Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a faraday box?

136 replies

stopmefeelingsick · 29/12/2023 06:44

For my car keys to protect them from thieves intercepting the signal and stealing my new car?

I don't really want one (would look a little out of place by the door and we're on a frugal living push so avoiding unnecessary expense) but it would be interesting to know if other people use them and just how widespread this type of car theft is?

OP posts:
JingleSnowmanTree · 29/12/2023 13:17

BlueMongoose · 29/12/2023 11:56

The police round here have been handing them out for free.

@BlueMongoose

im less surprised they're being given away, than I am that you actually see police in the flesh. We used to have a station in the village, nearest one now is mikes & mikes away, and it shows!!

CroccyWoccy · 29/12/2023 12:42

OneTC · 29/12/2023 11:41

Can you still buy nice cars with a physical key?

Seems bonkers that manufacturers are making them less secure and not footing the responsibility if they get stolen with an easy hack. When the banks opted to make debit cards less secure they at least agreed to take the hit

Yeah it really defeats the object that for the “convenience” of keyless entry to my car I now have to retrieve my key from an inconvenient location in the house and fanny about with a steering lock every time I want to use the car. What wonderful progress!

JingleSnowmanTree · 29/12/2023 12:41

EmmaEmerald · 29/12/2023 11:28

Using what's left of my brain cells....she's not keyless?

I'm guessing you can drive a bit without the keys in the car - enough to get it towed.

You do need a Faraday cage, I think.

I hate all this stuff. I no longer drive but was using an ugly steering wheel lock and a pouch.

Regular keys were so much easier!

@EmmaEmerald thank you for replying.

she was sold to me as 'keyless', as in I don't need to put a key in a hole in the door, just press a button. I wouldn't be without the facility! (I'm always carrying too much!!)

but she's not 'keyless' as in opens if the key fob is near her.

🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't know how far I could drive? I just assumed as far as the petrol would take me, but I wouldn't be able to start her again if I stopped.

I thought I didn't as she doesn't open without pressing buttons in the fob???

anniegun · 29/12/2023 12:17

Get a good one. If you put a mobile in it and it rings when you call it the bag/box is not secure enough

longtompot · 29/12/2023 12:12

We have these and are small enough to have in my handbag or my dhs pocket
Faraday pouch for car keys
My dh also bought a wheel lock as a deterrent. We know these things won't prevent it being stolen but it might slow them down enough.

Dh also has put in a tracker which he gets text updates on. You can set what you want alerts for, we just have for when the engine is started. It's free, just sues a phone sim which he got a cheap top up for every few months or so.

uclpp · 29/12/2023 11:59

SausageCasseroles · 29/12/2023 09:37

Wow seems a lot of work for a nicer car... almost better to stick to a normal one!

I agree with this.

Definitely better not to own a Range Rover, Mercedes etc.

i remember a burglar breaking into our house when i was about 12. I’ve never really wanted to own much since.

BlueMongoose · 29/12/2023 11:56

The police round here have been handing them out for free.

Pluviophile1 · 29/12/2023 11:56

stopmefeelingsick · 29/12/2023 07:08

Ah, okay. This type of car theft really is a thing then! You're right, a £15 expense to potentially save a £50k car is worth it. I'm just on a massive decluttering drive and we've spent the last year scrimping to pay for the car (it's electric so saving us £600 a month in costs as my husband is a high mileage driver!)

I'll look into the pouches too. At the moment the key is in a bowl by the front door and the spare is in a drawer upstairs (but by the window overlooking the drive!)

I guess I feel lulled into a false sense of security as we live in a tiny village with virtually no crime. My daft neighbour often leaves his car unlocked on the driveway and even went on holiday and didn't bother locking the house!

Thanks everyone! Off to peruse faraday boxes on Amazon now!

I live in a small village with hardly any crime. Someone from here posted a video on the local FB group of a couple of days ago showing some would-be thieves scanning the front of the house, trying to find the signal for his car fob, whilst their mates tried the car doors. They didn't succeed in taking it (the key fob was in a pouch away from the doors).

Secure your keys!

CrapBucket · 29/12/2023 11:53

I am the sort of forgetful person that would 100% microwave my keys if that’s where I kept them. Probably more than once. I think that’s the worst advice I’ve ever seen on here for me personally.

Teaandtoast456 · 29/12/2023 11:48

A microwave is basically a faraday cage. Test it with your phone because they’re sometimes a bit leaky, and obviously don’t microwave your keys.

ReindeerRider · 29/12/2023 11:45

christmaspawpaws · 29/12/2023 11:09

It'll usually end up being shipped off somewhere else in a storage container

Once they arrive though how are they removed from the container and used? Can they make duplicate keys? Or like reset the program on the car? Are they just used for scrap?

EmmaEmerald · 29/12/2023 11:45

@OneTC oh I didn't know the banks did that.

@RiverCartwright the fob is still hackable, so they'll disrupt the sleep mode

you are right to use a pouch.

bloody tech. So sick of it and I don't drive any more. If I start again, I'm guessing a non tech key system no longer exists.

OneTC · 29/12/2023 11:41

Can you still buy nice cars with a physical key?

Seems bonkers that manufacturers are making them less secure and not footing the responsibility if they get stolen with an easy hack. When the banks opted to make debit cards less secure they at least agreed to take the hit

RiverCartwright · 29/12/2023 11:39

TreadLightly3 · 29/12/2023 10:55

A lot of people don’t realise you can actually switch your key off for some makes so it’s no longer sending signals that could be intercepted and you don’t need a box/pouch.

For example Mercedes - you double click the button to lock the car and a red light blinks on the key to show it’s off. See manual for details.

Take the switched off key to the car and you’ll see it doesn’t work at all. Or if you really need convincing, open the car again with your spare key and take the switched off key into the car and try to start the engine (make sure the spare key is back in the house). The car will say “no key detected “.

Becomes second nature to double click and no ugly box needed!

My mini has a motion sensor key. It goes into sleep mode when motion isn't detected so in theory should be safe. I still use a box though.

NormalForNuneaton · 29/12/2023 11:30

InTheRainOnATrain · 29/12/2023 10:37

Purely an anecdotal observation but I think it’s area dependent. Our street is densely packed terraces and all cars parked bumper to bumper on the street so you’d have no way of knowing if the range rover belongs to the house it’s parked in front of or 10 doors down. I’ve literally never heard of a home break in car theft but the relay theft happens all the time. I did hear in the range rover service dept of a guy whose car was lifted off onto one of those tow trucks like the council have to move cars parked in suspended areas because yes if they really want the car they’ll find a way whether you have a faraday box, ghost immobiliser, disklock etc etc but breaking into houses would attract a lot of attention and would be unlikely to yield success so presumably that’s why it doesn’t really happen here. So if your area is similar I really wouldn’t worry.

Sorry, I didn't make it totally clear ...the parking means the car could only belong to one of 2 houses...ours or the neighbours.

It doesn't help that ours is the more immediately visible of the two

MadeOfAllWork · 29/12/2023 11:29

JingleSnowmanTree · 29/12/2023 11:14

QUESTION for people with working brain cells..

I have a Ford Focus 2015. It's not worth a lot, but I can't work without it, plus she's my wee girl. I don't want her stolen! She's 'keyless' but I need to press a button to lock/unlock.

i though as I needed to do that it wasn't emitting any signal, so I don't need faraday boxes/pouches.

but it does say 'key not in the car' (or something similar), if you go to drive off.

so now I'm confused. Do I or don't I need them?!?!

TIA

If the key has a battery then it is emitting signals. The best thing to do is either keep the key in a biscuit tin or the microwave.
But, most of the cars being stolen are being stolen to order. It’s the expensive Range Rovers that are in trouble.

EmmaEmerald · 29/12/2023 11:28

JingleSnowmanTree · 29/12/2023 11:14

QUESTION for people with working brain cells..

I have a Ford Focus 2015. It's not worth a lot, but I can't work without it, plus she's my wee girl. I don't want her stolen! She's 'keyless' but I need to press a button to lock/unlock.

i though as I needed to do that it wasn't emitting any signal, so I don't need faraday boxes/pouches.

but it does say 'key not in the car' (or something similar), if you go to drive off.

so now I'm confused. Do I or don't I need them?!?!

TIA

Using what's left of my brain cells....she's not keyless?

I'm guessing you can drive a bit without the keys in the car - enough to get it towed.

You do need a Faraday cage, I think.

I hate all this stuff. I no longer drive but was using an ugly steering wheel lock and a pouch.

Regular keys were so much easier!

WildFlowerBees · 29/12/2023 11:21

We have a faraday box but you need to shut it properly for it to work. Also don't keep your keys by the door.

PegasusReturns · 29/12/2023 11:21

This is likely a silly question but how to the thieves continue to use the car?

Our last car got stolen - was silliness on our part it was on drive and gate was open. There was a small windows and we suspect house was being watched.

it ended up recovered in Easter Europe. The police told us it would have been on the shipping container that night.

That was when they also told us that we should leave keys by door. The car was probably stolen to order and preventing that happening would have put us at risk. A neighbour was woken up in bed by someone wanting her car keys. I would never risk that.

Oldraver · 29/12/2023 11:19

Oh and on our local FB group someone posted CCTV footage of their house being 'scanned' by potential thieves.

They were on a drive in between two houses and scanning the wrong house

HideTheCroissants · 29/12/2023 11:19

CrapBucket · 29/12/2023 10:36

How does a faraday cage/pouch ‘stop working’- surely metal lined is metal lined?

Is it that the pouches are flexible and so the inner metal lining gets cracked? so a biscuit tin is fine indefinitely?

A biscuit tin is fine indefinitely. Apparently the pouches can fail as the mesh can wear out or get holes from the keys being taken in and out.

Oldraver · 29/12/2023 11:17

An expensive car on the next street to me was stolen. The owner didn't use a pouch but now has one and a parking bollard. Were just off to check our pouch as didn't know they don't last..thanks for that whoever posted

JingleSnowmanTree · 29/12/2023 11:14

QUESTION for people with working brain cells..

I have a Ford Focus 2015. It's not worth a lot, but I can't work without it, plus she's my wee girl. I don't want her stolen! She's 'keyless' but I need to press a button to lock/unlock.

i though as I needed to do that it wasn't emitting any signal, so I don't need faraday boxes/pouches.

but it does say 'key not in the car' (or something similar), if you go to drive off.

so now I'm confused. Do I or don't I need them?!?!

TIA

CroccyWoccy · 29/12/2023 11:12

We’ve recently bought an old-fashioned steering lock. We live in a busy part of London and I think the objective is just to make your car a less attractive prospect than the next one. Surely staging home invasions is limited to really high-end cars? I can’t imagine most thieves would want to added complication and risk of breaking in to a house and threatening the homeowner, unless the pay-off is substantial? They’d just move on down the street to the next vehicle they can more readily liberate, wouldn’t they?

christmaspawpaws · 29/12/2023 11:09

ReindeerRider · 29/12/2023 11:06

This is likely a silly question but how to the thieves continue to use the car? Looking at the video posted up thread they used an ariel to first unlock the car then again to start the engine. Then they drove off. What happens next though? The keys are with the owner in the house as nothing taken just the signal intercepted. So how does the thief stop and start the car again with no keys?

It'll usually end up being shipped off somewhere else in a storage container