Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are your kids allowed to get their own food?

121 replies

Wholetthepugsout · 28/12/2023 22:31

Do you allow your younger children 4 upwards to go in the kitchen and into the fridge etc? Do they have to ask you first or do you just get all their food and they’re not allowed in the fridge/cupboards?

OP posts:
FlamingoYellow · 29/12/2023 14:06

PuttingDownRoots · 29/12/2023 13:34

I think some people are mixing up cause and effect. If your child is good at self control you don't need to control their access. If they haven't got self control they need the extra help to chose appropriately.

I was thinking this reading some of the replies.

Unfortunately, allowing free access to healthy snacks does not mean your child will develop amazing self control. Proof of this is my DC1, who used to happily fetch himself cups of water and healthy snacks (in moderation!) from his little snack cupboard aged 2, but as he got older he started comfort eating so we had to bring in restrictions. Children are not born knowing how to make sensible food choices.

In my house we have set rules about how many snacks the dcs are allowed per day (2 pieces of fruit, 2 biscuits and 1 item from bread bin) , so they can help themselves to those without having to ask first. If they're still hungry then they have to ask.

AndThatWasNY · 29/12/2023 13:36

Mine ask.
They would eat all the fruit, biscuits, bread, cheese, yoghurt, cereal etc otherwise and not then want to eat their dinner.
I am conscious of them eating healthily so that means moderation, they aren't able to self moderate (as we had about a year of free access and they ate all the snacks and no dinner).
Some kids aren't so greedy but mine are!

PuttingDownRoots · 29/12/2023 13:34

I think some people are mixing up cause and effect. If your child is good at self control you don't need to control their access. If they haven't got self control they need the extra help to chose appropriately.

BobnLen · 29/12/2023 13:33

Are children scoffing fruit and yogurt all day, it's not very good for their teeth

Universalsnail · 29/12/2023 13:32

Yes they can get food whenever they like.

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 29/12/2023 13:30

No, they got meals at appropriate times and snacks as deemed necessary, I didn't encourage indiscriminate snacking but they could always ask of course

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 29/12/2023 13:28

No, they got meals at appropriate times and snacks as deemed necessary, I didn't encourage indiscriminate snacking but they could always ask of course

momonpurpose · 29/12/2023 13:28

Catza · 28/12/2023 23:06

Absolutely. I grew up in the household where I had to ask and was told off for eating things without permission (it was out of necessity as we lived in poverty). It was awful and I don’t want to put my kid through it.

My grandma grew up that way in the depression in the states in the 1930's. Because of that we would get in trouble if we asked. She said if you want something get it but do not ask. I'm the same way.

BobnLen · 29/12/2023 13:26

DS is adult now but he had to ask especially when he was younger or he might have taken something I was planning to use for lunches, I wouldn't want to go to work and all the bananas or grapes were gone which I wanted for lunch

Inyourwildestdreams · 29/12/2023 13:20

VivaVivaa · 29/12/2023 08:22

DS1 (age 3.5) is identical to this down to the centiles and all. We have to be very careful with him and there is not a snowballs chance in hell we’ll be giving him unfettered access to snacks, even if fruit/veg/cheese/crackers (all of which he loves and would chose over sweet things) when he turns 4. Of course they are all healthy things but number of calories matter too.

@VivaVivaa Exactly the same here! Mine would pick fruit/veg/cheese/crackers over sweet stuff too but I worry about the volume and portion sizes he wants so I do try to be careful.
We sit down for all meals together, eat the same healthy home cooked meals, snacks (max 2 per day) are had at the table so he isn’t eating when playing etc. I don’t restrict any foods particularly - although we didn’t introduce any sugar until he was able to ask for it himself (much to my family’s disgust 😅😂.

RedToothBrush · 29/12/2023 13:19

If you are fed properly you don't need to snack.

JenniferJuniper80 · 29/12/2023 13:18

My children are adults now.
They were all allowed to help themselves to snacks, fruit, crisps, yoghurt etc from as soon as they could.

I notice my grandchildren are the same.

Unless dinner is imminent and they are trying to make themselves a sandwich, then let them eat when they're hungry.

JazbayGrapes · 29/12/2023 13:17

mine don't have to ask, but they're supposed to tell if we're running low on something. Also not to leave a mess

spriots · 29/12/2023 13:15

I think children vary a lot on self control - my 4 year old frequently only eats a small part of a chocolate bar and saves the rest for later, my 7 year old could and has eaten himself to the point of being sick, he needs clear boundaries with food

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 29/12/2023 13:15

No, when my dc were younger they had to ask. I don't remember ever setting that as an overt rule though. That's just what they did.

Caspianberg · 29/12/2023 13:12

@UsingChangeofName - but they don’t just snack all day. My 3.5 year old is all to snack whenever really, unless just before meal, and I’m not that strict about chocolate either. But because it’s always been unrestricted he isn’t obsessed with it. Some days he will get several snacks if he’s hungry, but other days he doesn’t snack at all.
His chocolate Santa from Christmas he hasn’t touched yet and it’s just sitting on the side.

UsingChangeofName · 29/12/2023 13:04

MsChatterbox · 29/12/2023 06:22

Mine (6 and 3) have to ask. Sometimes they want a snack right before a meal. Sometimes they want chocolate when they've already had enough sugar for the day. They ask and I make the appropriate choice (wait for your dinner or yes these are your choices of what you can have).

Glad to see more answers like this today. I was very surprised yesterday to see how many people yesterday felt that 4 year olds could make reasoned decisions about just eating whatever they want, when they want - let alone how they reach things.....

Flufferblub · 29/12/2023 09:56

Yes they can just get food when they're hungry. Sometimes if it's late at night and they've had dinner, I'll tell them that the kitchen is now closed. They're a bit older now.

I might tell them to lay off the snacks if we're going to be having dinner soon.

I read a good idea a while ago about a "yes box". You can have a box in the kitchen that you can stock up with healthy snacks and drinks that they can always dip into. I thought that was a good idea.

spriots · 29/12/2023 09:56

Interesting question - my 7 year old and 4 year old do ask, we have never particularly had this as a rule, it's just what they do naturally. And snacks are all out of sight so they don't think to help themselves.

Except for fruit which is in a bowl on the table - the little one is always helping himself to apples.

4timesthefun · 29/12/2023 09:52

My oldest 3 (ranging from 7-12) don’t have to ask. The youngest one is only 2 and can’t reach anything for herself, so she has to ask because of that. The older kids have basically helped themselves from the time they could reach the fridge, fruit bowl, and necessary cupboard snacks. I grew up in a household where there was a lot of control around food, so I’ve been determined to be the exact opposite. Whether I’ve made the right choice we will see in time…. So far so good.

I should add - we rarely have anything other than water or milk, so they aren’t drinking juices and soft drink at all. I think it’s VERY easy for kids to drink excessive amount of calories, but 2 of mine would benefit from putting on a little weight anyhow. It’s more around wanting them to prioritise water intake.

PumpkinPie2016 · 29/12/2023 09:37

My son is 10 and allowed to help himself - has been since about age 4. I think sometimes, limiting access to food can make kids eat more when they are given more freedom.

He will usually get fruit/cheese/crackers, sometimes crisps or one of his sweet treats. I buy sensible amounts of crisps/sweets and he knows that once gone, that's it until the next shop. He actually doesn't eat many crisps/sweets - he'd far rather something else like cheese. Drinks he does himself- water/milk/lemon squash usually as I don't often buy fizzy drinks.
He is able to get his own cereal in the morning too.

It works well - I am fortunate that he is an excellent eater. Always eats the main meals cooked, eats veg etc. He is very tall for his age and skinny (like his dad) and does eat quite a lot but I don't worry as he is perfectly healthy and a healthy weight (probably on the lower side for his height).

Apparently my husband was the same as a kid - his mum used to joke that he had one meal a day that started when he woke up and ended when he went to bed 😂 despite this, he has been very slim all his life.

lightisnotwhite · 29/12/2023 09:07

It was just me and DS so it was easy to control food in and out. If DS ate it all ( bread, cheese etc) he’d know there was no more until the next weeks shopping. Mostly we had ingredients but always had fruit and some favourite biscuits for DS ( I don’t eat them).
He eats very healthily and he’s now late teens. Cooks for himself and doesn’t do fast food.

MirrorBack · 29/12/2023 09:07

We have dialogue, not so much a ‘have to ask’ but we discuss timing and what’s available. For example the 13 year old May say ‘anyone mind if I finish the yogurt?’ and I may say ‘if your hungry it’s ages until tea, want to have a bit more or- could you start dinner off and I’ll finish it when I’m done typing this…’. I give some guidance too, like suggesting they’ve already eaten x today, why not have something else- two have a tendency to binge the same things. I may ask they don’t eat certain things, like ‘I’m using the bacon for dinner- you can cook a bacon sandwich if you’re willing to go get more before dinner’.

Familiaritybreedscontemptso · 29/12/2023 09:06

At 4 they had to ask.

Now they are older (10 & 11), they can access the fruit bowl and their snack cupboard independently. 11 year old will cook simple things (jacket potatoes, scrambled egg, pasta dishes) independently if everyone else is going to be late home or he wants something different to eat.

BertieBotts · 29/12/2023 09:03

However, both my older kids are more "eat to live", they wouldn't be constantly seeking out food, they have to be persuaded to eat when they are getting hangry TBH.