Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
Teenagehorrorbag · 29/12/2023 21:26

My Dad was in the navy and they used to pay for children to attend private schools (maybe still do) so I went to boarding school from 11. I wanted to go (too much Malory Towers 😃) and loved it. I was very academically able anyway - it was a selective entry school - and came out with pretty good O Levels. But I wanted to leave and experience the world a bit so did A Levels at the local tech - so maybe didn't get all the benefits of private school that I might have if I had stayed longer. I didn't go to uni as I had met a local boy and wanted to work. Had I stayed I would have gone on to uni and who knows......

But I did do pretty well in the end - got my degree-equivalent qualification through work and had a fulfilling and successful career.

DSis was three years younger and went to the local comp, as we had stopped moving around so much by then. It didn't have a great reputation and presumably had distractions etc, but she did really well, and has done fantastically career-wise ever since. She did go to uni, and then got a masters.

So I think it's really hard to know. You might do better at private if you aren't that engaged at school, or need motivation. But if you are keen you should do well wherever you go to school. Even the lowest achieving schools still have some great kids and some great teachers!

I think the other differences are things like - making useful contacts, having great sports facilities, maybe not picking up bad attitudes or mixing with the wrong crowd if you're easily led, etc? (Although people always say that our local private school has just as many dodgy kids as the comprehensive - but theirs buy cocaine whereas ours smoke fags behind the bike shed.....😂.)

Sorry - no helpful advice. I would never pay for it at primary as I think the benefits are more at secondary. But every situation is different.......

IAmTooOldFor · 29/12/2023 21:10

Definitely worth it for me but it really is a personal choice to weigh up. I (plus 3 siblings) went to boarding school and it gave us so much in terms of stability and all round education, not just academics. My DD now goes to a private (day) school despite us being in the catchment for 2 o/s primary schools. Academically it’s not anything special but it is known for turning out well rounded, well mannered, kind, self aware, confident adults which will likely give a higher chance of happiness and success than a suite of A*’s at A levels!

Longlielover · 29/12/2023 20:52

Also, as an aside - first time I saw class A drugs was at a Private School party. My other mates could barely afford 10 ciggies to share out ….

Longlielover · 29/12/2023 20:50

I had a private education, only possible with 2 scholarships, and I hated it.
Massive bullying problem based around wealth, I just did not fit in. The teaching staff were fairly openly scathing too…
Hard to try to fit in with families who had an Au Pair and “Daily Lady”, one long-haul, one short-haul and one skiing holiday a year.
Not being able to afford the music tuition, latest sports kits, high-end fashion for parties was really stigmatising.
We are fairly comfortably off now (due to DHs salary - he left school at 15 1/2 to start an apprenticeship) and I’d not consider it for my kids. If they needed extra help I’d maybe consider extra few hours of tutoring at home for them instead.

RiddlePiddle · 29/12/2023 20:40

Just back to the financial aspect - you also need to consider the many extras you would have to pay for, eg. expensive uniform, expensive trips, the friends they will be making and how much you might feel pressured to spend on parties and gifts as to not have your child feeling lesser than their peers. If none of that is going to be an issue, I would say it is worth it.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 29/12/2023 20:35

Anyway, the private school had more of everything than state schools. We had two teachers convicted of paedophilia which I believe is higher than average for state schools.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 29/12/2023 20:34

I went to a sex segregated private school and wish I hadn’t. Socially really hard, I went to school in a town a long way from home so I was set apart from the kids in my street who didn’t want to know me after switching schools. Then we moved closer to school but all the other kids near us were toddlers.

And it was single sex which was shit. I didn’t make many friends at the private school. I did well academically though, spending all my lunchtimes in the library or design & technology rooms doing my homework and extra reading. I was on an asisted place and then won a commercial sponsorship for 6th form. Won everything in terms of prizes in my last year of sixth form, then inexplicably wasn’t accepted on any of the uni courses I applied for despite great grades. At the time we just shrugged and I joined an IT course at a local uni despite not having studied that at A-level or even GCSE. Nowadays I’d be trying to find out why. Such a weird experience in hindsight.

ZsaZsaTheCat · 29/12/2023 20:20

EmmaGrundyForPM · 28/12/2023 09:12

DH and I were both privately educated. DH went to boarding school,I went to a girls day school.

The biggest issues for both of us were not having friends locally. The school I went to was in a different town, so I had a long commute. Both dh and I suffered from being in single sex schools.

DH went to Cambridge and I suppose its arguable that his school prepped him really well for the interview, but we'll never know.

When we had our dc we were adamant that they would go to the local state school, which they did. Absolutely no regrets.

Just interested how you actually ‘suffered’ in a single sex school?

EmpressoftheMundane · 29/12/2023 20:19

Sometimes having the broad choice that being able to pay facilitates is magic. You can match the perfect school to your child. Then it’s worth every penny. It really depends upon your specific child and the schools available.

Menomeno · 29/12/2023 20:11

Also worth pointing out that state schools might not always equal huge class sizes. My dd did 6th form at an inner city comp. So few pupils stayed on for 6th form that her A Level class sizes were between 4 and 10 pupils, and she did excellently.

Dorisbonson · 29/12/2023 20:08

I'm currently weighing up whether we move house (when I return to the UK) for my son to go to a top 10 UK boys day and boarding school or stay in the area where we are and for him to go to one of the grammar schools.

Franky neither are terrible options but my choice is basically being driven by the opportunity for him to have access to a range of extra curricular opportunities that he won't get at the grammar school and hopefully making him a more rounded individual.

I don't give a monkeys about the exam results as long as he works hard, I care far more about whether he leaves either school with sufficient determination to achieve his dreams and not give up.

JMSA · 29/12/2023 19:54

I'm going to be really honest with you here. I went to a state secondary school and was an overachiever. My 3 children attend private school and are academically mediocre. I'd never say it to them, but it hasn't been worth it at all.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 29/12/2023 19:47

sabbii · 29/12/2023 19:21

Never begrudge anyone who puts their children into private education or the sacrifices but I have never seen the appeal or the benefit. All that matters in life is getting into a good uni with a good pass

Seriously? What a sad comment

willWillSmithsmith · 29/12/2023 19:46

sabbii · 29/12/2023 19:21

Never begrudge anyone who puts their children into private education or the sacrifices but I have never seen the appeal or the benefit. All that matters in life is getting into a good uni with a good pass

That obviously isn’t all that matters. Having a good school experience is important too, whether that is state or private. Having a bad time at school can seriously affect you for a long time to come. You may not really notice or register that your time was good but you sure as hell know if it’s bad.

Ticktockk · 29/12/2023 19:46

I went to state and private. I can say that my two years in private were my happiest and most memorable years. I was a quiet, hard working child and they helped me to be more confident and to understand how to learn. I had opportunities I’d never imagined.

I have also taught in private and although my children are at a lovely state school, I am disappointed by the slow teaching, lack of excitement, uninspiring curriculum…. But it really depends on the school. There are some incredible private schools and some rubbish ones.

DecorationsDown · 29/12/2023 19:43

PropertyManager · 28/12/2023 09:33

I'm 44 now, went to private school for prep and senior, now run a business - never underestimate the power of the old boys network / old school tie.

Not only did I have a great education, I have at my disposal many friends who I can call on for advice, for example I met an old chum who is a barrister for a coffee and bit of free legal advice before Christmas, I would have had to pay had I not had the contacts. Of course it works the other way too.

More remotely I was at another businesses offices touting our services, noticed a Harrow straw boater on the bookcase in the MDs office, struck up a conversation, said where I went, response was the works yours if you want it...

Back when I had salaried jobs i got them all through people I knew / friend if a friend, informal chat and I was in.

The investment is still paying off big time...

You come across like you are from a different era. I was surprised to see you were only 44! I am in my fifties and the friends I have from ‘top’ private schools come across nothing like this. They definitely started off by merit rather than ‘connections’. They wouldn’t have had it any other way.

DecorationsDown · 29/12/2023 19:39

My youngest has just left home. They were at a local mixed-sex private in London. Lots of friends nearby. Their parents are now our friends ‘for life’. They have confidence and ambition but are kept grounded, kind and humble by having us as public sector parents to guide and advise. Both at great universities now.

It was truly an amazing experience overall. In all their time, we had one or two bad teachers. They rest were either good or amazing. We were very lucky and privileged.

Glo1988 · 29/12/2023 19:37

I went and had such a good experience. Good exam results and lots of extra curricular activities.

My two girls 7 and 3 have started too in the last year. Very happy with it so far, it is a push financially but well worth it. They are so happy and engaged. The excellent wrap around care has enabled us to work / earn more too.

They often do discount if you pay for a year’s fees up front, so bear that in mind - it can be worth saving up for (and nice to be a year up front in case circumstances change!)

make sure you budget for uniform, it is probably 50% more than state schools.

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 29/12/2023 19:26

All that matters in life is getting into a good uni with a good pass
😮

sabbii · 29/12/2023 19:21

Never begrudge anyone who puts their children into private education or the sacrifices but I have never seen the appeal or the benefit. All that matters in life is getting into a good uni with a good pass

Madamum18 · 29/12/2023 19:10

It depends on the quality of state school options around you as to whether its worth it!!

For me private school (parents didn't pay couldnt afford; it was job related and paid for by employers) did benefit me academically but not socially. Admittedly it was boarding school so a bit different to your circumstances.

Efrogwraig · 29/12/2023 19:01

Depends what you want. Son went to local schools & did well. (Now a graduate teacher) Why would he not with two graduate parents & a house of books?

His primary school was "inadequate". We became governors & worked to make it a school good for all local children.

He has friends from all backgrounds & cultures. His confidence is not the super-confidence of a private education but that of someone who has the measure of mixing with everyone & knowing their value.

MonthofSunnydays · 29/12/2023 18:55

A relative is in a private school and it’s much better than state school. So many more opportunities for extracurricular activities. The school work seems to be of a higher standard. He had full days of work all through covid lockdown. Lots more social stuff. Mine go to an outstanding rated secondary and it’s no where near as good.

LookingforMaryPoppins · 29/12/2023 18:50

It really depends on which independent school, what the state provision is like and the individual child. We moved all three of our children to an independent primary school having realised that the state system doesn't suit all.

Our eldest is academic however does need some minor reasonable adjustments made to meet her needs. The state system isn't geared to children that meet expectation but would exceed with the correct adjustments in place, they need to fall below expectation before there is any intervention. My second child exceeded expectations in everything, the national curriculum only permits greater depth learning rather than moving into older year group curriculum - he wasn't pushed at all and was expected to help other children when he finished rather than being permitted to progress which didn't suit him.

Snaller classes and her needs being met made a huge difference to my eldest. Being pushed and able to progress at his own rate made a huge difference to my middle one. Both are now back in the state system at Grammar schools (all of which are better than any of the independent local secondary schools).

My youngest daughter is still at primary school, she is different again in that she is of an age where lockdown had a huge effect on her year group. The home schooling offering in the private sector far exceeded that in the state sector and we subsequently moved her across.

There really are so many variables but where we live there is a grammar system in place and the non selective secondary's schools are not good. I do not regret sending my children to an independent primary school. I am happy that we chose state grammar over an independent secondary however if my youngest isn't suitable for a grammar school we will keep her in the independent sector.

Pliudev · 29/12/2023 18:32

Have you taken a look at the higher echelons of the Tory Party? Not a great advert for private education and one particular well known school. Of course, as has been said elsewhere, it's the experience and connections that count. And still more likely to get into Oxbridge. Sadly. I bet the folk I'm thinking of are 'proud of achieving' too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread