Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
fyn · 28/12/2023 09:45

DD is at a private school and has absolutely thrived since she got there. She doesn’t come home say X has hit or pushed her yet again. They really have really worked with her to find out what she is passionate about, Maths and Music, so she has stretch focus sessions based on these 1 on 1 with the teachers. Her confidence has also increased massively. I’m really pleased we were able to send her!

MrsBuntyS · 28/12/2023 09:44

My DS went private until end of year 5 when they could ‘no longer meet his needs.’ They were very good, but they didn’t have the experience of the local offer to get him an EHCP. The local state primary did and we eventually managed it in time for secondary. He is now in state mainstream and is not doing brilliantly but there aren’t any other options for us. It really depends on the school and on the individual child.

mrboombasticwhy · 28/12/2023 09:44

I know 3 siblings who went to a private school, all adults now and not worth it

One has never worked at all!
One works for the family so doesn't need private education
One is a baby machine

Total waste of the parents money and they struggled to afford it too

Paintmybathroom · 28/12/2023 09:44

DH went to private school from age 8 and ended up getting kicked out of Uni at the end of his first year - so not sure his parents see it as a particularly worthwhile investment.

I'd say he does have a high level of self-confidence (but who can say that's not his natural personality?) The only other benefit that I've seen is that he's very good at rifle shooting games when we take DC to the fair!

CloudPop · 28/12/2023 09:44

Another76543 · 28/12/2023 09:23

In my experience, worth every penny. My children have loved school, and have always been happy to go in every day. The schools have been very good at spotting where their strengths lie, and challenging them so they don’t become bored. Smaller classes mean they get more attention. Quieter, well behaved children don’t become lost and left to coast. Not everyone will agree with this, but the private schools I have had experience of don’t have the same level of disruptive pupils as they are often not offered a place.

I am so pleased that my children were in the private sector during the covid years. The difference between what they had and what the local state school pupils had was stark. From day 1 of lockdown, they had a full day of lessons.

I would caveat it by saying that there are definitely some private schools which I don’t think are worth the money. You need to choose carefully and do a lot of research.

Agree with every word of this.

olderbutwiser · 28/12/2023 09:43

Yes for one child, no for the other.

It doesn't buy good academic results. My experience was that as you go up towards A levels if your child is not academic and/or a sports achiever the school will lose interest in them.

In all honesty one of mine would have been OK anywhere (bright, sociable, fairly sporty but not a fanatic, nothing quirky); the other should have been home schooled. But private school was better than my local alternatives.

Allfur · 28/12/2023 09:43

the 'whole experience' of not mixing with just a privileged elite is one of the main reasons we choose state, which all my kids thrive in.

Fireyflies · 28/12/2023 09:42

I had one at each at secondary age (both state school at primary, though DSC were at private so I'm familiar with that too). Advantages of private were teachers with much more time for individual pupils, better communication with parents and ability to meet any specific needs or issues. Much better sports (many teams playing competitively and also more hours/week for all) and more choice of extra curricular and trips (some £££, but not all). Also, a culture where it's cool to be bright and to ask questions in class, which was sadly lacking in the state secondary school.
Advantages of state schools were the community feel and DC having lots of local friends - particularly a good thing at primary age. Privately educated DC also returned to the state system for sixth form partly for A level choices, but also because she had decided by then that she felt the others in her school to be annoying snobs. She mixed with a wide circle outside school and I think was a bit embarrassed about being at the private school.
Personally if I was in your shoes I'd start them off at the local state school if it's reasonable and consider a move to private at age 7 or 11, depending on how they were getting on and what your state secondary options were like

ItsMyPartyParty · 28/12/2023 09:40

For me personally, I absolutely think it was worth it. Gave me support and self confidence, I think I would have floundered badly in state (specifically, the really awful state secondary that I would have had to go to).

I had a mixed group of private and state friends. It’s really obvious to me looking back that the private pupils came out ten years ahead of the state ones. These are people I know so well, there’s no difference in their intelligence and capability, but most of the ones who went to private school did well at university, then in to good jobs. The ones who went to state school either floundered and didn’t go to university, or did but didn’t do as well then ended up in lower paying jobs. About ten years post-uni everyone had evened out a bit and found their own preferences and successes.

We can’t afford to send our two to private school, and it does worry me. But we have a lovely local primary and are looking to move ahead of secondary applications to get in to a really good secondary. My outgoing child I don’t worry about so much, but the shy, introvert, struggles with dyslexia one I definitely do - the individual child and individual school makes a big difference.

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 09:40

When my eldest daughter started at her high school we had just moved back to the states after being in Germany for 6 years. She also missed an entire grade of secondary (8th grade) because we put her with her age group again, after being put back a grade in Germany to acquire the language before going to secondary at 11.
She especially needed help with math so I had a local tutor help her with homework. She told me she was shocked at how challenging my daughters homework was and that it was harder and there was a lot more of it, compared to the local state high schools, some of which are considered among the best in the nation. She was studying math at a local uni and said our dd was doing more work than she was. In fact, when our dd went to college, despite it being considered in the very top universities in the nation she found it EASIER than high school. She found she had often read books and academic papers given to them in class at uni during high school.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 28/12/2023 09:39

SwingTheMonkey · 28/12/2023 09:16

My children go to a private school and it’s worth every penny. Small class sizes, specialist teaching from an early age, excellent co curricular activities, lots and lots of sport/exercise, competitive sports matches for all, lots of trips/visits, no dropping non core subjects to cram for SATs, poor behaviour not tolerated and most of all, a culture of being proud of achieving.

You’ve described my state school here. In fact many people moved theirs from the private over the road to state recently.

I did what another poster said and used the money to move house to guarantee a place.

OP it’s a lottery I think, just review each school individually on the basis on the needs of your child and see which environment makes them feel safe and excited for the opportunity

twistyizzy · 28/12/2023 09:39

edithfg · 28/12/2023 09:00

I’m not asking about exam results. I mean the overall experience. Thanks

Exactly this! So far we are more than happy with the experience DD is having in private school Vs experience her state secondary friends are having. Calmer classrooms, less disruptive behaviour, smaller class sizes and access to amazing sports, music, art and drama facilities.
It isn't about the results for us, but the whole experience she will have throughout school

Bornonsunday · 28/12/2023 09:37

It's the kids that would put me off. My daughter has a bunch of friends from private school that we've known since primary and meets at a shared activity. A couple of them are insufferable with constant boasting about their school, academic prizes and amazing holidays. They are the top performers in their year and the success seems to have gone to their head.

Intelligence is massively linked to genetics according to research so the better academics will be mainly because their parents are clever and successful.

Haveyouanyjam · 28/12/2023 09:37

Definitely depends on the private school, the state school options and your child.

I went to private school and didn’t find it particularly beneficial, in fact I found that the overt competition regarding grades etc almost completely destroyed my love of learning and I preferred to be responsible for myself and my own learning. I also found it difficult being around only people of privilege. In the end I have made great friends from school, and somehow we happen to be the ones whose parents worked hard and earned the money for us to go (rather than any inherited wealth etc) and 5 of the 6 of us now work in the public sector.

I did get more of an opportunity to play sport as fewer students means if you are average at sport you’ll still get a look in.

However, children who need quite a lot of support or encouragement with learning may benefit from private school. I think my sister would say she was glad she went; whereas I would have preferred to go to the comp which was a good school just a lot more people.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 09:37

That sounds awful @Windthebloodybobbinup - a good, inspiring teacher can make so much difference, and these can exist in state or private schools - alas the overworking of teachers and support staff in state schools recently has led to many such teachers losing their motivation and enthusiasm because it's just so darn hard every single day!

Tiredalwaystired · 28/12/2023 09:36

Zanatdy · 28/12/2023 08:43

What are your local schools like? If they are outstanding for example I’d wonder what you’re getting for your money from going private? My DC have been fortunate to be in catchment for an outstanding primary & secondary; DS got all top grades at both GCSE and A level and is in 2nd year of degree with internship and hopefully graduate job lined up. He got an average of 95% in his A level papers. DD is on track for top GCSE grades too in the summer. Both good kids and keep good company. I could have spent a few hundred K and not sure what difference it would make. Maybe DS would have had better access to sports at school instead of local team - all I can think of. Had they been in catchment for poor schools I’d have considered others options but I don’t see why you would want to if you’ve got access to good state schooling

This is exactly our experience. We are fortunate enough to have a really outstanding state high school nearby. Both of mine have done brilliantly, plus we’ve had the option of a really really wide mix of highly academic and vocational subjects to choose from, which I suspect is broader than many private schools. So I think in some areas it won’t make a difference and some it will. Of course, mine won’t get the benefits of the “old school tie” where it occurs though (really hoping this is becoming less of a thing).

arethereanyleftatall · 28/12/2023 09:36

In my area - the parents themselves describe their children at private as confident and happy. True. The general mood around town is that the children are entitled and superior. Also True. Many parents are pleased that their children are the confident/happy/entitled/superior ones as they tend to do well as a cohort.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 09:36

100% worth it in every way - I also taught at the school so got a fee reduction for mine as they came through.

Spendonsend · 28/12/2023 09:35

There tends to be more variety in the independent sector. Schools will carve out a niche in the market. So some will be academic, some sportier some music, some mixed ability etc.
The state sector isnt homogenous but the variety is based on where you live. If you are london there might be meaningful choices but elswhere not so much.

Ariela · 28/12/2023 09:35

Really your question depends on what the state schools are like in your area.
Another option might be tutor + state.

NeverHadHaveHas · 28/12/2023 09:35

Knitgoodwoman · 28/12/2023 09:30

With private schools it isn’t about the grades. So many jobs and industries that have access to very high paying wages are still nepotistic. (unfortunately I went to a state school).
The difference I’ve noticed with friends who went private vs state, is how quickly they’ve gone up the ladder, got the cushy jobs , access to money for investments…. All through networks.

This nepotism argument has always confused me. I think that unless you go to one of the big public schools, these networks just don’t exist. Both me and my husband attended not particularly well known private schools in the midlands, and neither of us can think of any peers who got a leg up from contacts made while at school. I went into law, and have never dealt with any school peers in my career.

ActDottie · 28/12/2023 09:34

My dad was privately educated and it made him very passionate about not privately educating my brother and I as he thought it was a waste of money.

Tbh my personal opinion on education is that if parents are prepared to help their kids and put time into educating them then go state. My parents helped me a lot with GCSEs and A Levels. Literally my dad would be back from work at 7:30 and be doing science questions with me until 10. I did well at school because of my parents not the school. If you don’t have time to do that then I’d go private if you can afford it. Alternatively you can look at tutors.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 28/12/2023 09:34

It’s not as simple as yes or no. It honestly depends on the child and the school.

If you’re lucky enough to get a place at a really good state primary school then I would save your money for secondary if that option isn’t as good. I recently taught in an excellent state primary while my children were at the local prep school. The academics and quality of teachers were similar. The major difference was the access to art, sport and drama lessons by specialists at the prep school. Also more time spent outdoors, often having lessons in the beautiful school grounds. At the state school, children finished school an hour earlier. Many parents collected children and took them to the local hockey club or art club (very middle class area). Some pupils of course just went home every day and didn’t get the extra experiences. Overall, I could see how the prep school gave a slightly ‘better’ experience, but not £7k per term better.

I’ve taught in several schools I wouldn’t send my children to. Disruptive children, lack of outdside space, really poor art, PE and music provision, taught poorly by the class teacher due to lack of specialist teachers. This could apply to private or state. You need to have a really good look at the schools in your area and make a judgement. It’s definitely not a simple yes/no answer.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 09:34

PropertyManager · 28/12/2023 09:33

I'm 44 now, went to private school for prep and senior, now run a business - never underestimate the power of the old boys network / old school tie.

Not only did I have a great education, I have at my disposal many friends who I can call on for advice, for example I met an old chum who is a barrister for a coffee and bit of free legal advice before Christmas, I would have had to pay had I not had the contacts. Of course it works the other way too.

More remotely I was at another businesses offices touting our services, noticed a Harrow straw boater on the bookcase in the MDs office, struck up a conversation, said where I went, response was the works yours if you want it...

Back when I had salaried jobs i got them all through people I knew / friend if a friend, informal chat and I was in.

The investment is still paying off big time...

Through any of this education or networking did you learn how to explain your privilege in a slightly more humble manner at all?

tenbob · 28/12/2023 09:34

LunaLovegoodsLeftEyebrow · 28/12/2023 09:23

Depends on the school and the child.
Private schools are good at getting decent grades from mediocre or lazy kids.
If your kids are bright and motivated, and there is a decent state school nearby, don’t waste your money.

It’s really sad when the sum total of education and school is viewed as grade results.

What I observe to be the biggest difference between state and private is how much extracurricular enrichment there is as standard.

Not just the sports and clubs, but the other things which spark a love of learning in children.

We have an outstanding state primary, and a famous private prep locally. I follow both of social media, and know kids at both.
The stark difference for me is how the schools approach events like world book day, Pride month, Black history month.
One gets kids to dress up. The other invites famous authors and activists to speak to the children and do activities and community events with them.

One school gets kids to dress up as doctors and nurses for a day. The other built a mock hospital and gave all the children roles and had them working together to perform an operation and then look after the patient.

It’s those sorts of learning experiences which you pay for, and which light up imaginations

Grades are important but it’s so antiquated to think that learning experience begins and ends with prepping for exams

Swipe left for the next trending thread