Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a faraday box?

136 replies

stopmefeelingsick · 29/12/2023 06:44

For my car keys to protect them from thieves intercepting the signal and stealing my new car?

I don't really want one (would look a little out of place by the door and we're on a frugal living push so avoiding unnecessary expense) but it would be interesting to know if other people use them and just how widespread this type of car theft is?

OP posts:
ReindeerRider · 29/12/2023 11:06

This is likely a silly question but how to the thieves continue to use the car? Looking at the video posted up thread they used an ariel to first unlock the car then again to start the engine. Then they drove off. What happens next though? The keys are with the owner in the house as nothing taken just the signal intercepted. So how does the thief stop and start the car again with no keys?

Findingmypurposeinlife · 29/12/2023 10:59

Use a steering wheel lock as a visual deterrent

TreadLightly3 · 29/12/2023 10:55

A lot of people don’t realise you can actually switch your key off for some makes so it’s no longer sending signals that could be intercepted and you don’t need a box/pouch.

For example Mercedes - you double click the button to lock the car and a red light blinks on the key to show it’s off. See manual for details.

Take the switched off key to the car and you’ll see it doesn’t work at all. Or if you really need convincing, open the car again with your spare key and take the switched off key into the car and try to start the engine (make sure the spare key is back in the house). The car will say “no key detected “.

Becomes second nature to double click and no ugly box needed!

Dbank · 29/12/2023 10:53

I can't see how a faraday cage would degrade, but it's easy enough to test its effectiveness, i.e put the keys in it, stand next to the car and try an open it.

Also worth being aware many key fobs now automatically sleep when they haven't moved for a couple of minutes making faraday cages completely redundant. I believe all Mercedes keys sleep after 2018, but worth checking with your dealer etc.

You can often turn the keys off as well, usually by holding a button down for a few seconds. Always a good idea for spare keys anyway.

I've gone back to using a steering lock, I thought those days were long gone...

MadeOfAllWork · 29/12/2023 10:53

I don’t understand how people are saying that the pouches stop working. There is nothing to fail. It’s literally just anything that’s completely metal surrounding it.

As an aside I’m getting a new car that doesn’t have this problem as it’s got a card like a hotel key card. The thing with keyless entry is that the key is powered and is sending out a signal. The thieves use a device to find the signal. They then use that to open the car.
You need to block the signal being sent from the key. To do that you put it inside something metal.

AIstolemylunch · 29/12/2023 10:50

The key pouches are lined with a metal mesh, not metal lined, so that they are still maleable and you can put your keys in and out easily. Presumably the mesh can tear or break down or get large holes in it over time with use that stops it being as effective. I don't know what the boxes are made of but metal lined would be heavy and mines isnt so perhaps they are metal mesh lined too and can degrade.

Guineapig123 · 29/12/2023 10:49

This type of theft is extremely common where I live. We have a pouch and then I put that in a tin or in the microwave as the pouches are not fail safe and do degrade over time with the opening and closing. I will buy a box at some point but can’t be bothered at the moment and I have loads of tins!

Nonimai · 29/12/2023 10:48

10 years ago I had the contents of my car, (2 suitcases, 1 over night bag and most painfully my iPad) stolen at a motorway service station by some scrote who must’ve jammed our locking signal. The police don’t care. If there is an easy fix to avoid any theft I would do it.

Pudmyboy · 29/12/2023 10:39

@CrapBucket I came on to ask the same thing! There is nothing to wear out, so Howell do they stop working? Unless they have cheap foil type linings which tear easily (thinking of the pouches)?

Beachhutgirl · 29/12/2023 10:39

I love my Faraday box, I used to lose my. keys constantly, but now I always know where I put them. (Misses point of thread)

christmaspawpaws · 29/12/2023 10:38

Switch off keyless entry
Ghost immobiliser
If it's a Land Rover 2018 onwards there's a security update for them

InTheRainOnATrain · 29/12/2023 10:37

NormalForNuneaton · 29/12/2023 10:18

I wish I hadnt read this thread now.

We don't have this sort of car but our neighbours do. However, because of the way parking is there's no way of telling which house the Range Rover belongs to. I'm now thinking that thieves could break in to our house for keys that we obviously don't have!

I'm not sure that they'd be palmed off with our Seat keys!

Purely an anecdotal observation but I think it’s area dependent. Our street is densely packed terraces and all cars parked bumper to bumper on the street so you’d have no way of knowing if the range rover belongs to the house it’s parked in front of or 10 doors down. I’ve literally never heard of a home break in car theft but the relay theft happens all the time. I did hear in the range rover service dept of a guy whose car was lifted off onto one of those tow trucks like the council have to move cars parked in suspended areas because yes if they really want the car they’ll find a way whether you have a faraday box, ghost immobiliser, disklock etc etc but breaking into houses would attract a lot of attention and would be unlikely to yield success so presumably that’s why it doesn’t really happen here. So if your area is similar I really wouldn’t worry.

CrapBucket · 29/12/2023 10:36

How does a faraday cage/pouch ‘stop working’- surely metal lined is metal lined?

Is it that the pouches are flexible and so the inner metal lining gets cracked? so a biscuit tin is fine indefinitely?

miserablecat · 29/12/2023 10:34

AIstolemylunch · 29/12/2023 10:23

I really don't think they need to break in anymore, all the many thefts that have been done round here (lots of owners post the camera footage on FB) they seem to do it all from the drive.

Yes, I'm pretty sure most thefts near us are done within seconds on the drive, lots of people on local pages report their cars being stolen, but I'm pretty sure most don't involve breaking into the house.
It would be quicker, easier and probably a lot less likely to be caught if you don't have to enter a house

Polis · 29/12/2023 10:33

Fairly sure that claim about contactless cards is bollocks

I watched some tests on a TV programme and it was disproved. The reader has to be very close to the card and I seem to remember that if there were several cards stacked together, it can’t read any of them.

Missingmyusername · 29/12/2023 10:30

stopmefeelingsick · 29/12/2023 06:52

I've never had an expensive car before (usually my car was a heap of junk that nobody would steal!) so it's not crossed my mind before. I was just wondering if this intercepting key signals was really a thing or just something you occasionally hear about

No it’s happened to me.
Stole money from
inside the car and threw all belongings out in the gutter or around the car. Didn’t take the car.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 29/12/2023 10:28

Nannyfannybanny · 29/12/2023 08:43

If you're really short of money, just stick the in the microwave, assuming you have one. Yes,of course it's a Faraday cage,to keep the "microwaves" in. I have a Faraday cage wallet. Have had it for years, because when bank cards went contactless,thief's were "reading the cards" from quite a distance away.ie on the tube.

Fairly sure that claim about contactless cards is bollocks. They don’t work in the same way as keyless cars.

HideTheCroissants · 29/12/2023 10:27

OP you don’t need something specifically sold as a faraday box. I have a smallish metal biscuit tin. We put our car keys and a small amount if cash so we always have some for the window cleaner etc. The box is on a shelf in the centre of the house so equidistant from all windows and doors.
If your car opens by proximity to the key rather than having to push a button on it you can check the box is working by getting close to the car and trying to open it. My little box works very well I can stand holding the box right next to the car but can’t open it.

AIstolemylunch · 29/12/2023 10:23

I really don't think they need to break in anymore, all the many thefts that have been done round here (lots of owners post the camera footage on FB) they seem to do it all from the drive.

NormalForNuneaton · 29/12/2023 10:18

I wish I hadnt read this thread now.

We don't have this sort of car but our neighbours do. However, because of the way parking is there's no way of telling which house the Range Rover belongs to. I'm now thinking that thieves could break in to our house for keys that we obviously don't have!

I'm not sure that they'd be palmed off with our Seat keys!

Polis · 29/12/2023 10:16

We just use an old biscuit tin.

BooBooBaloo · 29/12/2023 10:11

We have two keyless cars and keep the fobs in a faraday box. It just looks like a box on the side

Spare keys are kept in pouches and hidden away

Utini · 29/12/2023 10:10

Lifestooshort71 · 29/12/2023 07:49

Brain fog here, how do I test my Faraday pouch still works? (Be gentle, feeling rough 😕)

@Lifestooshort71 try using the key while it's in the pouch, if the keyless entry / start works then the pouch is not working.

Hope you're feeling better soon.

HamstersAreMyLife · 29/12/2023 10:07

This thread has been enlightening! Feeling relieved I swaped my lovely Merc for a VW family estate earlier in this year as they seem to be less popular. Hadn't appreciated the Faraday pouches could deteriorate, will test ours and my dad's. Will also look into keyring pouches so thanks for the tips.