Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex Wife Boundaries

417 replies

2ChildDad · 28/12/2023 11:57

My ex wife and I share 50/50 custody of our children. I tend to have them slightly more than that over Christmas and half terms due to her work schedules (I am not complaining about that- any time that I spend with my kids in a gift). The kids spent Christmas with me and returned to her on Boxing Day.
She has started a relationship with another man (the kids were somewhat resistant to this, but I have been as supportive as I can be-he has even thanked me for this).
My boundary on this are that if the kids are with me, I don’t contact her unless absolutely necessary. She has her life to lead.
Yesterday, I received a call saying ‘we are coming over to your house now as he (my son) wants his other pair of trainers’.
I was actually having lunch with a lady that I have begun dating and said that ‘now is not convenient as I have company. Tomorrow will be fine’.
She slammed the phone down and then sent a text saying ‘Don’t bother I am going to buy some new ones’.
I think she is getting too aggressive here and not respecting boundaries. Or AIBU?

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 15:57

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 15:38

@CandyLeBonBon there is some significant middle ground between rigidly adhering to an arbitrary division of time and ‘utter chaos’

Yes. And 50/50 attempts to go just that!

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 15:56

No, of course that would be too much, but if OP is in the house he should allow EW to pick belongings up for the kids (until the kids are able to do this themselves). Would have taken 30 secs to meet her at door. This is a bare minimum ask of a parent to compensate for requiring a child to live between two homes.

He offered to put the trainers on the doorstep. Why does she need any more than this when it's all about the belongings? Sometimes it really isn't appropriate for people to drop round at short notice, yes, including your own children. There is a very good reason for keeping the kids out of the OP's dating life until the relationship is more established. And saying 'well no dates' is really unreasonable.

That’s the misogynistic spin that has been read into this scenario. I Dont see any evidence of that from the facts OP presented.

He said that the ex was gaslighting to him during the relationship and since splitting, kept finding reasons to pop round. You don't seem to appreciate that it can be incredibly stressful for someone to have to deal with intrusive behaviour for an ex and that stress can affect the children too.

work is an entirely different scenario . Adults who live between two homes (say their first home and their partner’s home) very often find the issue of stuff being different places challenging. This would be even more the case if the division of time were as split as 50/50 and if they weren’t able to go get / pick up stuff as and when. If it’s stressful for adults , that stress is magnified many times for a small child who doesn’t have the same maturity / self regulation / independence / perspective that an adult has.

Okay but it is an inevitability and the alternative is that they live with only one parent so that they don't get stressed about their belongings and will suffer in other ways as a result. So given that the OP has the kids slightly more than 50/50 here, should the kids not spend any time living with their mum? Or is it only women who should have sole residence do you think?

Lots of children find shared parenting arrangements stressful. One of the main triggers/ stressors is the issue of belongings. Shared parenting arrangements can work really well when there is : 1) good communication and cooperation between the two parents, 2) they live close and 3) children are able to move relatively freely between homes.

Actually, routine is good for kids so the moving freely between two homes isn't necessarily good. They want certainty. Sometimes the parents are not able to communicate effectively but that doesn't mean that splitting time between them is a bad thing.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 15:54

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 15:51

He should put his new lady first. Children need to fit in. Will the children be with him every day when he is old, or will his romantic attraction. It will be his romantic attraction, not his children who will have their own lives. It does children no service if they are allowed to dictate what their parents do and are taught the whole world revolves around what they want - finding out it does not then becomes an existential shock.

He should put his new lady first. Children need to fit in. Will the children be with him every day when he is old, or will his romantic attraction

😮😮🤭🫣. Well now that is a fresh take 😂

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 15:52

@Grammarnut thrash the boy soundly for his idle nature and be done with it, eh?

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 15:51

Tinkerbyebye · 28/12/2023 12:11

It’s your child that wants his trainers so well done for putting your new lady first instead of your child. Let’s hope that doesn’t continue

you could have put the trainers outside the door for them to collect

your kids should be coming first

He should put his new lady first. Children need to fit in. Will the children be with him every day when he is old, or will his romantic attraction. It will be his romantic attraction, not his children who will have their own lives. It does children no service if they are allowed to dictate what their parents do and are taught the whole world revolves around what they want - finding out it does not then becomes an existential shock.

CoParents · 28/12/2023 15:50

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 15:47

This is nonsense. My DD went to a sleepover with my sister. My sister rang saying DD forgot her top that she wanted to wear the next day. I was going for a bath and wanted to chill out so I told my sister to tell her to just leave it, she had other clothes with her, wear something else. My child, her home. She was fine.

If you can’t understand the difference between a child living through a 50/50 shared parenting arrangement (after relationship breakdown), and your daughter having a sleep over at her aunt’s house, you are very obtuse.

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 15:47

CoParents · 28/12/2023 14:03

This. YABU.

This is nonsense. My DD went to a sleepover with my sister. My sister rang saying DD forgot her top that she wanted to wear the next day. I was going for a bath and wanted to chill out so I told my sister to tell her to just leave it, she had other clothes with her, wear something else. My child, her home. She was fine.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 15:45

HootyMcBoob · 28/12/2023 15:33

Yes, and the outcome would have been the same, i.e. no trainers until later. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Yes, but if OP were out, the “outcome” (shit as it may be) couldn’t easily have be avoided. As it was , he was in, so he could quite easily have handed over the shoes . 🤷🏼‍♀️

CoParents · 28/12/2023 15:40

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 15:24

But what would you suggest as an alternative then? That the ex wife has a key and can walk in at any time to get things for the children? Or that OP cannot have any sort of private life during his child-free time? What about the fact that she seems to be using this to control the OP?
Adults and children would be able to cope if it was explained to them why they couldn't have a specific item right at that moment if it was in a different place. It's not that uncommon for adults to split their time across two places (for work or living part time with partner) and it's not too distressing and shouldn't be overstated for children either, most of whom cope well with shared residence arrangements.

That the ex wife has a key and can walk in at any time to get things for the children

No, of course that would be too much, but if OP is in the house he should allow EW to pick belongings up for the kids (until the kids are able to do this themselves). Would have taken 30 secs to meet her at door. This is a bare minimum ask of a parent to compensate for requiring a child to live between two homes.

What about the fact that she seems to be using this to control the OP?

That’s the misogynistic spin that has been read into this scenario. I Dont see any evidence of that from the facts OP presented.

its not that unommon for adults to split their time across two places (for work or living part time with partner)

work is an entirely different scenario . Adults who live between two homes (say their first home and their partner’s home) very often find the issue of stuff being different places challenging. This would be even more the case if the division of time were as split as 50/50 and if they weren’t able to go get / pick up stuff as and when. If it’s stressful for adults , that stress is magnified many times for a small child who doesn’t have the same maturity / self regulation / independence / perspective that an adult has.

and it's not too distressing and shouldn't be overstated for children either, most of whom cope well with shared residence arrangements

Lots of children find shared parenting arrangements stressful. One of the main triggers/ stressors is the issue of belongings. Shared parenting arrangements can work really well when there is : 1) good communication and cooperation between the two parents, 2) they live close and 3) children are able to move relatively freely between homes.

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 15:38

@CandyLeBonBon there is some significant middle ground between rigidly adhering to an arbitrary division of time and ‘utter chaos’

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 28/12/2023 15:37

@Workworkandmoreworknow
Ok so in that case perhaps (and we're inferring a lot here) "He's desperate to have his trainers, he's been waring me down this morning and I can't take it anymore." And then dad could have said "Ah ok, yes come and get them but it's a bit tricky right now, I'm a bit busy with something here but if it's ok with you I will just bring them to the front door?" Seems like to communication was not the best on either side?

I suppose really point was that if it was so desperately urgent surely all mum would be concerned about was finding a way to facilitate getting hold of them, whether it be handing them over at the door or whatever?

And seems very weird/drastic to just buy a whole new pair of trainers because there might (doesn't even have to be!!) be a slight delay in getting said trainers back? Not a very balanced or stable response to a slightly annoying/inconvenient situation?!! Surely the child is also old enough at pre teen to explain that she's asked dad and he's said yes but I'm just trying to sort out when we can go and get them?

I don't doubt there is a backstory where mum is doing her best/ dad also is not a saint but I really can't see how it excuses the entitled tone of impatience and downright rudeness from his fellow co-parent here?

CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 15:34

@Olive19741205 I've since updated on subsequent posts.

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 15:33

CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 13:37

@2ChildDad how many dates have you had - how long have you been seeing her? Sounds pretty soon to be playing happy families - especially as you have 50% of the time available for dating.

The trainers thing is a red herring I think? I imagine the trainers is a mask for the fact that she's upset you've possibly introduced your dc to a very early-days relationship too soon?

I think you're getting threads mixed up. You don't seem to be reading any of OPs posts at all.

HootyMcBoob · 28/12/2023 15:33

Tandora · 28/12/2023 15:23

If he were out he could have simply said “sorry I am out. I’ll be back xx”. Entirely different scenario 🤷🏼‍♀️

Yes, and the outcome would have been the same, i.e. no trainers until later. 🤦🏻‍♀️

MumLass · 28/12/2023 15:33

@2ChildDad as a separated Mum I think you did nothing wrong on the face of it. If there is a back story (Like you were meant to send the trainers with him and you forgot, and it's not the first time) I can understand your ex's frustration. My ex is forever doing stuff like that. School shoes, sports kit, coats, water bottles. I don't understand why it is so hard to remember what your own kids need.

ZforZebra · 28/12/2023 15:31

Despite many of the posts on this thread I’m glad to see most people voting think YANBU.

Honeychickpea · 28/12/2023 15:30

She probably got wind of the fact that you were seeing someone, and made up the trainer issue so that she could come over and have a nosy.

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 15:28

NewNameNigel · 28/12/2023 13:34

Hilariously I once mentioned on a thread that DSD had popped back to her mums for something (this is DSD not DP) and I got lambasted because this is mums free time and we should have a replica wardrobe here. Even though DSD was 14 at the time and has made the arrangements herself with her mum this was my fault

Edited

I once got told on here that because DSCs mum wanted us to have the kids on HER day, very last minute, literally half an hour before I was due to leave as I had plans, had made childcare plans for my own DD, DH was coming off a night-shift and it wasn't HIS day...we were a pair of bastards who treated the kids like plant pots🙄

TinyKittenPaw · 28/12/2023 15:27

I think on this occasion i would have offered to meet her briefly outside to hand her the trainers, which it sounds like you did, but i would have a conversation later about the fact you are now dating and it can’t just be assumed that you will A) be in or B) be available, when you are not scheduled to have the kids. What if yourself and the new partner had been in bed when she arrived at short notice - intrusive and awkward for everyone.

I don’t think you are wrong to be annoyed or to set come clear boundaries around this for the future. Do you think she could have known you were seeing someone and wanted to find a reason to call by? Seems odd when he has two other trainers?

Nily4567 · 28/12/2023 15:27

Hmm…think you are getting roasted for being a man tbh…gobsmacked by majority of responses to be honest.
lot of bitter divorced people commenting I suspect 🤦‍♀️

MrsHughesPinny · 28/12/2023 15:25

YANBU. It was your ex-wife’s time with the children so you were doing your own life. If your DS has another pair of trainers it won’t kill him to wear those. I can’t believe how vitriolic some people are being when she’s clearly in the wrong.

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 15:24

CoParents · 28/12/2023 15:18

Well you can declare that if you want 💁🏼‍♀️. However, as above, research shows that the stress/ anxiety/ upset (all forms of “suffering”) sometimes caused to children by having to split time between homes very typically centres around belongings. Most adults would also find it difficult and unsettling if their stuff was spread across two homes, especially if they couldn’t access that stuff as and when they wanted.

But what would you suggest as an alternative then? That the ex wife has a key and can walk in at any time to get things for the children? Or that OP cannot have any sort of private life during his child-free time? What about the fact that she seems to be using this to control the OP?
Adults and children would be able to cope if it was explained to them why they couldn't have a specific item right at that moment if it was in a different place. It's not that uncommon for adults to split their time across two places (for work or living part time with partner) and it's not too distressing and shouldn't be overstated for children either, most of whom cope well with shared residence arrangements.

DeeLusional · 28/12/2023 15:23

SecondUsername4me · 28/12/2023 12:21

Interesting that you didn't include this in your opening post.

If people included every single word in every situation in every single post, the website would crash! It's called "summarising" and people who don't do it and relate every single "I said and then they said and then I said and then they said..." are the most boring fuckers in the universe.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 15:23

HootyMcBoob · 28/12/2023 15:20

Utter nonsense, the OP isn't being unreasonable at all. On the other hand, the EW sounds like a control freak. What would have happened if the OP had been out?

If he were out he could have simply said “sorry I am out. I’ll be back xx”. Entirely different scenario 🤷🏼‍♀️

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 15:22

Luxell934 · 28/12/2023 13:26

It seems like the child was the only one who suffered here though just so you could stick to your “boundaries” with your ex to spite her, when in reality you probably upset your child.

The child suffered? Oh behave. That is just so ridiculous 😂. No wonder we've got teens and adults who can't cope with being told no on occasion.