Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex Wife Boundaries

417 replies

2ChildDad · 28/12/2023 11:57

My ex wife and I share 50/50 custody of our children. I tend to have them slightly more than that over Christmas and half terms due to her work schedules (I am not complaining about that- any time that I spend with my kids in a gift). The kids spent Christmas with me and returned to her on Boxing Day.
She has started a relationship with another man (the kids were somewhat resistant to this, but I have been as supportive as I can be-he has even thanked me for this).
My boundary on this are that if the kids are with me, I don’t contact her unless absolutely necessary. She has her life to lead.
Yesterday, I received a call saying ‘we are coming over to your house now as he (my son) wants his other pair of trainers’.
I was actually having lunch with a lady that I have begun dating and said that ‘now is not convenient as I have company. Tomorrow will be fine’.
She slammed the phone down and then sent a text saying ‘Don’t bother I am going to buy some new ones’.
I think she is getting too aggressive here and not respecting boundaries. Or AIBU?

OP posts:
Summasolstice · 28/12/2023 19:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

YuleDragon · 28/12/2023 18:15

can't believe the amount of mothers on here who think they have a right to just walk all over their exes time/make demands of them outside their contact time.

Its at best bad manners, and at worst, controlling, narcissistic behaviour.

If i'd come on here and posted that my ExH had kicked off at me and demanded i dance to his timetable you'd all be telling me to hold to my boundaries.

The only difference here is that the OP is male.

Beezknees · 28/12/2023 18:06

Meh. I'm very of the opinion that you should always put kids first but making a fuss over trainers is ridiculous imo. If it was my DS and I was the ex I'd have just told him to wear a different pair. Not the end of the world is it.

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 18:01

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/12/2023 17:21

I imagine she's frustrated at seeing a date prioritised over their child. I know I certainly would be.

It's the child's home too. He should be allowed to get his belongings if he wants ( not the ex)

You sound exactly like DHs ex. She too thought that she could call him up for favours/pop over, make demands etc. when she had the kids. She used every excuse in the book. Every phone call started with "where are you, who you with?"

We finally insisted on boundaries being put in when she thought it was totally reasonable to give DH a timetable of when it suited HER for him to see me, obviously she tried to re-arrange the whole childcare schedule that had worked fine for 2 years. 🙄 (This was while we were dating and before I'd even met the kids)

She too used to say "how can you choose HER over the kids? Even though she had a boyfriend...the boyfriend she cheated on DH with. Even though DH had the kids 4/7 days. He wasn't allowed to have a life on the 3 days the kids were with her.

Thisreallyisntmyproblem · 28/12/2023 17:32

Tandora · 28/12/2023 17:13

I think she was angry at his initial dismissive and condescending response “tomorrow will be fine”. Fine for who exactly?
She obviously thought he was being unreasonable in refusing to hand over the trainers (as do I and many others on this thread) and became upset as a result.

It sounds like if he did offer to leave the shoes outside, this was after the initial refusal and EW, already wound up, responded “don’t bother”. But perhaps OP can clarify.

Angry that she couldn't have things her way and that her ex didn't dance to her tune. He has said she has previously demanded he return home so the child can get things.

Given that he already had 2 pairs of trainers at mum's, tomorrow would have been fine. And aged 9 or 10, she should have just told him that. End of discussion. She didn't even need to ring her ex, other than interfering in his life.

For those saying the child didn't need to know about his new girlfriend just to come over and get trainers, maybe her car was on the driveway? Or in that moment, when put on the spot by his ex, OP briefly couldn't think of a reason why he wanted his son kept away that could be used with him. Didn't want to provoke questions later etc, or have to say to new girlfriend to stay out of sight (awkward, much!). Because he wasn't expecting to see his son yesterday.

Illpickthatup · 28/12/2023 17:28

Its not that easy to just get full custody. The bar is very low for what is considered neglect. Also, just because she's awful towards OP doesn't mean she's a bad mother.

CoParents · 28/12/2023 17:24

auntiesatthere · 28/12/2023 17:16

Flexibility yes
Stupidity no

Ex shouldn't dictate that she's coming over now. She needs to learn to communicate

op has every right to state no I am busy

The child won't be scarred for life with PTSD because they had to wait for their trainers because mum cut her nose off to spite her face and didn't want the trainers left on the doorstop and to be honest telling a child no from time to time is not a sin

Ex shouldn't dictate that she's coming over now. She needs to learn to communicate

I actually agree with this -
it should have been framed as a respectful request. Sounds like they both communicated really poorly.

people need to stop with the dismissive “scar for life” crap though. Yes this one episode is one episode about a pair of trainers, but if OP and EW continue like this it will be a horrible arrangement for DC that will leave lasting scars.

Sounds like OP needs to get off his high horse , and EW needs to moderate her temper.

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/12/2023 17:21

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 17:09

Then that’s the fault of the ex saying ‘we are coming over to your house now’.

She needs to learn to communicate better.

I imagine she's frustrated at seeing a date prioritised over their child. I know I certainly would be.

It's the child's home too. He should be allowed to get his belongings if he wants ( not the ex)

auntiesatthere · 28/12/2023 17:16

Flexibility yes
Stupidity no

Ex shouldn't dictate that she's coming over now. She needs to learn to communicate

op has every right to state no I am busy

The child won't be scarred for life with PTSD because they had to wait for their trainers because mum cut her nose off to spite her face and didn't want the trainers left on the doorstop and to be honest telling a child no from time to time is not a sin

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 17:14

@Coolhwip as co parents they don’t seem to be communicating effectively. I’m sure they’ve both got opinions on where the blame lies but in reality it’s likely shared. In the meantime this is unlikely to be working as well as it might for the kids.

It’s a pretty minor issue that’s blown up and clearly bugged OP enough to start a thread about. That’s not a good co parenting relationship! If they’re under 3 years out from the split it’ll probably calm down, I can’t recall the timeline on that

Tandora · 28/12/2023 17:13

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 16:53

Why would she buy new trainers when ds already had 2 pairs at home?

Sounds like ex had a tantrum all on her own without any help.

I think she was angry at his initial dismissive and condescending response “tomorrow will be fine”. Fine for who exactly?
She obviously thought he was being unreasonable in refusing to hand over the trainers (as do I and many others on this thread) and became upset as a result.

It sounds like if he did offer to leave the shoes outside, this was after the initial refusal and EW, already wound up, responded “don’t bother”. But perhaps OP can clarify.

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 17:09

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/12/2023 17:05

Yeah that would have been fine. As long as he got the trainers.

Initially prioritising his date over his child by telling him to wait until tomorrow was wrong imo.

Then that’s the fault of the ex saying ‘we are coming over to your house now’.

She needs to learn to communicate better.

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 17:08

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 17:01

@Coolhwip The advice @CoParents os giving about flexibility & communication to make 50:50 work was given to me 5 years ago in mediation and to a friend recently by a family law solicitor

Flexibility and communication doesn’t mean the parents need to be in contact every day, especially if it means one parent makes unreasonable demands. And the poster did say they contact each other if there's an emergency or to request a change to the schedule.

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/12/2023 17:05

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 13:34

If she was putting her child first she would have been fine OP leaving the trainers outside.

Nosy cow wanted to get in the house.

Yeah that would have been fine. As long as he got the trainers.

Initially prioritising his date over his child by telling him to wait until tomorrow was wrong imo.

Wristfolds · 28/12/2023 17:01

@Coolhwip The advice @CoParents os giving about flexibility & communication to make 50:50 work was given to me 5 years ago in mediation and to a friend recently by a family law solicitor

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 16:56

CoParents · 28/12/2023 14:34

All the evidence shows this is really bad practice if you are doing 50/50. Not good for the kids at all. If there’s hostility like this, you ought to have a diff arrangement tbh.

Can you link to this ‘evidence’? Because it sounds made up.

OhmygodDont · 28/12/2023 16:54

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:49

I think if he did honestly offer this it must have been after the whole thing had escalated into an argument (phone slammed down etc) and EW had already decided against coming (shed rather just buy new shoes). Otherwise the OP doesn’t really make sense as originally written.

Perhaps OP can clarify exactly when and how he offered this option?

Yeah I’m wondering if the conversion was going around and around.

Son really needs/wants them today… sorry not today… seriously he can’t just grab his shoes?… I said no I’m busy… for god sake I’ll just bloody go buy new ones then…(getting ready to hang up) ok I’ll put them on the door step… don’t bother (hangs up)

could be totally wrong tho.

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 16:53

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:49

I think if he did honestly offer this it must have been after the whole thing had escalated into an argument (phone slammed down etc) and EW had already decided against coming (shed rather just buy new shoes). Otherwise the OP doesn’t really make sense as originally written.

Perhaps OP can clarify exactly when and how he offered this option?

Why would she buy new trainers when ds already had 2 pairs at home?

Sounds like ex had a tantrum all on her own without any help.

Coolhwip · 28/12/2023 16:51

Workworkandmoreworknow · 28/12/2023 14:51

Mum clearly doesn't care that much about boy getting his trainers either since she slammed the phone down and said don't bother

really? Maybe said boy has been droning on and on and on about getting the trainers. Maybe mum did everything she could to not to have to go and get them, but after hours of going on about it, she gave in. And then, when told no, you can’t get them realised she was going to have to buy a pair to keep the peace with said boy. So slammed the phone down.

is is convenient for the ‘second wives club’ to see things one way only. There is always a back story.

You must have a bad back after all that reaching.

NewNameNigel · 28/12/2023 16:49

AmethystSparkles · 28/12/2023 16:24

I think there’s another side to this too. It was the ‘Any time I spend with my kids is a gift’ thing.

My ex would have our kids staying over three nights a week at one stage but I’d collect them from school, give them dinner, get all their school stuff ready…it was a mad rush and exhausting! He’d pick them up, have a bit of a relaxing time watching tv and put them to bed. He did none of the emotional stuff (they’re ND), no interest in any assessments - more like active opposition to anything ND related.

Then he’d say “You see the kids as work whereas I love spending time with them”. He once told me that he had them an equal amount of time. So I worked it out properly and he had them for half the amount of time he stated.

You’re just seeking validation and none of it means anything unless we have your ex wife’s side of the story.

This whole post is classic projection. What does the shit man that you chose as a father for your children have to do with the op?

melj1213 · 28/12/2023 16:49

YANBU

I co-parent 50/50 with exDH, we have remained good friends and do lots of things together with DD, but he would never just tell me he was coming to get something from my house, he would ask if I was in/if it was convenient and if not then he'd figure something else out, he wouldn't have a hissy fit if I dared say "No it's not convenient to come over".

Likewise I would never see his house as an extension of my own. It is DDs home, just as my house is her home too, but it is not mine and I have no right to enter as and when I want.

Obviously if it was something important and/or time sensitive eg medication or her spare glasses because her main pair got broken then I would do everything in my power to get it sorted asap regardless of what I was doing but for something like "I want a different pair of shoes/top/bag etc" then if I was busy then tough, she'd have to wait.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:49

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:41

Then why not be happy with them being left out the front which OP offered (I know many posters don’t believe he did offer this but on the assumption that is true)?

I think if he did honestly offer this it must have been after the whole thing had escalated into an argument (phone slammed down etc) and EW had already decided against coming (shed rather just buy new shoes). Otherwise the OP doesn’t really make sense as originally written.

Perhaps OP can clarify exactly when and how he offered this option?

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:41

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:33

This is not clear at all.

Then why not be happy with them being left out the front which OP offered (I know many posters don’t believe he did offer this but on the assumption that is true)?

CoParents · 28/12/2023 16:33

Olive19741205 · 28/12/2023 16:32

It's very clear that you are all for trampling over ex partners boundaries.

lol.

Tandora · 28/12/2023 16:33

Needsomesupport84 · 28/12/2023 16:29

Because it’s pretty clear that ex was being nosy about the date which is why she wouldn’t accept getting the trainers without an interaction with OP.

This is not clear at all.