Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is elitist?

62 replies

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 08:44

State secondary school, year 7&8 currently has sets 1-5 for all classes (DD isn’t with her form group for any lessons and every class is different children).
Letter just before half term advised from next week when they return all the classes will be moved around and they will have a new timetable. Going forward, set 1 will be based on ability and be the highest achieving standard. Then classes 2-5 will now be mixed ability, there will be no ability setting within these groups.
Now I know there are lots of arguments for or against ability setting, but surely it’s one or the other. Why should the set 1 children get taught with like minded children but a child who just missed out on set 1 not, or a child who is really struggling academically now has to listen to a child who just missed out on set 1 know all the answers every week.
It feels totally elitist to me, but interested in hearing other peoples opinions.

OP posts:
Tooshytoshine · 29/12/2023 13:21

All sets are mixed ability to some extent.

In my experience set 3 out of 7 is the hardest set to teach properly as in this set you have an odd mixture of bright but poorly behaved kids (who probably could be in the top two sets but would cause a disturbance) and kids who sit around the average but try hard or are very quiet. It can be like teaching two distinct classes at once.

Sets aren't a science at all and most kids are predicted sixes at GCSE but some of those will get sevens or eights and some fours or fives as their ability/behaviour can develop, plateau or deteriorate. But all the sixes would be in a set together as who can predict the future.

The classes the school has formed will not be random but will be carefully thought about in terms of dominant personalities, behaviour management and different abilities. They just won't have been set solely in terms of ability.

Having an absolute bottom set that is formed for a purpose other than SEND is brutal for the teacher and soul destroying for the kids as it predetermined their outcomes.

TheaBrandt · 29/12/2023 13:16

The middle aren’t being “over looked” they are being taught to their level. It’s shit being in a class full of people who are more able and you struggle to keep up happened to me with maths (my weakest subject) when the middle sets were full.

Dds school ruthlessly sets in everything. I think it’s great. The pupils take it in their stride there’s no judgement from them and there is a lot of movement between the sets. Dd2 was sad to be put up a maths set as the teacher of the upper middle set was better and really nice. Her two best friends just been moved down from her top English set.

Betwixpotter · 29/12/2023 13:10

It's better for everyone but the top of the second set, which works out best overall for the majority of the students (and the schools results!) they get to push 1/5th to get high grades, and the other 4 sets should get majority passes as the bottom is pulled up by mixed streaming.

Mischance · 29/12/2023 13:07

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 12:13

But is it, or is it teaching the highest and lowest ability children to their ability and the average middle ground child just plods along having the best of no worlds?

The average middle child can be taught according to their ability - it does not have to be "plodding" with the best of neither worlds - maybe this is their appropriate level where they can thrive and learn.

5thCommandment · 29/12/2023 13:04

Why is this even an issue? Sets are good. The top students should be pushed and you can't do that in a mixed set. The middle and lower sets then get more help which gives pupils the chance to get better and move up. I was in set 4 and moved to set 2 over the years, you want to do better than your mates as well.

This country is so soft it's ridiculous - have some competition, aspire to be better.

It's like "everyone's a winner". No they're bloody not. 1st, 2nd, 3rd. Done. Aspire to do your best - as long as you beat your last score you are improving, if everyone wins, no one does, and that's the same with sets. Push aspiration and learning for success not the alternative weak woke nonsense.

LolaSmiles · 29/12/2023 12:59

But is it, or is it teaching the highest and lowest ability children to their ability and the average middle ground child just plods along having the best of no worlds?
It's teaching the higher attaining pupils in an environment that is appropriate for the additional challenge they need, it's teaching the middle attaining children to their ability and because the ability range is narrower with the top set removed, there's space to provide appropriate support for lower attaining students.

Schools generally will group their students based on their knowledge of their cohorts and curriculum.

What your child's school has done would work brilliantly in one school I worked in, but wouldn't work for another I worked in because the cohorts were very different. Some schools I've worked in have had a separate stream for those students who need a different offer. Those classes are much smaller than a typical bottom set. It worked well in those schools. It wouldn't necessarily be right in all schools.

JMSA · 29/12/2023 12:47

I work in a secondary school, with the most challenging children we have there.
This is not a good move. Not at all. Traditionally, bottom sets have always been kept very small, due to behaviour and the amount of input needed from the teacher.
I'm guessing this will no longer be possible.
Only the top set benefits in this situation.

Theimpossiblegirl · 29/12/2023 12:38

I'd want to know if all sets have equal access to qualified teachers, preferably specialists. So many schools are struggling to recruit as the DfE fails to meet target after target. This is what you should be asking.

CuriousGeorge80 · 29/12/2023 12:20

When I did GCSEs we were mostly taught in sets for Y10 and 11 but for a few subjects it was mixed due to student numbers. The mixed sets were horrific. As an able student I learned next to nothing. My mum basically taught me history GSCE. I would never send my child to a secondary school that didn’t set as a result of my experiences. I am sure it can be done well, and I don’t doubt it benefits some if so. But not in my experience

Peasand · 29/12/2023 12:15

I think they should all be in sets, for the best outcomes. I’m an ex teacher and mixed ability is a hellscape.

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 12:13

Mischance · 29/12/2023 11:30

Elitism does not come into this at all - it is about teaching each child appropriately to their ability.

But is it, or is it teaching the highest and lowest ability children to their ability and the average middle ground child just plods along having the best of no worlds?

OP posts:
SomethingBetterChange · 29/12/2023 11:45

theduchessofspork · 29/12/2023 11:30

It seems odd to me and not in your child’s interests if they are in the top third but not in the top 10%

I suspect it’s because it gives them a grammar school stream, guaranteed to get great resents, and then less timetable hassle for the rest.

I can see that PPs say there is research to support it, but I am instinctively doubtful about it, especially because of the disruptive caused by lower ability kids in the classroom (not because they are bad, but because they are bored).

Speak to any teacher and they will tell you that the higher attaining children can be just as disruptive as the lower attaining ones.

Your focus is with the ones who haven't got it yet. The ones who got it straight away and complete the work easily become bored.

They might find it easier and complete it more quickly but in order for them to be appropriately challenged, they need teacher input too. And, when they don't get it, they mess around.

A lot of it is to do with the pace of the lesson - particularly in maths.

willWillSmithsmith · 29/12/2023 11:43

When I was at school we had a top, middle and bottom set. Initially I was put in the middle set then a year later ‘promoted’ to the top set. The abilities (and behaviour) of the middle set and bottom set were not compatible, there was quite a gulf so I can understand your view that this is not fair. There really should be some middle ground.

OhNoOhNo · 29/12/2023 11:42

As a working class child under the poverty line who went to what is now an academy that was always requiring improvement, I’m happy I was in the top set. It gave me the confidence to keep achieving.

SomethingBetterChange · 29/12/2023 11:37

OP, I'm a primary teacher in UKS2 and we do something similar.

There's no perfect solution when you have 32 children in a class with a huge range of abilities and attainment levels but this approach works pretty well tbh.

The very highest attaining children benefit from working like this because they pick things up very quickly; grasp concepts more easily; and are able to apply them more readily. As a pp said, they do become bored and it's hard to challenge them appropriately if you are busy explaining the basics in 101 different ways when they'd understood it almost before you'd finished teaching it the first time. They get to collaborate with children whose thinking is on the same level as theirs and develop the deeper understanding that they are ready for.

Presumably, there would be a separate group for the working below keystage children who maybe aren't accessing the curriculum at all?

The rest benefit from the collaborative working working in a mixed ability group offers. Eg the ones who get it more easily consolidate their understanding and learning by discussing concepts and explaining them to children who haven't quite got it yet. And the ones who haven't quite got it yet equally benefit from exploring it with a peer.

There's a big focus on metacognition at the moment. Being able to discuss what they are doing facilitates this.

Sometimes the highest attaining children find this hardest because they don't know how they know the answer, they just 'know' it and this can be a focus.

The lower children in the mixed groups get exposed to thinking that is higher than they are currently doing which benefits them, the more able children in the mixed group benefit from explaining.

And, again, as a pp said, there isn't much difference in the others. The very highest and the very lowest attaining need a different approach the rest, teachers can pitch it to the middle fir the mixed ability groups and better meet their needs.

theduchessofspork · 29/12/2023 11:31

Benibidibici · 29/12/2023 09:49

Im not surprised at the school doing this but its unusual to communicate it so openly. Most schools these days favour an approach of leaving you guessing what set your child is in and only communicate progress rather than relative achievement against peers.

Kids aren’t thick! They will work it out pretty quickly

theduchessofspork · 29/12/2023 11:30

It seems odd to me and not in your child’s interests if they are in the top third but not in the top 10%

I suspect it’s because it gives them a grammar school stream, guaranteed to get great resents, and then less timetable hassle for the rest.

I can see that PPs say there is research to support it, but I am instinctively doubtful about it, especially because of the disruptive caused by lower ability kids in the classroom (not because they are bad, but because they are bored).

Mischance · 29/12/2023 11:30

Elitism does not come into this at all - it is about teaching each child appropriately to their ability.

Mischance · 29/12/2023 11:29

I am puzzled by the mixed setting below set one.

My GS is in the bottom set for maths and is perfectly happy with this - as he said "It is the right place for me." He gets set work that is at his standard, as do those in the other graded sets. He would not want to be in a set with "set one just misses" as he would struggle.

The nature of the setting is open and transparent and he and his parents are entirely happy with this.

TigerRag · 29/12/2023 11:26

We had this for GCSE Science and I think English. I used to get so bored in science because it was too easy. And then we had a supply teacher who couldn't teach

ladyvimes · 29/12/2023 11:23

Research shows this is this most effective way to teach children as mixed abilty improves results for all except the most able. Pretty common approach nowadays.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 29/12/2023 11:21

The dds school have a kind of similar set up.
top set are on their own. Then there’s 3 mixed ability but “higher” sets and 3 mixed ability but “lower” sets. Then there’s the extra help set for those needing to go at a slower pace. This is only for maths and english, also science in y7 -9 but in y10 & 11 science is different due to some doing triple and others double (purely a choice, it’s not based on ability at their school). So there are higher and lower sets for both double and triple. All other subjects are fully mixed ability.

as far as I can see it’s works fine and the schools results are good. Both my dds have always been in the top sets though so don’t know first hand how the kids find it for sure, but it doesn’t seem to be an issue.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/12/2023 11:19

There's also classroom behaviour to take into account.

You might assume that I mean the lower ability kids, but I don't; a bored, high ability kid or two in a class can be an absolute nightmare.

I know I was, as once I'd finished everything, done the extension work, helped everybody around me, drawn multiple cartoons in my exercise books and slumped in almost physical pain at the unfortunates struggling to read aloud and knew that whatever else happened, I'd be fine academically, there's only finding new and exciting ways to wind up the teacher (correcting spelling and grammar was one of my regular ones), arguing/debating about what they were teaching, taking them off on tangents, tapping, making excuses to get up or leave and generally making their lives a misery for the remaining 45 minutes of a 1 hour lesson.

FawnFrenchieMum · 29/12/2023 11:05

KnickerlessParsons · 29/12/2023 11:00

This.

Or Music, or Drama, or any of the arts.

Kids at the bottom academically get extra help, so why not the kids at the top?
These are the people who will become high earners and pay lots of taxes. They will become the doctors, nurses, engineers, lawyers etc that this country needs more of to succeed as a country. The school will target them, but Ofsted will ensure it also targets the least able kids to help them be the best they can be too.

I’ve responded above about my thoughts on sports so yes I would think the same.

Based on your post it will be the middle / average children that are over looked. Not the top performing or least able.

OP posts:
KnickerlessParsons · 29/12/2023 11:00

WickDittington · 29/12/2023 09:07

Tall poppy syndrome - why is it always academic achievement that’s seen as elitist? Would you say the same about sport?

This.

Or Music, or Drama, or any of the arts.

Kids at the bottom academically get extra help, so why not the kids at the top?
These are the people who will become high earners and pay lots of taxes. They will become the doctors, nurses, engineers, lawyers etc that this country needs more of to succeed as a country. The school will target them, but Ofsted will ensure it also targets the least able kids to help them be the best they can be too.