Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
SandandSky · 28/12/2023 10:51

I think it also partly depends on the kid -

DH was privately educated and it really benefited him. He’s got very severe dyslexia and the provision that was there for him was fantastic. He’s also got that sort of confidence you only see in privately educated people - he really goes for things even if they are a bit out of his league and people seem to like that about him.

I also know other people - BIL, friends etc who are quite anti establishment, who were privately educated but might as well have gone to the local shitty comp. They have nothing more to show for it than friends who have been state educated at a decent school.

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 10:46

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 10:40

It is. Yes it can make a difference ie job prospects but if you think every person who went to private school is more intelligent, developed, well rounded & moral you’re absolutely wrong.

I didn’t say it was an absolute statement but if you think it doesn’t make much difference you’re wrong.

MsFogi · 28/12/2023 10:44

Definately not - we live in an area with outstanding local state schools but went private for junior school. Having had the dcs go through the state secondaries if I did it all again I would put them in state juniors in a heartbeat and I would put the dcs that went to grammar schools into the same non-selective comp as the other dcs (the non selective was a million times better than the grammar - as one dc puts it 'the same results but without all the stress').

PegasusReturns · 28/12/2023 10:44

It depends what you mean by “worth it”.

My DC are all still in FT education but I suspect it has enabled them (and me!) to fulfil their potential in a way that a state school may not have.

specifics:

excellent wrap around care and ECAs allowed DH and I to work and run successful companies

ECAs were varied and encouraged/ required. As a result they have a variety of skills that are not available at many state schools.

SEN provision has been excellent

After school study in exam years whilst not mandatory was something that virtually all DC participated in. There was no stigma in “trying” or “achieving”.

I think two of my DC would have done as academically well in state schools (but may have suffered socially by being perceived as a bit “nerdy”, whereas their ability was/is celebrated by school and peers in their previous/current schools).

the other two DC private school has been fabulous for them.

My DC were all in single sex schools, I think that made a huge difference to them.

fishfingersandtoes · 28/12/2023 10:42

We've sent one of our kids to a specialised private school for secondary (specialised in a vocational area she loves). The decision was made blind really as it was during lockdown. She's Y9 now and although the school has it's plus points I regret the decision. It's disorganised, very poor communication, teachers are the usual mixed bag you get in state. I think she'll do well at GCSE, and pretty sure that would have been the same or higher in the state option (which our other DC go to), we'll send her to a normal school for a levels.
My advice would be to really investigate all your options, private is not always better. Also if you have the cash, be generous to school funds if you go state.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:42

Panicmode1 · 28/12/2023 10:23

I really think it depends on the schools you have available to you. DH and I went to boarding schools - I loved it, he didn't. I wouldn't have played as much sport or music possibly, but my results weren't stellar and a local state would have sufficed I'm sure. My world view was very narrow at 18 - I didn't know anyone at state school and thought everyone had big houses, ponies and tennis courts.

Our four children have all been through (superselective) state grammars - one is at Cambridge, one at another excellent RG and the younger two still there. Many of the things people are citing are offered at their school - they are one of the best (state) cricketing schools in the country, have matches against the big local indies, a strong fencing team, have sports tours to Dubai, Argentina etc, trips to NASA, MUNGA, have amazing sport and drama opportunities - and have an enviable conversion rate of Oxbridge application to offer ratios (superior to several well known public schools near here, acc to recently published data in the Telegraph).

I did feel guilty for ages that they weren't at private school - DS1 won a top scholarship to a prep school and whilst we were agonising over what to do, my parents advised against getting on the fees treadmill if we didn't have to...!

Research carefully what you are paying for and investigate beyond the glossy brochures...two really terrible teachers have just gone from the boys school to big name indies...!

Yes we need more grammars instead of fewer!

Christmassss · 28/12/2023 10:41

To the people who went to private schools but have now chosen not to send their own DC to them either because they disagree with private schools or can’t afford them, would you have preferred to have received some of the money your parents spent on fees as a really big house deposit?

OVienna · 28/12/2023 10:40

Paperbagsaremine · 28/12/2023 10:32

I would add that the recent COVID enquiry highlighted the problem with people being given very expensive private school education from a very young age - an incomplete experience which can come back to bite you in the bum.

I went to state until twelve and so I had friends who had immigrant parents, friends who were taken "back home" and spent months in schools where they still used the belt, friends whose Dad's belted them at home, kids who weren't bad but obviously fucked up from their messed up families, kids who had a lot of plus points but who just were.not. academic in the least, and so on.

It makes a huge difference to have seen "real life" with your own eyes, rather than just intellectually knowing that certain things happen. Huge.

I had a 'mixed' education too, my kids have not. My husband is state educated.

I have friends and acquaintances whose children have only gone private - there is a minority with seriously shocking views and they will struggle in the 'real world' I am convinced. Possibly we are self-selecting with our friends though, so that's why it's not more! But I am convinced that it's totally down to the parents and values in the home, how this plays out. You can't blame the school and the people I am thinking of could have been assholes in a lot of different environments.

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 10:40

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 10:27

That’s not true.

It is. Yes it can make a difference ie job prospects but if you think every person who went to private school is more intelligent, developed, well rounded & moral you’re absolutely wrong.

arethereanyleftatall · 28/12/2023 10:40

@SandyWaves
I teach prep swimming. There is no one checking what you are doing. No lifeguard, no parents watching from the gallery, no class teachers waiting for the dc to have the lesson, no curriculum to follow. So essentially you can do what you like. A good teacher will put in loads of effort as normal. Lazy teachers will vaguely teach eg frontcrawl for a couple of minutes, then let the kids mess around essentially having a pool party. End result is kids who are very happy/think Mr X is fabulous/love swimming, but who have learnt fuck all. Lovely if it happens some of the time. Not every time.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:39

whatdidshedotogetahillnamedafterher · 28/12/2023 10:19

Thats not strictly true. We were so not wealthy and it took all of us including grandparents to pay for school. I did mix with some very wealthy people in our time there but to my knowledge they never looked down on me or my son. If they did they were too polite to say anything or make me feel bad. The kids who came to see us out of school may have lived in very lovely houses with parents who had really nice lifestyles but they too worked hard and were very nice people, I was not decked out in designer gear or had the latest range rover but they were welcoming always and were as comfortable in my semi when they dropped their kids off and had a coffee. The wealth aspect made no difference at all. They werent that shallow,

This has always been my experience too.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 10:39

ChristmasFairyGodmother · 28/12/2023 10:29

I doubt it. There is a lot of kudos that comes with graduating from a top school that makes life so much easier than for those who don't. It's about opportunities and connections, basically the leaders of tomorrow. It isn't about grades and going abseiling, it's about the networks and opportunities.

And therein lies one of the problems of society, private schools perpetuate the idea of some folk being better than others when actually they've just had more privilege.

Paperbagsaremine · 28/12/2023 10:39

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 28/12/2023 10:31

I’m finding this really interesting, that 70% of posts seem to focus on academics, and the other 30% on confidence. My main drivers for considering private are that I don’t want my quirky, bright but sensitive child to be beaten up. That sounds dramatic, and probably is - it’s more nuanced than that, but I guess it comes down to me wanting them to be able to enjoy school, get on and learn, and have friends, and not be afraid to go to school. I’d also like him to have an actual
maths teacher, rather than a PE teacher teaching maths, and be taught in a classroom with a reasonable number of other children, not in the hall with 60 others because the geography teacher left and hasn’t been able to be replaced. Our local secondary is seemingly on the up now after a massive intervention when its own teachers apparently called ofsted because it was so out of control. I’ve not seen a worse ofsted report. A few years back it was considered to be a reasonably good school, but took a massive dive. Maybe it will continue to improve. Perhaps it won’t. As a pp said, it feels like by going private you’re paying for the lesser gamble, the better bet? I don’t know. It shouldn’t be like this. I want to be able to just send my children to the local state school, but I care about their well being and so I need to consider whether the reality of that is as good as the principle.

See I think this might be why Mum sent me. I got bullied at primary and middle school, then learned to fight back and "be normal" at middle school, but perhaps this transformation was going too far (swearing... bad influences haha).

For all me going on about hot housing and spoonfeeding and poor socialisation, it WAS a relief to be at a school where minor psychological violence was all you got . I was a swotty child and was happy to just get on with work (of which there was a lot!!!).
I remained somewhat feral until my thirties at least though, so from that pov perhaps she should have moved me earlier...

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:38

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 28/12/2023 10:21

The big question is how you judge whether it was "worth" it. Is it purely salary that the DC earns later as several PP are suggesting?

One of my DC is trying to go into an interesting, well-paid, job... the other into a real passion, which is never going to earn much money. I don't personally feel that's a failure.

I have noticed this too - there is far more to education that getting a well paid job.

Usernamen · 28/12/2023 10:36

It makes a huge difference to have seen "real life" with your own eyes, rather than just intellectually knowing that certain things happen. Huge.@Paperbagsaremine

But so few state schools actually offer this? I don’t have children but I live in a desirable catchment area (estate agent couldn’t shut up about it when I was buying) and everywhere around me is middle class yummy mummy types and their hipster husbands. I hardly think their children are going to be mixing with the offspring of drug addicts and prostitutes?

Howbizzare22 · 28/12/2023 10:35

PropertyManager · 28/12/2023 09:33

I'm 44 now, went to private school for prep and senior, now run a business - never underestimate the power of the old boys network / old school tie.

Not only did I have a great education, I have at my disposal many friends who I can call on for advice, for example I met an old chum who is a barrister for a coffee and bit of free legal advice before Christmas, I would have had to pay had I not had the contacts. Of course it works the other way too.

More remotely I was at another businesses offices touting our services, noticed a Harrow straw boater on the bookcase in the MDs office, struck up a conversation, said where I went, response was the works yours if you want it...

Back when I had salaried jobs i got them all through people I knew / friend if a friend, informal chat and I was in.

The investment is still paying off big time...

Yep. Lucky, fortunate you. The inequality money brings is still live & kicking in 2023.

Paperbagsaremine · 28/12/2023 10:32

I would add that the recent COVID enquiry highlighted the problem with people being given very expensive private school education from a very young age - an incomplete experience which can come back to bite you in the bum.

I went to state until twelve and so I had friends who had immigrant parents, friends who were taken "back home" and spent months in schools where they still used the belt, friends whose Dad's belted them at home, kids who weren't bad but obviously fucked up from their messed up families, kids who had a lot of plus points but who just were.not. academic in the least, and so on.

It makes a huge difference to have seen "real life" with your own eyes, rather than just intellectually knowing that certain things happen. Huge.

HmmmIAmPondering · 28/12/2023 10:31

My son was bullied at Junior school, and I thought he was dyslexic, the teachers kept brushing me off. I just couldn't get anywhere with school. My son was miserable and about to go to senior school with the same batch of kids, so we moved him to a local private school which has taken all our spare money. It has been without a doubt worth it.
He quickly made friends, came home smiling and started to excel in the maths and sciences and was picked up as being dyslexic. His self esteem recovered and he has completed 4 A levels with excellent results. The support in university applications was also excellent.
He completed his Gold D of E while at school and took part in lots of extra activities included in the fees, and was so encouraged by the staff. He is a delightful young man, and I know his relaxed, considerate engaging manner has been influenced by the school and pupils.
I was worried that the other families would be completely out of our league, and although many of his friends have bigger houses and more money it's never been a problem. The school is down to earth and the kids are lovely. It's not the most prestigious school in the area or the one with the best results but it was definitely the right choice for our son.
The local school went from a good to unsatisfactory Ofsted grading in the time he would have been there.
The only down side is having to deal with the judgement from past friends but I wouldn't change my decision.
Good luck in making your decision.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 28/12/2023 10:31

I’m finding this really interesting, that 70% of posts seem to focus on academics, and the other 30% on confidence. My main drivers for considering private are that I don’t want my quirky, bright but sensitive child to be beaten up. That sounds dramatic, and probably is - it’s more nuanced than that, but I guess it comes down to me wanting them to be able to enjoy school, get on and learn, and have friends, and not be afraid to go to school. I’d also like him to have an actual
maths teacher, rather than a PE teacher teaching maths, and be taught in a classroom with a reasonable number of other children, not in the hall with 60 others because the geography teacher left and hasn’t been able to be replaced. Our local secondary is seemingly on the up now after a massive intervention when its own teachers apparently called ofsted because it was so out of control. I’ve not seen a worse ofsted report. A few years back it was considered to be a reasonably good school, but took a massive dive. Maybe it will continue to improve. Perhaps it won’t. As a pp said, it feels like by going private you’re paying for the lesser gamble, the better bet? I don’t know. It shouldn’t be like this. I want to be able to just send my children to the local state school, but I care about their well being and so I need to consider whether the reality of that is as good as the principle.

1990thatsme · 28/12/2023 10:30

I think you have to be aware that the difference in standards between the best and worst private schools is likely to be far wider than that of state schools.

I attended a world renowned public school and yes, it was fabulous both academically and socially. I went on to Cambridge and am privileged in pretty much every way.

However, I have friends who attended smaller private schools and they didn’t even have qualified teachers. Their experience was nothing like mine, in any aspect.

ChristmasFairyGodmother · 28/12/2023 10:29

Allfur · 28/12/2023 10:03

Christmasfairygodmother, My kids have that, and I didn't pay for it

I doubt it. There is a lot of kudos that comes with graduating from a top school that makes life so much easier than for those who don't. It's about opportunities and connections, basically the leaders of tomorrow. It isn't about grades and going abseiling, it's about the networks and opportunities.

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 10:27

Howbizzare22 · 28/12/2023 10:26

Doesn’t mean it makes much difference when they’re adults though 🤷🏼‍♀️

That’s not true.

user1497207191 · 28/12/2023 10:27

Depends on your options. Not all private schools are top of the league. Some state schools are excellent, some are poor. A low private school is unlikely to produce better grades than a top state school.

Here in the North West, our "local" private school is for "problem" pupils rather than the top academic ones. All manner of parents send their kids there after they've struggled at the state options, such as getting into trouble, school refusing, etc.

One of my clients is a plasterer whose teen son was half way down the road to crime, never did any school work, constantly in trouble at school for disruption, bullying, etc. They couldn't afford it, but sent him to our local private school which is a boarding school, just to take him away from his "friends" who were leading him astray. It turned him around and he's now at Uni, but "only" got mediocre/average GCSE and A levels - better than nothing which is what he'd have got if he'd stayed at the state school.

Howbizzare22 · 28/12/2023 10:26

Celticliving · 28/12/2023 08:39

I've been a nanny for over 25 year.

I've looked after kids from both private and state schools. I hate to say it but the kids in private schools have ALL been miles ahead.

Doesn’t mean it makes much difference when they’re adults though 🤷🏼‍♀️

Draconis · 28/12/2023 10:26

I feel that the kids I know who went to private school have more confidence and got great exam results without working as hard as the kids in state school.
It might be because private schools expect high standards consistently or peer pressure for working hard from the start but the state school dc I know, had to work much harder and much more independently to get their grades for uni.
They also have to be more independent when it comes to extra or super curricular activities. State schools don't have the provision to offer these to all pupils but may be able to offer only to a select, if at all.
It's more effort, but once they get to uni, I guess it doesn't matter. They all end up at uni with each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread