Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 28/12/2023 15:54

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/12/2023 15:51

A lot more ket in the private sector.

And state schools are famously drug free 🙄

it's a very lazy stereotype.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/12/2023 15:51

A lot more ket in the private sector.

Another76543 · 28/12/2023 15:47

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/12/2023 13:13

I would worry about the drug-taking. It's absolutely rife in private schools.

The one you're looking at must be quite cheap, if it only costs one holiday and a few grand on the mortgage. Just how good are the results?

If your kid is smart, send them to a decent state school. They'll still get 8s and 9s.

I would worry about the drug-taking. It's absolutely rife in private schools.

That is partly why it’s so important to pick your private school carefully. Yes, there are schools with drug problems, but there are others with a zero tolerance approach to drugs, where a child will be immediately expelled if they are caught having taken drugs.

Drug taking amongst teens is certainly not just a private school problem though. There are plenty of drug problems in state schools as well.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/12/2023 15:46

squirrelnutkin10 · 28/12/2023 10:51

There are good and bad in both sectors but imo, if you were to put the best state school beside the best Independent school, then the Indie would top the state school.
It HAS to fit your child though or it is a complete waste of money. Look at the child you have and really consider what they need to bring the best out of them.

Mine are completely different children,
DD, very quiet, but fiercely academic, driven and competitive, fits in with somewhat nerdy, geek,y independent friends with drive, her current private school (6th Form) has allowed her to excel, Prefect, Head of Debating, Subject ambassador etc. Her confidence has rocketed and the opportunities to excel where she is strong have been very good.

Her Prep school took her from a quiet, shy, child and gently but persistently helped her to come out of her shell, take part in discussions and school plays and give speeches to an audience. They found her intellect and developed it.
Particularly important as she has a chronic health condition and missed a lot of early school years. They were very accommodating of this.

But we looked very hard to find what would fit her, and have for years driven her 35 minutes each way to school and back daily.

DS, sociable chatty and a bit lazy academically but has lots of energy, his Prep offered lots of exposure to music of all kinds, he has been playing an unusual instrument for 10 years now and loves being part of an orchestra. He was taught every sport imaginable and decent academics. But was bullied eventually, so we removed him straight away, and he went to a tiny Prep with little facilities but really good academics, which prepared him for Senior school.

We decided on a family feel co-ed small Private school with solid academics but a very warm inclusive ethos and it has been great for him, rebuilt his confidence, and he has a great group of friends. He is now confident enough to look at a more academic 6th form nearby.

Each school has given them something important, and built their characters in a very positive way, we listened to their input and reacted accordingly, but always made the final decision. It gets easier as they get older and their personalities shine through.
I do not like the rather woke leanings of some state schools, and wanted both to have the aspiration and character that we believe in, luckily the schools have done this admirably.

This is so true. My dd started at private school in year 9. I wanted her to go to private school for secondary but when the time came, she refused. Then covid struck in year 7 and 8. I realised something was going terribly wrong at her former (Ofsted outstanding) state school when the one and only Parents’ evening at the end of year 8, for the most part, I didn’t recognised my child. Home schooling actually saved her education as she did all the work and learned a lot.

Dd chose to go to a smallish co-ed secondary with a real family feel as she wanted something, which felt like her former primary. She never looked back. Seeing how happy dd was, the parents of 3 of her friends decided to follow suit. None of them are at dd’s school btw. All are thriving as the schools suit them.

As for dd, her confidence has blossomed. She is a completely different person and has found she’s quite good at certain subjects. She is in year 11 and we have looked around at other schools, college (which she felt was too much) and are also considering state school. She passed the interview and had a provisional offer at a larger all girl’s more academic school. She is thrilled as the facilities are amazing. The question is whether this or staying where she is will be the better choice. The latter has a brilliant alumni network, which is tempting for me, someone, who went to a dire, rough state school, which would have failed ofsted. We haven’t looked around the state school btw so that’s also on the cards as it is the only one, which offers 4 A levels.

Like SQUIRREL’S dd, mine also has a health condition. It didn’t affect her much in primary. However, she really struggled with being different in secondary, which is a large part of why she was struggling at the large state school. She will do far better at GCSE in her current school for sure. She had plenty of friends in state, was very popular but because she doesn’t want to be seen as different, she felt very ‘stuck’ in lessons, unable to participate, either to ask or answer questions so her academics were suffering.

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 15:41

@Teenangels

We have 4 children that have all gone through Private (Public) and the cost was £36,000 per year per child plus extras.
I have yet to spend over £140,000 on one holiday

An average holiday is probably about £5,000.00

People who are contemplating private education by giving up one holiday a year aren’t spending £5k on that holiday.

School fees could be anything between £10-40k pa. As could a decent holiday. Why are you finding that so hard to grasp?

Paperbagsaremine · 28/12/2023 15:32

tenbob · 28/12/2023 14:46

Have I massively misread this, or are you suggesting an ideal education is one where you have friends who are abused by their parents?

Also, what did the Covid enquiry highlight was incomplete about private educations? I’ve googled it but can’t find anything to suggest an ‘incomplete experience’

To clarify: Helen Macnamara gave evidence to the COVID enquiry (https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/01/boris-johnson-unbelievably-bullish-over-covid-top-civil-servant-tells-inquiry for one link) saying that the narrow outlook of the almost uniformly privileged decision makers caused problems.
The video of her evidence is online and it's very interesting.

Lack of diversity in No 10 led to women’s deaths in lockdown, Covid inquiry told

Helen MacNamara says women became ‘invisible overnight’ and criticises Johnson’s failure to challenge ‘misogynistic language’

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/01/boris-johnson-unbelievably-bullish-over-covid-top-civil-servant-tells-inquiry

ValkyrieAssassin · 28/12/2023 15:27

GogoGobo · 28/12/2023 15:16

This post really resonates with me.
My SIL and BIL spend huge amounts of time telling me how "if they're smart they'll get the grades".
They have two in state secondary, I have one in private.
SIL and BIL both went to private schools, but they like to tell me all about state schools. Well, I am pretty much the only person in our social group who grew up on a council estate and went to a very rough state school.

What @pegasusreturns recounts as her husband's school experience is pretty much the same as mine!
Maybe mine was a little more forgiving as I am female, and so it was fine to be in the school play!

The experience my son has compared to mine, is night and day.
I've made a couple of big financial trade offs in order to pay for his schooling, which means I won't retire early and I will carry debt for about 5 years after he's left school.
Every day I am thankful that his formative years are spent in an upbeat, well resourced, forward thinking environment. He plays sport, and instruments, and has many many opportunities to try new things. Being smart is cool. Contributing is cool. Working hard is cool.
That's what I'm paying for.

This to me is the best response. It's one that resonates with me. For slightly different reasons as i said in my post with a SEN child, but yes resonates deeply.

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 15:25

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 14:38

I have as much idea as those saying giving up a holiday doesn’t allow for private schooling. It could. Easily.

We have 4 children that have all gone through Private (Public) and the cost was £36,000 per year per child plus extras.
I have yet to spend over £140,000 on one holiday.
An average holiday is probably about £5,000.00 for a week away, and a private school that provides an adequate education is certainly going to cost more per year.

TheaBrandt · 28/12/2023 15:25

I am smug that my 15 year old has extraordinarily good social skills and has close friends from both extreme ends of the social spectrum and gets on beautifully with both families. She slots into both the Manor House and the council flat without batting an eyelid and judges her friends purely on their merit as people.

GogoGobo · 28/12/2023 15:16

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 12:00

This idea of no real life experience is an interesting one.

my DC certainly have a somewhat “narrow” view of the world. But my DH who had a very different up bringing also had a narrow world view.

by 15, his best mate and neighbour was in a YOI, his pals stole cars, took drugs, robbed and fought. Going to school was “sad”, achieving had you in line for a beating. He’d never been to a theatre, restaurant or on holiday. Singing in a choir or acting in the school play was for “wankers”. Debating, model UN or learning an instrument was unthinkable.

My DC have never seen a fight, heard a teacher be verbally abused or skipped school. They didn’t have the street smarts that seem so important at 15/16. But as young adults they have full confidence in their ability and can navigate pretty much any social setting.

Of course life is a spectrum but I know which is the better end to have one’s experiences.

This post really resonates with me.
My SIL and BIL spend huge amounts of time telling me how "if they're smart they'll get the grades".
They have two in state secondary, I have one in private.
SIL and BIL both went to private schools, but they like to tell me all about state schools. Well, I am pretty much the only person in our social group who grew up on a council estate and went to a very rough state school.

What @pegasusreturns recounts as her husband's school experience is pretty much the same as mine!
Maybe mine was a little more forgiving as I am female, and so it was fine to be in the school play!

The experience my son has compared to mine, is night and day.
I've made a couple of big financial trade offs in order to pay for his schooling, which means I won't retire early and I will carry debt for about 5 years after he's left school.
Every day I am thankful that his formative years are spent in an upbeat, well resourced, forward thinking environment. He plays sport, and instruments, and has many many opportunities to try new things. Being smart is cool. Contributing is cool. Working hard is cool.
That's what I'm paying for.

goldenrachita · 28/12/2023 15:09

I can see why you would if the state schools in your area are poor. We are in a relatively affluent area and I can't understand why a friend of mine spends the money sending her children to a small private school locally. The class sizes are very small and at parties I see how much less social confidence her children have compared to the ones like mine at the excellent local state primaries with 30 or 60 in a year. I think academically at private school they are definitely ahead, but that's inevitable with small class sizes. You can't change your child's natural academic capabiliites that much- by senior school they will even out anyway. I also feel my children have had more opportunities to learn teamwork and collaboration and to work with a range of different personalities- this is probably the main thing they'll need in life to be successful. Might not be much of an issue at big private schools.

Also- probably being a bit stereotypical here- but I find in affluent areas the private school parents are generally a bit less educated themselves, younger (early 30s at private compared to around 40 at my children's state primary) and there is quite a high percentage of children with minor special needs who are sent privately as the parents worry about how they'd do in a state school. It's been great for a couple of children I know who are obviously not quite 'average' and the close attention has helped them. You'll also probably find a lot of Indian and SouthEast Asian families (coming from countries where anyone "successful" goes private), and a lot of only children and children with both parents work very long hours away from home. Visit to get a feel for how you'd fit in. I think it's one of the biggest factors. Culturally you need to weigh all this up and find the best fit for your individual family.

usernother · 28/12/2023 15:04

Depends on local schools and the child. Having worked in state secondary schools in my area I'm glad my children went to private schools.

Kirkeee · 28/12/2023 14:50

I’d say objectively you’d have to say it was worth it for my parents. My brother is a pilot, sister works for one of the big 4 as a management consultant and I’m a doctor.

My sister and I both got into grammar schools at 11. We were just surrounded by people who all wanted to do well - we were told we could be anything we wanted.

I tried a term at the local 6th form college (boy crazy) and it was shocking the amount of pratting about the other students got up to. Luckily I was able to go back to my secondary school.

And my parents are first generation (British Indian) and not from money. We never went on holiday and presents were scarce. My mum would put us to sleep and go clean offices after working a full time job.

Education is amazing. My grandfather was a bus driver in Delhi, his wife (my grandmother) couldn’t even read.

tenbob · 28/12/2023 14:46

Paperbagsaremine · 28/12/2023 10:32

I would add that the recent COVID enquiry highlighted the problem with people being given very expensive private school education from a very young age - an incomplete experience which can come back to bite you in the bum.

I went to state until twelve and so I had friends who had immigrant parents, friends who were taken "back home" and spent months in schools where they still used the belt, friends whose Dad's belted them at home, kids who weren't bad but obviously fucked up from their messed up families, kids who had a lot of plus points but who just were.not. academic in the least, and so on.

It makes a huge difference to have seen "real life" with your own eyes, rather than just intellectually knowing that certain things happen. Huge.

Have I massively misread this, or are you suggesting an ideal education is one where you have friends who are abused by their parents?

Also, what did the Covid enquiry highlight was incomplete about private educations? I’ve googled it but can’t find anything to suggest an ‘incomplete experience’

Fuzziduck · 28/12/2023 14:40

arethereanyleftatall · 28/12/2023 09:11

I teach in the private schools and the state schools in my area (specialised sport). The state schools are WAY better. I only started at the private this September, and I have been horrified.

Way better at the specialised sport?

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 14:38

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 12:31

You have no idea what the OPs financial situation you are assuming.
The fees could be £4000.00 a year or £36,000 a year per child that we were paying.

I have as much idea as those saying giving up a holiday doesn’t allow for private schooling. It could. Easily.

VikingsandDragons · 28/12/2023 14:36

I went private, my parents were teachers so saved every penny to send myself and my sibling. I was always academic, so I think I'd have done well anywhere but I was incredibly shy and nervous at 11. My school built up my confidence and helped me to feel seen in a way my primary (90 kids per year vs 40 at private secondary) hadn't. I was surrounded by families who got on in life, not mega flash but no one was failing. It sort of set this expectation that anyone could do if you set your mind to it, because none of those parents were mega geniuses that I can tell. I went on to found my company, have more than 20 employees, I genuinely think if I'd gone to the state school I'd have gotten a decent job, but the idea that I could do more than that would never have really entered my mind. Likewise my brother was very quiet at 11, he still is as an adult, but he's also the most self-assured person I know. Kind, quiet but he's very secure in himself. We weren't at the same private school, he picked a much sportier one and mine was single sex and more academic, but for both of us I'd say it helped our grades, but not hugely, but more over it's set both of us up very well for the rest of life. Personally my one regret was going to a single sex school, but at the time there wasn't a co-ed private within 50 miles, by brother was the first year at his school that took both.

Two of my friends are secondary teachers and both very strongly advised private if we could at all afford it. What struck me more than anything was one of them saying 'I see each child an hour a week, that's more than 700 a week, unless your child is genuinely gifted (in my subject) or a real troublemaker, I won't even know their name until GCSE'. In comparison we get phone calls or emails a couple of times a week from our daughter's school to update us on anything we need to know specific to her (she has some issues which require extra support) as well as obviuosly all the extra-curricular etc that state just can't match. I do also like that they don't have to follow the national curriculum, which in parts is antiquated and irrelevant, so the education can be more relevant.

Our daughter has a strong interest in IT, which is the area my husband also works in. We went around 3 privates and 2 state secondaries. He spent a long time talking to the IT departments in each, 2 of the private schools taught to a standard that he could have any of their pupils at 16 walking into a 45k trainee role, the other private much more followed the standard state curriculum which he felt was not close enough to what was needed in the workplace now without requring a degree to get there. It's not the fault of the school, but the curriculum that is set for them and not adaptive enough to changes in tech. This in part made our decision because what we spend on fees in 7 years could be easily the difference in earning capacity in the following 5 years.

With all that said I don't think all private is created equal, some isn't going to be worth the money, and some state ed is worth going to (but our town secondary is supposedly in the top 200 in the country and yet no one has a good word to say about it). Speak to the parents in your area about what they think of your schools in particular, league tables are much, much less important than the outlook they each have to nurturing your child.

Marchitectmummy · 28/12/2023 14:30

Panicmode1 · 28/12/2023 13:24

Behaviour, confidence, happiness and rounded education in our girls and their school friends far outstrips their peers in state school. Yet the author of this post states they only have experience of private schooling....?!!

Some people will choose to privately educate, some will choose to put their children in state (even if private were an option), and some parents don't get a choice....making pronouncements such as the one above, are why these discussions about 'state v private' always descend into bunfights. There are happy, rounded, well educated children thriving at state and private schools, there are unhappy children at state and private schools, there are outstandingly good state schools, and achingly awful ones - and the same in the private sector....! No two schools are the same and no two children are either. What does make a difference (IMO) is parenting..the values, habits, life lessons, and cultural capital that you give your children, the time and effort spent broadening their minds and opportunities - whether they are on site or you have to drive them all over the place to find them - are what makes a child the whole person they become.

Yes i do, in rhe same vein as many on the post also have experience only of state. The nature of life is that all of our experiences are limited thus all are throwing in the hat their lived experiences.

Whatever our experience we all will have encountered children who are either state educated or private and will im sure draw comparisons.

Employees children, neighbours children, children we come across at parties, my husbands colleagues children all include both state and privately educated children - my comments are based on a comparable of those.

I agree with a lot of your post, engaged parents of course make a massive difference to a child's behaviour, success, happiness, surely that is a given. However peers also influence children, private schools can control who those peers are, state can not.

Funding in state schools also appears to be a major issue, if the local fundraising is to be believed some state schools do not include stocked libraries, are missing teachers assistants, are boomeranging the same disruptive children around all of the local schools, some schools have metal detectors installed. These things can not be spun into positives and are not things I recognise in any private school.

edithfg · 28/12/2023 14:09

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 13:37

The one you're looking at must be quite cheap, if it only costs one holiday

how much do you think a family holiday is?

@PegasusReturns i haven’t quoted the right poster sorry, but the fees are 20k a year, not sure where that sits in terms of cheap or not.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 28/12/2023 14:07

The thing that worries me is lack of teachers. Affecting state more but also private. .

Despite being quite pro state as our family have succeeded and thrived using state education the way public services are being degraded would not make me blame anyone for going private. The primary ours left 4 years ago is really struggling now with lack of resources and pupil behaviour. Thuu I s is according to teachers there so not idle gossip.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 13:51

Some important thing to remember when making comparisons. First, most private schools are overtly or covertly selective. And the parents are more affluent than average. And a significant indicator of achievement is parental income. So most private school kids are the kind who would probably be top se in a state school, and the published results are whole school. So look at the high achievers results. Even in grammar school areas where there are no comprehensive schools, the top set in the high schools tend to do as well as the grammars.

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 13:37

The one you're looking at must be quite cheap, if it only costs one holiday

how much do you think a family holiday is?

XelaM · 28/12/2023 13:25

From people I know whose kids are at state schools - I would say grammar schools give you the same value as a private school, but the private schools I know are all much better than the local comps, even those rated “outstanding”.

Panicmode1 · 28/12/2023 13:24

Behaviour, confidence, happiness and rounded education in our girls and their school friends far outstrips their peers in state school. Yet the author of this post states they only have experience of private schooling....?!!

Some people will choose to privately educate, some will choose to put their children in state (even if private were an option), and some parents don't get a choice....making pronouncements such as the one above, are why these discussions about 'state v private' always descend into bunfights. There are happy, rounded, well educated children thriving at state and private schools, there are unhappy children at state and private schools, there are outstandingly good state schools, and achingly awful ones - and the same in the private sector....! No two schools are the same and no two children are either. What does make a difference (IMO) is parenting..the values, habits, life lessons, and cultural capital that you give your children, the time and effort spent broadening their minds and opportunities - whether they are on site or you have to drive them all over the place to find them - are what makes a child the whole person they become.

XelaM · 28/12/2023 13:22

My brother went to private school in Germany and it was the making of him. He has an amazing career and degrees from both Cambridge/Harvard. He has been on 100K+ straight out of uni. However, most importantly the friends he made at school he is still friends with today and they all have amazing careers. A lot depends on the individual private school though because not all are the same.