Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
Karrak · 28/12/2023 09:33

It depends on the child and whether that specific private school can bring out the best in them. If that objective is met then it is good money. On the other hand I have seen grammar schools bring out the best in boys.

Another76543 · 28/12/2023 09:33

Oganesson118 · 28/12/2023 09:27

My daughter is at a private prep school and it's definitely worth it. They have the staff numbers required to deliver a fully differentiated curriculum and deploy staff as required e.g. in my daughter's class there's a massive range of abilities so sometimes they can have 5 or 6 teachers in there, in other classes, they only need one or two as the abilities are more even. They have specialist teaching from a young age, brilliant extra-curricular offering, zero tolerance for bad behaviour and a real ethos that instils a love of learning and taking personal accountability from an early age. The teachers and the head take a lot of care to get to know all the children as individuals, in our case this has been invaluable as we navigate some ASD assessments for our daughter and whilst the school look at providing some alternative arrangements for her academically as she appears to be "gifted" in some way (basically they're teaching her a lot of the core subjects with the year group above her, a state school would have their hands tied and be unable to do this apparently) They're also very open door policy, you can rock up or email at any time and a member of staff will make the time to talk to you.

They have the staff numbers required to deliver a fully differentiated curriculum and deploy staff as required e.g. in my daughter's class there's a massive range of abilities so sometimes they can have 5 or 6 teachers in there

This is another very good point. From reception, ours were set for reading and writing. There was about 5/6 groups, each with a different member of staff. This meant that the more able were stretched, and the ones who found it more challenging got the extra support they needed.

PropertyManager · 28/12/2023 09:33

I'm 44 now, went to private school for prep and senior, now run a business - never underestimate the power of the old boys network / old school tie.

Not only did I have a great education, I have at my disposal many friends who I can call on for advice, for example I met an old chum who is a barrister for a coffee and bit of free legal advice before Christmas, I would have had to pay had I not had the contacts. Of course it works the other way too.

More remotely I was at another businesses offices touting our services, noticed a Harrow straw boater on the bookcase in the MDs office, struck up a conversation, said where I went, response was the works yours if you want it...

Back when I had salaried jobs i got them all through people I knew / friend if a friend, informal chat and I was in.

The investment is still paying off big time...

Windthebloodybobbinup · 28/12/2023 09:32

I've not been to a state school in this country but I've been to 2 boarding schools and it really depends on the school. The first had poor uninspired teachers- mainly creepy older men. This was for GCSEs. The school was incredibly cliquey so after trying to take part in horse riding/drama/etc I gave up. The second school was for A levels and was a very academic hot house type environment- very small classes and passionate teachers which I loved. But absolutely no other enrichment on offer. In both schools there were incredibly damaged kids, some who had been boarding for years, and that was really sad.

DanceMumTaxi · 28/12/2023 09:32

Mumsnet is very pro private school. I don’t think you’ll get many people saying they wasted tens of thousands of pounds and regretted it.

ClottedCreamScone · 28/12/2023 09:30

What are your locale state schools like? If you have excellent state provision then I wouldn’t pay for private - so many of the benefits private education seems to confer are actually the benefits of just generally growing up wealthy. You will generally get smaller class sizes and better facilities in private education but if you’re in the catchment area for a good state school anyway those things are less important.

Knitgoodwoman · 28/12/2023 09:30

With private schools it isn’t about the grades. So many jobs and industries that have access to very high paying wages are still nepotistic. (unfortunately I went to a state school).
The difference I’ve noticed with friends who went private vs state, is how quickly they’ve gone up the ladder, got the cushy jobs , access to money for investments…. All through networks.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 09:30

Celticliving · 28/12/2023 08:39

I've been a nanny for over 25 year.

I've looked after kids from both private and state schools. I hate to say it but the kids in private schools have ALL been miles ahead.

'Miles ahead' in what regard, specifically?

As for the original question @edithfg it's impossible to answer unless you took hundreds of sets of four identical people (more identical than actual identical quads, which of course isn't possible), kept every other factor the same, but put one through a not so good state school, put one through a very good state school, put one through a not so good private school and put one through a very good private school, and then compared them. Even then, how do we measure success? Hopefully not just in academic terms. The reality is that any parent who can pay their child's way up 'the success ladder', in some form or other, is most likely giving them an advantage overall. Money talks.

Menomeno · 28/12/2023 09:30

*our (sorry typo, not poor education 😂)

Oganesson118 · 28/12/2023 09:30

Forgot to mention the reason we considered this school in the first place was because the state options within our area are either brilliant or appalling and I didn't want to risk the state school lottery and getting one of the terrible ones.

flutterby1 · 28/12/2023 09:30

Are you commutable to a Grammar school , definitely worth it if commute is an hour or under.

ItsReallyOnlyMe · 28/12/2023 09:30

My children both went to private school.

I would have to say for them - absolutely it was the best thing. They both achieved well academically and are now in good jobs. My DD also hugely benefited from the sport on offer.

Would they have done they sane at state school ? No one knows. When we started the private school journey I knew it was less of a gamble going private and I was prepared to pay for that decision.

Menomeno · 28/12/2023 09:29

My DCs were state schooled, and my DSCs were privately educated. My DH has seen both sides of the coin and says if he had his time over, he definitely wouldn’t have wasted his money on private education before the age of 11, but still would have sent the to a private secondary. All are DCs are broadly similar academically, and gone into decent careers. The one main difference I have noticed is that my DSCs are MUCH more confident than mine as young adults.

HappyAsASandboy · 28/12/2023 09:29

I have DC in private and state schools. The level of independence, academic expectations, extra curricular activity, freedom, politeness etc is leagues ahead in the private school.

My only caveat is that the state school is not a particularly good one. There might be a less stark contrast if the state school was a good one.

RandomButtons · 28/12/2023 09:29

I had a private education. Not worth it unless state schools are dire.

NeverHadHaveHas · 28/12/2023 09:28

I came from a very working class family where no woman had ever been to uni. Got an assisted place to a private school in the early 90’s, then went to uni and ultimately became a lawyer. I believe that my school broadened my horizons and made me believe that any career path was open to me, if I wanted it.
My two DC now attend private schools. My first DC attended state for the first few years of infants but we made the decision to move to private and are really happy we did. They both love the extra curricular opportunities and the teachers just have so much more time with them with only 12-15 in a class

EasternStandard · 28/12/2023 09:27

I think it depends a fair bit on the state schools you have available

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 09:27

I want to add that the kids continued with full-time school all through COVID either online or were the first ones back on campus months before the state schools. The standards remained very high and tests showed the students didn't fall behind. I was very impressed with how creative the teachers were to keep high schoolers engaged while they were at home.

Allthatglittersisntart · 28/12/2023 09:27

I went through state then grammar but have supported children through private school. I would say the private schools give children a lot of confidence and significantly help with Oxbridge admission. They will possibly network with future useful connections .

They also tend to push really hard for academic achievement (which is not always a good thing, can create very stressed children). However , it depends on the individual schools and you would have to compare the schools in your area. Look at lists of alumni from those schools and what they have achieved.

Oganesson118 · 28/12/2023 09:27

My daughter is at a private prep school and it's definitely worth it. They have the staff numbers required to deliver a fully differentiated curriculum and deploy staff as required e.g. in my daughter's class there's a massive range of abilities so sometimes they can have 5 or 6 teachers in there, in other classes, they only need one or two as the abilities are more even. They have specialist teaching from a young age, brilliant extra-curricular offering, zero tolerance for bad behaviour and a real ethos that instils a love of learning and taking personal accountability from an early age. The teachers and the head take a lot of care to get to know all the children as individuals, in our case this has been invaluable as we navigate some ASD assessments for our daughter and whilst the school look at providing some alternative arrangements for her academically as she appears to be "gifted" in some way (basically they're teaching her a lot of the core subjects with the year group above her, a state school would have their hands tied and be unable to do this apparently) They're also very open door policy, you can rock up or email at any time and a member of staff will make the time to talk to you.

Bigcoatweather · 28/12/2023 09:26

You’re right to not just focus on the academics OP. The academics were the last thing we were thinking of when sending DCs private. It’s the whole package of sport, care, convenience and the ability to have more control as a paying customer over matters such as bullying etc…

The behaviour in independent school was SO much better than our brush with an ‘excellent’ state junior school, where our very calm and friendly daughter was consistently placed beside disruptive pupils who couldn’t concentrate in order to help them, yet no thought given to how it affected her.
I wanted then to have a traditional, happy education and positive school experience - we got that in spades despite occasionally (financially) being on the bones of our arse 😄

ChristmasinBurrRidge · 28/12/2023 09:25

Yes - worth every penny.

Feralgremlin · 28/12/2023 09:25

I went to a private school from reception until end of GCSEs and definitely feel that it was worth it. I did well in my exams but more than that I feel that it gave me a really solid foundation for higher education in terms of knowing what my learning style is, how to revise, not to be put off at the first hurdle etc. I had so many extra curricular options - I did singing lessons, was in the choir, took part in school musicals. It was seen as cool to be intelligent and hard working, and to be involved in either sports or the arts, so no one was embarrassed to do well.

My son is now at a private school as he has SEN and the support available to him is far above and beyond what we could expect at any of our local state schools.

Christmassss · 28/12/2023 09:24

I went for the other approach and moved to a bigger house near a good secondary school. We had three or four foreign holidays per year, days and meals out every weekend, the DC did every club/sport they wanted to do and had/have lots of lovely local friends. They went to good universities and my DH and I were able to retire at 52 and 55.

Another76543 · 28/12/2023 09:23

In my experience, worth every penny. My children have loved school, and have always been happy to go in every day. The schools have been very good at spotting where their strengths lie, and challenging them so they don’t become bored. Smaller classes mean they get more attention. Quieter, well behaved children don’t become lost and left to coast. Not everyone will agree with this, but the private schools I have had experience of don’t have the same level of disruptive pupils as they are often not offered a place.

I am so pleased that my children were in the private sector during the covid years. The difference between what they had and what the local state school pupils had was stark. From day 1 of lockdown, they had a full day of lessons.

I would caveat it by saying that there are definitely some private schools which I don’t think are worth the money. You need to choose carefully and do a lot of research.

Swipe left for the next trending thread