Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Etiquette about electric cars- views??

134 replies

AWanderingMinstrel · 28/12/2023 20:53

First thread, long term user. Just interested in views.
Given that more people are buying electric cars , what do you think will become the correct etiquette for charging when visitors come to your house?
Given that if someone comes to visit me in a petrol car, I don’t pay for their petrol to visit me ( should they need to fill up) what do you think is the right approach if someone arrives in an electric car to your home ( possibly staying overnight) has no more charge , and then charges their car enough to get home using your electricity??
AIBU- to not allow people to charge, you are not responsible for their costs to visit you
AINBU- visitors are coming to see you, their car needs charging, it’s convenient for them to charge during their visit to you, you bear the cost of their travel

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AdobeWanKenobi · 31/12/2023 11:39

Backtomyoldname · 30/12/2023 12:09

This reminded me of something......

The quote, rating etc is using a mains socket charger, very slow ie overnight in a smaller capacity car. (sometimes called a Granny Charger) A day+ for a bigger batteried car that is nearly flat.

2.4 Kw is fine out of a socket. It's what a kettle uses, less than a 3 bar radiator. It's 10 amps. But for a prolonged period......

If the plug and/or socket is dirty it can get very hot. Ours has overheated an external socket to the point of it needing to be replaced. Keep your plug clean, quiet WD40 into the socket and pull the plug in and out a few times.

I’m really hoping that’s a typo there because WD40 is flammable and should never come into contact with electrical sockets.

facep · 30/12/2023 19:24

Nobody has ever asked but we have an electric charger at home and would happily let guests use it. I say that from the privileged position of not worrying (excessively) about bills.

StillWantingADog · 30/12/2023 16:49

ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 30/12/2023 12:23

I'd be more worried about the security risk of having to trail a plug out of the window, since we don't have an outdoor one, than the cost. I'd also worry it might short if it rained. I think I'd say they could charge during the day but not overnight. I wouldn't ask for costs as a one off but I would for any frequent visitors. No one I know on visiting terms has an EV though.

The rain thing is not a thing. I get why you might think it’s a concern but, honestly, it isn’t.

security is a valid concern though, depending on where you live. We have outdoor power sockets but appreciate not everyone will.

StillWantingADog · 30/12/2023 16:46

zaazaazoo · 30/12/2023 13:14

Because it takes far longer to charge than to fill a tank with petrol.

Also it’s far more efficient (and usually cheaper) and better for the car, to charge more slowly, say overnight. You CAN rapid charge a powerful EV in 10-20 minutes but do it all the time and you’ll suffer some battery degradation.

ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 30/12/2023 15:13

Mumsnet is populated by people who never need to eat or drink on a journey,have bladders of steel and co drivers with whom they do Le Mans style changeovers and thus never need to stop for more than 30 seconds no matter how long their journey

😂

MrsAvocet · 30/12/2023 14:57

You don't even really need to leave a lot of extra time for charging. Ok, I know Mumsnet is populated by people who never need to eat or drink on a journey,have bladders of steel and co drivers with whom they do Le Mans style changeovers and thus never need to stop for more than 30 seconds no matter how long their journey, but for us mere mortals who do like a snack, a rest and a wee from time to time, you can generally charge when you're stopped anyway.
We did a roughly 400 mile round trip to relatives yesterday. We charged for maybe 20 mins on the way down whilst I got a coffee and about 10 mins on the way back during a toilet stop. If you ignore the 30 seconds or so spent plugging and unplugging the charger, charging added absolutely zero journey time as we would have made both those stops anyway.
Yes, it can take quite a long time to charge a completely empty battery to full depending on the car and the charger but the chances of ever needing to do that mid journey are incredibly small. You do need to change your mindset somewhat as you generally don't want to get yourself into the situation where you need to do the equivalent of filling up a full tank of petrol, unless you're doing it at home on your own cheap rate electricity, but it's perfectly possible to travel long distances in an EV without needing to devote a lot of time to charging. We do the vast majority of our charging when we are doing something else, or asleep, it's not like you have to stand there holding the charging lead in! It's best for most batteries to be kept between 20% and 80% charged most of the time anyway, you don't have to wait til it's empty before you recharge. You just need to think a bit differently to when you're driving an ICE vehicle.
Our other car is diesel and I have got so accustomed to the EV now that it's going to the petrol station that I view as an inconvenience, not charging the EV.

DdraigGoch · 30/12/2023 14:25

HappiestSleeping · 30/12/2023 10:29

I am with British Gas, they only offer a time of use tariff for electric car users, or one other which is reduced rate at certain times on a Sunday.

Also, I've had two failed appointments for a smart meter where I had to take aa day off each time for which I don't get paid. They let me down both times on the day of the appointment. I gave up after that as I can't afford the loss of earnings.

I'm not meaning to be argumentative, just to point out that it isn't always as simple. My tariff suits my needs, and I don't intend to change it for the benefit of the odd visitor who happens to have an electric car. Per my previous post, I only know one, and they live two doors down with their own charge point, so unlikely to ever need to charge at my house.

On that score I can recommend Octopus' customer service.

Not that it will ever be practical to charge an electric car at my home anyway, the nearest parking is on the other side of the street and probably occupied anyway. I once had to park all the way down the bottom of the hill, this village wasn't designed for cars full stop. That's why I got rid of the damned thing and started cycling to work instead.

Brumbies · 30/12/2023 14:02

@zaazaazoo

So allow extra time for charging.

bellac11
I think this is a bit of a cheek to be honest. Why dont they fill up at service chargers, just in the same way you would with petrol?

Because it takes far longer to charge than to fill a tank with petrol.

CurlewKate · 30/12/2023 13:25

I would expect someone to offer-but I would refuse.
I suppose it's not absolutely new etiquette- I wonder what people did about stabling horses?

zaazaazoo · 30/12/2023 13:14

bellac11 · 28/12/2023 21:29

I think this is a bit of a cheek to be honest. Why dont they fill up at service chargers, just in the same way you would with petrol?

Because it takes far longer to charge than to fill a tank with petrol.

zigzag716746zigzag · 30/12/2023 13:05

faffadoodledo · 30/12/2023 08:41

The reality is it does vary hugely. These aren't just estimates. A tiny little EV will cost around £15. My great heavy 4WD volvo will cost double. That's on a home charger. Out in the world of public fast chargers both those figures will rise.

I guess that raises interesting questions about assumptions made.

So I’m assuming yours is an EX90 with a 110kwh battery. 119kwh at 28p per kWh would be about £30 for a full charge, as you say. But that assumes you’re charging on a standard capped tariff.

However you also say “on a home charger”. I don’t know anyone with a home charger who doesn’t have an overnight or smart tariff. For example ours is about 7p per kWh regardless of what time of day it is charged, so long as it is done as a ‘smart charge”. So if you were charging the EX90 from empty to full at ours it would be £7.70. My car is 77kwh so a full charge is £5.40. And of course normally I am topping up from 20% to 80%, so about £3.

I have done 1000 miles his month and it has cost £32 in total.

I just thought it might be useful to see the difference, for those asking why it varies so wildly. And what that might mean for the etiquette of charging because it could cost a lot more on different tariffs, and for different battery capacities.

Someone topping up a Leaf just enough to get them home might be a very different prospect to a full charge on a 110 kwh battery.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 30/12/2023 12:43

faffadoodledo · 30/12/2023 08:41

The reality is it does vary hugely. These aren't just estimates. A tiny little EV will cost around £15. My great heavy 4WD volvo will cost double. That's on a home charger. Out in the world of public fast chargers both those figures will rise.

Exactly, it can vary massively. My car has an 84 KwH battery. If I charge at home overnight a full charge will cost less than £10. But during the day at home that’d be nearer £25. At a the cheapest slow public charger nearby it’d be just over £30, and at at a fast charger on the motorway a full charge would be over £60. I use fast chargers maybe once every few months - the rest is done at home / destinations, so I don’t worry about the fast charger cost as it’s so infrequent.

ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 30/12/2023 12:23

I'd be more worried about the security risk of having to trail a plug out of the window, since we don't have an outdoor one, than the cost. I'd also worry it might short if it rained. I think I'd say they could charge during the day but not overnight. I wouldn't ask for costs as a one off but I would for any frequent visitors. No one I know on visiting terms has an EV though.

Backtomyoldname · 30/12/2023 12:09

JennyMatrix · 30/12/2023 11:08

I'd offer 33p per kwh x 2.4kw = 80p an hour.

This reminded me of something......

The quote, rating etc is using a mains socket charger, very slow ie overnight in a smaller capacity car. (sometimes called a Granny Charger) A day+ for a bigger batteried car that is nearly flat.

2.4 Kw is fine out of a socket. It's what a kettle uses, less than a 3 bar radiator. It's 10 amps. But for a prolonged period......

If the plug and/or socket is dirty it can get very hot. Ours has overheated an external socket to the point of it needing to be replaced. Keep your plug clean, quiet WD40 into the socket and pull the plug in and out a few times.

StillWantingADog · 30/12/2023 12:06

@Winnading
”issues reported” doesn’t mean not working. It means someone has reported an issue of some kind at some point recently but it may no longer be relevant eg. Been fixed. It is often that the charger is working slower than it should be. Or that the payment mechanism is being a pain. The comments usually make it clear what’s going on- most will be working.

but you do have a broader point that you cannot sadly assume that the location of a chargepoint will mean a trouble free charge is possible. Unlike the presence of a petrol station which will mean in 99.9% of cases you can get fuel. In the case of a public charge point the chances are probably around 80%, but you may need to wait.

Backtomyoldname · 30/12/2023 12:01

An interesting question. The answer will possibly change with time, adoption of electric cars and their general range.

We only know 3 other family members with electric cars.
Nephew is unlikely to visit us but if he did I'd offer him a charge. Having one at his is unlikely as no point of his own.
BIL and SIL. We go to theirs more often than they come to us. He always offers us a plug in - fortunate as it's towards the end of our comfortable range. They've plugged in at ours en route North.
Daughter - she always plugs in at ours - she always only seems to have 20 miles or less to go. She's no charger of her own or space - terraced house.

I'm a part time carer for my Mum and plug into hers via 3 pin plug so overnight. Means I can get back home, take her out etc. Her bills are huge, storage heaters, 25+ deg C, plus fan heaters so a fivers worth is a drop in the ocean.

I can't see many others I know needing this. Indeed some friends would rather walk barefoot than even sit in it.

If friends A had an electric car and B had come a distance I'd offer.

Winnading · 30/12/2023 11:54

I have just looked on the zap app thingy. There is no pay for charge point accessible to the public within a mile. Which is weird, cos I live in a suburb, outside of that mile are loads of charge points. One is on a street the rest are at supermarkets and gyms. Plenty have "issues reported" which I assume means out of order? I know there are private ones dotted about inside the mile but for company use or personal use.
Also looked at government/local council guidelines and running a cable across paths is not allowed.

Would I let someone charge from a plug socket inside my house, yes. I would not take payment. But someone short of money will be struggling to say no to cash for charging.
I foresee many threads on here worrying about accepting money or not. And cables across streets or not etc.

Caspianberg · 30/12/2023 11:19

@JennyMatrix - why? That’s a very random number. Cost and time taken completely depends on car battery size, and it take a longer to charger 80-100% compared to 20-80%.

our electric costs 0.08cents per kw. And we have a 22kw charger. So it costs €6.16 to fully charge our 77kw car from 0%. And would take 3.5 hrs approx to charge a completely empty car. So 80p an hour would only be around 1/2 the cost.

It would cost you 0.77cents per per kw at nearest motorway charger, costing €59 to fully charge, but that’s a 350kw charger, so would only take 22mins a for a full charge.

So at home you get cheap charge, and it’s easily charged by the time someone came for lunch a few hours. But motorway offers fast convenience if you’re not stopping.

Starzinsky · 30/12/2023 11:12

Let them charge and tell then the cost assuming you have a ev charger with an app that will calculate the cost based on your tariff. It will be cheaper than a public charger so the visitor benefits from the generosity of letting them use the charge over a public one.

JennyMatrix · 30/12/2023 11:08

I'd offer 33p per kwh x 2.4kw = 80p an hour.

TitaniasAss · 30/12/2023 11:01

I would feel like I was taking the piss expecting someone else to pay for charging my car. Most people would feel they needed to refuse reimbursement too. We stayed at relatives over Christmas but charged in the way then went to services on the way home for lunch and to charge again. I wouldn't expect anyone else to pay for charging my car.

DRS1970 · 30/12/2023 10:57

Interesting point. But I think people will plan to charge at home or public charge points. I don't think many would expect to top up their car free of charge whenever they visit you - except in emergencies.

JenniferJuniper80 · 30/12/2023 10:50

We actually drive an electric car and love it.
We would and have charged other peoples cars overnight and it cost about £7.00 Maybe that's too much for some folk, but for us it was very doable. Also there are ample charged points all over the country so if you don't want to charge them, send them to a charge point.

FizzyStream · 30/12/2023 10:46

We have an electric car and when my dad and stepmum come to visit about every 6-8 weeks they do a full charge but they give us money for it. Even though we don't ask for it they insist. Works well for us.

We'd let them charge up regardless but on a regular basis I think it'd be a bit cheeky without at least offering some remuneration.

MrDirtyBear · 30/12/2023 10:42

Charging facilities == socket. Nothing more fancy than that. But yeah, without a drive and if there isn't "lamp post" chargers, you have to rely on the nearby rapid chargers, much like you would a petrol station.

Swipe left for the next trending thread