Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bye bye bigot MIL

559 replies

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 03:44

My MIL has always had questionable views on things but I’ve always for the most part not engaged with her as she is the kind of idiot it’s impossible to reason with.

now I have a DS (10 months) .On Xmas day, she said most disgraced celebs are innocent and women “put themselves into these situations” she used a number of racial slurs Infront of my family (my parents are immigrants and my brother in law / nieces are people of colour )

she then proceeded to tell me I read “ too much science ” when raising my son and her way (the old fashioned way) is the only way.To which my mother replied current guidelines are based on research to reduce SIDS so cannot be a bad thing.

I guess my point here is.Can I really have an anti feminist,racists science denier around my son? She is from the boomer generation but still…?Husband says he supports cutting down contact if she says things like this around him when he is older but obviously cannot completely disown his mum.In an ideal world,I would never mix with someone so ridiculous so at a loss as to how to handle it.She is also very angry she will not be assisting me with childcare when I return to work .Obviously all of the above is the reason why.Should I get DH to explain this to her?

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 09:26

LakieLady · 29/12/2023 09:11

But there are significant differences within generations, as well as between them. Treating any group with a given characteristic as homogenous and "other" is discriminatory, whether it's an age group, an ethnic group or people with disabilities.

OP's MIL has racist views because she's a racist, not because of when she was born.

And the question is, how did she become a racist ? And to a certain extent that is determined by when she was born. Her generation were exposed to casual racism/homophobia/sexism almost as the norm. It was across broadcasting, the press, movies of the day, and it was rife in advertising - you couldn’t even buy a bloody jar of marmalade without racist imagery right there on the jar, and in by-products aimed at children, and it engendered unconscious/casual racism that in a lot of older people still exists today. Just because it’s unpalatable doesn’t make it any less a fact.

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 09:24

I understand it to mean that all white people have automatically benefitted off the backs of black people and that is simply not true for ''all white people''. I do not have white privilege.

mottytotty · 29/12/2023 09:22

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 09:19

well, you can't please everybody, as I'm about to demonstrate, as an Irish person whose ancestors literally survived a famine, I'm not keen on the phrase ''white privilege''! But, this is exhausting! There was another thread on here yesterday, very interesting about how all of mumsnet's problems could be solved by simply not being offended, and that is true (but hard)

My Spanish school friend agrees, she is living in Spain again now and her mil is still quite damaged by the franco era. Fears for them owning a dog (dogs bark, dogs can't be ordered to fear Franco) and she now lives in a tiny flat in the centre of the city where she feels much safer than where she hid out rurally for decades. So, tbh, the notion of white privilege is also a mostly American concept. Even the British who were responsible for the problems in Ireland for centuries, it's not like the average white British person was benefiting from that ! most were dirt poor too, most didn't even have a vote, most probably hadn't a clue that their food was cheaper than market value because a neighbour country was being plundered like a resource. So, with that said, namaste! I know that no offence was meant, and none is taken honestly, but everybody reacts slightly differently even to terms that are mainstream. I'm gen x and I await the day that genexxers are lambasted online for being dumb/resistance to change! It's going to happen. Cycle of life.

Ps just because I don't fully and automatically subscribe to the idea of white privilege doesn't mean I think that racism doesn't exist.

My xmil wouldn't have believed in any information that was on google. She would have known better. What @MrsTerryPratchett says is true, you do marry into a whole family. I was this boundaryless creature who only grew a backbone finally when I had to defend myself on some really important matters. I'd always said 'oh, ok'' before that. I almost feel sorry for my xmil looking back. She thought I was a wet lettuce, how could she have known I'd stand up to her.

You clearly don’t understand what ‘white privilege’ means @ChanelNo19EDT . Google it.

Zarah123 · 29/12/2023 09:21

AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 29/12/2023 09:02

Typical Mumsnet.

Calling someone n**er: perfectly fine, just an opinion, everyone's entitled to an opinion, black people need to stop being so oversensitive and stop "playing the race card" because racism doesn't exist in this country, critical race theory is just an American thing.

Calling someone boomer: the worst bigotry and hatred the world has ever seen, middle aged white people are the single most oppressed people on earth.

So true.

And then they wonder why minorities stick to their own kind.

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 09:19

well, you can't please everybody, as I'm about to demonstrate, as an Irish person whose ancestors literally survived a famine, I'm not keen on the phrase ''white privilege''! But, this is exhausting! There was another thread on here yesterday, very interesting about how all of mumsnet's problems could be solved by simply not being offended, and that is true (but hard)

My Spanish school friend agrees, she is living in Spain again now and her mil is still quite damaged by the franco era. Fears for them owning a dog (dogs bark, dogs can't be ordered to fear Franco) and she now lives in a tiny flat in the centre of the city where she feels much safer than where she hid out rurally for decades. So, tbh, the notion of white privilege is also a mostly American concept. Even the British who were responsible for the problems in Ireland for centuries, it's not like the average white British person was benefiting from that ! most were dirt poor too, most didn't even have a vote, most probably hadn't a clue that their food was cheaper than market value because a neighbour country was being plundered like a resource. So, with that said, namaste! I know that no offence was meant, and none is taken honestly, but everybody reacts slightly differently even to terms that are mainstream. I'm gen x and I await the day that genexxers are lambasted online for being dumb/resistance to change! It's going to happen. Cycle of life.

Ps just because I don't fully and automatically subscribe to the idea of white privilege doesn't mean I think that racism doesn't exist.

My xmil wouldn't have believed in any information that was on google. She would have known better. What @MrsTerryPratchett says is true, you do marry into a whole family. I was this boundaryless creature who only grew a backbone finally when I had to defend myself on some really important matters. I'd always said 'oh, ok'' before that. I almost feel sorry for my xmil looking back. She thought I was a wet lettuce, how could she have known I'd stand up to her.

Wokkadema · 29/12/2023 09:17

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 08:33

I like debates but what she said isn’t uk for debate coz it’s hateful and nonsensical

There's also a massive difference between debating, say, whether the moon landings actually occurred, or whether social media encourages narcissism, and debating whether people of XYZ racial background are worthy of being treated with respect in front of those people. Which is, I gather, where MIL made her racist comments.
OP at the very least I think you need to tell DH that MIL will never again be invited to family gatherings with your side of the family, as she has shown she cannot be trusted to behave appropriately around them. If that means she misses Christmas or birthday parties- oh well.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 09:16

Sadly you may be right before I just thought they were not PC which I could have dealt with but now I can see downright hateful the nan is the same super mean

OP posts:
Libertyy · 29/12/2023 09:16

And i wouldn’t put about race on aibu either, try the black mumsnetter or south Asian boards instead

WickDittington · 29/12/2023 09:15

MockneyReject · 29/12/2023 04:01

Presumably, OP means that she understands that they grew up at a time when such attitudes were acceptable, so has previously given some leeway because of that?

Except that the baby boom generation were leaders in trying to slough away bigotry. You have a lot to thank us for - maternity leave, equal pay legislation, anti- discrimination legislation and so on.

Was you MiL born before 1960? That’s the general understanding of “baby boomer”. After that, she’s a Thatcher’s child.

Libertyy · 29/12/2023 09:14

Never date a white person that has a racist family. This is where a lot of Asians/black people go wrong

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 09:14

I understand that I get a lot of advice from my mum who is actually older than her .Its not the advice it’s the way she disregards all I am doing which is not to with age but I thought maybe coz she did it so differently in her time and just her own personal views are so different to mine maybe it was just to opposite for her to accept that’s all I was getting at.my mum know many more traditional things to do with babies(from our home Country ) that have saved my butt a few times no disrespect to all the lovely mothers who came before us

OP posts:
toomuchfaff · 29/12/2023 09:12

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/12/2023 04:10

You met, dated, married and got pregnant with a man whose mother was like this. Now you want to cut her out. Now there's a baby who won't get a grandmother.

IME you marry a family as well as a man. She got an ageist DIL, you got a racist MIL. No one won the lottery. Have good boundaries, parent your own way, but this is your DH's mum and your child's GM. You chose him with his family.

People grow up without Grandparents all the time. Mine; GM were both dead by time I was 8, GD both dead before I was born (WW2)... Your reasoning is a bit off...

If the grandparent was a bit touchy with the kids (pedo Pete type) or a raging maniac (Ted Bundy type), would the same go? Carry on and keep them in contact with the children, after all they're "family", can't stop the GP seeing the kids or have the child with no GP even if they are a registered sex offender or murderer.. of course not! Utter BS.

There are reasons why you cut people, many reasons... what OP has to decide is whether the MIL influence is acceptablor to their views or manageable. Regardless if you married into the family or not, and GM either adheres the boundaries or doesn't.

LakieLady · 29/12/2023 09:11

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 29/12/2023 08:04

I think you're getting an unnecessarily hard time on here. It's not ageism to say that different generations had different ideas and attitudes, it's a fact. People will continue to insist on being offended though. With MIL just call her out on it, every single time. She'll either rethink herself, learn to keep it to herself or shout louder. If it's the latter then you can reduce contact and it shouldn't come as a surprise to her if she's any common sense at all.

But there are significant differences within generations, as well as between them. Treating any group with a given characteristic as homogenous and "other" is discriminatory, whether it's an age group, an ethnic group or people with disabilities.

OP's MIL has racist views because she's a racist, not because of when she was born.

Soontobe60 · 29/12/2023 09:07

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 04:15

Oh sorry that was not meant to be offence ! I mean her generation had a completely different set of parenting guidelines so I can see how she struggles watching the things we do

I am a grandparent, born in the late 50’s so brought up under different guidance. However, as I am intelligent, can listen to / read current advice regarding child rearing etc I am able to make informed choices as to how I take care of my grandchildren.
My DD, mother of grandchildren, often phones myself and her MIL to ask for advice - she knows we have raised our own children well and is able to accept our advice and support. My experience and that of my friends who are grandparents is similar. Our children look to us for advice and support - they don’t dismiss us because we happen to have been born in the mid 20th century!

Flowers4me · 29/12/2023 09:05

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 08:50

She seems to look down on my family and has to always assert the fact they are not working class like us and she’s been quite rude to them afew times .They’ve just ignored even other members of her family say she’s a nightmare but whenever we try to tell her she responds with this whole family make me feel like I can’t speak etc and just kinda turns it round

Oh, she sounds immature that she's throwing it back on you. I am curious as to what her upbringing was like; wonder if there are issues there? Anyhow, I'm digressing; some people have very bigoted views on everything. Is there anyone she's close to as maybe that's the way in; in a trusted relationship she might open up and there may be an opportunity to understand her more. If everyone is challenging her I wouldn't be surprised if she reacts like "whole family make me feel" etc. Its difficult OP; try and keep to your boundaries and enjoy your little one. If its any consolation, we have a relative like yours and my children have not been poisoned by their views. As another poster said, their peers have influenced them the most.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 09:03

@AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato and what you said in your first line was not too disimilar to what my family and I had to hear so you are 100% right this whole things screams white privilege

OP posts:
AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 29/12/2023 09:02

Typical Mumsnet.

Calling someone n**er: perfectly fine, just an opinion, everyone's entitled to an opinion, black people need to stop being so oversensitive and stop "playing the race card" because racism doesn't exist in this country, critical race theory is just an American thing.

Calling someone boomer: the worst bigotry and hatred the world has ever seen, middle aged white people are the single most oppressed people on earth.

CaptainMyCaptain · 29/12/2023 09:00

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 08:54

There is no defence of racism and homophobia. It wasn't a universal experience in the 70s.

You only have to look at some of the prime time TV programming of the time to know that this just isn’t true. Til death do us part, love thy neighbour, the black and white minstrel show, and many more of what passed as comedy/light entertainment shows of the time will never see the light of day again because of their racist/sexist/homophobic content. Same for the likes of stand up comedian acts of the day such as Bernard Manning and Bob Monkhouse. It might be uncomfortable to admit, but casual racism was everywhere.

Yes there was that kind of thing on TV and I, personally, didn't like it then. Some people accepted it at the time but have since changed their view and are shocked by it - you don't have to stay stuck in an era 40 or 50 years ago that's the point. |Most people carry on living and learning and evolving and there's no excuse not to.

Brefugee · 29/12/2023 08:58

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 08:54

There is no defence of racism and homophobia. It wasn't a universal experience in the 70s.

You only have to look at some of the prime time TV programming of the time to know that this just isn’t true. Til death do us part, love thy neighbour, the black and white minstrel show, and many more of what passed as comedy/light entertainment shows of the time will never see the light of day again because of their racist/sexist/homophobic content. Same for the likes of stand up comedian acts of the day such as Bernard Manning and Bob Monkhouse. It might be uncomfortable to admit, but casual racism was everywhere.

bloody norah, i don't know how many times some of us need to say it: yes, of course there was institutional racism. We didn't take part in it as far as it was possible to avoid (my grandad worked in a factory with people mostly from Pakistan - he would always switch off the racist shit when it came on because he knew from them how damaging it was.)

My family, and other families i knew didn't partake in Sexism and Racism and Homophobia in the 70s or at any other time. Any unconscious or unknowing -isms were apologised for if/when it was brought up. We KNEW (because we had first hand experience) how bad policing was in terms of treatment of women and our black relatives and friends. And that is why we went to Rock against Racism and so on.

Again: it wasn't a universal experience, and where it occurred there were those of us calling it out. And it is frankly insulting for the posters who are implying it was.

Kwasi · 29/12/2023 08:58

FIL and SMIL are a particular religion. They generally believe that homosexuality is akin to paedophilia. You simply cannot reason with them.

HulaChick · 29/12/2023 08:56

Zarah123 · 29/12/2023 08:43

Tell me you’re white without telling me you’re white.

For some of us, racism isn’t a ‘juicy’ debate, it’s our lived reality. It affects our self-esteem, our sense of worth, and contributes to a feeling that we don’t belong anywhere. I don’t want to talk to racists, I just want them to stay the fuck away from me.

I wasn't referring only to racism but to many, many different topics. My point was, there were opposing views and we would pull-up / challenge the views of whoever may have made an inflammatory remark. Rather than having a major fallout we were capable of discussing it (as,said, often extremely heatedly but not throwing insults at each other) but without resorting to going 'no contact'. Also,my being white has nothing to do with it, as prejudice in any guise would be pulled up but our debates weren't centred on racism but lots of hot topics.

EmmaOvary · 29/12/2023 08:55

No, you don’t need to have your kids exposed to this bigoted nonsense. Your kids, your boundaries.

222333Annie · 29/12/2023 08:55

I can’t say it on here but it’s very bad not just a mistake like I made earlier

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 08:54

Brefugee · 29/12/2023 08:35

maybe in your family - not in mine. We didn't have those dolls. I was given a collection of the Robertsons jam figurines. I had no idea they were racist until a neighbour told me. Then we binned them.

There is no defence of racism and homophobia. It wasn't a universal experience in the 70s.

There is no defence of racism and homophobia. It wasn't a universal experience in the 70s.

You only have to look at some of the prime time TV programming of the time to know that this just isn’t true. Til death do us part, love thy neighbour, the black and white minstrel show, and many more of what passed as comedy/light entertainment shows of the time will never see the light of day again because of their racist/sexist/homophobic content. Same for the likes of stand up comedian acts of the day such as Bernard Manning and Bob Monkhouse. It might be uncomfortable to admit, but casual racism was everywhere.

101Nutella · 29/12/2023 08:52

Classic. Lack of accountability, emotionally immature. Mud slinging.
hold your line.