Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with DP after they upset DD?

320 replies

Violah · 28/12/2023 22:12

Sort of looking for advice on what to do but I think the damage will already be done.

DD13 was measuring her height and weight so that I could work out what size of clothing to order as she wanted a new coat.

She shouted her weight from another room so I could put it into the calculator. DP was astounded she weighed that much (more than him) to which I said before DD came through - do not make a big deal of this.

DD brought the scales through and weighed herself again and he pointed out to DD he weighed less than her.

DD left the room. I went to check on her and she was crying in bed. She pushed me away as I was tried to give her a cuddle. I tried to get across that she needn't worry about his stupid comment. But I know I've felt self-conscious all my life over weight so probably projecting those worries onto her.

I told DP off and I'm upset with him and on DDs behalf.

Any advice?

OP posts:
Mariposistaa · 29/12/2023 04:01

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 01:29

Nobody knows what’s normal anymore because over 70% of the population are over weight either a little bit to morbidly.
Drop a kid into an early 1990s classroom, 79 % of kids today who’s parents think they are normal and healthy would look like the fat one.
it is normal to
be overweight, that’s the problem, it will never be healthy

Totally this, and being overweight is now acceptable and people are burying their heads in the sand. Yet another case of ‘you’re fine as you are’. Would love to actually see what this child (and adult) look like before everyone says how cruel the comment is!

Nanaof1 · 29/12/2023 03:50

Meemawdebs68 · 28/12/2023 23:17

Don’t know how! Googled it and thought I’d done it right- will delete earlier post - sorry everyone!

Please do start your own thread though. You seem sad and in need of support, a hand-hold or a shoulder right now.

CarrotCake01 · 29/12/2023 03:40

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 02:46

No. The reason OP hasn’t mentioned DD’s height, weight or clothes size is because she doesn’t want to put sensitive information like that onto an online forum. That, and the blindingly obvious - it wasn’t her DD’s weight she posted for advice on. It was leapt on right from the start and her actual question has been largely ignored in favour of hitting her with a barrage of questions entirely irrelevant to the advice she was asking for. And her partner - who she describes as slim - was ‘astounded’ that DD weighed as much as him. Which to me, indicates that she doesn’t look overweight.

Although it's sensitive information, we're all total strangers and no one has a clue who her or her daughter are. She could post any rough figure and it wouldn't mean a thing to any of us. I don't really see the point of the secrecy personally.

Yeah, her post was about her partner, not her child's weight I get that, but I do think the context and relevance are key factors.
Sure, he was being insensitive and shouldn't have made his comment, particularly in the way that he did, I said I'd also be cross with him saying what he did. However context is important, being an asshole to your teenage daughter and making fun of her / making her unnecessarily self conscious is one thing but if his daughter is unhealthy and obese and in need of some genuine help, he's allowed to feel shocked by this wake up call.

I just got the impression that maybe this is an issue that OP tries to sweep under the rug which ultimately isn't going to help if DD is struggling with her health 🤷🏼‍♀️ OP put this online for the world to see and asked for advice. We only have limited information and have to make some assumptions.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 03:34

Don’t think the OP’s coming back. Don’t blame her. This whole thread is one perpetual derail.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 03:28

steff13 · 29/12/2023 03:17

Okay I must be missing it, where is the word slim?

The majority of people are overweight so looking normal to someone is not really a good measure of whether that person is a healthy weight.

DP is not small (slightly taller than me and I'm 5.7) as such, but more a slim frame.

Second paragraph.

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 03:21

steff13 · 29/12/2023 03:17

Okay I must be missing it, where is the word slim?

The majority of people are overweight so looking normal to someone is not really a good measure of whether that person is a healthy weight.

Ummm … in the second paragraph. Where it has the letters S.L.I. and M in that order🤨🤷‍♂️

Bestyearever2024 · 29/12/2023 03:20

Perhaps a parent who realizes his kid needs a serious wake up call?

Oh come on! Serious wake up calls for 13 year old girls, are not handled in this way. Shaming a 13 year old about her weight is NEVER the solution. Long or short term

The OP knows there is some emotion around DDs weight hence the OP warning Twat not to make a thing about it and yet Twat knows best. 🙄

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 03:20

Honeychickpea · 29/12/2023 03:11

Perhaps a parent who realizes his kid needs a serious wake up call?

Or perhaps a parent who was shocked to find his DD weighed more than himself because there is nothing in her appearance to suggest a weight problem ?

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 03:17

Honeychickpea · 29/12/2023 03:11

Perhaps a parent who realizes his kid needs a serious wake up call?

That just isn’t how a sensible, sensitive and responsible parent would go about it. OP, this isn’t of your making. You asked her in a natural, open and healthy way. But sadly I think, given the tears, you do now have a problem to unpick. A few posters have given ideas but honestly I would seek help given what has happened. Eating and body image issues are better prevented than halted once they have taken hold. If you start with your GP you can also get help IF your DD needs to manage her weight.

steff13 · 29/12/2023 03:17

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 03:15

*Violah · Yesterday 22:22

I dont think she needs to lose weight though. She looks normal to me. She's always been larger framed than other girls her age and so was I growing up.

DP is not small (slightly taller than me and I'm 5.7) as such, but more a slim frame.

I'm broad shouldered and DD takes after me.*

Okay I must be missing it, where is the word slim?

The majority of people are overweight so looking normal to someone is not really a good measure of whether that person is a healthy weight.

Midnightgrey · 29/12/2023 03:16

She likely is fat. Assuming that she is not a bodybuilder or elite athlete the BMI will tell you. The fact that she was upset is key. I have weighed 50-55 kg my entire adult life and I'm in my 50s. (yes obviously not 13) My youngest son in his 20s who is 5 cm taller than me weighs less than me because he is really skinny. I am not upset - I'm not upset because I'm not overweight for my height. My son would love to weigh more.

My older son has been painstakingly losing some weight. He's a medical student dealing with patients - obviously under supervision - abd knowd there is a family history of heart disease. He's seen enough heart attack survivors (and ones who didn't make it) to decide that what he called his chub had to go. He now has a normal BMI when it crept a bit high before thanks to irregular hours and lack of time for exercise.

Wilfully closing your eyes to an overweight teen's weight does not make them thin. Can you just serve her slightly less food on plates and cut down a bit on available snacks and encourage some family walks. Her dad sounds particularly thick.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 03:15

steff13 · 29/12/2023 03:11

I don't see where she used the word slim?

*Violah · Yesterday 22:22

I dont think she needs to lose weight though. She looks normal to me. She's always been larger framed than other girls her age and so was I growing up.

DP is not small (slightly taller than me and I'm 5.7) as such, but more a slim frame.

I'm broad shouldered and DD takes after me.*

Honeychickpea · 29/12/2023 03:11

Bestyearever2024 · 29/12/2023 03:08

You specifically asked her father NOT to comment on her weight, he ignored you and deliberately upset his own daughter. DELIBERATELY made the choice to comment on her weight.

Whether your 13 year old daughter is overweight or he is underweight......THIS is what I find so appalling

What sort of parent deliberately chooses to upset their child?

He is a twat

Perhaps a parent who realizes his kid needs a serious wake up call?

steff13 · 29/12/2023 03:11

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 03:09

What size ? OP hasn’t mentioned the weight of either DD or DP, except to say that DP is slim. Plenty of men are of slim build and a growing teen will carry weight a lot differently ahead of a growth spurt for example. You’re projecting.

I don't see where she used the word slim?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 03:09

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:57

And you don’t get to be that size without seriously unhealthy mindset around food and just eating too much.

What size ? OP hasn’t mentioned the weight of either DD or DP, except to say that DP is slim. Plenty of men are of slim build and a growing teen will carry weight a lot differently ahead of a growth spurt for example. You’re projecting.

Bestyearever2024 · 29/12/2023 03:08

You specifically asked her father NOT to comment on her weight, he ignored you and deliberately upset his own daughter. DELIBERATELY made the choice to comment on her weight.

Whether your 13 year old daughter is overweight or he is underweight......THIS is what I find so appalling

What sort of parent deliberately chooses to upset their child?

He is a twat

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 03:07

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 03:04

And so is this.

And so is the suggestion that OP stuffs and reward feeds DD.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 03:04

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:57

And you don’t get to be that size without seriously unhealthy mindset around food and just eating too much.

And so is this.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 03:04

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:56

I didn’t develop because of eating disorders, I could never weight the same as an adult man even if I wanted to which I don’t want to.
i didn’t have periods until I was nearly 16, I had fertility problems, period problems, I’ll probably have osteoarthritis and osteoporosis and god knows what else from being literally starving for most of my late teens and early twenties, the irony is I need to lose weight now and I need to do it without killing myself.
over eating is just as disordered and health damaging as under eating.
a 13 year old girl who weighs the same as an adult man, unless he is unhealthy is probably above a healthy weight that’s just a fact

No, it’s not a fact. It’s an assumption that you and many other have made, based on nothing. You don’t know the height or weight of either DP or DD and without that information it’s supposition, and in your own case, a fair bit of projection.

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:57

And you don’t get to be that size without seriously unhealthy mindset around food and just eating too much.

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:56

I didn’t develop because of eating disorders, I could never weight the same as an adult man even if I wanted to which I don’t want to.
i didn’t have periods until I was nearly 16, I had fertility problems, period problems, I’ll probably have osteoarthritis and osteoporosis and god knows what else from being literally starving for most of my late teens and early twenties, the irony is I need to lose weight now and I need to do it without killing myself.
over eating is just as disordered and health damaging as under eating.
a 13 year old girl who weighs the same as an adult man, unless he is unhealthy is probably above a healthy weight that’s just a fact

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 02:51

Honeychickpea · 29/12/2023 02:40

No, it is an observation that a 13 yr old who is heavier than an adult man almost certainly has an issue with eating. Anorexia is not the only eating disorder.

Some girls reach full adult size by their early teens. The majority of girls ( not boys) have stopped growing altogether by 15. If the Op’s DD is destined to have her mums build she could very well be heavier than a slight man. And anorexia is not the only eating disorder, but it is a killer. I know someone who had just such a build at that age who has been dead for many years because of these sorts of observations about her early development.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/12/2023 02:46

CarrotCake01 · 29/12/2023 02:17

Lets be honest, I think the fact you're avoiding mentioning her weight or clothes size etc indicates that she's probably overweight. You can't blame your partner for being shocked or concerned.

However I agree that it really doesn't sound like he approached the subject in a particularly helpful or sensitive way, so I'd be pretty cross too. There's a way to bring it up and to talk to her about it though and it sounds like now might be the time to do that rather than tip toe around the issue.

No. The reason OP hasn’t mentioned DD’s height, weight or clothes size is because she doesn’t want to put sensitive information like that onto an online forum. That, and the blindingly obvious - it wasn’t her DD’s weight she posted for advice on. It was leapt on right from the start and her actual question has been largely ignored in favour of hitting her with a barrage of questions entirely irrelevant to the advice she was asking for. And her partner - who she describes as slim - was ‘astounded’ that DD weighed as much as him. Which to me, indicates that she doesn’t look overweight.

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 02:42

Bujobug · 29/12/2023 02:40

Over eating to the point of ill health is disordered, funny it’s only us anorexics and bulmics are labelled with disorder.
hard for people to understand when food is everywhere.

eating or feeding others to the point you or they are having health problems or self esteem issues is disordered.
Stop eating or force feeding.
I’ve seen so many parents force feeding kids and threatening no pudding just take one more bite it’s crazy, just leave them alone and stop treating certain foods like they need to be earned, they don’t it’s all just food.

You are doing so much projecting here. Op has said nothing about pudding or force feeding or reward feeding.

GrannyRose15 · 29/12/2023 02:40

Is it a fact that she weighs more than him? If so then she needs to hear it. There may be better ways of putting it but don’t condemn him for telling the truth.