Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
spriots · 28/12/2023 18:05

twistyizzy · 28/12/2023 17:48

The extra curricular stuff can only be done outside of school if parents have the time though. DH and I both work FT. In order to match the sports, drama, music and other extras DD gets at private school we would have to spend every evening and all weekends ferrying her around to various clubs. It just isn't feasible or desirable. With private school she does all the extras as part of the school day so we can spend quality time as a family on an evening/weekend.

I think it depends on whether all extracurriculars interest you or not.

Also some are covered at state school too - mine do musical instruments, drama and sport after school as part of the after school clubs offerings so it's mainly swimming we do outside school

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 28/12/2023 18:04

spriots · 28/12/2023 18:00

I did get excellent results to be fair.

I think one of the reasons that I am reluctant to send mine to private school is that I think I would struggle not to then be disappointed if they weren't academic and got top grades. Which isn't the parent I want to be - I want to encourage them to follow their dreams academic or otherwise.

I can totally understand this. My oldest DC wasn't particularly academic and didn't get great grades, but, like me all those years ago, discovered some subjects that were real passions (and which weren't taught at any other local school), and is now thoroughly enjoying uni.

spriots · 28/12/2023 18:00

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 17:45

@spriots "
Is it? My parents definitely sent me to private school for the results.

Most of the other things can be done out of school"

If they sent you just for the results they probably wasted their money. As I said earlier, the only thing that might have tempted me to use private schools is not having to do everything else out of school!

I did get excellent results to be fair.

I think one of the reasons that I am reluctant to send mine to private school is that I think I would struggle not to then be disappointed if they weren't academic and got top grades. Which isn't the parent I want to be - I want to encourage them to follow their dreams academic or otherwise.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 17:59

@Framilode You are talking about schools 31 years ago.....

Framilode · 28/12/2023 17:51

My two girls were both very bright and both did well in state primary schools. We sent the eldest to the local comp, this was in the days before ofsted inspections etc. It was a disaster. She left with no GCSE's and in with a bad crowd.
After this, we paid for our second daughter to go to a highly selective independent grammar school. Acadamically, that worked very well. She has ended up as a senior partner in an international law firm and earns zillions.
However, she says she would never send a child of hers to a school like that, as she calls it an exam factory. Her children all go to indpendent/public schools but far more rounded than hers.
I don't know what the answer is. If she had gone to the local comp I don't think she would have done so well but, maybe, she would have been happier.

twistyizzy · 28/12/2023 17:48

spriots · 28/12/2023 17:37

Is it? My parents definitely sent me to private school for the results.

Most of the other things can be done out of school

The extra curricular stuff can only be done outside of school if parents have the time though. DH and I both work FT. In order to match the sports, drama, music and other extras DD gets at private school we would have to spend every evening and all weekends ferrying her around to various clubs. It just isn't feasible or desirable. With private school she does all the extras as part of the school day so we can spend quality time as a family on an evening/weekend.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 17:45

@spriots "
Is it? My parents definitely sent me to private school for the results.

Most of the other things can be done out of school"

If they sent you just for the results they probably wasted their money. As I said earlier, the only thing that might have tempted me to use private schools is not having to do everything else out of school!

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 28/12/2023 17:41

spriots · 28/12/2023 17:37

Is it? My parents definitely sent me to private school for the results.

Most of the other things can be done out of school

I think that it's just as hard to generalise about private school parents' motivations as it is to generalise about private schools! As a teacher, I see plenty of parents and students who are entirely motivated by grades and/or university and job prospects. And plenty who aren't.

As a parent I think I fall into that second category, but I'm aware that it takes a lot of financial security to support DC while they 'follow their dreams' and make the most of opportunities.

mathanxiety · 28/12/2023 17:39

I had the enormous benefit of private elementary school education in a single sex setting, and my DCs also benefited enormously from their private elementary school. (In Ireland and the US respectively).
State for secondary - both great schools.

I'd choose a single sex private primary school experience for girls every time.

spriots · 28/12/2023 17:37

notlucreziaborgia · 28/12/2023 17:08

It’s not just about the results though, is it? A big part of what motivates parents who privately educate ime, is providing their kid/s with the opportunities and experiences that private schools offer. The results aren’t the whole of it.

Is it? My parents definitely sent me to private school for the results.

Most of the other things can be done out of school

Perthsmurf · 28/12/2023 17:12

As some pp have said, it depends on your other options plus the private school itself.

My DCs are thriving at an independent school, the class sizes are small and the facilities mean they get to do a lot more than most schools. One of my DC has additional needs which are met (and more) at their current school, and which were not being met at their state school. We saw a huge improvement after we switched for our DC in terms of their wellbeing and inclusion in all activities.

i wouldn’t change it, but then another independent school might not be nearly as good. We chose this one because it’s sporty and encourages critical thinking. It doesn’t excel academically, which for some parents is really important.

My advice is to think about what you want from a school, and then think about what would be best to deliver that- it may be that your local state school actually does a great job.

notlucreziaborgia · 28/12/2023 17:08

It’s not just about the results though, is it? A big part of what motivates parents who privately educate ime, is providing their kid/s with the opportunities and experiences that private schools offer. The results aren’t the whole of it.

Midwinter91 · 28/12/2023 17:03

I think this depends on the school, and possibly the child’s ability and personality. At my Russel Group University I was surrounded by people with paid for educations who’d gotten the same grades as me and others from Comps and I must admit I thought their parents had wasted allot of money.

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 16:44

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 16:35

Good Lord.

Your basic maths does not even add up.

Only it does.

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 16:42

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 15:41

@Teenangels

We have 4 children that have all gone through Private (Public) and the cost was £36,000 per year per child plus extras.
I have yet to spend over £140,000 on one holiday

An average holiday is probably about £5,000.00

People who are contemplating private education by giving up one holiday a year aren’t spending £5k on that holiday.

School fees could be anything between £10-40k pa. As could a decent holiday. Why are you finding that so hard to grasp?

I am finding it hard to grasp because if you can "give up" one holiday to be able to afford the fees, even with a surplus, what will happen if one parent has to give up work, you are then as a family not able to afford the fees.
My children went to fee paying schools, and we could afford them on one wage and be able to afford, a nicer house. Public school is something that you commit to for 16 years (pre prep) to 18. Fees increase dramatically once in Senior, exam fees, music, sports, trips etc.

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 16:35

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 16:25

Good lord.

I’m sorry you cannot grab basic maths. If private school fees cost £30k and they have £24k available cutting back on that one holiday will enable them to afford the fees.

Good Lord.

Your basic maths does not even add up.

Purplesilkpyjamas · 28/12/2023 16:34

Celticliving · 28/12/2023 16:23

It's not a generalisation at all. I've told you what my experience with the kids that I've looked after. It's a fact not a fabrication.

You missed the point completely. Private schools cream off the brightest so children in most private schools are already bright. State schools (apart from grammar) don't do this. It is like comparing apples with oranges.

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 16:34

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 16:25

Good lord.

I’m sorry you cannot grab basic maths. If private school fees cost £30k and they have £24k available cutting back on that one holiday will enable them to afford the fees.

Good Lord.

I can't believe that you can't grasp the fact that school fees only increase in price and that you have no idea what the OP certain Financial position, someone can not afford fees by giving up one holiday a year.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 16:26

Another problem is that these discussions are, by definition, anecdotal and specific. People can say that private education was worth it/not worth it for their child because XYZ , but we have no idea what would happened to that child at any other school. To some extent we're saying that privileged well supported children do well at school. Which is basically a no brainer. I'm pretty sure my own privileged well supported children would have achieved exactly the same if they had gone to private school. I would have had a much easier life though- and I do think they would have been less rounded individuals.

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 16:25

Teenangels · 28/12/2023 15:25

We have 4 children that have all gone through Private (Public) and the cost was £36,000 per year per child plus extras.
I have yet to spend over £140,000 on one holiday.
An average holiday is probably about £5,000.00 for a week away, and a private school that provides an adequate education is certainly going to cost more per year.

Good lord.

I’m sorry you cannot grab basic maths. If private school fees cost £30k and they have £24k available cutting back on that one holiday will enable them to afford the fees.

Celticliving · 28/12/2023 16:23

Purplesilkpyjamas · 28/12/2023 15:54

This is a big generalisation. Most private schools cream off the brightest students. I have state educated children that went to top universities on very competitive courses.

It's not a generalisation at all. I've told you what my experience with the kids that I've looked after. It's a fact not a fabrication.

Another76543 · 28/12/2023 16:08

CinnamonJellyBeans · 28/12/2023 15:51

A lot more ket in the private sector.

I’m not sure that anyone would be able to prove or disprove this because I doubt there are any accurate and reliable studies. No one can possibly think that by sending a child to a state school, it means they won’t come across drugs though. State schools are hardly known for being drug free.

AgeingDoc · 28/12/2023 16:01

Nobody can really answer that question as they don't know what would have happened if they'd made a different choice. If a child has done well following a private education then naturally parents want to believe that it is because they chose that route, but then lots of bright, state educated kids do very well too. Equally, parents of a child who hasn't achieved as well as hoped at private school might feel it was a waste of money, but who knows, their outcome might have been far worse elsewhere. Or it might have been better. Or not much different. Nobody can say with any real certainty.
We could have afforded to educate our children privately, but we have great state schools where we live. So why would I spend lots of money on the local independents that have barely discernably different results or facilities? However, if I lived in the town where I grew up I would have moved heaven and earth to try to avoid sending my children to the failing comprehensive I attended.
And perceptions of "value" vary. A friend of mine was determined to send her children to top boarding schools and she did, even though it was a huge stretch financially.Her children all got decent A levels, decent degrees and have decent jobs, but whether they're better than if they'd gone to the local comprehensive, who knows? Statistically, probably not. But they have a certain self assurance and they've had some very interesting experiences that a state education would be unlikely to provide. They also have very strained relationships with their parents now. My friend thinks 100% it was worth it, but her offspring don't seem quite so sure. But again, would different have been better or worse? Who knows.
Whether it's worth it will depend massively on the quality of schools in both sectors which are realistically available to you, your child's interests and personality and exactly what the cost will be to you, in financial and personal terms. The answer will be different for everyone.All we can do is do our best with the information and resources that we have at the time.

jollywhite · 28/12/2023 15:57

Hmm. I would say "not worth it"

I honestly don't believe I've ended up any better off as a adult. The only 'skill' I think I've learnt is not to be impressed by money. Lots of well off parents at DD's school now, and they don't seem wealthy at all to me after going to school with children from proper money.

I went to a regular 6th form and did very well.

In private school you're simply paying for a better breed of bully and not having to mix with chavvy parents or kids. That's the gods honest truth. I would imagine nowadays drug problems are rife in private as the kids can actually afford it!

Purplesilkpyjamas · 28/12/2023 15:54

Celticliving · 28/12/2023 08:39

I've been a nanny for over 25 year.

I've looked after kids from both private and state schools. I hate to say it but the kids in private schools have ALL been miles ahead.

This is a big generalisation. Most private schools cream off the brightest students. I have state educated children that went to top universities on very competitive courses.