Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just throw out most of the toys and start over?

155 replies

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 19:15

I know this is my own fault but we are in a toy nightmare. Countless jigsaws with missing pieces, toys that have several different pieces (eg toy car transporter with several different cars but all of them all over the place and don’t know how to find them amongst the several thousand other toy cars.)

Obviously some toys will survive the cull but is it really awful just to throw most of them away and start over?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MamaGhina · 28/12/2023 21:00

Sell it on Facebook marketplace. Tip it out of the box, take photos and list it for £10 as a job lot (box not included). People buy this stuff to split up and re-sell. I’ve had lots of success over the years.

If that fails, list it as free collection only. Honestly, someone will come get it.

LeonoraFlorence · 28/12/2023 20:59

The children will likely know what goes with what! My DDs know each and every tiny piece by heart it seems, even though they have thousands of toys!
If they’re unsure, look the toy up online and you’ll see photos of what should go with what.

uclpp · 28/12/2023 20:59

I would have a go at rough sorting.

All cars together
All animals together
All jigsaws together

etc

Then once you have done that it might look a bit better.

I wouldn't throw or get rid - your dc probably enjoys the toys even if bits are broken or missing or with the wrong toy.

And don't beat yourself up about this.

Lovewinemorethanhusband · 28/12/2023 20:59

I go through our playroom every 6 months or so, any toys/puzzles/games that are missing pieces or broken etc get put in recycling! Don't know why people hold on to stuff that's missing bits in our case the dog eats puzzle bits left on the floor !

RoachFish · 28/12/2023 20:59

ladybossmum · 28/12/2023 20:42

This is ridiculous! So you never throw away any missing or broken items at all because you’re saving the planet?
How about the fact that children can’t play effectively (which is an important part of their development) in a cluttered and overwhelmed space?

Well, I do my best to avoid buying plastic things. My kids are grown now but other than lego they had barely any plastic toys. In this case there is just waaaay too many toys so they aren’t treasured or looked after so nobody has the time to sort through them but if they did I’m sure they will find the missing pieces and the toys can be used or given away again. The OP wants to chuck it out and buy new toys. It’s just very far from my reality and I personally couldn’t do that but I know some people doesn’t see a problem with that.

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 20:58

I don’t think it looks that bad from the photos. What do you want to end up with?

IfTheresTeaTheresHope · 28/12/2023 20:56

I don’t think that you should just throw away their possessions. My dad would cull my toys and I would get so upset, no matter how much I pleaded or loved a toy if he decided it had to go there was no negotiation. I couldn’t do it to my children, everything that they have got rid of has been their decision, I’d obviously explain broken toys or those with pieces missing weren’t any good and they would agree to dispose of those toys but anything else was their decision to keep or re home.

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 20:54

@crumblingschools Of course it matters because I don’t live in Buckingham palace.

If that was the only thing that was a bit excessive that would be fine but as it is there are four huge boxes filled with toys, and four drawers, and that’s for one child (the baby isn’t massively into toys yet) but when she is it will get a bit out of control.

Believe me, I don’t want to be horrible or anything like that. But look at those photos - it really isn’t sustainable.

OP posts:
beetr00 · 28/12/2023 20:53

@Malteasercheesecake if you need to start again and establish a possibly, more rigorous "toy sifting" regime in the future, then do what's best for you.

It is understandably, overwhelming to have so much "stuff" that's not even complete, even if you would like to pass it on.

It is NOT awful, it is practical. Good luck

Occasional2023 · 28/12/2023 20:52

DragonCatcher · 28/12/2023 20:46

Put half of the good toys in to a large container or bag (bin bag will do!) and then put it away in storage (garage/loft/under the bed) so you only have half of them in your house. If your DC hasn't asked for any of the missing items by Easter, sell or donate them. Or, you could swap them so the stored ones become the play ones and continue like this every 3 to 4 months so it feels like new toys! Much more manageable for tidying too.

Anything with small parts goes in a small/medium/large labelled zip wallet. E.g. Duplo sets, all toy cars, animals, dinosaurs, colouring pens, jigsaws. Throw out any incomplete jigsaws. Throw out the jigsaw boxes and just cut out the front picture part so you know what the puzzle is and pop it in the zip wallet. Same for board games or the Orchard Toy games that are popular.

It will be a bit of a job initially but once it is done you will have so much less to clear away in the future that you'll thank yourself.

Yes I think this kind of system works well. A bit of effort required initially but in the long run everything feels more manageable. When I had to do a sort out I had a plastic box to put bits that had got separated from the puzzle or game. Great sense of satisfaction to put a missing puzzle piece back into a toddler wooden puzzle and then decide if to keep or donate it to charity.(Having a close connection to a charity shop, I would never donate a broken toy or incomplete jigsaw.).

LegoDeathTrap · 28/12/2023 20:51

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 20:31

Do the play with the Lego @LegoDeathTrap?

Yes, very nicely and imaginatively. But we have a box of general Lego pieces that we bought 4y ago, and another we inherited from a friend, so I wanted to keep the small sets (City, Friends, Starwars pieces) separate and neat. No way. In fact, we don’t buy them that anymore because it seems so wasteful to buy a special set and have it dissolve in the sea of pieces, but they still get them as presents.

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 20:49

Does it matter if he has 4 fire engines?

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 20:47

And while I have bought DS some toys, I am definitely not the only or main culprit.

OP posts:
DragonCatcher · 28/12/2023 20:46

Put half of the good toys in to a large container or bag (bin bag will do!) and then put it away in storage (garage/loft/under the bed) so you only have half of them in your house. If your DC hasn't asked for any of the missing items by Easter, sell or donate them. Or, you could swap them so the stored ones become the play ones and continue like this every 3 to 4 months so it feels like new toys! Much more manageable for tidying too.

Anything with small parts goes in a small/medium/large labelled zip wallet. E.g. Duplo sets, all toy cars, animals, dinosaurs, colouring pens, jigsaws. Throw out any incomplete jigsaws. Throw out the jigsaw boxes and just cut out the front picture part so you know what the puzzle is and pop it in the zip wallet. Same for board games or the Orchard Toy games that are popular.

It will be a bit of a job initially but once it is done you will have so much less to clear away in the future that you'll thank yourself.

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 20:46

I can’t think of a single particular toy DS has ever asked for. They are mostly cars, tractors, fire engines etc. I’m not suggesting throwing every single one out but he wouldn’t be devastated at the loss of a fire engine when he has about four others, if you see what I mean.

OP posts:
SALWARP2023 · 28/12/2023 20:43

Are they your toys? If not then no you should not throw them away. However, try sorting through toys when you watch TV or are waiting for the dinner to cook. Broken stuff, throw away, otherwise, put lots in a box or bag and if the kids don't ask after them for 6 months, feel free to throw away. I actually find sorting and decluttering relaxing.

ladybossmum · 28/12/2023 20:43

@RoachFish nursery and charities don’t want other people's old crap that can’t actually be played with

ladybossmum · 28/12/2023 20:42

This is ridiculous! So you never throw away any missing or broken items at all because you’re saving the planet?
How about the fact that children can’t play effectively (which is an important part of their development) in a cluttered and overwhelmed space?

RoachFish · 28/12/2023 20:38

It’s pretty much all plastic toys. It will take hundreds of years for that to decompose on a landfill somewhere on the planet. If you are going to buy so many environmentally unfriendly things at least make sure they get maximum usage and sort them out and donate to a nursery or charity shop. It’s the only planet your children will have to live on.

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 20:35

@Occasional2023 i can do the following

  1. chuck quite a lot.
  2. leave everything as it is
  3. Try to sort
  4. a mix of the above.

At no point have I said I am definitely going to do anything. But you keep coming back insisting I am going to throw it all away and why did I even ask Hmm to be honest, while it isn’t just the house getting me down, someone being like that for no good reason is pretty upsetting.

OP posts:
Derb · 28/12/2023 20:31

I always have a massive, tidy, sort and toy cull right before birthdays and Xmas.

I find my kids get overwhelmed with too much so we don't go overboard and buying more until we have space. Most goes to charity, given away or binned if can't be used.

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 20:31

Do the play with the Lego @LegoDeathTrap?

LegoDeathTrap · 28/12/2023 20:28

YANBU.

DS7 and DD5 mixed up their lovely new Lego sets before they even finished building them. I found a new Switch controller in the sofa the day after it was opened. Drives me insane.

I’ve given up on toys and just do other bits of the house while DH and DC sort toys. They are crap at it though so we end up in more mess. I just can’t make it “my” job or responsibility because then I’ll be permanently frustrated.

PurpleBugz · 28/12/2023 20:27

Incredibly lazy and terrible for the planet.

I have a system where I have a missing parts box I throw things in as I go then periodically spend the time putting each bit back in its box. Also have a few game/toys sat on top of toy cupboard that have missing parts after a couple months up there without finding the bits I do recycle them (orchard toys let you order missing bits!).

For jigsaws not unreasonable to start over if you recycle them. I'm very eco aware and feel guilty but jigsaws take literally hours and hours to sort if you own lots. I gave up and binned 4 or so last year Constantly trying to sort them out made me irritable far too often

Occasional2023 · 28/12/2023 20:26

Malteasercheesecake · 28/12/2023 20:21

I’ve said the opposite @Occasional2023 .

I am getting the impression you want me to say I’ll throw them all out so you can berate me. Don’t you?

Apologies if I have misunderstood. You indicated that it would take you a long time to sort the toys out, and we all can agree that charity shops do not want toys with bits missing or broken. So I don't quite understand what you were intending to do. If the unsorted toys are not to go to charity then where are they going if not the bin? . I acknowledge that you intend to sort out and keep the train set. I hope that you can find a happy medium and importantly that your son is not upset by whatever happens.