Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
LunaLovegoodsLeftEyebrow · 28/12/2023 09:23

Depends on the school and the child.
Private schools are good at getting decent grades from mediocre or lazy kids.
If your kids are bright and motivated, and there is a decent state school nearby, don’t waste your money.

Flickersy · 28/12/2023 09:22

Education is more important than one additional holiday and a bigger house (assuming the current house is sufficient and you're not overcrowded, which it sounds like you're not).

Assuming your local private schools are better than the local state schools, it would be a no-brainer for me.

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 09:22

I am in the USA and our kids went to Catholic schools through 18. Due to the legal separation of Church and State they are private. Catholic schools are usually half the price of secular private schools in our area as they are subsidized by the parish, diocese and voluntary hours by parents.
There are plenty of excellent state schools in our area but we are still very glad our kids went to Catholic schools. The school has a caring and supportive ethos and the smaller school especially at high school level (14-18) means no kid is ignored or falls through the cracks. Our youngest had a tough time around age 15-16 emotionally after COVID and my cancer journey. I think he was ripe for going off the rails but the school helped prevent that and assured us a good 30-40% of boys were unmotivated at his age until maturity kicked in. Sure enough he has turned it all around, has straight As and applied to study engineering at uni. I don't think our experience is unique to Catholic schools but I do think the support and close knit community is rare. I also like the amount of strong, supportive families from diverse backgrounds. For us it has been the right choice. All three kids are very self motivated, the first 2 were very well prepared for college and have done really well there. They also gained an emotional maturity and expectation that they need to put the work in that I feel the school emphasized. So I appreciate the work ethic they have built and the level of critical thinking they were taught. I do think the school prepared them for adulthood.

Baffledandalarmed · 28/12/2023 09:22

Yes. I went to private school. One local state was good but no guarantee I’d get in (catchment areas and all that).

We didn’t have holidays the entire time I was at school. We ate basic food. Old cars. Grandparents helped with fees (just to demonstrate what a huge stretch it was for my parents). Didn’t go on any of the big trips either. At sixteen I got a job to help my parents out financially (the jump in fees between YR11 - YR12 was £3K a year).

I ended up;

  • Excellent results
  • Good university + degree
  • Good job
  • Own home (before 30 paid for by me)
  • Good contacts
  • Happy

I had a few friends who did go to the local states, including the good one. Most ended up in none blue collar jobs (nothing wrong with that but they were exceptionally bright and could have done much more - which they admit themselves). The two I still speak to resent eg fact their parents prioritised nice cars and holidays over giving them the best chance to succeed.

It’s not just about the education but the opportunities it gives you, the contacts, the confidence etc.

Georgieporgie29 · 28/12/2023 09:21

My DC’s have both gone to private secondary and for us I think it was a good thing. Our local state schools are ok but not great.

it’s the overall package that works for us, longer days so easier for working parents and after school clubs so everything is in 1 place and we aren’t taking them here there and everywhere of an evening.

smaller class sizes so they are less likely to hide away which builds confidence and just more opportunities, sports they would never have tried, clubs we hadn’t even thought of. My dd has never been particularly sporty but she has actually found a sport she really enjoys.

like others have said though, it totally depends on the schools and there are some fantastic state schools, just unfortunately not near us

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 28/12/2023 09:21

Depends on the child and depends on the school. They are not all made equal.

from my time working in an outpatient setting where we saw a lot of the local private boarding school kids along with the state school kids. I would say that on the whole the state school kids seem happier, but the private school ones more resilient. These are boarders though, so wouldn’t be the same for day pupils.

PermanentTemporary · 28/12/2023 09:20

We live a 20 minute bus ride from one of the top boys day schools in the country. They do great bursaries too. But having seen the boys laden down with huge bags on the bus, and the friends child who was chucked out in GCSE year because their results weren't going to be good enough, I'm quite glad we decided not to put ds in for a scholarship.

If you want your ds to have high level music, dance or sport (particularly cricket) i would definitely consider it - ds's school isn't terrible at music but nothing like what my privately educated relatives have got, and the sport was minimal. But not for academics.

arethereanyleftatall · 28/12/2023 09:19

OliviaFlaversham · 28/12/2023 09:11

If you can afford private, I wouldn’t hesitate. More choice, longer holidays, smaller classes, greater freedom with curricula, free from govt control, teachers less burnt out, better financed…

The private school I work at does talk a good game, but here's how the list @OliviaFlaversham posted, pans out..

smaller classes, - yes, and most of the children are entitled and superior and don't listen as they know more. Just don't get the respect as one does in state automatically. I know some parents like that, but it makes it difficult for them to learn
greater freedom with curricula, - not a good thing in my area. State school ks2 curriculum for swimming is 25m and 30seconds tread. The state schools kids in my area can all do it, the private can't.
free from govt control - see above, gov control is a good thing here
teachers less burnt out - yup, they all muck around. At my school it's a very high percentage of really good looking staff in the pe dept, all young, all unqualified, all just mess around because no one is watching
better - not in my experience

CloudPop · 28/12/2023 09:19

Put two through private. Like you, affordable but meant we didn't upgrade to a bigger house etc. very comfortable life though. Worth it? Yes - 100%. They are two very different kids but both very motivated, good level of self confidence (not public school twats, but confident of their place in the world.). Couldn't be happier with the people they are and I do believe having a good education has been key. As others have said, if you have genuinely excellent state schools accessible this may well be as good, but I don't regret a minute of my kids education.

FrenchandSaunders · 28/12/2023 09:18

We couldn't afford it but if we had been able to I worry that I would have put huge expectations on our DDs, even subconsciously. I would want a return on that money I spent.

Whereas my attitude at state school was just do your best, have fun, and hopefully end up doing something you enjoy that makes you happy. Which they did.

StrawberryWater · 28/12/2023 09:17

So far, so good.

They're extremely good with ds and supporting his needs. I doubt he'd get the attention and 1-on-1 he needs in a state run school. He also wouldn't have access to nearly half of the facilities he does now if he didn't go to private school. Our town has no swimming pool for example, his school does.

Atishooooo · 28/12/2023 09:17

Nice and nephew attended a long established and very traditional public school. Academically, they've done no better than my kids at the local comp and in fact ending up at less prestigious universities - but they have gained something extra in confidence and useful connections.

FaiIureToLunch · 28/12/2023 09:16

I moved mine at 5&7 into private, they’re quiet academic kids and they’re thriving, they were bored in state.

but the biggest thing is actually the sense of confidence and responsibility which you can really see. I went to a private school myself and hated the boorish hooray Henrys but they seem to be able to handle it.

SwingTheMonkey · 28/12/2023 09:16

My children go to a private school and it’s worth every penny. Small class sizes, specialist teaching from an early age, excellent co curricular activities, lots and lots of sport/exercise, competitive sports matches for all, lots of trips/visits, no dropping non core subjects to cram for SATs, poor behaviour not tolerated and most of all, a culture of being proud of achieving.

LaPalmaLlama · 28/12/2023 09:15

edithfg · 28/12/2023 09:00

I’m not asking about exam results. I mean the overall experience. Thanks

Again I think it really depends on what the other local options are in terms of sports, music, drama etc and what your own capacity is to manage ECAs for multiple children. One of the main benefits of a private school to a certain parent might be sport every day and a focus on specific team sports so that the child gets to a good level vs a child who only plays once or twice a week at a club. Another child might find the longer school day that facilitates that hour of sport and the consummate match commitments an obstruction to regular participation in a minority sport that’s not played at school or a club sport with a high time commitment ( eg academy football). That’s just one example but there would also be parallels in pretty much any interest.

The benefit of a private school is that the children can often access everything through school so it’s less running around for parents. But if your child has interests that aren’t typically offered at school they might be better off at a state school and access that separately.

Appleblum · 28/12/2023 09:13

Yes. Not all private schools are the same though so make sure it's a good one.

YireosDodeAver · 28/12/2023 09:12

It does depend totally on the school and some state schools are brilliant and some private schools are really not all that.

Go to the open days of the schools you have a chance at getting in and rank them as if money were not involved.

Often a private school will have a lot more extracurricular activities, and more sports. Be cautious if there's any chance of neurodiversity or additional needs for your dc, as some private school curate their results by asking weaker pupils to leave.

The small class sizes of some private schools isn't necessarily a brilliant thing if it means your dc have a much smaller pool of potential friends and doesn't "click" with any of them.

We went with state for primary and private for secondary and have been very happy with our choice. State primary has a lot of advantages at least till y4. Y5&6 can be dull for a bright child so moving a couple of years early is worth considering if you choose that path.

MintJulia · 28/12/2023 09:12

So far, yes.

My ds was the youngest & smallest in his state primary school class. He's strong academically but not at sport. He loathed school PE and was made to feel useless, isolated and miserable because he didn't like football.

It was reasonable up to yr 5 in terms of academics but yr 6 was spent bringing the less able children on, to get them through SATs, which I understand as a tactic but left DS bored, angry and resentful, where he had mostly enjoyed school before..

I moved him to a small academic independent at 11. They have been brilliant.

He has done well academically, but they have resolved his issues with PE, he's made friends and is confident and happy. He's forecast 7-9s for all his GCSEs but has also grown in every other way. It's a huge relief.

KatyN · 28/12/2023 09:12

I went to private secondary. I am incredible self confidence, it developed during secondary school as I was really shy in primary.
I have a gazillion weird quirks too from private education.

From my circle of friends, you can spot the privately educated by the confidence. This isn't always a good thing, obviously.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 28/12/2023 09:12

DH and I were both privately educated. DH went to boarding school,I went to a girls day school.

The biggest issues for both of us were not having friends locally. The school I went to was in a different town, so I had a long commute. Both dh and I suffered from being in single sex schools.

DH went to Cambridge and I suppose its arguable that his school prepped him really well for the interview, but we'll never know.

When we had our dc we were adamant that they would go to the local state school, which they did. Absolutely no regrets.

spriots · 28/12/2023 09:11

I think private school was good for me - I was a quiet academic child, with some quirks. I really benefitted from the additional academic stretch and high expectations.

My children are at a state primary - my view was that it made sense to start them in state and then see how we felt about it. They are doing really well and I don't plan to move them unless something changes. I feel like at primary level the enrichment that DH and I can provide goes a long way.

I will think about it again for secondary

OliviaFlaversham · 28/12/2023 09:11

If you can afford private, I wouldn’t hesitate. More choice, longer holidays, smaller classes, greater freedom with curricula, free from govt control, teachers less burnt out, better financed…

MirrorBack · 28/12/2023 09:11

From what I’ve seen it’s a lucky dip, with some areas also having wildly better options.
Locally as a teacher/tutor I saw many poor private schools, a steady stream of children moving to state at yr 2,5,7 and 9 who were asked to leave as they weren’t keeping up. Even with this pushing out of the lower achievers the results aren’t amazing. We often helped these kids gain both confidence and move on academically. I’ve tutored a fair few whose parents were desperate to keep them in private school, but who made poor progress at school.
However for friends in south london and Surrey it sounds like a different picture, there’s some excellent options for those who can afford them.
I must say among my adult friends a few did well at boarding school, very well, but more seem messed up by the experience.

arethereanyleftatall · 28/12/2023 09:11

I teach in the private schools and the state schools in my area (specialised sport). The state schools are WAY better. I only started at the private this September, and I have been horrified.

MBL · 28/12/2023 09:09

Exams are not everything but as you get closer to that stage you might find you care a bit more. Whichever you go for you will want choices for your child and that often means doing OK to well in exams.