Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex Wife Boundaries

417 replies

2ChildDad · 28/12/2023 11:57

My ex wife and I share 50/50 custody of our children. I tend to have them slightly more than that over Christmas and half terms due to her work schedules (I am not complaining about that- any time that I spend with my kids in a gift). The kids spent Christmas with me and returned to her on Boxing Day.
She has started a relationship with another man (the kids were somewhat resistant to this, but I have been as supportive as I can be-he has even thanked me for this).
My boundary on this are that if the kids are with me, I don’t contact her unless absolutely necessary. She has her life to lead.
Yesterday, I received a call saying ‘we are coming over to your house now as he (my son) wants his other pair of trainers’.
I was actually having lunch with a lady that I have begun dating and said that ‘now is not convenient as I have company. Tomorrow will be fine’.
She slammed the phone down and then sent a text saying ‘Don’t bother I am going to buy some new ones’.
I think she is getting too aggressive here and not respecting boundaries. Or AIBU?

OP posts:
Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 16:32

CoParents · 28/12/2023 15:50

If you can’t understand the difference between a child living through a 50/50 shared parenting arrangement (after relationship breakdown), and your daughter having a sleep over at her aunt’s house, you are very obtuse.

It's very clear that you are all for trampling over ex partners boundaries.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:32

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 16:26

Your suggestion means staying in a marriage that is not working. I was not being selfish, I think. I did what I knew would mean a stable life in which I can have my children. My ex tried to stop me from having access to them, inveigled me into handing over money that was legally mine on the promise of access and then denied it, lied to the court that access was sorted, threatened me with the CSA (he'd have lost on this one - I paid over the odds) and fought me over custody when I finally went back to court. He wanted 100% custody and access 'by arrangement'. I wanted 50% and every other week-end, so that the DCs had two homes. I could not have offered a home without prioritising my new relationship, for I was depressed and incapable of action following the divorce and only DH held me together, got me to see a GP (I had not even registered with one!) and pulled me out of self-defeating guilt. I did what was best for me because that was best for my children. If that is selfish, then so be it. I am a older generation and I do not have sentimental ideas about children or childhood, but practical views on how we can surmount the disasters that we fall into. NB I did not trust my ex with the care of my 13-year-old DD. He was in the habit of leaving her alone with my 17-year-old DS while he went away. I saw this as a safeguarding red flag, for who knew who he would have to stay/visit etc?

Your suggestion means staying in a marriage that is not working.

oh gosh no I wouldn’t say this. My parents had an awful marriage and stuck it out for a long time and it def wasn’t in my best interests. But if after divorce if they had chosen to prioritise a new romantic interest over my needs, on the grounds that I would grow up and leave them, hell yeh I’d call that selfish. And harmful to kids.

I do appreciate your perspective , however, in that you are calling out OP’s attitude for what it is.

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:29

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:25

Please explain how OP handing over shoes to EW at door entails revealing his dad is unexpectedly dating someone 😂. When you get a delivery at your door does the mail man’s son have insight into your relationship dynamics? This thread is just getting stupid tbh,

Because it’s pretty clear that ex was being nosy about the date which is why she wouldn’t accept getting the trainers without an interaction with OP.

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:27

AmethystSparkles · 28/12/2023 16:24

I think there’s another side to this too. It was the ‘Any time I spend with my kids is a gift’ thing.

My ex would have our kids staying over three nights a week at one stage but I’d collect them from school, give them dinner, get all their school stuff ready…it was a mad rush and exhausting! He’d pick them up, have a bit of a relaxing time watching tv and put them to bed. He did none of the emotional stuff (they’re ND), no interest in any assessments - more like active opposition to anything ND related.

Then he’d say “You see the kids as work whereas I love spending time with them”. He once told me that he had them an equal amount of time. So I worked it out properly and he had them for half the amount of time he stated.

You’re just seeking validation and none of it means anything unless we have your ex wife’s side of the story.

Would you type this message if it was a woman complaining about her controlling ex? You’d say “none of this means anything unless we hear his side”? If you did, I think most people would be disgusted and you’d have your arse handed to you. The OP has his kids more than half the time and the ex brings her young child round to his when she’s had an argument with him. Yes she sounds like mum of the year doing all the grunt work 🙄

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 16:26

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:16

I mean your viewpoint is essentially that you are entitled to be selfish, as that is what is in your best interests.
When your child is 15, I’d say perhaps fair, at 12- no, and even younger (as is OP’s kid) def not. When you have children you sign up to putting their needs ahead of your own imv. Not always and forever, but certainly while they are still little.

Your suggestion means staying in a marriage that is not working. I was not being selfish, I think. I did what I knew would mean a stable life in which I can have my children. My ex tried to stop me from having access to them, inveigled me into handing over money that was legally mine on the promise of access and then denied it, lied to the court that access was sorted, threatened me with the CSA (he'd have lost on this one - I paid over the odds) and fought me over custody when I finally went back to court. He wanted 100% custody and access 'by arrangement'. I wanted 50% and every other week-end, so that the DCs had two homes. I could not have offered a home without prioritising my new relationship, for I was depressed and incapable of action following the divorce and only DH held me together, got me to see a GP (I had not even registered with one!) and pulled me out of self-defeating guilt. I did what was best for me because that was best for my children. If that is selfish, then so be it. I am a older generation and I do not have sentimental ideas about children or childhood, but practical views on how we can surmount the disasters that we fall into. NB I did not trust my ex with the care of my 13-year-old DD. He was in the habit of leaving her alone with my 17-year-old DS while he went away. I saw this as a safeguarding red flag, for who knew who he would have to stay/visit etc?

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:25

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:20

I love how it’s far more damaging for the kid to not get his third pair of trainers immediately than having it sprung on him unexpectedly that his dad is dating someone.

Please explain how OP handing over shoes to EW at door entails revealing his dad is unexpectedly dating someone 😂. When you get a delivery at your door does the mail man’s son have insight into your relationship dynamics? This thread is just getting stupid tbh,

AmethystSparkles · 28/12/2023 16:24

I think there’s another side to this too. It was the ‘Any time I spend with my kids is a gift’ thing.

My ex would have our kids staying over three nights a week at one stage but I’d collect them from school, give them dinner, get all their school stuff ready…it was a mad rush and exhausting! He’d pick them up, have a bit of a relaxing time watching tv and put them to bed. He did none of the emotional stuff (they’re ND), no interest in any assessments - more like active opposition to anything ND related.

Then he’d say “You see the kids as work whereas I love spending time with them”. He once told me that he had them an equal amount of time. So I worked it out properly and he had them for half the amount of time he stated.

You’re just seeking validation and none of it means anything unless we have your ex wife’s side of the story.

Boomer55 · 28/12/2023 16:21

I should ignore your ex - nothing you’ve said or done seems unreasonable, unless there’s a back story.

CoParents · 28/12/2023 16:20

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:18

Lol @CoParents that it’s reasonable or proportionate to fly off the handle and say “fine I’ll buy him some new ones” when you don’t get your own way. Especially in the context of gaslighting and controlling behaviour before and after separation. You will pardon me if I don’t take your advice on what’s best for kids particularly seriously.

lol ok. 👍🏻
(ps it hardly seems likely that EW going out of her way to pick up her kids trainers from OP’s house was about “getting her way” but okk 😂)

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:20

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:16

I mean your viewpoint is essentially that you are entitled to be selfish, as that is what is in your best interests.
When your child is 15, I’d say perhaps fair, at 12- no, and even younger (as is OP’s kid) def not. When you have children you sign up to putting their needs ahead of your own imv. Not always and forever, but certainly while they are still little.

I love how it’s far more damaging for the kid to not get his third pair of trainers immediately than having it sprung on him unexpectedly that his dad is dating someone.

MeMySonAnd1 · 28/12/2023 16:18

GabriellaMontez · 28/12/2023 12:07

Your son wants his trainers... he should be allowed to get them. He's your child. It's his home.

It's hard enough for children when there is a situation like this. This isn't a 'boundary' issue.

Sorry but no, the child can survive for a few hours without that pair of trainers (unless is it his one and only pair of shoes) if mum or dad are busy, out, working or in a date.

OP only asked her to pick them up “later” rather than straight away. Much like when they were married, he, she or the children should NOT be expected to drop everything and run to get whatever the other(s) need straight away, without, delay unless it is an emergency.

Divorce is not a marriage with two houses, the whole family needs to adapt to the new set up and its requirements and provide respect and privacy to each of their members.

Her having a huff and getting new shoes is highly unreasonable, I bet she would have made the child to wait if she was in the same situation.

I think OP she just got a bit of a shock to realise you were dating already and in the moment of shock reacted as she would have reacted if she was still your wife and you had told her you couldn’t deal with a request from her because you were having a coffee with a female colleague. How did you dare to tell your ex wife, the mother of your children, to wait rather than ending the date and run to do as wifey told you???? Again, this is part of getting used to the new set up and I’m sure in time she would realise this explosion was not about the children needs but about realising the level of influence she had over you is diminishing:

I remember my exh throwing a tantrum because I refused to order and pick up the food for a party he and his new partner were organising for HIS own birthday, he even shouted at me and told me I should do it because he was busy and new partner couldn’t help, even when we had been separated for years and both had our own new partners 😁

I suggest OP, for the sake of your children, let them have keys of the house so they can pick up stuff as needed if they are teenagers and you can trust them to knock first.

Don’t sweat the small stuff, just make sure you ask your kids if they have everything they need when they go back to mum’s house.

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:18

Lol @CoParents that it’s reasonable or proportionate to fly off the handle and say “fine I’ll buy him some new ones” when you don’t get your own way. Especially in the context of gaslighting and controlling behaviour before and after separation. You will pardon me if I don’t take your advice on what’s best for kids particularly seriously.

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 16:17

CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 15:34

@Olive19741205 I've since updated on subsequent posts.

Yes sorry. I see that now.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:16

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 16:05

But true. I am divorced and my DH is my second. My children were not hostile to him, and he had nothing to do with the break-up of my first marriage. DH was very careful (was a trained youth worker, as it happens) and understood they might be hostile. My ex-DH was hostile, and certainly told our DCs his version of what had happened in such a way that they were unable to listen to me, even if I wanted to tell them (bad idea). I knew that they were growing up (15 and 12 when we divorced) and would leave the nest at some point. Thus I put effort into the relationship I knew would be sustaining me now, when, indeed my children are living their own lives. Had I put them first maybe they would visit more often, but maybe not (visits seem evenly distributed), but my DH is here all the time. What is more his DS and his DCs are more than welcoming to me, and my DCs are included as family. Both like my DH.
Thought this view would be not entirely popular, but children cannot come first most of the time. If they were to do so we would none of us take a better job in another town, go on holidays that are not totally child-centred or move to a better house that happens to be away from the DC's friends or meant changing school. All of which would mean our family life would suffer.

Edited

I mean your viewpoint is essentially that you are entitled to be selfish, as that is what is in your best interests.
When your child is 15, I’d say perhaps fair, at 12- no, and even younger (as is OP’s kid) def not. When you have children you sign up to putting their needs ahead of your own imv. Not always and forever, but certainly while they are still little.

OhmygodDont · 28/12/2023 16:15

Illpickthatup · 28/12/2023 16:12

And what if his dad was having sex? Would it be ok for his son just to run in for his trainers?

Be a bit rude to answer the phone to your ex wife while having sex with your new lady 😂

Now if the son when a teenager has his own key… deadbolt or no sex on the sofa 😂

1983Louise · 28/12/2023 16:13

I think you did the right thing, I don't think you've harmed your son by not allowing him to have a particular pair of trainers, he should have taken them home in the first place 🙄. I think the problem is you have probably been too easy going with them, remember boundaries are a good thing. Hope the new romance goes well.

Illpickthatup · 28/12/2023 16:12

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 28/12/2023 12:49

If he was out that would be different. He was busy but there’s no reason his sim couldn’t have just run in and got his trainers. It’s his home too after all.

And what if his dad was having sex? Would it be ok for his son just to run in for his trainers?

CoParents · 28/12/2023 16:10

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 15:56

No, of course that would be too much, but if OP is in the house he should allow EW to pick belongings up for the kids (until the kids are able to do this themselves). Would have taken 30 secs to meet her at door. This is a bare minimum ask of a parent to compensate for requiring a child to live between two homes.

He offered to put the trainers on the doorstep. Why does she need any more than this when it's all about the belongings? Sometimes it really isn't appropriate for people to drop round at short notice, yes, including your own children. There is a very good reason for keeping the kids out of the OP's dating life until the relationship is more established. And saying 'well no dates' is really unreasonable.

That’s the misogynistic spin that has been read into this scenario. I Dont see any evidence of that from the facts OP presented.

He said that the ex was gaslighting to him during the relationship and since splitting, kept finding reasons to pop round. You don't seem to appreciate that it can be incredibly stressful for someone to have to deal with intrusive behaviour for an ex and that stress can affect the children too.

work is an entirely different scenario . Adults who live between two homes (say their first home and their partner’s home) very often find the issue of stuff being different places challenging. This would be even more the case if the division of time were as split as 50/50 and if they weren’t able to go get / pick up stuff as and when. If it’s stressful for adults , that stress is magnified many times for a small child who doesn’t have the same maturity / self regulation / independence / perspective that an adult has.

Okay but it is an inevitability and the alternative is that they live with only one parent so that they don't get stressed about their belongings and will suffer in other ways as a result. So given that the OP has the kids slightly more than 50/50 here, should the kids not spend any time living with their mum? Or is it only women who should have sole residence do you think?

Lots of children find shared parenting arrangements stressful. One of the main triggers/ stressors is the issue of belongings. Shared parenting arrangements can work really well when there is : 1) good communication and cooperation between the two parents, 2) they live close and 3) children are able to move relatively freely between homes.

Actually, routine is good for kids so the moving freely between two homes isn't necessarily good. They want certainty. Sometimes the parents are not able to communicate effectively but that doesn't mean that splitting time between them is a bad thing.

He offered to put the trainers on the doorstep

A claim which is in complete contradiction to OP’s first post. Sounds like- if that drip feed is actually true- op initially said he was occupied and “tomorrow would be fine” (rude for reasons pp’s have already pointed out) at which point EW slammed down phone (as per OP). Maybe he then followed up with he could leave them outside, but EW already (understandably imv) v upset, replied “don’t bother I’ll buy some new”.
Either way it hardly seems like a big deal for OP to hand over shoes at door and in no way entails child getting “involved in his dating life”. Not buying that crap for a second. No different to a delivery of a parcel interrupting his lunch for 30 seconds.

Okay but it is an inevitability and the alternative is that they live with only one parent so that they don't get stressed about their belongings and will suffer in other ways as a result. So given that the OP has the kids slightly more than 50/50 here, should the kids not spend any time living with their mum? Or is it only women who should have sole residence do you think?

what works best depends on the family and the kid. But if you are doing shared parenting, one thing you need to be flexible about is belongings. That’s all. Simple as that. This flexibility would normally be more onerous , as it might require picking up/ delivering things to other parent’s house at inconvenient times. Handing over something at one’s own door really is nothing!!

Actually, routine is good for kids so the moving freely between two homes isn't necessarily good. They want certainty. Sometimes the parents are not able to communicate effectively but that doesn't mean that splitting time between them is a bad thing.

by moving freely between two houses I didn’t mean to imply that children shouldn’t have a routine! 🤦🏼‍♀️ Just there shouldn’t be a sense of some strict apartheid between houses such that a child is banished from one home or the other at all times.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 28/12/2023 16:09

Workworkandmoreworknow · 28/12/2023 16:02

I don't doubt there is a backstory where mum is doing her best/ dad also is not a saint but I really can't see how it excuses the entitled tone of impatience and downright rudeness from his fellow co-parent here?

If it is the 15th time in 15 handovers that trainers have been forgotten, being impatient and downright rude has context, perhaps?

@Workworkandmoreworknow Perhaps, but there isn't really enough information to infer that is there?

@2ChildDad How are you at helping the kids remember their stuff?

CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 16:05

Workworkandmoreworknow · 28/12/2023 16:02

I don't doubt there is a backstory where mum is doing her best/ dad also is not a saint but I really can't see how it excuses the entitled tone of impatience and downright rudeness from his fellow co-parent here?

If it is the 15th time in 15 handovers that trainers have been forgotten, being impatient and downright rude has context, perhaps?

Where have you got 15 times in 15 handovers from? Or is that something else I've missed? 😂

Grammarnut · 28/12/2023 16:05

Tandora · 28/12/2023 15:54

He should put his new lady first. Children need to fit in. Will the children be with him every day when he is old, or will his romantic attraction

😮😮🤭🫣. Well now that is a fresh take 😂

But true. I am divorced and my DH is my second. My children were not hostile to him, and he had nothing to do with the break-up of my first marriage. DH was very careful (was a trained youth worker, as it happens) and understood they might be hostile. My ex-DH was hostile, and certainly told our DCs his version of what had happened in such a way that they were unable to listen to me, even if I wanted to tell them (bad idea). I knew that they were growing up (15 and 12 when we divorced) and would leave the nest at some point. Thus I put effort into the relationship I knew would be sustaining me now, when, indeed my children are living their own lives. Had I put them first maybe they would visit more often, but maybe not (visits seem evenly distributed), but my DH is here all the time. What is more his DS and his DCs are more than welcoming to me, and my DCs are included as family. Both like my DH.
Thought this view would be not entirely popular, but children cannot come first most of the time. If they were to do so we would none of us take a better job in another town, go on holidays that are not totally child-centred or move to a better house that happens to be away from the DC's friends or meant changing school. All of which would mean our family life would suffer.

SerafinasGoose · 28/12/2023 16:04

I've read most of the thread and the OP's updates. There have been some ridiculously OTT responses, not to mention an incredible overreaction from the ex-wife herself, who seemingly went out of her way to create a scene from a mere triviality. And a triviality it is; failure to capitulate instantly to her demands is hardly tantamount to child neglect.

@2ChildDad - your sense of discomfiture is the sound of your boundaries being being tested and largely found wanting, as your updates also indicate that this behaviour is a pattern and not a one-off. Your inclination that maintaining firm, strong boundaries are the answer to your dilemma is right. Your response to this situation gives her a good message: that anything less than an emergency doesn't necessitate her encroaching into your space. You should now hold to this and keep her at arm's length until that message begins to sink in. There will invariably be pushback, as this always happens when a pattern of control and capitulation is broken.

I'd also be inclined to put her on a strict 'information diet'. Unless your life events directly relate in some way to the children, any other personal information is none of her business. Who and when you are dating has precisely nothing to do with her.

You've done nothing wrong. Hope you had a pleasant lunch!

Workworkandmoreworknow · 28/12/2023 16:02

I don't doubt there is a backstory where mum is doing her best/ dad also is not a saint but I really can't see how it excuses the entitled tone of impatience and downright rudeness from his fellow co-parent here?

If it is the 15th time in 15 handovers that trainers have been forgotten, being impatient and downright rude has context, perhaps?

CandyLeBonBon · 28/12/2023 15:59

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 15:52

@Grammarnut thrash the boy soundly for his idle nature and be done with it, eh?

Grammar but is a proponent of some very outdated parenting techniques based on some of her previous comments on other threads!

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 15:58

He's not putting his 'new lady' first ffs. He's actually putting his kid first because he doesn't want the ex and child to drop round when he has a date there and risk confusing the child (like the mum clearly did). How is that anything other than being a responsible parent? Unless the answer is that he shouldn't have any dates ever until his child is 30 or something.