Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am i raising a brat??

185 replies

Mimikyuu · 28/12/2023 18:37

My 10 year old (nearly 11) daughter argues with me all the time. I’m starting to think I’ve gone wrong somewhere or is this just normal for this age?

Example: tonight, she wants me to do her nails for her (I have gel paints and a uv lamp) for a party she’s going to tomorrow. I said yes that’s fine but in order to have time to do this I need to you to help me by tidying the living room while I’m sorting out the toddlers and putting them to bed. Que massive argument because she doesn’t want to do this so I’ve said no nails.

Since learning to cook (she goes to private lessons) she’s become very overly critical of anything I cook (I worked as a chef for a number of years so my cooking isn’t bad at all!). She makes comments about my food while we are eating and I tell her I think he’s being rude and just eat it or leave it.

My husband thinks I’m too soft, but I don’t think I am, I think Im being fair. We both had very strict upbringings, and here he hasn’t been effected by this I have and don’t want to repeat this sort of parenting with my kids.

Im just at a loss because she always such a lovely, pleasant girl and she mostly still is but she has become lazy and demanding recently and it’s making my life difficult. I don’t ask her for much, but I do tell her that as a person who lives in the house, she is also responsible for maintaining it, such as her bedroom and any little jobs I ask her to do.

Does this sound like normal 10 year old girl behavior or do I need to crack down a bit harder? Im on my own most evenings so it’s difficult as the toddlers are a fucking nightmare!

OP posts:
Superquiet · 28/12/2023 20:06

I know it's not what you are asking but as an aside, I think gel nails with UV is too advanced for 10 years old.

Anyway, you were reasonable to invite her to help you create time to do something she wanted, and it was her choice not to, so that's a fair boundary to set. Although not too much of it. Even if you are very pushed for time, it could breed resentment that in order for you to do something just for her, she must first help you with the siblings. It'd be better if you either had the time freely or you didn't and not necessarily attach it to bargaining.

The cooking comments.... I'd use this as an opportunity to teach her the difference between criticism and constructive criticism (two very different things) and also, timing of when to offer opinion and when best to save it for another time. I don't think saying "eat it or leave it" teaches her anything useful (social skills wise) when it really could. Perhaps she feels empowered by her knowledge of cooking, and feels she is sharing her opinions in a "tasting judge" kind of way, perhaps she's seen the cooking and baking programmes on TV where the judges are quite blunt in their opinions and she's emulating that. Especially as you have professional experience in that area, she might think she can share her opinion with you quite plainly. You perhaps need her to see there's a difference between cooking for something to be discussed, and cooking just to get dinner on the table.

OhwhyOY · 28/12/2023 20:06

@Mimikyuu sounds like the right approach to me except the 'eat it or leave it' comment which sounds like it's coming from a place of (understandable) frustration. Perhaps you could say that you value her opinion and are happy to talk about what she likes about things and why but the constant criticism is upsetting. How would she feel about her food in class constantly being criticised?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/12/2023 20:06

I remember as a 17 year old making lots of comments on my dad's driving while I was learning. Did it make me a brat for doing this when he gave me lifts? I wouldn't say so but it probably was very very annoying and he would have been ok to boundaries in place about this

Username123343 · 28/12/2023 20:05

Yes this is standard behaviour for this age. Keep doing what you’re doing - holding the boundary of acceptable/unacceptable behaviour. There’s a lovely piece of prose online that this has reminded me of.

I’ll find it for you.

JMSA · 28/12/2023 20:05

Jesus OP, just ignore some of these comments. Who cares if some miserable random thinks your daughter shouldn't have gel nails or cookery classes!
Anyway, I sympathise. I have 3 daughters. Enough said!

Terrribletwos · 28/12/2023 20:04

Are nail salons doing nails for under 18s, I have never seen this.

Caerulea · 28/12/2023 20:03

Gel nails are an absolute no at that age for health & allergy reasons - unless you're a professional and have been through the relevant training & even then no self respecting professional would do a kids nails in the same way a good tattooist wouldn't touch a drunk or do neck/face/hands on a virgin body.

The chemicals involved are no joke at all and are sensitisers. Incorrectly cured gel varnish can cause an irreversible sensitivity.

This is something that's becoming more and more of an issue with gels being available to the general public with no warning on how bloody dangerous they can be if incorrectly used - no matter how careful you think you're being.

By all means do your own nails but you really really should not be putting that on your daughter.

I was helluva careful, have a really good hand & did my own nails for years & guess what? I developed the sensitivity & can no longer use it at all which is gutting! Potentially I'm now sensitive to some fairly important medical stuff as a result.

Don't do your daughters nails!

Chonk · 28/12/2023 20:02

@Igotagoodcard I'm surprised a salon is willing to apply gel polish at that age, it can be really damaging to nails!

Chuzzle · 28/12/2023 20:02

I wasn't sure which answer was NBU and which was BU...but she's 10. You are the parent. You need to find a way to communicate which doesn't lead to conflict.

Ghostgirl77 · 28/12/2023 19:59

It’s normal for her to push boundaries but you should be teaching her some empathy too. So when she criticises the meal talk to her about how that makes you feel and why it upsets you, don’t just punish her without explaining why. Same with the tidying/nails. At this age she needs to be understanding the impact her behaviour has on others.

coldcallerbaiter · 28/12/2023 19:59

She will grow out if it and come out the other side. It is several years for girls so hang on to your hat..
Very bumpy and lots of drama.

Keep your boundaries but pick your battles, Be fairly strict. You know best. We wouldn’t have dared to behave like that with our mums in the 70s and 80s, we would have got a thump. Life and society still has rules and you cannot go around doing as you please at home. My home, my rules.

momager1 · 28/12/2023 19:58

@Mimikyuu Former professional chef and restaurant owner (retired this year), mother to 3 . I love the fact that you got her lessons!! It is not the same having your mum teach you no matter how much you, her mother, knows about food and technique. However. My daughter started working in a restaurant at 15, and suddenly became a KNOW IT ALL. I was really hurt as I have worked so hard (as has her dad) to provide her with a good life, and she has the audacity to start complaining about the meals I make. My husband did the thing I did not have the balls to do. After several meals where she cut me down, my husband got up from the table, took her plate and dumped it in the dogs bowls. Told her to make her own if she was so fantastic at it. Took two times for him to get the point home. Dogs had chicken kiev and beef wellington that week. She is no longer a brat. She is now a 35 year old that her 13 year old and 12 year old complain about the food LMAO. I live in the carribean now, and am heading up to see her for a week late January and they are all making the menu for me to cook for the week LOLOLOL.. Morale of the story..all teenagers can be brats.. they DO grow out of it and most turn in to amazing adults and parents with their own "brats" and that... is our REVENGE

PurpleBugz · 28/12/2023 19:58

It's age appropriate she got hormones kicking in. How you handle it will determine if she becomes full brat. I think what you did with the nails was correct.

And I think if she keeps insulting your food then yes take it away. If she doesn't like it take note don't intentionally serve stuff she hates but yes take it away when she's so rude about it. Allow fruit and toast/cereal instead don't starve her but don't panic about SS from comments on here fruit and toast is fed

DeeLusional · 28/12/2023 19:55

Mimikyuu · 28/12/2023 18:57

I don’t have time to teach her how to cook, hence the lessons. Plus she gets to cook in a group of kids her age and she enjoys the social element.

You have all the answers and are rejecting every comment / suggestion, so why are are you asking, exactly?

SlashBeef · 28/12/2023 19:53

I'm surprised by all the people saying this is fine and normal. My 11 year old doesn't speak to me this way. He might be in a bad mood after something happens at school or whatever but he's not regularly rude or critical to me. I wouldn't tolerate it, to be honest, especially as she seems to have quite a privileged lifestyle.

Zoreos · 28/12/2023 19:50

Shadowsindarkplaces · 28/12/2023 19:31

'so why did mum take away your dinner?'
'I was rude about her cooking'
yep...like SS would even give two hoots unless there were a whole raft of other issues. A stroppy know it all 11 year old would not be a problem for them.

If you want to live in a world where you genuinely believe SS wouldn’t care about a child having food removed from them for having an opinion rightly or wrongly then I’m afraid you’re living in cuckoo land. Many 11 year olds are hormonal and say things a lot without regard. It won’t be the last time she makes comments, I can guarantee it. There are many ways of enforcing positive behaviour other than authoritative parenting. It doesn’t mean anyone has the right to deprive them of basic necessities that is disgusting and controlling. Not to mention can form disordered eating. Wouldn’t give a two hoots - utterly ridiculous nonsense.

Riverlee · 28/12/2023 19:50

mayorofcasterbridge · 28/12/2023 18:56

One word - hormones!!!!

My first thought.

Also she’s boundary pushing. However, your responses have been fair. Ie. No nails if she doesn’t help you. She’d be a brat if you gave in to her every demand and tantrum.

falalalalalalalallama · 28/12/2023 19:49

No, she doesn't sound like a brat. Ignore posters saying she's a brat because you giver her a special treat of nails, or because she has an interest (cookery). Some people here just like to put the boot in.

She does sound like she's boundary pushing, which although annoying is a normal part of growing up and away from our parents.

You would be raising a brat if you told her that she could only have the nails if she helped you, she refused and you let her have nails anyway. Just keep being consistent with the consequences like you are already.

isthismylifenow · 28/12/2023 19:49

Has she started menstruating yet? If not, expect her to within the next few months.

My dd was similar just prior, so out of character. I could not or say do a thing right.

Thankfully she did go back to her usual (less miserable) self.

Wavingnotdrown1ng · 28/12/2023 19:48

All very normal for the age, having a grown up one who aired her opinions freely from age 10 and Christmas visits have just reminded me of the delights of the preteen age group. Well done for holding the line on the nails. Perhaps, when another adult can watch the toddlers, the two of you could cook together and she can show you what she has learnt and you can show her some of your skills? It may be that she wants some one-on - one time with you but is going about asking for it in a demanding way.

helpme5 · 28/12/2023 19:48

I don't actually think she sounds like a brat and would probably put it down to hormones like a pp mentioned. Age gap between siblings probably won't help either.

I think the cooking lessons sound great and I'd be getting her more involved at home. Things that she's critical about is give her the opportunity to try and make herself.

Princessfluffy · 28/12/2023 19:46

Re behaviour I agree this is probably hormone fuelled.

If she wants to talk about the food you have cooked maybe have a discussion about how to do this without being rude.

If she is deliberately being rude I'd tell her she doesn't have to eat it and is welcome to cook dinner herself one night with help if she would like it.

Cmonluv · 28/12/2023 19:44

I'd have loved cooking lessons at that age, our youth club did an occasional baking lesson where we'd make cakes or biscuits and I LOVED it! I would have been 10. Proper cooking would have been amazing

Terrribletwos · 28/12/2023 19:43

I think maybe the fact you have toddlers might be a key factor too. Does she feel neglected or somehow put out?