Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get my brother fired

170 replies

Hooplahooping · 28/12/2023 18:56

A couple of months ago my brother told me he looked at my students files while he was working in the student office (he’s doing a masters at the uni I did my under grad at yrs ago - and is working in admin there part time while studying

I brushed it off at the time as poor judgement. But it bothered me sufficiently that I requested my own records to see what was on file there which arrived today.

  • All my transcripts + degree grades etc
  • A disciplinary panel record from when I sloppily referenced an essay + had to discuss plagerism with faculty and re submit.
  • a disciplinary record for poor seminar attendance and ‘attendance agreement’
  • a letter from my GP about anxiety
  • a letter from Marie Stopes about a pregnancy termination which required absence from said seminar series I’d signed an attendance agreement.
  • some standard halls of residence + student loan details.

I am truly not ashamed of 19 year old me - nor is any of it info that would explode my life if the world knows (DH knows everything anyway) - but that doesn’t mean that I would chose to share that information widely. Certainly not with a brother who I am not particularly close to.

I’m happy now, I have a happy balanced life with DH and two lovely DDs

what was he thinking? Is he trying to secretly shame me? Hang it over my head to make me feel bad?

He’s extremely brittle and if I ask him about it further he’ll cry and make excuse and melt into a puddle.

I think I’m just going to sit down and tell my parents all the potentially upsetting stuff just so I feel like I have control of the information. I’m not concerned that it will change their opinion of me.

I am furious though. I want to tell the university and get him fired.

how dare he? I’m so fed up with treading on eggshells around him because ‘life is harder for him’

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · 28/12/2023 23:37

titchy · 28/12/2023 20:15

They certainly can hold onto stuff that long. GDPR is an excuse for shitty record keeping.

GDPR in principle is great, but yes good god it is (mis)used for justifying shitty record keeping practices.

Gardeningtime · 28/12/2023 23:37

You need to try to stop caring so much. As an onlooker I read that list and think so?so what if he knows. So what if he tells your parents, you’re a grown up. Not a teen any more. If he does, you just say, so what, it was two decades ago. You’re too 0ld to play “my brother is going to tell on me.”

honestly. Let it go. Stop,investing so much energy in it. Yes if he’s read it it’s bad, a breach of privacy but not something to go running to your parents to fess up about.

Snowdogsmitten · 28/12/2023 23:34

Hooplahooping · 28/12/2023 23:02

This is the part I am most angry about.

I’m not ashamed of the actual information. I’m furious that he dropped into conversation that he’d accessed privileged info so casually. It ties in to a pattern of compwtititive behaviour from him. He needs to make himself the ‘winner’.

That I got a drank-too-much 2:2 seems to be a source of solace to him when people say something positive about me.

I try and boost him up, he tries to tear me down. I’ve tried to be vulnerable. He’s gone digging for more information to support his negative narrative about me.

this is eye opening for me.

You sure you don’t want to get the weasley little fucker sacked?

Notalldogs23 · 28/12/2023 23:31

You say he's your brother so you love him, but I don't think he has your best interests at heart - he resents you and puts you down. Don't share your vulnerabilities with him - he may well throw them back in your face when it suits him, I know my awful brother did.

I think this is a good opportunity to put some distance between the two of you, he is very unlikely to change and become a decent brother, and it's not your role to be his emotional punchbag.

Hooplahooping · 28/12/2023 23:02

Ramalangadingdong · 28/12/2023 21:35

Something I find quite worrying is why he told you what he did.

It is one thing to have done it, but then you wouldn't tell another soul would you? Not even the person you'd looked up. You'd be too embarrassed and keep it to yourself. Unless you wanted to get one over on them.

Why do you think he told you, op?

This is the part I am most angry about.

I’m not ashamed of the actual information. I’m furious that he dropped into conversation that he’d accessed privileged info so casually. It ties in to a pattern of compwtititive behaviour from him. He needs to make himself the ‘winner’.

That I got a drank-too-much 2:2 seems to be a source of solace to him when people say something positive about me.

I try and boost him up, he tries to tear me down. I’ve tried to be vulnerable. He’s gone digging for more information to support his negative narrative about me.

this is eye opening for me.

OP posts:
tianabiscuit · 28/12/2023 22:57

Tell the university that it has come to your attention that sensitive information from your historic file has been searched and read.

Let them deal with the rest of it.

GreigeO · 28/12/2023 22:56

I think if you go in and start telling him that you’re not ashamed of anything that he might have read, you are flagging up to him that you have done things that most people might find shaming.

HelpMeGetThrough · 28/12/2023 22:52

No big deal, I would sneak a peek at someone I knew records if opportunity was there. Just out of curiosity-

Then you are extremely stupid. Computer systems have full audit trails, so everything you do is recorded.

When responding to tenders for any of the systems we develop (and we have a diverse portfolio), this is one of the questions that we have to go over the top on answering.

Fraaahnces · 28/12/2023 22:47

Honestly it sounds like he told you this to leverage some psychological power. To imply that he had dirt he could hold over your head. I think you need to make it very, very clear that by admitting that he did this, he broke privacy laws and breached his contract of employment. The fact that he had gone out of his way to illegally look at your transcripts without your permission gives you the power to have him lose his job and impact his ability to get future jobs. You could even potentially sue him for damages.

Thepumpkintrials · 28/12/2023 22:37

If it were me, I wouldn't report him tbh. I think it's human nature to want to snoop, but most people understand the seriousness of getting caught, so don't do it. I think in a moment of madness he did something he shouldn't have. But if he loses his place in his masters or this effects his future employability , he'll probably always blame you for not beibg able to achieve what he hoped to achieve. You will probably blame yourself or feel guilty for it too. We all have to live with our conscience, and I don't think I would have a clear conscience if I reported my brother.

Hellenika · 28/12/2023 22:24

blackpear · 28/12/2023 22:13

Yes, I think this is the most likely scenario too. He certainly wouldn’t be able to see everything you have received, OP. I’m a HoD and wouldn’t have access to half of the stuff you mention.

Same here. Be a serious oversight if they had given him such access. It may be to wind you up snd watch you explode. Trolling by him.

whatsitcalledwhen · 28/12/2023 22:20

@Peppermint81

No big deal, I would sneak a peek at someone I knew records if opportunity was there. Just out of curiosity- doubt he thought he would uncover anything important

Would you really? That's not as normal as you seem to think it is. It's a really really weird, intrusive thing to do.

It's a sackable offence in many jobs for a reason. It certainly isn't 'no big deal'.

What a bizarre attitude you have to privacy.

ThreeRingCircus · 28/12/2023 22:20

I used to work in University admin and would say it is highly unlikely he was able to access all of that, it will have been held in different places.

That said, I'm surprised a lot of that information wasn't permanently deleted years ago. I'd be interested in hearing their legitimate purpose for holding that information on your record. I think in your shoes I'd be tempted to say you're surprised that your private medical information is still on file with them and as it is so sensitive, could they please check who has accessed your personal records.

That way, you're not accusing your brother directly to the University and if they investigate internally and find out he has well then, that's too bad....

LittleMissSunshiner · 28/12/2023 22:19

YANBU but personally I wouldn't try to get him fired, I'd try to think of a different strategy to let him know live and direct that it's not OK

Hellenika · 28/12/2023 22:19

If it were my brother I would read him the riot act and then give him a second chance. It’s possible he claimed he accessed them as a joke to wind you up. If you report him and then there is no access log showing he looked at them, then you’d have egg on your face and your wider family would likely turn on you.

eardefender · 28/12/2023 22:15

Abusers always consider themselves as the victim. He did it and told you about it to get power over you. He is also doing it to his colleagues and course mates. He is vile and needs to be stopped. Please report him. He can do his masters somewhere else and he will learn a valuable lesson. The university needs to seriously increase their GDPR practices as they are lacking. You owe your brother nothing, no explanation, no apology. He has brought all of this on himself by being an abusive little twat. I would be fuming and letting him have it with both barrels. He is an adult and needs to learn some very serious lessons about the consequences of his behaviour.

blackpear · 28/12/2023 22:13

Annonymiss123 · 28/12/2023 22:02

I work in a university (albeit in Ireland) and there’s absolutely no way a student would be able to access student records. We have “student help” working with us throughout the year but they are not able to access the student record system. Could he just be saying this to wind you up?

Yes, I think this is the most likely scenario too. He certainly wouldn’t be able to see everything you have received, OP. I’m a HoD and wouldn’t have access to half of the stuff you mention.

Annonymiss123 · 28/12/2023 22:02

I work in a university (albeit in Ireland) and there’s absolutely no way a student would be able to access student records. We have “student help” working with us throughout the year but they are not able to access the student record system. Could he just be saying this to wind you up?

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 28/12/2023 21:57

A pp suggested setting up a WhatsApp group with him and your parents and informing him that you are considering your options around his serious transgression. This is a great idea. Point out the consequences of his action if you take your own action with the uni authorities, and wait to see his and your DPs' reactions.

Then you'll have a better idea of how or if to proceed. No more eggshells around 'D'B - time to put a stop to all that. He's adult enough to be doing a masters, so old enough to behave like one.

Snowdogsmitten · 28/12/2023 21:46

I don’t want him to get fired. I certainly don’t want him to end up losing his masters place etc.

Shame. It’s no more than he deserves.

Threeboysadogandacat · 28/12/2023 21:45

Very sensible decision op.

Similar happened to a friend of mine in the NHS. Someone she knew well was admitted to the ward next door. During her night shift break she read this patients notes discovering that a mistake had been made during a surgery that may have affected her prognosis and that the medical staff had decided that there was no benefit in telling the patient this as her condition was now terminal.

My friend has felt guilty for the last 20+ because if she’d told either the patient or her husband there may have been some form of compensation as he was left with two very young children. She knew what she did was very wrong even at the time and she knows that it is her own fault that she has this on her conscience.

EdinGirl · 28/12/2023 21:45

Peppermint81 · 28/12/2023 19:05

No big deal, I would sneak a peek at someone I knew records if opportunity was there. Just out of curiosity- doubt he thought he would uncover anything important .
He unlikely to tell your parents or anyone, just will perhaps understand you better or have more empathy towards you.
Just forget it, not relevant to your current life now and you trying to get your brother fired seems rather extreme in this understandable situation - let him finish his masters and try to do well with his life

It is a HUGE deal and I am shocked that anyone would think it isn't.

It is no different than someone accessing someone's medical files at a doctor's surgery.

Disgusting behaviour.

He deserves to be fired.

thebestinterest · 28/12/2023 21:38

Oh, for sure report that. That’s such a breech. Weird!

DojaPhat · 28/12/2023 21:37

As a PP said - your 'record' so to speak doesn't exist in singularity. He may have just been able to see 'Hoopla Hooping - BA English Lit - 2016-2019' or something to that effect. The other info you detail shouldn't be readily available to anyone who happens to have access to student records for one thing or another.

Also, I wouldn't see this as any sort of push to tell your parents if you genuinely don't want to. Thing is, if he tells them you could easily deny it - if pushed to the extent he prints out a paper copy to literally show your parents then you've got quite a legal case on your hands.

All that aside - generally these things don't operate as simply as they appear to have here and if they did as you say your brother accessing your records is the least of the contraventions he's most definitely committed.

SteadyEddi · 28/12/2023 21:35

This way he is warned not to divulge or look at other records and there will be consequences if he does