Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racist family members

35 replies

literaryloveaffair · 28/12/2023 11:25

I am at a family reunion in a European country where there are family members in attendance from Israel, Germany, America. I have been treated to quite a few statements like:

  1. Having a population that is 5% Muslim is one Muslim too many
  2. UK is in danger of becoming a sharia law state due to the Muslims
  3. It is fundamentally difficult for Muslims to integrate because most of them are religious fundamentalists who do much more than keeping ramadan and eating halal food
  4. Immigrant children are causing lots of havoc in schools, the arab students throw chairs around
  5. Low income immigrants are a burden on the state (including nurses) and importing nurses mean increasing the burden on the state cos they are low income.

Maybe i am sheltered but I am an immigrant and i have lived for 10 years in the UK and I have never heard so many statements said in any group of people. This is just the tip of the iceberg in just two days and frankly quite a small selection. I don't meet these family members very often so therefore don't hear that much. But it is shocking to me, is uk a much less racist society?

The bulk of the statements were said by my sisters' in laws' partners. It is unfortunate but my SILs made aliyah to israel (so they moved there after university without having ever worked in the UK and then tried to survive there). They then fell in love before they became 'established' in the new country and I suppose in the absence of jobs and the structure that provides, they fell in love with other 'unsettled people' who also came from similarly rich countries like america and netherlands. I suppose the chance of a potential partner being the kind of disaffected people who struggle to find job opportunities (and then pin the blame on immigrants/muslims/bogeyman of the time) is high. Its not that all people who move to Israel are like that (that is far from the truth), but I expect most people who move to a new country (esp one as expensive as Israel) would have some sort of plan (and probably hang out with other people who also had a plan). On the other hand, if you can't find a job, its quite easy to say you are a Zionist and move to Israel cos then a period of unemployment is easy to explain away (cos you are learning hebrew obviously and there is now a war on).

So I am wondering if perhaps such racism would be common in UK amongst people who are long term unemployed /or disaffected; but as I have always had a job, i don't really meet people in such circles. Or is UK really far less racist across all groups of people.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 28/12/2023 13:59

My husband is third/fourth generation British. He's kind of only Jewish by blood, not by culture/religion. None of us are religious, I would describe us as 'cultural Christians'. If anything it's me rather than him who tries to keep Jewish traditions alive. His parents were both atheist and adopted British traditions. His cousins are 'proper' Jews though. His only sibling also married out.

literaryloveaffair · 28/12/2023 13:46

Kendodd · 28/12/2023 13:38

God you should meet my family OP. They're the archetype Brexit voting racist. From your post I'm guessing you're Jewish? My husband is (atheist) Jewish according to my mum 'lovely though, and you'd never know he was Jewish'. Obviously, they hate anyone brown the most.

yes i am jewish. we are a mixed group. DH's mum is a convert and he grew up with non jewish grandparents. I am also a convert and they accept me as jewish. we are also not all ashkenazi, there are mizrahi/half mizrahi in the group.

Most people we know are jewish people in north london. Pretty conservative on the whole but most of them have partners who are non British (British Jewry is so small) and they are often in professions and worked with people from all over the world. Was talking about immigration with the americans and I said in the UK, I scarcely know a couple who is Jewish and where both partners are from the same country! This includes our family, everyone including him and my sister in law is an international couple (American/British). My American BIL looked like he never thought of this before, he hasn't had to do the immigration stuff as he and my SIL live in Israel but i know they are thinking of moving back to USA as an option to reduce their financial burden. But he knows the requirements and that he would probably have to hire an immigration attorney! Based on my understanding, a big part of the current waiting times for spouse visas in USA is due to extra requirements on work visas which creates more work for the staff processing the applications. It was the same in UK too, often when they tighten restrictions on all immigrants, usually includes immigrants spouses including those of British nationals.

OP posts:
DailyCake · 28/12/2023 13:45

I'm an immigrant to the UK but attended university here and live in a fairly international city where many sector specific based foreigners are employed in highly paid technical/engineering jobs. I can honestly say that the locals have been welcoming to the point of bending over backwards, not to be racist. I have been here for several decades and would say that the new anti Muslim sentiments seem to come from the older right wing Christian immigrant group who love Trump's anti abortion stance and people concerned about the waves of mostly male "asylum" seekers. I have lived in several countries and would definitely say that the UK, in the main, is NOT a racist country, but has parts that are.

Kendodd · 28/12/2023 13:38

God you should meet my family OP. They're the archetype Brexit voting racist. From your post I'm guessing you're Jewish? My husband is (atheist) Jewish according to my mum 'lovely though, and you'd never know he was Jewish'. Obviously, they hate anyone brown the most.

Chilicabbage · 28/12/2023 13:30

Do you read their newspapers? Because man. Some continetal really don't hold back. That then shapes opinions and whether or not you say them out loud even in a group rather than just with your spouse at home.

Chilicabbage · 28/12/2023 13:27

People in UK usually keep it to behind closed door. Unless they are interviewed about if they will vote for or against brexit...

OneTC · 28/12/2023 13:20

The difference isn't in the attitude it's in the willingness to express it

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/12/2023 13:17

BTW, I sometimes go on Quora, an international question-and-answer site, and have certainly encountered American posters who think that we are under Sharia law, 'ruled by Muslims', and even that Rishi Sunak is a Muslim.

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/12/2023 13:12

YANBU- but one can get this anywhere, including the UK- look at the Tommy Robinson supporters; and, on a slightly less blatant level, the tabloids.

Are the Israeli relatives perhaps equating all Muslims with Hamas (not an excuse of course)? Are the American ones Trump supporters?

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 28/12/2023 12:02

I've encountered these sorts of attitudes, and have lived in areas with high populations of Muslims.
It's all Bullshit. Muslims, like any other group of people can be good, or bad.

I've encountered a lot of good.