Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 11:45

TheCookieCrumblesThisWay · 28/12/2023 11:42

This previous comment sums it up for us “It was seen as cool to be intelligent and hard working, and to be involved in either sports or the arts, so no one was embarrassed to do well.” Would absolutely choose private school again but you need to select the right one as they aren’t all equal.

That's also seen as cool at my son's small state secondary school though.

notlucreziaborgia · 28/12/2023 11:43

I went to private school and loved it. I achieved high grades, but more than that I had a great time at school. I can’t personally compare and contrast to a UK state school of course, but based on my experience I would absolutely recommend private education.

TheCookieCrumblesThisWay · 28/12/2023 11:42

This previous comment sums it up for us “It was seen as cool to be intelligent and hard working, and to be involved in either sports or the arts, so no one was embarrassed to do well.” Would absolutely choose private school again but you need to select the right one as they aren’t all equal.

edithfg · 28/12/2023 11:42

Wow did not expect to come back to 9 pages of responses! I will start reading them on my lunch break, thank you!

OP posts:
AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 11:37

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 11:34

Some people don’t have time to be scouring the internet for articles to back their point on an online discussion forum. You clearly haven’t heard of and have absolutely no appreciation at all for the concept of anecdotal evidence which I have referenced throughout my posts. Funny that. You seem very triggered by my view and my explanation of what is very true in my personal experience. All I can guess is you’ve spent way more than you could truly afford on years of overly expensive education that hasn’t actually been worth it. Must hurt.

I didn’t need to scour. It’s a well known evidenced fact. If it wasn’t why would people pay?

I'm triggered? Says the person with the lengthy responses relying on anecdotal “evidence”.

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 11:34

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 11:25

Yet you’ve provided no evidence to support your view. Funny that.

Some people don’t have time to be scouring the internet for articles to back their point on an online discussion forum. You clearly haven’t heard of and have absolutely no appreciation at all for the concept of anecdotal evidence which I have referenced throughout my posts. Funny that. You seem very triggered by my view and my explanation of what is very true in my personal experience. All I can guess is you’ve spent way more than you could truly afford on years of overly expensive education that hasn’t actually been worth it. Must hurt.

AuContraire · 28/12/2023 11:27

I think if private school fees mean a compromise in your life (as in, you can’t easily afford it) then, if your children end up in "normal" jobs (teacher, nurse, engineer, normal lawyer, accountant, corporate drone-type jobs with a good-but-not-amazing middle-class salary) and they then, in turn, cannot afford to send their own children to private school too, then it was a waste of money really and you'd have been better off putting the £200k per child into living in the catchment of a good school and then helping them out with house deposits when they are older and settled.

If paying the fees are of no consequence to you, then it doesn't matter whether it was 'worth it'.

forjustnow · 28/12/2023 11:27

I went to a private school but teach in the state sector and have done for 14 years, my son is at a private school so I have a fairly good insight into both sectors.

I'd say that it depends entirely on your child and the school options available to you. There is no one size fits all and don't assume that a private school will always be the best option. Visit all your options and match them up with your child's needs.

MissingMoominMamma · 28/12/2023 11:27

I took DS, with ADHD, out of mainstream in yr 1 and sent him to a prep school where sport was heavily featured. It did him good. His energy and enthusiasm were appreciated, rather than barely tolerated.

We moved house when he was in yr5, so I found a local state primary where sport was also a big thing. He slotted in perfectly and was really happy.

I do believe that if he’d stayed at his first school, he would’ve ended up believing that he was ‘naughty’. It was already starting to happen. The boundaries and activities (the rules associated with sport particularly) helped him to regulate.

He passed the 11+ to go to grammar school, but opted for a nearby high school with a good record for sport, also.

He still has very close friends from both his last primary school and his high school, but not the prep.

I think the prep school helped enormously, but those four years were enough for him to break the ADHD ‘naughty’ label and use his condition to his advantage.

WellWillWoll · 28/12/2023 11:26

No.

I was privately educated and so were my children. School was lovely and we all really enjoyed it. But I don't think we're educationally any better off.

Randomsabreur · 28/12/2023 11:26

It depends.

  1. What are the state options like in your area?
  1. Are you available after school for extra curricular ferrying?

I am privately educated, as is DH. We can't afford to send ours private (unless they get scholarships) which probably shows the monetary value of our education, however private schools have got a lot more expensive than when we were children and we are basically equivalent to our parents professionally.

If you have an ok state school you could spend on targeted tutoring to step up academics if required.

You can get a better quality of extra curriculars outside school assuming you have the time to research and ferry.

If you want the "networking" opportunities you need to be going to one of the big names, no point in networking at a "normal" public school.

Big old names probably worth it (but check percentage of foreign boarders as of limited use for UK networking), normal town private school probably not, take care in a grammar area as the brightest kids will be aimed at the Grammars instead making the local privates more nurturing/missed grammar options rather than academically pushy.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 11:25

@EnidSpyton there are actually no non-state schools where I live (pupils would have to leave home and board/stay with family) and so we have a real mix of people at my son's school. Class sizes can also be quite small in some subjects, which can be good (more teacher time, less disruption, more chance to contribute) and bad (the main bad thing being small departments, so if a teacher is off they might well be the only specific teacher of that subject).
We do see privilege and networking here too, it's unavoidable really.

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 11:25

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 11:22

Look anyone can find articles, statistics and evidence to back what they believe to be true. And im not here for a row im simply pointing out what I have experienced as someone who works with people closely from both backgrounds and also has friends from both. And look im not disputing that having a private education can make a positive difference to someone as an adult at all- im just saying that it doesn’t necessarily make a big difference. But you must also realise that it can also be the case- though massively under appreciated- that a state education can have a very positive impact upon someone as an adult for one example in terms of resilience, working/dealing with people from varied backgrounds, self confidence in adversity and as a driver and motivator to want to be successful.
This is a debate that goes on and on especially on mumsnet and there are a lot of valid points to back each side of the argument. You think private education makes a notable difference to an adult and I don’t 🤷🏼‍♀️ it probably does for some and not for others. There’s a lot of factors at play in how someone turns out as an adult and I personally think parenting & life experience carries the most weight tbh like I said just my opinion/experience.

Yet you’ve provided no evidence to support your view. Funny that.

Ffs22 · 28/12/2023 11:22

We have family/ friends with kids at private school and they have so many more opportunities than our dc. It’s hard not to be envious. I am however making sure i save enough to help support my dc through university, should they decide to go down that route.
I worry for the future of children being educated in state schools in the uk.

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 11:22

Look anyone can find articles, statistics and evidence to back what they believe to be true. And im not here for a row im simply pointing out what I have experienced as someone who works with people closely from both backgrounds and also has friends from both. And look im not disputing that having a private education can make a positive difference to someone as an adult at all- im just saying that it doesn’t necessarily make a big difference. But you must also realise that it can also be the case- though massively under appreciated- that a state education can have a very positive impact upon someone as an adult for one example in terms of resilience, working/dealing with people from varied backgrounds, self confidence in adversity and as a driver and motivator to want to be successful.
This is a debate that goes on and on especially on mumsnet and there are a lot of valid points to back each side of the argument. You think private education makes a notable difference to an adult and I don’t 🤷🏼‍♀️ it probably does for some and not for others. There’s a lot of factors at play in how someone turns out as an adult and I personally think parenting & life experience carries the most weight tbh like I said just my opinion/experience.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 11:21

Networks exist everywhere, who you interact with on a daily basis definitely influences opportunities which might arise and/or your life view.
Different people will also react to different experiences and/or opportunities differently, and something one person sees as an opportunity others may see as a burden. The reality is though that opportunities do generally present themselves more in situations of higher wealth, whether we choose to acknowledge that or not.

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 28/12/2023 11:19

"Cultural capital." Thank you, that's a phrase I was trying to remember!

Also, "resilience" is literally "jumping back" so pretty close to "bounce-back-ability."

EnidSpyton · 28/12/2023 11:18

I went to both private and state schools, and am now a teacher myself and have taught in both state and private schools.

I would say private education is worth it if:

  1. Your child would benefit from the more nurturing environment that comes with smaller classes
  2. Your child excels at a particular extracurricular activity the school specialises in, and can provide lots of opportunities for them to perform/play at a high level

In my view, these are the only benefits.

The quality of teaching in private schools is largely mediocre. Lots of teachers are looking for an easy ride and they get it with smaller classes and no Ofsted pressure. Many have been there forever, plan on staying there until retirement, and have no interest in professional development or innovation. This is especially true of schools outside of London.

London private schools should have better quality teachers because they are more academically competitive and so need staff who can deliver. That being said, I still know of many highly mediocre teachers in London private schools (I've worked alongside many!) who have PhDs and/or Oxbridge degrees, and so look very impressive on paper, but who can't teach for toffee.

Outside of the highly academically selective schools, of which there aren't as many these days, you'll find the academic standard of many of the children isn't particularly high, either. The reality is, many private schools are struggling in the current climate and it's a case of bums on seats - they will let anyone in. In my current private school, I have more SEN children than I've ever taught in my career, with very little provision for them - the school will let anyone in as long as they pay the fees - and this means that the bright children are not getting a great educational experience, because us teachers are having to teach to the bottom the whole time (we have no TAs). The old days of private schools equalling a high quality educational experience and excellent behaviour are gone. A large % of the student body of many of the top schools are now made up of Chinese and Russian students, who don't speak English and whose parents are paying for the name and couldn't care less about the results, which does affect the environment of the school. There is a lot of disruptive behaviour from students - I am seeing it more and more - particularly from the children of the uber wealthy who know they don't need grades or a good university place, because they've got a multi million pound trust fund coming their way. Behaviour is not what it used to be.

Private schools are not a guarantee of a great educational experience anymore. I would do my research very carefully, visit several - while also visiting the local state schools - and thoroughly weigh up what benefits your child will get for the money. Private schools are very good at marketing themselves, but beneath the surface, many don't offer anything other than a name and better lunch choices in the canteen. This obviously depends on where you are in the country - there are a lot of what I would call tinpot private schools in London and the Home Counties, designed for anxious middle and upper middle class parents with not very bright children who don't want their precious babies mixing with the great unwashed. It's those sorts of schools where you will be throwing your money down the drain. The large regional privates that also do boarding and that offer amazing extracurricular opportunities are a different kettle of fish, though the teaching still won't be guaranteed to be amazing. Lots of 'chalk and talk' and teachers who've been there since before the flood...

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 11:16

WinterNamechange · 28/12/2023 11:12

My DH had a private education, and I did not. I went to a Russell Group university and have a PhD, he went to an ex-poly and has a masters. We both now earn around the same, so I don’t think it’s particularly worth it. My parents were not pushy, but did push me if that makes sense so I think parenting is more important.

I've seen some folk who were very unhappy because their parents only pushed them in academic or sporting prowess and forgot to push them, aka encourage them, to be well rounded humans, who are resilient and can cope with challenges and failure. Some of the kids who do well all of the time don't react well when they don't do so well, for whatever reason the 'failure' comes about. 'Bounce-back-ability' is a horrible word but it basically sums up what we need to teach our children, oh yes, and that it's ok to be disappointed for a little while before bouncing back too!

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 11:15

theduchessofspork · 28/12/2023 11:12

In your circs almost certainly yes

It gives you a confidence that the world is your oyster, and usually a breath of cultural capital, probably a breath of education and possibly a network that you wouldn’t get in even the best state school.

I don’t think anyone should bankrupt themselves but you aren’t in that situation.
Pick a good one though, because my god it is expensive and you want maximum value.

Yes culture capital is not mentioned enough - people on here seem to judge the worth of an education only on the job people get at the end of it.

ZforZebra · 28/12/2023 11:15

Yes - DH and I went to private schools throughout, he boarded in secondary, I did not. For both of us it was definitely worth it in terms of small class sizes, extra curricular activities, better facilities and support for getting into first choice universities, and ultimately the top companies in our fields (e.g helping secure placements and internships, in part because of the PTA connections across various industries).

I really enjoyed my school years. It was a huge financial sacrifice for my parents (not so much for his). Both our DC are in private schools and doing well, as long as we can afford it we will keep them in private schools.

By the same token I know plenty of people who didn’t go to private schools and have just as happy school memories and have achieved similar/greater than people from private schools. Just do whatever seems to work for your family.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 11:13

CrapBucket · 28/12/2023 10:58

Don’t be sorry you’re entitled to your opinion. My post is written from many years of experience in the workplace though. I’m glad if your life has been different but I definitely know what I’m talking about here.

I taught in both state and independent sectors and in the independent school did work alongside several people from public schools - Charterhouse, Eton etc. but also many from the state sector and more ordinary independent schools. Those from public schools did seem to be a slightly different breed but were charming nonetheless.

I maintain that this 'network' that people are obsessed with on this thread really only relates to public schools but you are entitled to your opinion.

theduchessofspork · 28/12/2023 11:12

In your circs almost certainly yes

It gives you a confidence that the world is your oyster, and usually a breath of cultural capital, probably a breath of education and possibly a network that you wouldn’t get in even the best state school.

I don’t think anyone should bankrupt themselves but you aren’t in that situation.
Pick a good one though, because my god it is expensive and you want maximum value.

WinterNamechange · 28/12/2023 11:12

My DH had a private education, and I did not. I went to a Russell Group university and have a PhD, he went to an ex-poly and has a masters. We both now earn around the same, so I don’t think it’s particularly worth it. My parents were not pushy, but did push me if that makes sense so I think parenting is more important.

SoupDragon · 28/12/2023 11:10

I grew that it very much depends on the child and the local schools. All 3 of mine went to state primary and private secondary.

DS1 would have thrived in any decent school.
DS2 needed to be in an environment with good discipline and high academic expectations with a highly academic cohort (this could have been achieved with the right state school if it was available).
DD got a lot of support for her particular educational needs from her private school that I don't think a state school could have matched.

Swipe left for the next trending thread