Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bye bye bigot MIL

559 replies

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 03:44

My MIL has always had questionable views on things but I’ve always for the most part not engaged with her as she is the kind of idiot it’s impossible to reason with.

now I have a DS (10 months) .On Xmas day, she said most disgraced celebs are innocent and women “put themselves into these situations” she used a number of racial slurs Infront of my family (my parents are immigrants and my brother in law / nieces are people of colour )

she then proceeded to tell me I read “ too much science ” when raising my son and her way (the old fashioned way) is the only way.To which my mother replied current guidelines are based on research to reduce SIDS so cannot be a bad thing.

I guess my point here is.Can I really have an anti feminist,racists science denier around my son? She is from the boomer generation but still…?Husband says he supports cutting down contact if she says things like this around him when he is older but obviously cannot completely disown his mum.In an ideal world,I would never mix with someone so ridiculous so at a loss as to how to handle it.She is also very angry she will not be assisting me with childcare when I return to work .Obviously all of the above is the reason why.Should I get DH to explain this to her?

OP posts:
222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:44

@Twiglets1 also have you not seen how nice I’ve been up to this point for people to still be calling me out over something I said sorry for threads and threads back this place is full of trolls who love to be offended clearly

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 29/12/2023 06:43

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:37

@NotBadConsidering i appreciate the help and I understand what you are saying.I am not like those people in my generation you are generalising me as.I like a heated debate and to hear opinions of all.unfortunately my experience was not that it was just hate speech .Which I think we could agree is not acceptable.

so to summarise you think 20 something people stopping free speech is a thing but me thinking most boomers having different views on parenting can’t be a thing ? I’m running rings around all you people so unless you can help me with suggestions of how to talk to my son and or MIL constructively just don’t even bother .You boomers making it all about you 😂😂😂

you are generalising me

My comment about the current university generation was not remotely generalising about you, I have no idea how old you are because you haven’t said.

so to summarise you think 20 something people stopping free speech is a thing but me thinking most boomers having different views on parenting can’t be a thing ?

I can provide plenty of examples of people stopping free speech. I haven’t compared that to your views on boomers, I haven’t mentioned it once. You’re using my post to counter other people’s criticisms of you. You also have no idea how old I am. I am not a boomer.

I’m running rings around all you people

Headless chickens run in rings too.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:43

@Twiglets1 not a troll just frustrated and forgot myself for a moment.this has been playing on my mind and really upset me and now I have to keep defending myself for saying something that isn’t that out there like people parented different in different times not the same as racism end of and have apologised profusely for the use of the word boomer

OP posts:
DojaPhat · 29/12/2023 06:41

Protesting people and stopping people speaking because of their views is a new phenomenon most commonly in universities populated by people in their twenties.

Views like this make me think the younger generation(s) have done a few things right. More power to their elbows imo.

Twiglets1 · 29/12/2023 06:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:37

@NotBadConsidering i appreciate the help and I understand what you are saying.I am not like those people in my generation you are generalising me as.I like a heated debate and to hear opinions of all.unfortunately my experience was not that it was just hate speech .Which I think we could agree is not acceptable.

so to summarise you think 20 something people stopping free speech is a thing but me thinking most boomers having different views on parenting can’t be a thing ? I’m running rings around all you people so unless you can help me with suggestions of how to talk to my son and or MIL constructively just don’t even bother .You boomers making it all about you 😂😂😂

OP posts:
TempyBrennan · 29/12/2023 06:35

In surprised about how many people are shocked OP married a man who had a mother like this.
I was with DH and married for 9 years before our first child and the second he popped out my MIL turned into the woman from absolute hell, always a difficult lady but relative distance kept but after the grandchild arrived I never in a million year imagined how much she would up the awful behaviour.

op I’m with you, I would distance myself particularly as children get older and start listening and repeating things. I’d even be honest and say you don’t want you/your child around those remarks especially as a mixed race person it’s not acceptable.
She won’t change her ways because it’s who she is, but she may be able to put a lid on it for the sake of her grandchild.

(and for any one interest in 32 and a millennial apparently)

Holly60 · 29/12/2023 06:33

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 04:19

I don’t really care I meant in term of her generation ‘boomers’ parented differently so sometimes I feel bad getting annoyed at her as it probs all seems quite alien to her

The thing is - as you've realised, it's sometimes easy to say something which you think is acceptable but others are really offended by.

Isn't it better to call it out with her or at least call it out to your son -Granny is being unreasonable and unfair' rather than just cut her out?

My maternal grandmother had some very questionable views but she was my grandmother and actually very sweet to me and I valued that relationship. My dad never tried to cut her out of my life or stop me from seeing her. In fact he was endlessly respectful towards her even through I know how he felt about the things she thought/said. We used to laugh about it later and my parents always made it clear that they didn't condone it. They modelled amazing manners, morals and values to me at the same time and not cutting anyone out of our lives.

NotBadConsidering · 29/12/2023 06:29

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:19

@NotBadConsidering so you can say people in there 20s this and that ?hypocrite. I’m not actually offended by that at all.Haha honestly I’m sick of it .Starting to think you’re all just upset about your age now rather than offering constructive help you’re all just talking about what a good boomer you are or a nice boomer you know.I can use her age as a reason her views on parenting may be different there are many cultural,historical and social reasons people have different views .Pointing this out is not ageist .Ill say it again I don’t hate her coz she’s old I hate her because she uses racially derogative terms to my face and questions my parenting choices and disregards any hard work or research I’ve put into raising my son .youre ageist now LOL enjoy

Well given my post was my first on this matter and I haven’t been one of the posters criticising you for your views on age, no, I am not a hypocrite.

Protesting people and stopping people speaking because of their views is a new phenomenon most commonly in universities populated by people in their twenties.

I gave you constructive advice about how raise a child to deal with people whose views differ from yours or your child’s and how to use it to argue more constructively (more important when it means cutting out a family member otherwise). I think you should take this advice first, so you can pass on some learned skills to your child.

101Nutella · 29/12/2023 06:28

It’s absolutely fine to use the term boomer. It describes a group of people born within a certain time frame.
you used it as shorthand to imply there would be different generational standards and views- which there are.
one such socially accepted standard was to respect your elders and not to question authority. Both have changed dramatically in later generations eg respect should be earned etc. so the fact you are essentially questioning an elder will be triggering some people here.

People literally study the generational differences to aid teaching techniques and management techniques so it’s a huge thing! And of course there are exceptions but how we were raised and significant events which happened in the background of our life really affect how we view things now.

Twiglets1 · 29/12/2023 06:27

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:13

I’m still confused is it Agist to point out we did things differently as parents due to being born in a different time..NO.. if any of the older generation tell me they did things exactly as majority of parents do today I’d be very suprised as the world changes.One day I could be a grandparent and I’m pretty sure my DIL will be doing things different to me pointing this out is not ageist. Also ageist would imply I don’t like her because of her age I don’t like her coz she’s a dick

Language evolves and the word “boomer” is becoming a word that I believe will become non acceptable due to the way people use it to promote ageist stereotypes.

Im sure you can understand that certain words do have negative connotations. They were once used in society but now aren’t. If you want your son to grow up with an open mind not racist, sexist, ageist, homophobic etc in his attitudes then the language you use is important.

nettie434 · 29/12/2023 06:27

@222333Annie 'Boomer' is quite a controversial word here because it is often used to describe people who benefited from post 2nd world war reforms, like the expansion to higher education, but whose grandchildren face many more difficulties securing a comfortable job and lifestyle. It's more accurately used of the US population because we (in the UK) had different fertility patterns. It's such a large group numerically that it's rarely possible to make broad assumptions about their political views.

At 65, your MIL is at the tag end of the 'baby boomer' generation. At 64, I would never make allowances for someone in this age group being racist because it was the dominant attitude. The Race Relations Act was passed in 1965 so she was a tiny child when legislation to prevent discrimination was passed.

It sounds as if she is misogynistic too and used personal slurs towards your family. Her anti science approach doesn't suggest she would provide the sort of care you want.

You are in a really difficult position. There are some people with very entrenched views who can't even maintain a diplomatic silence. Do you think she values her role as grandmother enough to understand that her personal views cause offence?

I wish I had some practical ideas - I just was sorry that you'd got caught up in this boomer debate so just wanted to add a bit of context.

LangMayYerLumReek2024 · 29/12/2023 06:27

Autocorrects got carried away there.

LangMayYerLumReek2024 · 29/12/2023 06:25

@DirectionToPerfection

A clumsy generalisation about boomers is not in the same league as actual racism, for crying out loud

Prejudice, bigotry and discriminatory of all types is bad.

It's not a competition.

And you can see from OP subsequent posts that it's more ingrained than just one clumsy word. She continues to explain MILs behaviour as caused by her age. Her racism and sexism is caused by her age says OP.

MIL is a racist and sexism because she is. Not because of her age. Other older people do not share these characteristics. It last ageist to apply similar negative characteristics to those of the same generation.

Once you start to justify bigotry you are just as bad as MIL

Mills86 · 29/12/2023 06:21

A lot of PPs seem to have overlooked this part in their rush to be offended:
^^
On Xmas day, she said most disgraced celebs are innocent and women “put themselves into these situations” she used a number of racial slurs Infront of my family (my parents are immigrants and my brother in law / nieces are people of colour )

I was thinking the same, @Sakura7. I disagree that the OP’s mistake is on a par with the MiL’s comments like this as some have said.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:19

@NotBadConsidering so you can say people in there 20s this and that ?hypocrite. I’m not actually offended by that at all.Haha honestly I’m sick of it .Starting to think you’re all just upset about your age now rather than offering constructive help you’re all just talking about what a good boomer you are or a nice boomer you know.I can use her age as a reason her views on parenting may be different there are many cultural,historical and social reasons people have different views .Pointing this out is not ageist .Ill say it again I don’t hate her coz she’s old I hate her because she uses racially derogative terms to my face and questions my parenting choices and disregards any hard work or research I’ve put into raising my son .youre ageist now LOL enjoy

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 29/12/2023 06:15

LangMayYerLumReek2024 · 29/12/2023 06:05

It's not just the use of the word boomer - you then in subsequent posts continue to make this about her age.

Yes her bigotry is a real problem. But so is yours. Ageism is as bad as the prejudice you call her out for.

A clumsy generalisation about boomers is not in the same league as actual racism, for crying out loud 🙄

It's quite obvious what point OP was making. Societal norms were different in MIL's youth and may somewhat explain why she holds such views. It doesn't mean all, or most, boomers are racist or sexist.

101Nutella · 29/12/2023 06:13

A lot of these posters have likely never dealt with actual abusive family members. There is such a toxic narrative where people assume having vile people in your life because they are ‘family’ is always the desired outcome. I can only imagine people advising this either

  1. have the privilege of never dealing with such situations so it’s a blind spot. They see family as a happy loving thing.
  2. perhaps their own self esteem has been knocked by such people so they allow it in their own life so don’t realise it’s wrong.
  3. Or that they are triggered because they are actually the abusive people/bullies themselves.

honestly blood or not- you deserve better.
guve her the opportunity to grow and change whilst also controlling/limiting the impact she can have on your son. You don’t need to explain yourself to anyone. you are being kind already. If I was the child of an immigrant and had someone being racist in my house I probs wouldn’t want to spend any time with them.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:13

I’m still confused is it Agist to point out we did things differently as parents due to being born in a different time..NO.. if any of the older generation tell me they did things exactly as majority of parents do today I’d be very suprised as the world changes.One day I could be a grandparent and I’m pretty sure my DIL will be doing things different to me pointing this out is not ageist. Also ageist would imply I don’t like her because of her age I don’t like her coz she’s a dick

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 29/12/2023 06:09

It’s not pleasant to hear views expressed we considered racist.

We also have a societal problem with a generation of young adults who have been raised being unable to tolerate any view they deem wrong and cannot engage in any form of counter debate, instead scream “bigot!” at people who not only express views that are universally racist, but also views that are quite reasonable.

Your DH is clearly too cowardly to make a stand and challenge these views so it’s a great opportunity to do so by pointing out clearly when she expressed racist/sexist/ misogynistic views and showing a good example. No child becomes sexist/racist/misogynistic from intermittent exposure to a grandparent and if you and his dad raise him properly he won’t. And if you keep contact and challenge her in front of him you will also raise a child who can constructively challenge others when he’s older without being ironically intolerant of other people’s views, like a good deal of people in their 20s right now who don’t want certain people to speak at their universities.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:08

@Sakura7 thank you for talking some sense .If I posted what was actually said I wonder if the views would be different ? I won’t repeat it because I could never even bring myself to repeat that language.

OP posts:
LangMayYerLumReek2024 · 29/12/2023 06:05

It's not just the use of the word boomer - you then in subsequent posts continue to make this about her age.

Yes her bigotry is a real problem. But so is yours. Ageism is as bad as the prejudice you call her out for.

PuttingDownRoots · 29/12/2023 06:05

Toddler hears grandmother use slur
Toddler repeats slur to friend at nursery, not realising its bad
Nursery and parents then have to unteach it to toddlers

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 06:05

@HoppingPavlova this is great advice and what I was hoping for . Thank you, I like the way you’ve explained it to your children I could see myself doing that in the future.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 29/12/2023 06:04

@222333Annie the word boomer when used to express stereotypical negative characteristics is offensive to those of us who are “boomers” or married to “boomers “.

My husband is a “boomer” yet manages to not be racist or anti science. In fact he is a scientist. Sometimes people need to have it gently pointed out to them when their language is upsetting people. Maybe try that with your MIL.