Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with DP after they upset DD?

320 replies

Violah · 28/12/2023 22:12

Sort of looking for advice on what to do but I think the damage will already be done.

DD13 was measuring her height and weight so that I could work out what size of clothing to order as she wanted a new coat.

She shouted her weight from another room so I could put it into the calculator. DP was astounded she weighed that much (more than him) to which I said before DD came through - do not make a big deal of this.

DD brought the scales through and weighed herself again and he pointed out to DD he weighed less than her.

DD left the room. I went to check on her and she was crying in bed. She pushed me away as I was tried to give her a cuddle. I tried to get across that she needn't worry about his stupid comment. But I know I've felt self-conscious all my life over weight so probably projecting those worries onto her.

I told DP off and I'm upset with him and on DDs behalf.

Any advice?

OP posts:
Anonymouseposter · 29/12/2023 10:29

This thread was never meant to be about whether or not her daughter is overweight. It is about whether she is unreasonable to be upset with her husband over making an issue of her weighing more than him when OP asked him not to. She also asked how she can try to minimise any effect on her daughter's confidence. OP is NBU to be upset with him. It's difficult to know what best to say to her daughter now. I wouldn't make a big deal of it but just say that he's quite short for a man and everyone carries weight differently.

Sodndashitall · 29/12/2023 10:15

Maybe try to explain to your DD that weight is not a helpful measure in general. My DS is technical borderline obese on BMI scale, this is because he is obsessed with the gym and is incredibly muscled. I can't even get my hand to span his biceps ! So his weight is heavier than normal due to his build as muscle weighs more than fat.
Women can often weigh more than equivalent height men depending on build. It's all very context dependent, how muscly they are, how big boobs are etc.
Same for PP saying she should not be his weight. If you look at her and she looks like a good healthy shape and build and especially if she has a good waist to hip ratio then all good.

Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 10:07

Violah · 29/12/2023 10:02

Because I immediately saw his reaction to her weight when she shouted it down from upstairs, and I put myself in her shoes.

I would not have appreciated a comment like that when I was her age. So I warned him not to say anything while I could hear her coming down stairs with the scales.

Throw the scales out! She doesn’t need to know how much she weighs. Don’t let her get hung up on a number that isn’t reflective of how fit and healthy she can be.

SEG152 · 29/12/2023 10:06

Sorry OP but you sound in denial. Yes your partner should have waited until your daughter wasn’t around to bring up the topic but it sounds like something that needs addressing.

weight isn’t just about vanity, this is her health for the rest of her life we’re talking about. Make positive changes now for her future.

Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 10:05

Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 10:00

There’s a huge difference though between a child being severely overweight and their size increasing in puberty which naturally correct itself as the teenage years progress. Too many women have issues in later life with yo-yo dieting because they were forced into prescriptive weight loss regimes at a young age when really they just needed to outgrow the puberty weight spurt.

Edited

To add, the average weight gain in puberty is 20lbs. Left alone, the weight will eventually dissipate. I wish I had known that when my dad called me fat for weighing more than him as a teen, which pushed me to start the first of many, many diet - the latest of which I started in Oct aged 51. ☹️

hellsbells99 · 29/12/2023 10:04

Zara sizing varies a lot!
my 2 DDs we’re discussing their weight with their male cousin over Christmas. All 3 are between 24 and 26 years old and all weigh the same. Male cousin is just over 6foot and DDs are 5’5” and 5’6”. Cousin is very slim build but sporty. Both girls are fit and healthy and buy size 10/12 clothes. Weight is pretty meaningless unless you look very overweight.

Violah · 29/12/2023 10:02

Because I immediately saw his reaction to her weight when she shouted it down from upstairs, and I put myself in her shoes.

I would not have appreciated a comment like that when I was her age. So I warned him not to say anything while I could hear her coming down stairs with the scales.

OP posts:
Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 10:00

Zfactorstar · 29/12/2023 09:35

Parents are the worst judges of children's weight. A lot of times they don't want to see the issue at hand. I've worked with people with severely overweight children (they themselves were overweight) who insist that there isn't a problem.

There’s a huge difference though between a child being severely overweight and their size increasing in puberty which naturally correct itself as the teenage years progress. Too many women have issues in later life with yo-yo dieting because they were forced into prescriptive weight loss regimes at a young age when really they just needed to outgrow the puberty weight spurt.

Purplewarrior · 29/12/2023 09:55

Your DP sounds like a nasty piece of work.

Violah · 29/12/2023 09:52

I explained earlier in the thread that I don't know what the sizing is like in zara.
Then I found they have a calc where you can put in height and weight and also use a slider scale to put in additional info with regards to how you like the fit- perfect to oversized.
That was the correct coat that someone linked.

When someone asked why would I post here on such a topic. I don't really feel like I had anyone in real life to ask for advice. Is there any nice places I could have gone instead? 🫣

OP posts:
whiteshutters · 29/12/2023 09:52

@Violah why did you ask her father NOT to comment on her weight? This tells me you know there is a bit of an issue.

Your words She's always been larger framed than other girls her age and so was I growing up. Ditto.

whiteshutters · 29/12/2023 09:49

DotAndCarryOne2 · 29/12/2023 01:52

But we’re not talking thirty years ago, we’re talking now. And I would think the average, intelligent parent - as the OP seems to be - is more than capable of determining whether or not their child is overweight.

You would think so except you see masses of young obese women with their equally obese children walking about. It's OK though as due to body positivity that's fine. 🙄

ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 29/12/2023 09:45

Why would you weigh yourself to work out your clothes size? You don't buy a '10 stone coat'.

Re. slim men, my 5'7 husband weighs 7.5 stone - small frame and not an ounce of fat on him (he has weighed that all his adult life and is now in his 60s). I weighed more than that when I was 13.

SemperIdem · 29/12/2023 09:44

@MummyJ36

Yes I have come across adults as you describe.

The op’s daughter is not an adult.

MummyJ36 · 29/12/2023 09:36

I literally can’t believe the amount of posters saying OP’s daughter must be grossly overweight. Have you never come across a man who is on the thin side? And a woman who is tall and broad? You know the two can exist in unison and be perfectly healthy in their own right? Jesus Christ. Honestly this is the kind of attitude that gives young girls eating disorders, it really is.

Zfactorstar · 29/12/2023 09:35

Parents are the worst judges of children's weight. A lot of times they don't want to see the issue at hand. I've worked with people with severely overweight children (they themselves were overweight) who insist that there isn't a problem.

Happilyobtuse · 29/12/2023 09:30

Violah · 29/12/2023 01:05

She would be mortified if I took her to the gp to be weighed. She would refuse to come I'm sure.

I like the advice some said here about chatting to her around her being upset over the comment. I feel like those moments where we chat are quite few and far between now as I barely see her what with working shifts, or her being busy in calls with friends or out with them.

It might be challenging to get her to talk to me. But I do make the most of those moments when they happen.

She very much wears what her peers are wearing and she confirmed that this coat from zara is one that some friends at school have. They go shopping to primark together as a group and some buy teenage stuff and some buy adult stuff.
I specifically remember her telling me that one friend in particular is really petite that she has to buy younger child's clothing. So she obviously has compared her size to smaller frames. Girls of the same age won't always fit in the same aged clothing and it's mad to think they all should.

Just look at the sizing inconsistencies in adult clothing even from the same shop. No wonder we feel like crap when stuff doesn't fit.

My younger dd7 is not the same body shape as me or DD13. She has always fitted into the age of clothing same as her age but after a growth spurt I to have to go up a size for length. Neither of my dds follow the average percentiles.

Also noticed with girls clothing they skimp on material. Everything's shorter in the sleeve or fitted round the body compared to boys clothing. Argh rambling on here.

I worry for girls these days with social media being like it is now.

Agreed that sizing is very skewed and kids often don’t wear the same age clothing as they are due to differing body proportions. My 3.5 year old still wears 2-3 years clothing and sometimes even 18-24 months clothing! While my 7 year old mostly wears age 7 clothes but as she is tall and skinny she does sometimes wear 8-9 years for leggings etc.

But hand on heart can you say your child is not overweight?! Is her BMI healthy, the range is 18-25. Since you now have her latest height and weight you can calculate it. I always teach my children that when someone says something you don’t like to you, before responding think whether there is any truth to it. If there is, you can take it as feed back and work on it. We don’t always like the things people say to us, but sometimes we need a wake up call.

Also I think if she is overweight then even though your partner has communicated the message in a bad way, you should first comfort her and then help her become the best version of herself. Being overweight will cause more problems with self esteem, confidence etc. as she grows up.

Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 08:10

SplendidUtterly · 29/12/2023 08:05

Is your boyfriend a withered looking hobbit? How is a 13 y/o girl bigger tham him? Lmao!

What a moronic comment. A teen DD who is tall and stocky and has gained puppy fat in puberty could easily weigh more than a slight, slim man who is only just a bit taller than 5ft 7, which is how OP describes the DP.

sashh · 29/12/2023 08:08

I've just put Simone Biles' height and weight in a BMI calculator. She is just on the border between normal and overweight. The world's greatest gymnast that is.

OP your partner is a dick, well he might not always be but for this he is. You are right to be upset, and so is your daughter.

SplendidUtterly · 29/12/2023 08:05

Is your boyfriend a withered looking hobbit? How is a 13 y/o girl bigger tham him? Lmao!

Bearbookagainandagain · 29/12/2023 07:59

Have you tried talking to your husband about it? If he made that comment, it might be that he has a different opinion about whether she seems to be at a healthy weight or not. It would be interesting to hear his perspective before doing anything else.

I had weight issues at that age and I agree that your husband shouldn't have made that comment. It's hurtful and damaging for young teens. But the fact is that a 13yo shouldn't weight more than an adult male (unless she is an athlete or something), so it's not unreasonable that he was shocked about it.

Bookworm1111 · 29/12/2023 07:44

PaperDoIIs · 28/12/2023 23:57

One comment won't cause long lasting damage. It just won't. If it's not just the one comment then you need to talk to him and come to an understanding. If her weight is actually fine,he needs to shut up. If it isn't if he must approach it he needs to do that in a sensitive way or leave it to you.

As for what to tell her , it all very much depends on what she thinks about herself , how she feels about herself and what she wants. This is what you need to find out and focus on and then go from there. Focus on health and fitness. It's just as bad telling her she's fine if she doesn't feel she is as telling her she isn't if she feels she is .It's natural this has upset her, just like any other stupid comment would, especially with a negative comparison.

Yes it can. One very similar comment about my weight at 15 was all it took to send me into a binge eating, yo-yo dieting spiral of which I still feel the effects 30 years later. You cannot be blithely dismissive of the impact here, especially as the DD’s reaction was to burst into tears. She knows what he meant.

I wish I had some advice on how to walk back on what’s happened, @Violah. I don’t know if my dad apologising for the comment he made would’ve made any difference at the time, as I was too focused on being heavier than him. Throwing away the scales could help though. I became obsessed with weighing myself afterward, thinking I was too heavy - if we didn’t have scales I wouldn’t have. My teen DD has never had access to any and has no body issues, thank god.

My heart goes out to your DD. Your DP was a fucking arse to say something when you asked him not to.

Justleaveitblankthen · 29/12/2023 06:36

You needed to weigh her before ordering clothes?!

Measuring yes, but what has weight got to do with anything? 🤔

Mummyoflittledragon · 29/12/2023 05:48

These come up really big op as they are meant to be oversized... The medium of the Molly Mae jacket fit fits about a size 16. Idk how big your dd wants it? https://www.zara.com/uk/en/leather-effect-cropped-biker-jacket-p04341826.html?v1=324595230

As for his comments, I hope you can talk to your dd about it and she can understand the comment was so stupid. My dd is 15 and has consistently been losing weight over the past couple of years. She was high on the centiles as a child and at 13. Some of her friends have filled out having been really skinny children. You really don’t know where your dd will end up and as long as she’s exercising well for her age and eating healthily, your ‘d’p needs to learn to button it.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 29/12/2023 05:08

I don't appear overweight but I actually am.
Appearance and fitting into clothes isn't the same as being healthy OP.

The few people who know my weight are shocked at the number to the point of not believing me. Have been told my scales are faulty/ I haven't read it properly.

You seem to be sticking your head in the sand over this. Putting her weight and height on here would give you different answers than you want to hear but may be helpful.

It a anonymous so goes to show you're not just sad about the comment but not ready to tackle her weight issue.