the school doing this but its unusual to communicate it so openly. Most schools these days favour an approach of leaving you guessing what set your child is in and only communicate progress rather than relative achievement against peers.

autienotnaughty · 29/12/2023 09:14

Academically it's-

Great for the top set
Good for the bottom set as they have stronger pupils to pull them up/learn from. Plus a mix of students some who may be more willing to learn
Rubbish for second set as they will be pulled down
Difficult for the teachers teaching mixed abilities

Socially it creates a divide that would see the top set as superior. Unless you go to a school like the one I did where education is not valued in which case the top set would instantly become targets

WickDittington · 29/12/2023 09:07

Tall poppy syndrome - why is it always academic achievement that’s seen as elitist? Would you say the same about sport?

SutWytTi · 29/12/2023 09:00

It is fine. Focus on your child, if they are engaged, well taught and not subject to bad behaviour from others it'll be fine.

I would judge it after a year.

HawaiiWake · 29/12/2023 08:57

The concern is once it is set there will be no movement between the top sets and others. Also, types of teachers they will get. There is the potential for bias to be set. We see this happening in primary schools where parents can be very sharp elbow. Kids in top sets not move whilst others that have caught up have no chance to stretch or be expose to harder questions.

Mumofteenandtween · 29/12/2023 08:51

If I remember correct (and it was years ago I read this but I’m freakishly good at numbers) the research says that the top 10% of kids do best with setting. For those who are from 10% to 33% then setting has no impact. For those who are not in the top third, they do better with mixed ability.

So they are trying to give everyone their “best option”.

However, you have spotted the fallacy with the method.

That the kids who are from 20% to 28% are the new “top 10%” in the mixed ability group and so are losing out.

I guess that you could argue that this is the best option though as now only 8% of the year are losing out rather than 10% (if they went completely mixed ability) or 67% (if they stuck with setting).

Jf20 · 29/12/2023 08:50

Because groups 2-5 will be all close in range. No it’s not elitist. Some kids need to go faster than the others, the rest will still be taught, but once you get past the top group it is really mixed in terms of ability.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 29/12/2023 08:48

Is it not a reflection of the actual abilities of the children? There's a stand out group who will benefit from being taught - and stretched - together. It's more difficult for the teachers when there are mixed abilities.