Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am i raising a brat??

185 replies

Mimikyuu · 28/12/2023 18:37

My 10 year old (nearly 11) daughter argues with me all the time. I’m starting to think I’ve gone wrong somewhere or is this just normal for this age?

Example: tonight, she wants me to do her nails for her (I have gel paints and a uv lamp) for a party she’s going to tomorrow. I said yes that’s fine but in order to have time to do this I need to you to help me by tidying the living room while I’m sorting out the toddlers and putting them to bed. Que massive argument because she doesn’t want to do this so I’ve said no nails.

Since learning to cook (she goes to private lessons) she’s become very overly critical of anything I cook (I worked as a chef for a number of years so my cooking isn’t bad at all!). She makes comments about my food while we are eating and I tell her I think he’s being rude and just eat it or leave it.

My husband thinks I’m too soft, but I don’t think I am, I think Im being fair. We both had very strict upbringings, and here he hasn’t been effected by this I have and don’t want to repeat this sort of parenting with my kids.

Im just at a loss because she always such a lovely, pleasant girl and she mostly still is but she has become lazy and demanding recently and it’s making my life difficult. I don’t ask her for much, but I do tell her that as a person who lives in the house, she is also responsible for maintaining it, such as her bedroom and any little jobs I ask her to do.

Does this sound like normal 10 year old girl behavior or do I need to crack down a bit harder? Im on my own most evenings so it’s difficult as the toddlers are a fucking nightmare!

OP posts:
Freesiabritney · 28/12/2023 21:36

2dogsandabudgie · 28/12/2023 18:54

I would remind her to treat other people as you would like to be treated yourself, I'm sure she wouldn't want anyone criticising food that she had cooked. I think 10 is a difficult age because they want to appear grown up but are still very much children. I think you were right to say to her that if she wants you to do things for her then she needs to help you, as long as you stick to your guns when she starts moaning.

Completely agree with this. My DD was a nightmare at 10. Full of opinions but not quite grasped when it's appropriate to share them. Keep going with the boundaries and reminding her to be mindful of people's feelings and you'll come through the others side. My DD is 13 now, and though not perfect, is really a kind girl and delightful company.

Underwatersally · 28/12/2023 21:34

She sounds like a normal 10 year old to me.
My 10 year old is polite and kind with everyone but does push boundaries at home because that’s the safe place to push them.

Do you get her to look at things from your perspective?
For example if my daughter picked at something I did, cooking for example I would say to her ‘how would you feel if you spent ages cooking something and working really hard on it and then I told you what a bad job you had done?’
Not in a shouty way just in a conversation way.
I do that with my 10 year old and I do hear her saying it to her friends now if they say something to upset someone else. it just helps with learning empathy I think.

I think she’s probably really proud of her grown up cooking skills and wants to show you but is doing it in a typical 10 year old girl way.

With the tidying I bloody hate tidying now, I hated tidying as a child I think it’s pretty normal to say she doesn’t want to clean.
Again something I do with my daughter is break it down in to chunks with the obvious reward.

Asking her to tidy the lounge for example probably feels like a huge job. I get more success if I ask my daughter to do the cushions on the chair, then when she has finished that I will say pick up all the x and usually that’s enough.

I think at that age smaller very directed jobs seem less overwhelming.

I can’t believe all the brat comments. If she is a brat every 10 year old I know is too.

00100001 · 28/12/2023 21:32

I'd be tempted to get her to make dinner the next night she made poor comments.

"Thanks for the review, I'm sure the dinner you cook tomorrow will be perfect. It's chicken fajitas, everything is in the group and cupboards."

Or similar.

Basically the consequence for being rude about your cooking, is she does the cooking now.

Tacotortoise · 28/12/2023 21:30

Billybagpuss · 28/12/2023 18:47

She’s boundary pushing, your requests are quite reasonable she’ll grow out of it, but keep doing what you’re doing.

This. Tedious for you but just keep calmly reinforcing your boundaries and it'll come good.

KeepTrying0 · 28/12/2023 21:28

It sounds to me as though she is going to be an adult who knows her own mind, and maybe your job at the moment is to help her calibrate her judgement?

It might be worth reading this book. I found it really very helpful.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Get-Out-Life-bestselling-twenty-first-century/dp/1788163826/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3EZPXI9AIPF5L&keywords=Get+Out+of+My+Life...%3A+But+First+Take+Me+and+Alex+Into+Town&qid=1703798826&sprefix=get+out+of+my+life...+but+first+take+me+and+alex+into+town%2Caps%2C57&sr=8-1

fwiw, my main thought on reading this is that I would also like my nails down and private cooking lessons. You sound like a great Mum.

DragonMama3 · 28/12/2023 21:25

Mimikyuu · 28/12/2023 18:51

Really would you say the same about any other private lesson like swimming, football, ballet etc??

you're creating a rod for your own back, sweetie

Ramalangadingdong · 28/12/2023 21:24

Nope. She doesn't sound like a brat. She sounds like an honest person. I wouldn't want to do that housework you assigned her either. She probably had other plans for her time at that precise moment. As for your food isn't she just trying out her new appreciation for good food and the ability to talk about it on you?

Flamingos89 · 28/12/2023 21:21

No one was their best self at 10! Sounds really normal - With your guidance she will be absolutely fine! Really good you set boundaries and didn’t do her nails! You sound like a wonderful mother - parenting is hard sometimes, just keep doing what you are doing!

Rainbow1901 · 28/12/2023 21:19

Children are learning all the time and very often don't know how far they can go - but they can learn one very good expression - 'If you can't say something nice, then don't say anything at all!!
I don't think you should take away her meals but give her the choice of eating it or leaving it. If she is still eating it then it's not that bad is it? If she leaves it - then that is it until the next meal is due. Cooking as a skill is an invaluable one for everyone but I don't know that I would pay for it - you get better with practice the more often you cook.
As for the nails - she is at the age that (I think) she should still be playing around and painting them herself along with make up like little girls do!! Forget the machine! Not to mention the damage you can do to nails - they end up brittle, peeling, cracking and can age your hands prematurely and increase the risk of skin cancer.
I can't help but think that parents make their kids grow up too quick nowadays - can't believe that two lads I know were given mobile phones for Christmas - they are aged six and seven!!
Your DD isn't a brat yet - but she does need educating in social skills - carry on behaving as she does with friends and she could find herself being very lonely.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 28/12/2023 21:17

MancLass76 · 28/12/2023 21:13

I have a 10 year old and you could have been writing about her. Add to that, she has an answer for everything, doesn’t listen to anything I say or ask her to do without it being an issue and she always has to have the last word. Some of the things she throws at me in arguments, I have no idea where they have come from. She’s also lazy but very particular about certain things. Talking to other mums her friends are very similar in lots of ways and we have put it down to them growing up far too quickly now. Her Christmas list had more skin/hair products and make up on it than I’ve used in a lifetime - she didn’t get them all. I just have everything crossed when she is actually a teenager she’s gotten it out of her system ha ha

Same here but my dd is 12.
So bloody sassy and self confident it drives me mad.

Ohforfox · 28/12/2023 21:17

I have a 10 year old DD who is thoughtful, kind & so loving... But also drives me mad with her moodiness & acting like I'm sending her to prison if I ask her to brush her teeth. I don't think it's anything you're doing wrong, I think they do feel life is so difficult and unfair at this age. It wears thin when you've asked them to help & it's done grudgingly but I try to remind myself they have child brains & teen hormones & it's not my parenting! I'm sure they'll all turn out fine!

surreygirl1987 · 28/12/2023 21:16

You said you were a chef...so yes id say the same about swimming etc if you were a swimmer. Probably not football or other team stuff

Nah, I'm a swimmer and send my sons to swimming lessons. Just because you are good at something doesn't mean you are good at teaching it (especially to your own children!)

maddiemookins16mum · 28/12/2023 21:14

You mention toddlers, are there a couple of tots who get more time with you? It’s hard being the oldest child and having to do chores (I totally agree everyone needs to muck in of course). I don’t think she sounds like a brat.

MancLass76 · 28/12/2023 21:13

I have a 10 year old and you could have been writing about her. Add to that, she has an answer for everything, doesn’t listen to anything I say or ask her to do without it being an issue and she always has to have the last word. Some of the things she throws at me in arguments, I have no idea where they have come from. She’s also lazy but very particular about certain things. Talking to other mums her friends are very similar in lots of ways and we have put it down to them growing up far too quickly now. Her Christmas list had more skin/hair products and make up on it than I’ve used in a lifetime - she didn’t get them all. I just have everything crossed when she is actually a teenager she’s gotten it out of her system ha ha

Whiskerson · 28/12/2023 21:10

I can't imagine dealing with two toddlers of an evening without another adult around, plus also a ten year old stretching your patience. I honestly take my hat off to you, and you sound like a nice and thoughtful mum (the cooking lessons sound like a lovely thing for her) Flowers

She's getting into adolescence - hormones will be starting to have their effect on her mood, and all the rest that PPs have said. Plus she's still a child, figuring out the line between forgivably sassy versus plain rude, and wanting to show that she's not a child anymore (though she is). From what you've said, I don't think there's any big reason to worry. It sounds within the range of normal for a pre-teen. And maybe the sooner she gets it out of her system, the least damage.

Stay close to her, and I'm sure it will all come out in the wash!

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 21:05

FrenchGeek · 28/12/2023 20:53

Ignore the judgmental comments OP. I'm new on MN and am already stunned by the totally unnecessary nastiness on here (as well as many lovely helpful commenters). My DD is younger but going on lots of kids that age in my extended family, sounds like normal boundary pushing to me.

Also new and … whoa: what an eye opener in aggression!

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 21:04

boobashka · 28/12/2023 20:55

This

Yes it’s normal. She sounds spirited though so you’re probably going to get the hill walk not the valley walk! Just keep the faith! Sounds as though you are doing all the right things.

Mirabai · 28/12/2023 21:00

I find the best cure for criticism of food is for the kids to cook one meal a week. It’s not the same as doing it in a lesson and it’s a good learning curve in home economics and coming up with new recipes.

justasking111 · 28/12/2023 20:58

@Mimikyuu all normal, you're doing well, stay calm and be consistent. Withdrawal of privileges I always found worked best.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 28/12/2023 20:58

Yes, she is a brat! Show me a 10yr old who isn't!
She is perfectly normal!! !Frustrating the life out of you, of course. Give her clear instructions on what you expect of her. My mantra was always "actions have consequences" .Make a chores chart for her to clearly see and let her understand that yes you will treat her and go out your way for her but it's a two way street in the grand scheme o' things.
Urrrrggghh 10yr ols, 😑

boobashka · 28/12/2023 20:55

Sparkly12 · 28/12/2023 18:55

God, what a lovely bunch you've got on here replying!

Don't listen OP, she does not sound like a brat at all! But it's normal to constantly worry about your parenting techniques etc when they are pushing us.

She's just testing the boundaries, as hard as it is, it's a very normal part of their development xx

This

FrenchGeek · 28/12/2023 20:53

Ignore the judgmental comments OP. I'm new on MN and am already stunned by the totally unnecessary nastiness on here (as well as many lovely helpful commenters). My DD is younger but going on lots of kids that age in my extended family, sounds like normal boundary pushing to me.

TTC89Njna · 28/12/2023 20:52

I was a twat at 10/11. The hormones start kicking in then. I turned around to being a nice kid again around the age of 17. She's pushing boundaries, you have to push back. Easier said than done, good luck!

auntiesatthere · 28/12/2023 20:51

Sounds normal especially for this generation but doesn't make it right. She pushing boundaries personally I would nip it in the bud asap. Only thing worse with a lazy 10 year old is a lazy teenager who still won't do the simplest tasks and storms out of the house because you asked them to wash a dish and then your up until 1am wondering where they are while they don't give you a second thought.

She is 10 she's old enough to know what her comments are rude and it's it's not a lot to ask for her to tidy the room and you will sort her nails for her in return. Sounds like a damn good bargain to be honest

IfTheresTeaTheresHope · 28/12/2023 20:46

It sounds like there’s too much negotiation. You can be firm and fair about things. If she wants her nails done and you want her to do something in exchange when she refuses don’t get into a debate about it but then these types of things are good for bonding so when you have time offer to do her nails for fun, just the two of you. If she criticises your food, then the next meal, cook together but don’t take over or when you’re cooking ask her opinion on the dish you’re preparing. Ultimately she is a child and doesn’t have the tact of an adult but that’s your job as her parents to teach. You’re at a crossroads and she could go either way depending upon you and her father. Don’t infantilise her too much but remember that she isn’t an adult either. You’re the parents and you set any boundaries and rules.