Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Etiquette about electric cars- views??

134 replies

AWanderingMinstrel · 28/12/2023 20:53

First thread, long term user. Just interested in views.
Given that more people are buying electric cars , what do you think will become the correct etiquette for charging when visitors come to your house?
Given that if someone comes to visit me in a petrol car, I don’t pay for their petrol to visit me ( should they need to fill up) what do you think is the right approach if someone arrives in an electric car to your home ( possibly staying overnight) has no more charge , and then charges their car enough to get home using your electricity??
AIBU- to not allow people to charge, you are not responsible for their costs to visit you
AINBU- visitors are coming to see you, their car needs charging, it’s convenient for them to charge during their visit to you, you bear the cost of their travel

OP posts:
StillWantingADog · 30/12/2023 10:40

We have been an EV family for nearly five years. I don’t think what you are describing will be that much of a “thing” tbh with car ranges these days typically being close to or over 300 Miles. We have lots of family members with EVs and they have never asked to charge at ours.
if hypothetically we stayed somewhere and wanted to use their electricity I would absolutely offer to reimburse (we have done this at airBNBs but not at the houses
or people we know). If someone wanted to use our electricity then I would happily offer. If they used a lot I’d expect them to mention reimbursement but I probably wouldn’t accept it unless it was a lot. Our overnight tariff is super cheap.

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 30/12/2023 10:34

Well most people won't have charging facilities unless they have an electric car themselves surely - there is no power where ours are parked and you can't trail a lead down the street. There's fast chargers available nearby for guests

HappiestSleeping · 30/12/2023 10:29

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2023 08:27

SMETS2 smart meters can switch between suppliers, that's no longer an issue. Octopus offer a time of use tariff and as a shift worker I find it quite useful. It's not much of an inconvenience to start cooking at 7pm. I pay quite a bit less than my parents do on average. Not everyone has a smart meter but most people could have one, it doesn't cost you anything to fit.

Edited

I am with British Gas, they only offer a time of use tariff for electric car users, or one other which is reduced rate at certain times on a Sunday.

Also, I've had two failed appointments for a smart meter where I had to take aa day off each time for which I don't get paid. They let me down both times on the day of the appointment. I gave up after that as I can't afford the loss of earnings.

I'm not meaning to be argumentative, just to point out that it isn't always as simple. My tariff suits my needs, and I don't intend to change it for the benefit of the odd visitor who happens to have an electric car. Per my previous post, I only know one, and they live two doors down with their own charge point, so unlikely to ever need to charge at my house.

clara778 · 30/12/2023 10:27

@OddBoots I think it's a great way to extend their life. The problem is still going to arise, millions of cars and each year, lots of batteries will retire. It's a ticking time bomb.

There's several companies in America who are attempting to scale up operations to disassemble batteries, but they are heavily funded. Uk has a company that got 3m from government, but it's a drop in the ocean for what will become a huge problem.

It needs to be addressed as the environmental impact creating these batteries is horrific.

MrDirtyBear · 30/12/2023 10:24

James from James and Kate YouTube channel, who does mobile servicing has gone from accepting people offering a free charge at their premises to knocking the cost of the charge off the bill.

As he's an all round delightful person with impeccable manners, I'd follow his example and calculate it at 30p per kwh consumed (or 110% of what has been charged as there are charging losses.

OddBoots · 30/12/2023 10:00

@clara778 that is a good point but what do you think of suggestions of EV batteries to be re-purposed as domestic batteries?

I already have a domestic battery and it has been great this year not only for solar use but for shifting our energy use to times when the grid is lower carbon (so when it is windy and not peak use).

EV batteries even from the original Prius hybrid and early Leaf days still have enough useable capacity to work well domestically either solo or stacked.

MaudOHara · 30/12/2023 09:41

I just checked my smart meter readings for last night where I charged up from about 10%. I use a standard 3 pin plug as no dedicated fast charger.

It cost me £4.20 to charge to full. Mine is a very very old Leaf with low range so would only charge at someone else's if I needed the charge to get home.

I don't think there is a cost difference when using a fast charger or a 3 pin plug as it only takes the amount of electricity that the car needs.

clara778 · 30/12/2023 09:31

@OddBoots Because it is very expensive to recycle batteries, currently most get shipped to china.
There hasn't been funding to build the facilities needed. It will be decades before the industry catches up. Some one needs to fund it and that will be tax breaks and government grants. That has to be recouped.

It's very complicated to strip batteries, it's not like melting down gold.

gingercat02 · 30/12/2023 09:09

Charging at night only costs us about £4 as we have an EV tariff, but daytime would be loads more. I would have no issue with overnight but wouldn't be keen on a full daytime charge

OddBoots · 30/12/2023 08:59

@clara778 why do you think that when the batteries contain all the valuable minerals they do? It is more like disposing of jewellery than disposing of a fridge. So much science is going into the refreshing and recycling of batteries as doing so is so much cheaper than creating new batteries.

clara778 · 30/12/2023 08:51

I also agree with PP cheap overnight electric will go, I also think that there will be massive costs dealing with all the batteries in the future.
Some sort of disposal tax will arrive, it will be a bit like having to pay to dispose of your fridge.

clara778 · 30/12/2023 08:45

I think if someone has driven hundreds of miles to see you and is staying over and you have a fast charger and cheap overnight electric. Fine.

Anything else will be considered rude. The range for electric vehicles will only increase and there should be no need to ask. Someone popping in for a few hours, well they would be taking the piss to ask.

faffadoodledo · 30/12/2023 08:41

cordeliaflynne · 30/12/2023 08:17

I don't have an EV but I found the OPs original point interesting enough to look at the thread. However, the most interesting part scrolling through has been the vast difference in everyone's estimated of the cost of charging an EV. It does make me wonder how that impacts the calculation of the economics of EV ownership.

The reality is it does vary hugely. These aren't just estimates. A tiny little EV will cost around £15. My great heavy 4WD volvo will cost double. That's on a home charger. Out in the world of public fast chargers both those figures will rise.

OddBoots · 30/12/2023 08:40

Anyotherdude · 29/12/2023 00:03

@Tiggles you are adorably naive if you think that cheaper electricity will still be available once everyone (or even most) are driving EV’s: the Gov’t will be losing billions of revenue on tax from fossil fuels - where do you think they’ll recoup that loss from?

You may be surprised to know how much the government subsidises fossil fuels (https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/09/fossil-fuels-more-support-uk-than-renewables-since-2015 so that may not be the issue you would think.

We don't have an electric car yet (although we may get one next year, we are still deciding) but we have installed a charger on the drive for visitors to use as the alternative is a cord out of a window which isn't great for both keeping the house warm and secure. We could have had a 3 pin socket put out the front for cheaper but we thought it better to just bite the bullet.

Fossil fuels received £20bn more UK support than renewables since 2015

Exclusive: One-fifth of money given directly to fossil fuel industry was to support new extraction and mining

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/09/fossil-fuels-more-support-uk-than-renewables-since-2015

WonderingWanda · 30/12/2023 08:36

Well I don't have an outdoor plug socket and I won't be leaving a ground floor window open all night so they can charge it up the road in the village car park where there's a fast charging point they can pay for.

Brumbies · 30/12/2023 08:31

I dont expect someone else to pay my petrol, hence I don't expect to pay to fuel their car!

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2023 08:27

HappiestSleeping · 30/12/2023 08:22

I know economy 7 existed for years, however, that was years ago. Since the cost of energy has risen recently, exacerbated by Ukraine, it has actually be quite difficult to get to switch to a time of use tariff that is cost effective. My friend had trouble and could only do so once they had their car charger fitted. Also, why would you bother if you don't have an electric car, or some other reason to need such a tariff? Surely most people won't switch on the off-chance of having a visitor who needs to charge their car?

Also, not everyone has a smart meter, and even if you do have one, you may need to switch supplier for the best time of use tariff which may render the smart meter useless. They don't all work with all suppliers.

Edited

SMETS2 smart meters can switch between suppliers, that's no longer an issue. Octopus offer a time of use tariff and as a shift worker I find it quite useful. It's not much of an inconvenience to start cooking at 7pm. I pay quite a bit less than my parents do on average. Not everyone has a smart meter but most people could have one, it doesn't cost you anything to fit.

Zanatdy · 30/12/2023 08:27

I’d never charge visitors for charging their car no. I mean if I had an electric car though I’d personally offer to pay, but some people just don’t think. I just couldn’t charge them though so no from me

Ktime · 30/12/2023 08:23

I think it depends on the guest.

If it’s someone who I reciprocate visits with them I wouldn’t charge them as I’d charge my car at their house too.

If it was someone like a boiler company coming to fix my boiler I wouldn’t expect them to ask to ask to charge their car and if they did I would expect them to pay me.

HappiestSleeping · 30/12/2023 08:22

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2023 07:24

Anyone with a smart meter can sign up to a time-of-use tariff. Never mind that Economy 7 has existed for years

I know economy 7 existed for years, however, that was years ago. Since the cost of energy has risen recently, exacerbated by Ukraine, it has actually be quite difficult to get to switch to a time of use tariff that is cost effective. My friend had trouble and could only do so once they had their car charger fitted. Also, why would you bother if you don't have an electric car, or some other reason to need such a tariff? Surely most people won't switch on the off-chance of having a visitor who needs to charge their car?

Also, not everyone has a smart meter, and even if you do have one, you may need to switch supplier for the best time of use tariff which may render the smart meter useless. They don't all work with all suppliers.

cordeliaflynne · 30/12/2023 08:17

I don't have an EV but I found the OPs original point interesting enough to look at the thread. However, the most interesting part scrolling through has been the vast difference in everyone's estimated of the cost of charging an EV. It does make me wonder how that impacts the calculation of the economics of EV ownership.

Papillon23 · 30/12/2023 07:40

I'd be happy to let someone charge at my house as long as it was under about £15? Even over, I'd probably suck it up as driving a long way for a visit is a total pain.

But I'm comfortably off - I'd also expect people to offer to pay and to be careful who they were asking as you don't want to put others out.

faffadoodledo · 30/12/2023 07:35

This is becoming a live issue for me. We have a holiday let next door to our house. We also have an EV charge point bc we have an electric volvo. We will from this year be flagging that to future guests that we have a charger. The letting company has suggested a £30 extra charge per week per car. We will share the charger with guests.
Our volvo costs up to £30 to charge. It's a big car. Now, if the visitors come in a tiny EV we will likely be ok. We figure a guest will plug in on arrival (we live in west cornwall), and the night before they leave. But if they have a car like ours we'll be out of pocket. I think they are more likely to have a bigger car if they're coming on holiday with a family to W Cornwall. I have mentioned this to the letting company and we're going to keep an eye on things.
But back to the original questions with guests who aren't paying guests - I think the onus is to offer if it's your vehicle. I mean you wouldn't plug in without asking, so the conversaton would be 'would you mind us plugging in? And please let us pay'. I would demur but be happy they'd asked.

Londonrach1 · 30/12/2023 07:34

I wouldn't due to fire risk. There's local charging stations near by with the correct chargers...

LlynTegid · 30/12/2023 07:33

I think there will be an expectation that a request is accepted. And I expect more requests will come from people with cars more expensive than average, and from SUV owners (most of whom cannot drive their vehicle properly and should not have one).